. - Politics (390) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › . (768921 Views)
1 2 3 ... 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 ... 732 Reply (Go Down)
| Re: . by Curlieweed: 1:00pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
Obi1kenobi:You make an interesting point about civil service pay. It’s clearly a case of the government pretending to pay the workers while the civil servant pretend to work. You clearly can’t retain quality talent with 20k/month. When I was in school, I dated a civil servant. I visited her very regularly because the secretariat was close to my school. In the 6 months period, I never saw this babe do a minute of work and she had a whole office to herself. The point about IGR as a proxy for government effectiveness is not about whether more revenue isn’t better than less revenue but whether additional funds are better utilized by government than if the money is left with individuals. I consider Anambra as a relatively well run state (not withstanding the low wages lol). I understand that they have a deliberate policy of avoiding excessive taxation to encourage growth. I don’t know much about Lagos but from what people tell me the taxes (on micro businesses) are retrogressive and intrusive while government expenditure is concentrated in the affluent areas. In contrast to Anambra, most states concentrate on beautifying the capital cities and other projects with zilch effect on the welfare of a large proportion of the population. Additionally, these high IGR figures don’t stop them borrowing like down at luck gamblers. So you over tax me today, spend the money to benefit only the well off then over borrow to ensure that my children suffer the same fate (or worse). I believe that if the money isn’t going to be used judiciously, it’s better left with me to be solve my own problems. On the other hand, if there is a clear vision for the state ( or region), then clearly an efficient system of taxation will be invaluable component in achieving that aim. You don’t expect IPOB to criticize the SE leadership when that will serve to polarize local support. Additionally, such criticism will divert attention from the core issue which is the illogical structure of the country. |
| Re: . by Nobody: 1:27pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
oilPUSSY:no time replying useless post. |
| Re: . by hammerFC: 1:28pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
NEXT TOPIC, STATE CREATION... THIS IS THE TOPIC THAT WE ALL LOVE TO TOPIC ABOUT BUT NOBODY IS SURE ABOUT WHERE TO START. IN ALAIGBO TODAY, IF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT DECIDES TO RESTRUCTURE, ARE WE CERTAIN OF WHICH STATES NEED TO BE STRATEGICALLY CREATED FOR NDIIGBO? LET US DISCUSS STATE CREATION AND FOR THIS WE WILL CERTAINLY NEED SOMEONE WITH LINKE TO PETER OBI, BECOS HE IS THE MOST RELEVANT PERSON IN SE POLITICS AT THE MOMENT. WAT WE DISCUSS SHOULD BE CARRIED TO PETER OBI. |
| Re: . by OreMI22: 1:29pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
ckenneths:This is truly excellent chronological flow of verifiable FACTS! I'm waiting for the faceless Yoruba goons to come here and spread their fake census numbers.Like, 99% of those that speak Igbo in Nigeria are actually Igbira people and other fantastic concoctions they love to do in Nigeria.Yeye people ![]() |
| Re: . by hammerFC: 1:39pm On Nov 03, 2018*. Modified: 3:31pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
On state creation for Ndiigbo, the state that seems less complicated and strategically relevant to create is one out of Enugu North. The Nsukka axis, bring in Igbos scattered in the middle belt areas of Benue and Kogi. I dont know wat the state should be called but creating that state appears not to create much headache.
|
| Re: . by hammerFC: 1:42pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
The state is called Adada state. It should not be created without capturing Igbo in the middle belt area of Benue and Kogi. This is the most relevant state to be created out of the present day SE.
|
| Re: . by hammerFC: 1:48pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
I have noticed that aside Adada state, every other state creates a headache and complication. Igbo land should get at least two states, whilst other regions get one. Igbo definately need one more state, and even if state creation is not on the agenda, Adada state should be created in the SE. One state first has to be created in the SE before talks of more state creation for all regions in Nigeria. The southeast have been short changed long enough. |
| Re: . by Obi1kenobi(m): 3:42pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
Curlieweed:This is the point though: I don't believe it is a deliberate economic strategy. It is an oversight. If you have a well organized civil service, you'll earn good money. You'll plug tax-avoidance loopholes in the system. You can't compare Anambra and Cross River in economic output, but Cross River earns more because their civil service is more efficient. Same with Enugu which generates more in IGR than Anambra. These are failings that need to be addressed. I use my dad as an example who was an FIRS director, and is consequently sensitive about his tax obligations and a willing tax payer. Yet, according to him, he hasn't paid tenement rate in several years for the flats he owns in Nkpor. Free money that the state government is missing out on due to their lack of due diligence. I believe it is mismanagement, not a deliberate strategy. I stress this matter of IGR a lot because we are the group that are loudest about "restructuring" (that is even ignoring the IPOB fanatics who want a schism). Even the Niger Delta that have the most to gain from it don't make as much noise about restructuring as we do. Yet, we are failing at fundamental things to make it a viable reality. Without a healthy tax base, our public infrastructure will collapse and we'll be pauperized. Sectors like education, health, transportation, agriculture, mining, waste disposal and public utilities etc will always need to be driven by the government and the money to fund it must be there. Yes, more revenue might mean more waste and embezzlement, but it is our duty to ensure we hold our leaders accountable. |
| Re: . by Obi1kenobi(m): 3:56pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
hammerFC:Nigeria is far too fragmented, with far too many states and far too many ethnicities (where similar groups like Isoko and Urhobo, or Efik and Ibibio, or Igboid groups claim distinct identities). Something like 30 states in Nigeria are not economically viable. This states-creation obsession only serves to further entrench the status quo of states sharing money from Abuja rather than looking to stand on their feet as viable economies in their own right. Enugu was ripped in two to form Anambra. Provided a big chunk of land for Ebonyi, and now people want it balkanized farther to form another state? Why? Only reason that makes sense which I've heard is the extra National Assembly seats. But that is not good enough reason to override economic considerations. |
| Re: . by hammerFC: 5:40pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
Obi1kenobi:How does giving a region with just 5 states, one more state, to put it on equal footing with its peers, going to solve or create more issues? The SE is in critical need of at least one more state. Adada is the best and safest option. It provides a unique opportunity to capture our people in the middlebelt into the SE |
| Re: . by Curlieweed: 5:48pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
Obi1kenobi:It’s interesting that the two states you mentioned (Enugu and CRS) are older states. These states had better infrastructure for tax collection than the newer states which in most cases have not developed such systems. It goes to show you that most of these issues are structural. I guess that also kind of gives some credence to your “oversight “ assertion. I don’t think the state executives are too enamoured with “restructuring”. Why spoil a good thing? Of course we have already talked about their short term focus. In the SE, it’s mainly Ohaneze ( with frustrated political ambitions and have the luxury of being outside looking in) as well as ordinary citizens that are more in favour of restructuring. The whole country will gain from restructuring in the longer term despite real short term pain in many areas. Actually, that is the only solution to our myriad issues. Hopefully, state (or regional) political executive offices will be less attractive to the kind of carpet baggers we have currently and we can attract people with some vision. Accountability should also improve because there is no one else to blame. I think the tenement rate is a local government tax. That is the tragedy of the decision of most state executives to literally abolish that tier of government. In most countries, local governments (or municipalities) are responsible for streets (road maintenance), sewage, some utilities, basic education, waste disposal, police and a number of other services. They are usually financed mainly by property taxes. In Nigeria, the LGs do almost fvck all. Citizens have to provide these services for themselves while still paying taxes to state government which is very unfair especially to wage earners who can’t escape PAYE. That is also why the effects of restructuring (not withstanding the loss of revenue) will have less an impact on the lives of ordinary people than you may expect. Currently, the actual impact of state governments on the lives of most ordinary Nigerians is very limited. For example, I saw people praising Mr Umahi for building flyovers and “glass tunnels”. In Kano state, they built the longest flyover in the country. Amaechi left a half completed monorail system in Rivers state. How do these help the ordinary person who is struggling to make $1:00/day? |
| Re: . by hammerFC: 5:55pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
Curlieweed:If we get an opportunity to create one more state, let us push for Adada. |
| Re: . by Obi1kenobi(m): 6:30pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
hammerFC:Putting it bluntly, the SE doesn't deserve a 6th state. The "equality" you're demanding is unrealistic given the tiny size, population, and cultural homogeneity of the SE compared to other regions. Unless the 6th state is added from another region to the SE, it's a fruitless exercise to chop up what already have. Nigeria has more than enough states as it is and don't need farther chopping up. We could have 100 states in Nigeria and somebody will still be whining about marginalisation. Let us work with what we already have and make it work. |
| Re: . by Xander85: 6:33pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
| Re: . by OreMI22: 6:41pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
I hope that we will get to a stand in the SE that every new housing development area is well planned out before plots are sold and buildings are erected. It is slowly happening,at least in estates within some state capitals, but there are still too many slums in the making whereby the area were not well surveyed before plots were sold. Leading to haphazard erection of buildings and poorly planned streets. State governments must seriously pay attention to new estates being developed in the state to make sure they are well planned standard layouts fit for human habitation before plots are sold out.
|
| Re: . by murphyibiam15(m): 7:02pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
hammerFC:I prefer Etiti state that will involve all the whole SE states than only Adada for Nsukka axis, after all Ngwa people also needs Aba state |
| Re: . by GuyWise(m): 8:00pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
Xander85:Have you listened to Illbliss 40feet container? |
| Re: . by hammerFC: 8:32pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
Obi1kenobi:Whether u put it blunt or sharp, the SE are going to get a 6th state to be on par with other regions. |
| Re: . by hammerFC: 8:34pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
murphyibiam15:The best state for now is Adada, so we can removeour Igbo people from teh middlebelt. |
| Re: . by murphyibiam15(m): 8:39pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
hammerFC:the igbos in Benue can join Ebonyi, those in kogi should join Enugu and Anambra states. Etiti state is the fairest consideration...IMHO |
| Re: . by hammerFC: 8:41pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
murphyibiam15:No, Igbo as a people dont need any more state. Any move geared towards state creation should be strategically focused on retrieving our people delibrately cut off from us. This is y i need guys here that have access to Peter Obi or Ik Ekweremadu. Adada is the least contentous one and must capture Igbo people in the middlebelt. |
| Re: . by vanbonattel: 8:48pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
hammerFC:I was with Ike today, but no chance to ask questions. Such a humble power broker. |
| Re: . by Obi1kenobi(m): 8:51pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
hammerFC:Not anytime soon. And even if the SE get another state, other regions have been lobbying hard too for new states. They're not going to create an extra state in the SE, and leave the states at 37. I can't remember who said that at the last Confab, 50-something states or so were proposed. There will never be states equity because some geopolitical zones deserve more states than others. It's that simple really. The SE fails to make a case on 3 basis: the cultural homogeneity (the SE is the most culturally homogeneous zone in the country by far); the population; and the landmass. On all 3 counts, it is the least deserving region of having another state. |
| Re: . by hammerFC: 8:52pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
vanbonattel:Are u kidding me? He is the right person for this specific matter. I personally think, he championed the Adada state creation. Is he from the Nsukka axis? |
| Re: . by Obi1kenobi(m): 8:55pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
murphyibiam15:Etiti is actually most ridiculous proposed option. I'd rather support Njaba or Adada. You're asking for trouble creating a state like that with very different clans from different states merged together who everybody knows will engage themselves in a heated power tussle. Those that proposed it haven't thought it out well, and some of the groups involved have rejected the plans. |
| Re: . by vanbonattel: 8:56pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
hammerFC:I think he's from the west of Enugu. I think Awgu lg |
| Re: . by hammerFC: 8:59pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
Obi1kenobi:Yeah! We did not stop dem from creating states in other region. We insist on equal number of states for every region. Since SE is on a deficit, they create one first for the SE and then extra states for everybody including the SE. |
| Re: . by hammerFC: 9:01pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
vanbonattel:Awgu has a very beautiful landscape. Ekweremadu have truily been an asset to Ndiigbo. |
| Re: . by murphyibiam15(m): 9:54pm On Nov 03, 2018 |
hammerFC:Ekweremmadu is from Aninri LGA and not Awgu even though most people mix it up..Ekweremmadu I think won't have such powers he has now during the next senate |
IGBO POLITICAL LEADERS N THEIR PAST MISADVENTURES RESULTING IN CURRENT NAT PROBL • Junaid Mohammed: Igbo Political Leaders Haven’t Learnt Any Lesson From Civil War • Buhari And Economic Advisory Council In Close Door Meeting • 2 • 3 • 4
Yoruba Commonwealth and Politics • Anambra light of the nation, eastern economy power house. • Kenyans Are Far Behind Nigerians In Every Aspect – Fani-Kayode
Arondizuogu.