₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,400 members, 8,522,870 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 08:28 AM

Toggle theme

Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians - Business (5) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Business › Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians (21470 Views)

1 2 3 4 5 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by BRATISLAVA: 12:25pm On Sep 21, 2019
sureheaven:
Though may be difficult for some to understand because they've been misled by enemies of progress but the fact remains that this policy is new and may be hard in Nigeria but it's the best.
The western world are using cashless policy and is even better and good for prompt transactions .
It reduces excessive spending.
Allow minimization of fiscal expenditure .
In America , the least u can withdraw on the atm a day is $400 cash.
While ur other transactions is based on cashless transfer of transactions. Though u are entitled to come the other day and withdraw again, it will not go beyond same $400.
In all, there will be no development and advancement if we still retard ourselves with the old method of doing things in Nigeria.
Those in Diaspora understand what i am saying.
May God Help us in Nigeria.
You still pay cash there. There is already a withdrawal limit on ATMs.

All dats happen now is that the revenue from TSA will include people's personal money that will be fraudulently used. Why extend their thieving reach to people's personal money, people who are already paying taxes?
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by AlPeter: 12:26pm On Sep 21, 2019
Highlights1:
The Central Bank of Nigeria on Friday said it would continue to implement the cashless policy in line with its mandate to ensure an efficient payment system.

The CBN Governor, Mr Godwin Emefiele, said this while briefing journalists shortly after the Monetary Policy Committee meeting.

He said that contrary to claims in some quarters that many Nigerians would suffer the negative impact of the policy, only about five to 10 per of bank customers would be affected.

The apex bank had in a circular to Deposit Money Banks stated that from Wednesday, September 18, it would impose three per cent processing fees on withdrawals and two per cent processing fees on lodgements of amounts above N500, 000 for individual accounts.

For corporate accounts, the apex bank in the circular said that DMBs would charge five per cent processing fees on withdrawals and three processing fee on lodgements of amounts above N3m.

The House of Representatives had on Thursday through a resolution directed the apex bank to suspend the policy.

But responding to the development, Emefiele said if the Nigerian economy was to compete effectively with those of developed countries, a payment system that encourages the use of non-cash channels was desirable.

He said that before the cashless policy was first inaugurated in 2012, a lot of stakeholder engagements were done to sensitise Nigerians on its benefits.

He said the policy was suspended in 2014 to allow more payment channels to be developed by Deposit Money Banks.

The governor said that since the policy was suspended, currency management cost had continued to increase year-on-year at an average annual growth rate of 33 per cent.

However, he said the bank had continued to provide alternative channels, adding that people had embraced it.

He said Point of Sale transactions had moved from N48bn in 2012 to N2.2tn while electronic transfer had moved from N3.8tn in 2012 to N80.46tn in 2018.

Emefiele said, “Since the policy was first launched, currency management costs have continued to increase year-on-year at an average annual growth rate of 33 per cent.

“Notwithstanding, electronic transactions have increased within the economy. We have provided alternative channels and people have embraced it.

“This is a strategic timing of these actions because on Monday, September 23rd, the mutual evaluation by GIABA (Inter-governmental Action Group Against Money Laundering in West Africa) on the country’s anti-money laundry and CFT (Combating Financing of Terrorism) regime will begin.

“Passing the mutual evaluation positions Nigeria as a safe and credible destination for financial transactions across the world.

“GIABA will be in Nigeria to access the rate at which Nigeria has embraced anti-money laundry and CFT regime. It is important that we display and show to them that Nigeria is indeed in conformity with their practices as enshrined in their anti-money laundry and CFA laws.”

The apex bank boss said if the CBN did not implement the cashless policy, credit cards owned by Nigerians might not be used abroad.

On the Value Added Tax, he said the MPC supported the decision of the Federal Government to increase the rate from five per cent to 7.5 per cent.

He said with Nigeria having one of the lowest VAT rate in the world, and faced with fiscal challenge, the best way to shore up revenue was to increase tax.

He said, “The MPC endorsed the increase in the VAT rate from five per cent to 7.5 per cent. The government has the responsibility to fend for everybody.

“In fending for everybody means that it has to spend money to provide infrastructure – roads, airports, different things that will improve the lives of its people.

SOURCE: https://okfiscal.com/cashless-policy-will-only-affect-10-of-nigerians/
This is total bug wash
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by BRATISLAVA: 12:28pm On Sep 21, 2019
heybeemoney:
it will affect 10% of Nigerian?.. Does that implied that only 10% of Nigerian are rich, while d rest are poor?
The example they gave us is that, if we deposit 501,000 the 2% will only be on the excess 1000, amounted to #20 only...
what about if someone deposited 5 millions n the charge will b on the excess 4.5 millions (4,500,000*2% = NGN90,000)...
So bank will collect 90k of my hard earning just for deposit n for the sake of cashless policy?
... furthermore, just of recent FG announced that there will be charges on all online transactions.. why?..
don't forget also forget about VAT of 7%?
7.2%
Then taxes
Then deductions on deposits and withdrawals
Then bank charges
But what is being done with all the money? They should apply this to withdrawals of 50M and above. Those are the people who are the 10%.
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by AlphaT1(m): 12:37pm On Sep 21, 2019
demolinka:
Let's go cashless abeg...long overdue sturvs. Even tintini Kenya no dey too carry cash upandan, we dey carry big strong head dey vex for policy wen go make life easier in the long run.
Embrace the future angry
After 4 years of long run promises una still dey gullible enough to the hope for long run...kwatinu! Go and read about Rwanda and Senegal in those 4yrs...You can't give what you don't have, with Bubu you will suffer and hope for that long run for the next infinite years!
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by alezzy13: 1:17pm On Sep 21, 2019
hush15:
How do you do mobile transfer after collating daily sales to deposit in a bank?
Hmm. I get your point. But I do believe if most of these vendors make etransfers as AN OPTION, the vol of cash might not be eliminated, but would reduce.

The problem is most flatly reject any form of e-transfers.

Typical example: Iya Oyo is one of the biggest amala joint in Abuja, and I have no doubt that her daily sales would exceed 500k given the crowd I see there. However its all the strictly cash, in fact it's stated boldly on the wall.
So it's typical to see people buying food well over 10k but would be forced to pay cash. That doesn't make sense to me.
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by alezzy13: 1:31pm On Sep 21, 2019
Lush100:
Sir, try to understand,
Most people who buy fuel at filling station pay cash.
The turnover for that day if (and most do) the owner has more than 1 filling station will be more than 3M in cash.
They need to pay these cash into their account to then use electronic payment to transfer to the supplier usually at Nnpc depot.
That what he meant.
I purchased fuel and the POS debited me 4k on failed transaction.
It took over 2weeks before I got that money.
If I hadn't any money on me, I would have been stranded.

They should increase the threshold to 750k for individual and 4m for corporate and reduce the charges to like 1%. Then gradually increase these percentages every year.
My 2kobo
I see. Thanks for the matured response.

However to your first point, I think more vendors should make such options available. That way, we may not eliminate cash, but can substantially reduce it. the problem is very few make such option. To the best of my knowledge, only Total does POS.

However your point about failed transactions is certainly a valid problem and indeed a few persons I've interacted with have citied this as one of the singular reason for their refusal to embrace etransfers of any sort. The authorities would do well to look into it.
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by Hausaman(m): 1:44pm On Sep 21, 2019
Lugianostar:
10% or no % percent at all!!!

You guys are doom under that Mundane Daura Man...!
The CBN Governor not Daura man is the cause of this doom.
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by Hasjam(m): 2:00pm On Sep 21, 2019
So only just about 10% of our population can be able to do a transaction of 500K and above? I never knew we are this poor...
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by careidon: 2:21pm On Sep 21, 2019
we are truly poor. yes.

yet you're still missing the issue.

the point is Pareto already analyzed that this 10% owns 90% of the country's wealth put together and they thrive in cash!!!
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by Okoroawusa: 3:56pm On Sep 21, 2019
heybeemoney:
yes my Oga at the top...
you're entitled to your opinions n conclusion...
it possible that you are right or wrong, but that your conclusion is not for me n will never...
Thanks
We don hear
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by leofab(f): 4:58pm On Sep 21, 2019
rottennaija:
If I want to make a transaction of up to 500k, why will I need cash when I can comfortably transfer same amount? I pay my house rent through transfer, I buy stuffs (my TV, sound system, foam, refrigerator) through electronics transfer or POS. My salary is paid through transfer as well.

So, why will I need physical cash?
can you say for that for your dad and uncle’s ?
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by rottennaija(m): 5:01pm On Sep 21, 2019
leofab:
can you say for that for your dad and uncle’s ?
Yes. Any large sum, they have to get use to the fact that they need to embrace a better new way.
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by bskyb(m): 7:26pm On Sep 21, 2019
sureheaven:
Though may be difficult for some to understand because they've been misled by enemies of progress but the fact remains that this policy is new and may be hard in Nigeria but it's the best.
The western world are using cashless policy and is even better and good for prompt transactions .
It reduces excessive spending.
Allow minimization of fiscal expenditure .
In America , the least u can withdraw on the atm a day is $400 cash.
While ur other transactions is based on cashless transfer of transactions. Though u are entitled to come the other day and withdraw again, it will not go beyond same $400.
In all, there will be no development and advancement if we still retard ourselves with the old method of doing things in Nigeria.
Those in Diaspora understand what i am saying.
May God Help us in Nigeria.
Your comment is a breath of fresh air. Most of the comments reek of ignorance or perhaps it's just badbelle
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by themanderon: 8:15pm On Sep 21, 2019
What does he mean by only 10%? Okay they realise that they have so impoverished the people that it'd only 10% that can afford 500k and above? This is just outright stealing from the masses. After implementing failed economic policies that bit the dust they are now looking for how to recoup money to be squandered again.
I thought it was this same man that was caught on tape lamenting on some failed deal and the effect it would have on the economyhuh
Increase in vat and also these tax on lodgements are just means of robbing the already beleaguered people of these nation in order to satisfy the insatiable greed of these ogres in power.
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by GoodFaith:
sureheaven:
Though may be difficult for some to understand because they've been misled by enemies of progress but the fact remains that this policy is new and may be hard in Nigeria but it's the best.
The western world are using cashless policy and is even better and good for prompt transactions .
It reduces excessive spending.
Allow minimization of fiscal expenditure .
In America , the least u can withdraw on the atm a day is $400 cash.
While ur other transactions is based on cashless transfer of transactions. Though u are entitled to come the other day and withdraw again, it will not go beyond same $400.
In all, there will be no development and advancement if we still retard ourselves with the old method of doing things in Nigeria.
Those in Diaspora understand what i am saying.
May God Help us in Nigeria.
Whom told u this nonsense
"In America , the least u can withdraw on the atm a day is $400 cash."
Please stop ur Nigeria lies
The policy of charging people on deposit and withdrawal will not help the cashless goal of Nigeria government
it will discourage people from putting money in the bank or
IF I have 1,500,000.00 to deposit
i will do four transaction of 495,000.00,495,000.00 ,499,000.00 400,000.00 and 120,000.00
I don't understand ur nonsense
Please don't speak of things u don't know
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by hush15: 11:43pm On Sep 21, 2019
alezzy13:
Hmm. I get your point. But I do believe if most of these vendors make etransfers as AN OPTION, the vol of cash might not be eliminated, but would reduce.

The problem is most flatly reject any form of e-transfers.

Typical example: Iya Oyo is one of the biggest amala joint in Abuja, and I have no doubt that her daily sales would exceed 500k given the crowd I see there. However its all the strictly cash, in fact it's stated boldly on the wall.
So it's typical to see people buying food well over 10k but would be forced to pay cash. That doesn't make sense to me.
Exactly,ask uber drivers who have been duped using transfer. As for Iya Oyo, apart from customers who have eaten and playing pranks, he business is such that they refer to cash often, they don't do transfer to the meat sellers, pepper sellers, and other ingredients. She pays some workers on daily basis. Local Government officials comes for cash as well. Financial inclusions of informal sector is poor. Our society is so structured on cash movement even banks are not left out.
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by DeOTR: 2:00am On Sep 22, 2019
When you're trying to encourage people to do something, you don't make it harder for them.
It's common sense, don't charge people on cash deposit. You can then go ahead and put a 10% charge on cash withdrawal in excess of even 300k for individuals and 1.5m for corporate organizations. That way, you're making sure monies that make their ways to the bank don't get out in Cash.
But now, you're imposing a #50 stamp duty on individual PoS transaction, charging 2% on cash deposit in excess of 500k, and at the same time want to encourage people to embrace cashless transactions? It's like saying one thing, but doing the opposite.
Remember, you'll still have to pay VAT on these charges?
Very soon, this idiiot of a CBN Governor will direct banks to start charging people for money transfer per one thousand.
Re: Cashless Policy Will Only Affect 10% Of Nigerians by wisdomchukus199(m): 4:28am On Sep 22, 2019
I Just dey look you with half eye wink wink wink wink wink wink

1 2 3 4 5 Reply

Some Effect Of Cashless Policy • CBN Cashless Policy Is Good For POS Business • Polaris Bank's Notice Of Cashless Policy Implementation • 2 • 3 • 4

Banks Raise ATM Cash Withdrawal Limit To ₦‎200,000 • The Palms Shopping Mall Has Finally Opened • Naira Depreciates Marginally Against Dollar