Christianity Etc › Re: EVOLUTION SPOILER!: Soft Tissue In Dinosaur Fossil, University Settles Scientist by felixomor(op): 11:42am On Aug 19, 2017 |
LightandDarkness: Biologos Logo
Search
Common Questions Blogs Resources Forum “Soft Tissue” in Dinosaur Bones: What Does the Evidence Really Say?
October 19, 2015 | By Scott Buchanan (guest author) on Faith and Science Seeking Understanding
INTRO BY JIM: Paleontologist Mary Schweitzer made worldwide headlines in 2005 for announcing that she had discovered soft tissue preserved in 65 million year old dinosaur fossils. Those who deny the scientific evidence for the old age of the earth have attempted to leverage this discovery to cast doubt on dating methods. But that is a misrepresentation of her findings. Scott Buchanan has meticulously poured through the details of Schweitzer’s work and presented it on the blog, Letters to Creationists. He gives us here a summary of the issues. See also our interview with Schweitzer herself on the blog last year.
For fossils as old as dinosaurs (over 65 million years), the conventional wisdom has been that no original proteins from once-living cells could remain. If the delicate structure of soft body parts is discernable in a fossil, that is normally because these parts were converted to some type of hard mineral during the fossilization process. However, over the past two decades, paleontologist Mary Schweitzer has rocked the world of paleontology by presenting visual evidence of soft tissues recovered from the interior of dinosaur bones, and biochemical evidence indicating that these are in fact the remnants of the original cells and structures from within the dinosaur bone pores. For instance, here is a network of blood vessels, containing little round red things that look like red blood cells:
High magnification of dinosaur vessels shows branching pattern (arrows) and round, red microstructures in the vessels. Source: Schweitzer, et al., “Soft-Tissue Vessels and Cellular Preservation in Tyrannosaurus rex”, Science, 307 (2005) 1952. Reprinted with permission.
Young earth creationists have widely cited these findings as evidence that dinosaur fossils cannot really be millions of years old, and so the rock layers (radioactively dated to more than 65 million years of age) cannot really be millions of years old – and so, it is claimed, the whole old-earth dating edifice collapses. There are multiple reasons why these claims are false. I have read through most of Schweitzer’s papers on this topic, and reviewed the key findings from them in a 25-page article, which is posted on the Letters to Creationists blog as “Dinosaur Soft Tissue”. For lots of data and literature references, that is the place to go. For those who do not want to wade through all that information, here are some key takeaways:
TISSUES AND PROTEINS IDENTIFIED IN DINOSAUR BONES
These remarks pertain mainly to thigh bones from two dinosaur specimens, a T. rex (approx. 68 million years old) and a duckbill hadrosaur (approx. 80 million years old). In both cases, the fossils had been buried in sandstone (which may help wick away destructive enzymes from the corpse) and the fossils were analyzed within a relatively short time after excavation, which minimized degradation from sudden exposure to a new set of environmental conditions.
After dissolving away the mineral portion of the bone with weak acid, various types of flexible structures were recovered. They conform to the microscopic pores of the bone in which they had resided, so they are mainly viewed under a microscope. These structures include transparent, branching hollow vessels corresponding to the blood vessels found in modern animals (e.g. ostriches), and also what look like modern osteocyte (bone) cells. Various biochemical tests have indicated that these structures are composed of animal protein, showing that they derive from the original dinosaur tissue, as opposed to being merely biofilms produced by microbes which invaded the bone pores.
The proteins which have been identified include collagen, actin, and tubulin. These are known to have structures which are resistant to degradation, especially when they are crosslinked. Tests indicate that these proteins from the dinosaur bones are indeed highly crosslinked, which appears to be a key aspect of their longevity.
Iron from blood hemoglobin can be highly effective in promoting this crosslinking and in general passivating the reactive groups on the proteins. Schweitzer’s group performed a dramatic experiment to demonstrate this effect, using modern ostrich blood vessels: the blood vessels which were incubated in a solution of hemoglobin (extracted from the red blood cells of chicken and ostrich) showed no signs of degradation for more than two years. In contrast, the ostrich vessels in plain water showed significant degradation within three days, which is more than 240 times faster degradation than with the hemoglobin. The osteocyte cell remnants from dinosaur fossils are essentially coated with iron-rich nanoparticles.
Beside the effect of iron, being in contact with the mineral walls of the pores, and being sealed in tiny pores, away from the enzymes and other body chemicals, can act to preserve remnants of the original proteins. Also, if soft tissue is initially dried out before it decays, it undergoes changes that make it more stable even if it is later rehydrated. Thus, several plausible mechanisms are known to help explain the preservation of these flexible tissues, and there are likely other factors yet to be discovered.
WIDE VARIATIONS IN TISSUE DECAY RATES
There are plenty of other examples of wide difference in the rates of tissue degradation, besides the ostrich blood vessels cited above. For instance, raw meat may spoil in a few days at room temperature, but will keep for weeks in a refrigerator, and for years if it is frozen or (in the case of country hams) if it is treated with salt and smoke. All the flesh can decay off a human face within a month if a body is left outside. However, this chap found in a Danish peat bog looks pretty fresh after more than 2200 years, demonstrating a difference of more than 25,000 (1 month versus 2200 years) in decay rates:
Tollund bog-man. Source: "Tollundmannen" by Sven Rosborn. Licensed under Public Domain via Commons.
Thus, protein and soft tissue decomposition rates vary enormously, depending on the conditions. Some academics have done lab studies of protein degradation using accelerated conditions of high temperature and high acidity, but it is not valid to extrapolate those results to proteins locked in the pores of dinosaur bones. The reality is that we don’t know, with any precision, how fast proteins degrade under the conditions found in dinosaur fossil bones. Thus, it is incorrect to claim that we know that it is impossible for soft tissue to survive in any form for 80 million years. In contrast, the rates of nuclear decomposition of elements have been measured over and over again, and found to be essentially constant. As discussed in the main article, there are a few conditions where nuclear decay can be accelerated, but these conditions are known and predictable, and do not apply to the rock layers in Montana where these dinosaur fossils were found. Thus, it is absurd and insupportable to set aside the radioactive dating of these rock layers because some partly degraded soft tissue has been found in dinosaur fossils from those layers.
I appreciate the work of BioLogos in helping Christians to understand that we can welcome, rather than fear, the findings of modern science. Mary Schweitzer happens to be a devout evangelical Christian, who finds that her view of the Creator has been enriched, not diminished, as she learns more about the complexities of the natural world.
http://biologos.org/blogs/jim-stump-faith-and-science-seeking-understanding/soft-tissue-in-dinosaur-bones-what-does-the-evidence-really-say
Both the author and Mary Schweitzer are Christians. Already debunked above Follow this quote butterflylion: Oga I am sure you saw where the website clearly stated it was a report from The University College London research team.
That was no theory but evidence of actual scientific research.
Read it again and be healed of ignorance. I say be healed! Be healed! Be healed! Ni oruko Jeeesu! |
Christianity Etc › Re: Pastor Adeboye Kissing His Wife, Foluke (Photos) by felixomor: 11:37am On Aug 19, 2017 |
OtemAtum: Any plan to help get my money back? You didnt have a parish? So you lied, once again |
Christianity Etc › Re: Pastor Adeboye Kissing His Wife, Foluke (Photos) by felixomor: 11:21am On Aug 19, 2017 |
OtemAtum: yes, before I knew of my mission on earth. Which parish of RCCG were you in? |
Christianity Etc › Re: EVOLUTION SPOILER!: Soft Tissue In Dinosaur Fossil, University Settles Scientist by felixomor(op): 11:18am On Aug 19, 2017 |
MrMontella: Utter foolishness on their part, they were already masturbating on the thread, without understanding the story, even the poster sef, You can preserve soft tissue for 65 million years yet you have problems believing people can come back to life from dead..... Your own ignorance comes with hypocrisy! |
Christianity Etc › Re: EVOLUTION SPOILER!: Soft Tissue In Dinosaur Fossil, University Settles Scientist by felixomor(op): 11:12am On Aug 19, 2017 |
Ranchhoddas: You no get shame this guy? I know you love to have the last word. Take your best shot now because our discussion has ended on this thread. Sharrap there. Anything you are exposed on, and have nothing more to say You take this route. Foolishness, instead of you to quietly admit that those bones can never be 65 million years old, you decided to dig up "foolish postulations". Then telling us they were mere "postulate" when it was time to back up. Get out of here, Joker |
Christianity Etc › Re: Pastor Adeboye Kissing His Wife, Foluke (Photos) by felixomor: 11:07am On Aug 19, 2017 |
OtemAtum: The same mouths they use to embezzle our tithes and offerings, they are now using it to kiss themselves. Ride on pastor Adebothief and his wife. We are watching you in 3D  Have u ever paid tithe there? |
Christianity Etc › Re: EVOLUTION SPOILER!: Soft Tissue In Dinosaur Fossil, University Settles Scientist by felixomor(op): 11:04am On Aug 19, 2017 |
LordOfNaira: Stop embarrassing yourself. The guy never said iron preserves soft tissues. It was said by a paleontologist. And it was a postulation that should serve as a basis for argument. Science is not as straightforward as you people think. You cannot just feel you have discovered something and start passing it around as a theory or the truth. Yeah, he never said it But he used it as a basis to call out a discovery made by a scientist. Instead of trying to face the truth that those bones can never be 65 million years old, he chose to call the discovery "pseudoscience".... Please remove the chunk in your eyes, and read the thread properly before writing anything. |
Christianity Etc › Re: EVOLUTION SPOILER!: Soft Tissue In Dinosaur Fossil, University Settles Scientist by felixomor(op): 10:59am On Aug 19, 2017 |
Ranchhoddas: [s]Apart from being a certified m0ron you are also deficient in grammar. Please get a dictionary and look up the meaning of "postulate". Then come back and correct this nonsense you have written.
You are too dull to be real[/s]. Some one quoted research, you said it was from apologetics page And you say i have grammar problems? And then you used "postulate" to conclude that soft tissue can be preserved for 65 million years... And used it as basis to call out the scientist who just won a case.... You are an utter Joke  |
Christianity Etc › Re: EVOLUTION SPOILER!: Soft Tissue In Dinosaur Fossil, University Settles Scientist by felixomor(op): 10:03am On Aug 19, 2017 |
butterflylion: Oga I am sure you saw where the website clearly stated it was a report from The University College London research team.
That was no theory but evidence of actual scientific research.
Read it again and be healed of ignorance. I say be healed! Be healed! Be healed! Ni oruko Jeeesu! I earlier told him he has reading problem. This confirms it. |
Christianity Etc › Re: EVOLUTION SPOILER!: Soft Tissue In Dinosaur Fossil, University Settles Scientist by felixomor(op): 10:02am On Aug 19, 2017 |
Ranchhoddas: This is exactly my point. In science, you continue to build theories, break them down if they don't stand to scrutiny. You continue the process until you get something that is foolproof. You quoted article gave about five examples of that. This is how the scientific method works. Your guy failed to do that and he got fired.
I also noticed that your quoted article did not come with a link. I'm betting that it came from an apologist website. we are still waiting for your demonstration of 65 million years embalmment science secret.Besides, you just said the scientist got fired You just reemphasised the essence of the whole cover up and settling. |
Christianity Etc › Re: EVOLUTION SPOILER!: Soft Tissue In Dinosaur Fossil, University Settles Scientist by felixomor(op): 9:24am On Aug 19, 2017 |
butterflylion: A lot of people sabi yarn but no sabi understand their yarn! Honestly. Jurassic park scientists |
Christianity Etc › Re: EVOLUTION SPOILER!: Soft Tissue In Dinosaur Fossil, University Settles Scientist by felixomor(op): 9:19am On Aug 19, 2017 |
Ranchhoddas: Please read the thread. This was already published in 2005 by NOTABLE PALEONTOLOGIST Mary Schweitzer. His discovery was not new. In science when something is discovered, the next thing is to begin to make postulates which Mary Schweitzer did. Nothing is accepted as absolute truth in science until it is foolproof. You guy did not. He went and began to tell everyone that his discovery validates his beliefs. Very unscientific and he got fired. The University settled because it will be cheaper in the long run than a drawn out legal battle. Anyone who knows the American legal system will see that it was a prudent move. Do a Google search. Mark Armitage is a renowned pseudoscientist. "Nothing is acceptable as fool proof" you say Yet you just told us soft tissue can be preserved by Iron for 65 million years.Wow, Abeg demonstrate that for us and u get a Nobel You are the real pseudoscientist. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheist Neurosurgeon Finds God After Near Death Experience. by felixomor: 9:05am On Aug 19, 2017 |
CatfishBilly: [s]Like I said, christians are too dumb to recognize sarcasm, when you people believe fictional tales like the one from Dr. Eben and the Bible, why did I even expect you guys to understand sarcasm? I over estimated you people's intelligence.
Trust me, I'll never make that mistake again ever. From now on, it's straight talk, no more sarcasm cos y'all are too dumb to get it anyways.
As for you pathophysiology, I can't be sounding like a broken record all the time, y'all know what to do.
Or maybe I should write it and say that Jesus gave it to me while I was having an NDE for 7 days. I'm sure y'all will swallow that shitttt up like a cum hungry whoree[/s] Enough Dog-foolery Give us pathophysiology. Shikena  |
Christianity Etc › Re: EVOLUTION SPOILER!: Soft Tissue In Dinosaur Fossil, University Settles Scientist by felixomor(op): 9:01am On Aug 19, 2017 |
butterflylion: I was about to say 9mobile fall on you but when I saw that they already fell on you since yesterday I had to stop. 
See guy, desperation to sell a lie no dey make the lie to be truth you hear?
A truly scientific mind with ask a simple question. If iron can preserve tissues for so long why then isn't iron used for embalming corpses? If iron can preserve tissues for so long was iron part of the composition of the soil where this particular fossil was found?
You think say the Christian scientist no consider these things before speaking out? They knew they had no case and could not defend anything so they had to cut the guy loose using religious discrimination. At least that's a lesser evil than shooting evolution in the head by exposing this discovery.
They chose to save evolution with $400k 
Scientific thieves. Hehehehe, The guy wanted to clutch straws. You give am straw chop. |
Christianity Etc › Re: EVOLUTION SPOILER!: Soft Tissue In Dinosaur Fossil, University Settles Scientist by felixomor(op): 8:59am On Aug 19, 2017 |
Ranchhoddas: I knew I was about to waste my time. Sorry for disturbing you. Sorry for trying to inconvenience u with wisdom. I should have ignored your mention. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheist Neurosurgeon Finds God After Near Death Experience. by felixomor: 8:57am On Aug 19, 2017 |
CatfishBilly: Baba, na lying for Jesus naa, what else? Favorite Christian pastime. Wey person go commot say he get NDE for a whole 7 days and grown ass folks with brains go swallow am hook line and sinker without doing their due diligence and you talk say them well so?
Well, they believe that fictional book called the Bible, they can believe anything. Gullible people. LMAO  The so called people u call liars exposed your quackery so much so you had to employ " sarcasm" as cop out Secretary..... Lol, We are still waiting for your ground breaking "pathophysiology" .....  |
Christianity Etc › Re: EVOLUTION SPOILER!: Soft Tissue In Dinosaur Fossil, University Settles Scientist by felixomor(op): 8:52am On Aug 19, 2017 |
Ranchhoddas: You don't know what verbatim means? You dont know what read properly means?  |
Christianity Etc › Re: EVOLUTION SPOILER!: Soft Tissue In Dinosaur Fossil, University Settles Scientist by felixomor(op): 8:47am On Aug 19, 2017 |
Ranchhoddas: Stop being silly. Which part of the story? Quote it verbatim? Sharrap. And read the story properly. The school was sued for religious discrimination because of his discovery, and they lost the bid to stop the case before they agreed to settle. |
Christianity Etc › Re: I'm Fedup, What Can I Do? by felixomor: 8:44am On Aug 19, 2017 |
hope4black: Have never done anything successful in my life before, no matter how hard I may try, bad luck has been my middle name. Sometimes I felt God doesn't care about me, and truth be told He doesn't care. Since my childhood have been struggling with life, have never been in a happy mood throughout a day before, either happy in the morning or sad in the night. I tried a lot of things and it never works out,bad luck all the time. I prayed,fast yet God seems so far away, people do say a lot of testimonies about this same God ,I don't even have anothing to say about God in my life, cause no good has ever happened in my life before. This is my seventh years in school meanwhile I'm not a medical or law student, all my mates are 3 years ahead of me in every thing, money,happiness,joy etc. God doesn't care about me I can feel the hatred, have denied Him many times, yet I still find myself beleivig in Him cause I know I'm severing the living God. But now I don't know what to belive in anymore. Maybe there is another God out there who can answer my prayers and turn my life around I really need to know and find him, cause I'm fedup Cheer Up brah The Lord will Show Himself strong in You soon. Your life is not a competition against others 2 Corinthians 10:12 For we dare not make ourselves of the number, or compare ourselves with some that commend themselves: but they measuring themselves by themselves, and comparing themselves among themselves, are not wise.When God is done building your foundation, the building itself will be glorious. The more rugged the foundation, the more glorious the buildingShalom. Amen |
Politics › Re: Probe Obasanjo, Yar’adua, Jonathan Govts Over N11trn Electricity Fund – Serap by felixomor: 8:16am On Aug 19, 2017 |
wolesmile: seriously, you need help. I pray you get it, and soon too Hehehehrhe, Mumudeen, take sense  |
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is Butterflylion? by felixomor: 2:58am On Aug 19, 2017 |
xklass: Butterflylion want to go to bed, but instead,,, felixomor went offline? That cool.
It's getting interesting Only inside your mind, thats where such foolishness is "interesting" Where are the people u called? I told u, they already know this is idiocy |
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is Butterflylion? by felixomor: 2:20am On Aug 19, 2017 |
butterflylion: Felixomor make I go sleep. E be like say some people plan to hold vigil for my matter tonight.  Honestly |
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is Butterflylion? by felixomor: 2:11am On Aug 19, 2017 |
butterflylion: Oya gist us more. Felixomor how you feel? You need a bottle of malt as we receive the gist? The guy's comedy is enough already  |
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is Butterflylion? by felixomor: 2:04am On Aug 19, 2017 |
|
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is Butterflylion? by felixomor: 1:59am On Aug 19, 2017 |
xklass: I caught you on this Felix. You know people on NL have been saying you aint smart but I doubted.
You just proved to me you are butterflylion.
Cc Hahn, hopefullandlord, dalaman, catfishbilly Even the people you called Are going to confirm you foolishness shortly. Or they will pretend they didn't hear u Just wait |
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is Butterflylion? by felixomor: 1:57am On Aug 19, 2017 |
xklass: Now those it may concern.
This thread 99.9% certifies felixomor is butterflylion Shut that trap! |
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheist Neurosurgeon Finds God After Near Death Experience. by felixomor: 1:56am On Aug 19, 2017 |
butterflylion: Guy I am so honoured. Dem don open special thread for me o. One mentally challenged mofo like that called xklass opened a brand new moniker just for my sake.
Yippee! See rep.  LMAO |
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is Butterflylion? by felixomor: 1:54am On Aug 19, 2017 |
xklass: Mr man, stop denying the obvious.
You're Felix and as well spacetacular
To further proof my points, you manifest all traits of Felix.
You sleep on NL, wake up on NL Eiya. The torment is real LMAO  |
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheist Neurosurgeon Finds God After Near Death Experience. by felixomor: 1:52am On Aug 19, 2017 |
edicied: [s]Hahahah how can someone call you felixmoron? now the rest of ur text is irrelevant to me[/s] Not everyone intentionally uses different fake monikers to continuously vomit tomfoolery like you. You may retire from that assumption. |
Politics › Re: Probe Obasanjo, Yar’adua, Jonathan Govts Over N11trn Electricity Fund – Serap by felixomor: 1:50am On Aug 19, 2017 |
|
Politics › Re: Probe Obasanjo, Yar’adua, Jonathan Govts Over N11trn Electricity Fund – Serap by felixomor: 8:56pm On Aug 18, 2017 |
wolesmile: Don't you even see that your level of reasoning is reflective of the fact that your IQ is below average? I won't waste time telling you to receive sense. Obviously, it's a luxury you can't afford. Unfortunately You are the one who just demonstrated slow thinking process..... Mumudeen I thought you said "tonight wasn't the night"? |
Politics › Re: Probe Obasanjo, Yar’adua, Jonathan Govts Over N11trn Electricity Fund – Serap by felixomor: 8:27pm On Aug 18, 2017 |
wolesmile: I see! I think you need a touch of Adeboye's magic wand to restore your senses. Or a touch from Catfishbilly. The fact u had to think twice before getting the point confirms your mental state. Receive Sense!  |