Nairalanda1's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Nairalanda1's Profile › Nairalanda1's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 (of 839 pages)
Guestlander:That Ajaokuta plant, even if they finish it, the palaver is, it would have to compete with cheap chinese steel. Even if they finished the plant in say 1983, it would be forced to close down eventually once cheap chinese steel came in |
BlackViper:True, but here in the South, we have a lot of people who advocate for men keeping side chicks...and suchlike. Guess south too is in need of far reaching social reforms. |
All those men are polygamist geng...this is the end result of such belief. |
PremieJoshua:Oh? PremieJoshua:You are arguing for him, you know. You admit he cannot 'save nigeria' But then you are saying he should stay, because 'he understands how the system works. LOL..Na argument for mediocrity. It is also an argument for Atiku to come and take over, because atiku too has those qualites Even Obi, he is surrounded by folk who do have those abilites. We can't continue with failure because 'they understand'. Personally speaking, you guys really do not want good leaders, na your side you want. You say change has to start somewhere. I agree. But change must also be understood beyond the electoral process. Removing a government is a change in political leadership; it is not necessarily a change in the institutional arrangements that govern how the country functions.And can't the same government change the institutional arrangements? Ironically governments past and present have done so...so what would stop a new government from doing the same. Plus , Nigerian people cannot change things like how the power sector is run and how the transport sector is run, and how security is run. That's the job of the president. Tinubu is strangling the power sector by keeping subsidy, and thus by not making economy productive...which means not enough money for things like security. We can't continue like this, son. Let me make this clearer. If APC leaves and another party takes over, what guarantees that the political incentives responsible for patronage, institutional interference, weak accountability, corruption and poor policy implementation will disappear?So, we should keep the same old corrupt system because another corrupt system go take over? On productivity and security, these are precisely the issues I believe we should examine beyond presidential promises. Productivity depends on much more than a president's willingness to make difficult decisions. It involves electricity, infrastructure, access to capital, technology, skills, industrial capacity, functioning institutions and an environment where businesses can invest and expand.And it is the president's refusal to remove subsides on electricity and allow discos be free to set prices, that is preventing the sector from being profitable enough to invest in infrastructure When I say you tinubu and obi and atiku supporters na the same thing, all of you get angry. Let oga president remove subsidy and allow discos set prices, because we can't continue in darkness doing the same thing we have been doing for over 60 years.! Likewise, security requires functioning intelligence systems, effective policing, coordination between federal and state authorities, judicial effectiveness and institutions capable of responding to threats.Well, so let him improve tax to gdp so that they can raise money for improved security. Even difficult economic decisions, such as subsidy removal, should not be treated as proof of reform simply because they are politically difficult. We must examine their economic justification, implementation, consequences and whether the accompanying institutional and productive reforms actually materialise.So, you tinubu supporters are suddenly opposed to subsidy removal? Well, thanks to your oppositoon in 2012, we lost a chance to improve domestic refining years ago. My argument is not that Nigerians should tolerate poor governance while waiting for some theoretical institutional transformation. It is that we should not mistake changing the people who occupy political offices for changing the system through which those offices operate.That is exactly your argument. We can debate whether APC deserves another term. But that is a different question from whether replacing APC will fundamentally resolve Nigeria's structural problems.Well, you have made up your mind to support APC. I wish we could vote them all out, by the way, but you people don't listen. |
You are not going to have power without a cost reflective tarrif. Ivory coast implemented controlled , but still cost reflective tarrifs, and WB actually invested money into their power sector. World Bank. And before you shout corruption, the leader who implemented the cost reflective tarrifs was removed by the army a few years later for...corruption and he was also a bigot and tribalist. But anytime you mention cost reflective tarrifs to nigerians, you get a long treatsie on how a company can provide good service while operating at bone crushing losses thanks to government price controls. South Africa recently did 500 days of light being on...AND ....they also let ESKOM charge cost reflective tarrifs. Ditto Ghana. Yet, we keep lying to ourselves...lol. Make we get what we paid for. |
VOsimhen144:LOL, you guys should stop looking for sponsors. Like I tell you, you Nigerians do not vote for leaders who would increase domestic productivity. You vote for leaders who share oil money. That means no jobs, and a generation of entitled youth ,some of whom would try to get their hands on their share of oil money by gun shot. I always laugh at people who are shouting education na scam. And at people who laugh at those who do vocational education. THis is the result of that....a large cohort of underemployed and unemployed youth with no jobs , and no prospect of making a decent living. We Nigerians, North and South, are the cause of this problem. We won't vote for our deng and lky, na tinubu and obi and atiku wey dey share us oil money and do free awuff subsidy for us. Yes, fuel subsidy is a cause. Had subsidy gone in 1993, we would have had far more industrial development than we do. Instead we lost four refineries and a lot of industries...and now we are seeing the result. Why should someone go to school and graduate, when theire are no jobs thanks to running a sharing oyel and importing improting economy? We vote for people who share oil money to us to import, and then when the imports close down our productive capacity, leaving no jobs, we shout school na scam...meanwhile na we wey dey cause our problems. |
PremieJoshua:It's a good writeup, but change has to start from somewhere, and it can start from voting out APC... Yeah, I have said the same thing you said, but at the end of the day, you are advocating for the retention of a leader who is not doing anything about actually improving productivity, and security. And taking serious hard decsions like removing electricity subsidy. |
Flangelo12:It's true and at the same time, not true. Iran is being blockaded by the USA so, they can't pay for subsides, but at the same time, Iran would have these issues even if there were no sanctions because subsides are expensive as f. |
TrafficBOOSTERS:Because healthcare spending is low, and because our government doesn't do enough to raise money for budgeting for health. The way out is taxing the majority of nigerians who do not pay tax, plus allowing teaching hospitals to go private, and focusing spending on seconday and tertiary hosptials, as well as diversifying the economy to raise money ...for healthcare budget. The thing is, for all the benefits you want for doctors, money has to come from somewhere, and it won't come from less than 1.7 million bpd for 237 million people. So, taxes in short term, diversifying the economy long term. We also have to spend more on education, meaning more universites, medical schools, nursing schools, lab scientists school, etc etc...because it is not by doctor that hospital runs...ya need nurses, pharmacists, lab scientists, etc etc...even maintenance guys to fix the machine when it breaks down. And this one where our budget is less than 50 billion dollars...when countries like Spain spend three times that for a population that has not hit 40 million.....on HEALTH alone...I doubt we can stop brain drain (Though with the way UK is going, they may be able to train more of their doctors at home. Former PM Sunak opened three new medical schools when he was in power....and Labour is talking of doing more of that too.). |
Yampotatocarrot:Unfortunately not. Again, subsidy removal only means that 60% of oil revenue, our main earner is being spent on debt servicing...not the 90% it was prior to subsidy removal It does not increase nigeria's overall revenue, nor does it make us able to afford subsidy. Even if we fight corruptuon,...which none of our politicans are willing to do....it won't change the matter. Plus, oil prices are so volatile, costs of subsidy would be markedly high. Add the fact that our population is constantly growing, and that means higher fuel consumption, which would be worsened by fuel being cheap The result is government massively borrowing to keep subsidy. I haven't even mentioned smuggling, which would jump up with a subsidy. The main issue with subsidy is not corruption per se...it is high oil prices pushing up costs of production, as well as higher consumption rates when fuel is cheaper, plus higher levels of smuggling...which push up the subsidy cost for one year way beyond what the budget can cover....resulting in more borrowing and more of the budget being spent on subsides. That's why I cannot stand APC,...THEY Knew this in 2012, yet opposed subsidy removal. On another note, if Atiku is one of the main importers of generators as widely rumoured, I don't think he'll want to do anything to help in the electricity sectorELectricity is easy...remove subsidy on power, electricity would be profitable enough to improve things. Nigerians do not want that...meanwhile we spend far more on generator costs than we would have if electricity tarrifs were cost reflective. |
zenburster:You really are a riot... Go run for office, my darling child. |
zenburster:Looks like you don't want to run for office, so stop grumbling, son. ![]() |
zenburster:Okay, so do you, asa young nigerian have the time, money or willingness to run for any office? |
Atiku is 79 , tinubu is in his seventies, even Obi is old. And no, the problem is, most younger nigerians are too busy building their familes and lives to do political politics..really. It's the older ones that have time. |
Akalia:I supported subsidy removal from back in 2012 after I listened to the then government propaganda on the matter, and have done so since then.Before then, I was pro-subsidy. I even always parroted the same old story...it is the only benefit poor people get from government. What changed my mind was 1. Realizing what a subsidy was 2. Seeing what GEJ did with subsidy savings. SUREP and some other projects. And realizing he did that with partial removal of subsidy. It freaked me out and made me realize that I had been complicit in the wreckage of my country. Also, nothing like subtle justification...infact the danger signs have always been there. The Nigerian guardian published an article in 2022 august showing how bad things were as a result of subsidy. And they are not tinubu supporters.HERE IS THE ARTICLE. I strongly suggest you read it...you would see why obi, atiku and tinubu were all pro-subsidy removal then. Also, I did not vote for tinubu, never have voted for him, and he is an evil person. Period. You guys need to realize that sometimes some economic polices need to be supported without thinking about politics, son. You can blast a leader, like I do, and still support some of the policies if it is in the interest of the nation. You claim paying fuel subsidy is a major economic problem but since the fuel subsidy was removed , one would have thought that the borrowing would reduce but instead the borrowing increased so much so that relatively the current government that removed fuel subsidy took more loans than the past governments that paid fuel subsidies.Yeah, because our income has been based on crude oil. ANd crude oil alone. Tax revenue which would have helped to reduce borrowing is so low because of poverty. So, massive borrowing. If not for debt forgiveness in 2005, our debt by now would have been so large that subsides on education and healthcare would have gone too. If you think that less than 2 million bpd revenue from crude can satisfy 237 million people, I have a building in Kuwait and Beijing to sell you. If you read my posts, you go see I shout about industrialization and diversifying away from oil a lot.ANd taxation, so that in the end borrowing reduces. Plus sixty percent of our oil revenue goes from debt servicing. When we had subsidy it was 90% of oil revenue. Please don't put words into my mouth, as you are basically lying against me to prove your so called point. Please make it make sense to me why that is so?I just did. |
YankeeMan101:1. USA Has targetted subsides, not the one where dem go sell fuel at 50 cents a gallon and then pay the difference in consumption subsides. Fuel is sold at market price, and depending on the state, dem go add taxes ontop eg California. 2.USA also taxes people at rates that if any Nigerian leader were to try it here, he would be run out of Abuja before 12 midnight tonight. I no dey joke. Any Nigerian leader that passes American style tax laws here in naija would be run out of Abuja, and even his tribesmen would tell him to get out of the country and never come back. 1 Russia $113.8bn1. Russia has a diversified economy, and also crucially makes refineries from scratch inhouse. That helps with cost. Nigeria can't do that, and as for our economy..lol 2. Debt. 2 Iran $104.6bnDebt. Iran's per capita debt is worse than Nigeria.Also, subsidy exists for 50 liters of fuel. Anything more than that, you pay market price. Iran also makes refinery components at home too. 3 India $60.8bnTargetted, not consumption. 4 China $49.9bnTargetted, not consumption. 5 Saudi ArabiaSaudi arabia produces 11 million bpd and has 40 million people and 15.8 million vehicle owners. Nigeria produces 1.7 million bpd and has 12 million vehicle owners. Do the math. 6 Indonesia $27.9bnTargetted, 7 Egypt $25.5bnPhased out. ALso targetted. 8 Algeria $23.8bnAlgeria has less than 40 million people and produces 1.0 m bpd. And it is straining their economy. 9 Iraq $14.7bnSame situation as Saudi. 10 United Arab Emirates $14.7bnSame situation as Saudi 11 Kazakhstan $11.4bnTARGETTED...and even then, it is straining their economy. 12 Uzbekistan $10.9bnPhasing out fuel subsides, and replacing them with targetted spending on poor people 13 Malaysia $8.3bnOnly for 200 liters monthly, anything over, you pay market price. 14 Kuwait $8.0bnKuwait has 5 million people and produces twice as much crude as NIgeria. Of course they can afford it, son. 15 Turkmenistan $7.8bnIt is there, but once upon a time they had 'free fuel'. Also being removed gradually. 16 Venezuela $7.5bnVenezuela is heavily in debt and also lost it;s only mega refinery thanks to years of subsidy. One would think the country was being run by Nigerians self. 17 Pakistan $7.3bnLOL...it is so expensive that fuel is smuggled in from Iran. 18 Ukraine $5.5bnTARGETTED 19 Bangladesh $5.2bnDIfficult to maintain, and straining their budget badly, and leaving a large fiscal hole. 20 Qatar $4.7bn[/quote]Qatar has one million people and can produce 1.8 million bpd. I mean, this is the country that hosted a whole world cup without breaking a sweat. They can afford it. Now can Nigeria with 237 million people and a budget of 50 billion dollars afford a subsidy that may cost up to half or more of that budget? |
Nteogwuija:LOL...you get Nigerians well But even then on a more serious note, even many educated nigerians dem believe in the pandering too. |
Nteogwuija:Nigerians need to stop listening to pandering IN 2012, we could not afford fuel subsidy. That one was true. But Nigerians preferred to listen to pandering. Our not removing fuel subsidy then is a big part of why we have the bad economic issues we have now. Same thing in 1992 when they told us to remove subsidy. Same result. At some point, we need to stop looking at daily bread, and start looking at sustained bread production, and thinking for tomorrow...otherwise, we would forever lurch from bad economy to bad economy forever, even if we break up. |
Africans should also apologise to Africans for slavery. African tribes kidnapped and sold other africans to themselves and to europeans and arabians. Yes, this is the truth we no dey tell ourselves. Arabs should apologise, that one is true, but we must face the fact that slavery was a way of life in subsaharan africa, and unfortunately it was the whites that ended it, not we Africans. We also willingly sold other Africans to arabs and europeans. Let's not pretend that this was a one way street. |
Atiku is going to win, but he would never restore subsidies Here is the harsh fact of our budget....over half of it is borrowed. Over 60% of our oil revenue is going to fund debt repayments. We still need to borrow more money to fund next year's budget...and our tax revenue, VAT and customs duties included, as well as income tax revenue form less than 20% of the same budget In short, we have no money for subsidy, and we can't borrow our way out of it. I know people go abuse me, call me corruption defending person, etc...but the honest fact is, our leaders have not made enough money for our country. And the painuflul thing is stealing happens on top of the matter. And the painful thing is that even if we remove stealing the money still won't be enough. What's worse..monies spent on vp lodge, yacht, cars, etc...won't be enough to fund any subsidy at all at all. So, if Atiku or anyone else brings back subsidy, in a few years, we would be in such a bad state financially...that salaries would be in arreas, many things won't be paid for, and projects would grind to a halt. And we would be in serious financial troblule...worse than where we are right now. And that cheap fuel you asked for would be scarce, because dem go sell am for black market at N6000 per liter. Yes, you can abuse me, but there is fiction, and there is reality P.S I am not arguing for tinubu's reelection. I am voting for Obi, but I have also predicted an atiku win, most likely by a slight margin or runoff. If you read this as support for tinubu, then am sorry for thee. I have supported fuel subsidy removal since 2011/12/. |
zoghys:Yeah, yeah, yeah, so we should keep on voting for tinubu because obi na fraud...when tinubu is no better? You guys have never had a good enough leader |
Freshtruth:THe guy is an adult. He has the right to not be interested in his father's politics. He has a life, and things to do. Many politican's kids don't have interest in what their parent's do. And it's ok. Meanwhile 1. What is your candidate doing about corruption? 2. Subsides on electricity...going or not? 3. How is the war against corruption? 4. Security, anyone? |
Greenodds:So, that means that no nigerian state should introduce it, because some countries have introduced it for years? OK o, |
The problem is, NIgerians do not want leaders that would take the hard decisons needed to change nigeria (sorry tinubu fans, but tinubu is not that kind of leader). Nigerians want leaders that would feed them and feed them |
Lifediary:LOL...but you are, son. Otherwise, you won't have written this. |
Johnrake69:11 trillion would have covered subsidy ....some four years ago. By 2023, it was 12 trillion in the first six months of the year. It costs even more today to keep a decent enough subsidy at the level where it was in Jan 2023, and it gets worse especially since oil prices are bound to be more volatile if this iran thingie doesn't end. Yes, keep in mind that the naira has been devalued and oil prices have risen . That's why subsidy costs have gone up. Add the fact that once subsidy is in place, smuggling is going to ramp up. And this time it would be at our expense, whether we like it or not. (There is still smuggling, but not one kobo from treasury is going on it, unlike when we had a subsidy). Plus, where are we going to get the money from.? Over half of the budget is borrowed, at least 60% of oil revenue is going to debt servicing for debts incurred since 2007. When we had subsidy it was over 90% by August 2022. I hate this government. I hate corruption and how corrupt this government is, but there is fantasy, and there is reality. Even if we somehow miraculosuly destroy corruption tomorrow., any subsidy means massive increase in borrowing and debt. |
Johnrake69:Yes, all that is wrong, but subsidy costs would be higher than 20 billion dollars yearly. For fuel alone. |
BeardGangJnr1:Son, how can the borrowing stop when all of you support governments that do not make us productive enough, fight corruption, and raise enough money from tax to reduce borrowing? Please, think about it. You all are the same, tinubu and non tinubu supporters. You all want to chop , not to develop. |
Reference:I have mentioned the solution, na you wey no wan listen If you want subsidy, I am not blocking you from getting it. Ask your senator to pass the laws. We can't afford a subsidy. We never were. Sorry it hurts you so bad. And sorry you so angry about it. But it's life, son, it's life. |
greatiyk4u:We have lost those refineries permanently. Once we stopped doing TAM from 1994-2010, that was it. That's why subsidy should have gone, so that enough profit would have been made to keep the refineries running. Plus, you guys have so much fixation on oyel...you won't vote for nigerian leaders that would make thee more productive, you vote for tinubu instead. |
Lifediary:Saying that subsidy is wrong doesn't mean I support corruption, man. Be more mature in your response. |
