Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,151,337 members, 7,811,978 topics. Date: Monday, 29 April 2024 at 04:05 AM

Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better - Car Talk - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Car Talk / Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better (1186 Views)

Crankshaft And It's Functions / Pls Help ES350 Damaged Crankshaft / How To Replace A Crankshaft Pulley And Conventional V Belts For A Honda Accord (2) (3) (4)

(1) (Reply) (Go Down)

Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by romityl: 7:11am On Jul 11, 2021
Good morning Everyone ,I have a serious issue I need an opinion to make a decision .I got a car last week a Hyundai Elantra 2007 model and went to show my mechanic .have not noticed smoke from the engine ,but the mechanic said my crankshaft is bad ,that I should bring my engine so he will replace it with another customer who got a new engine because his engine was smoking....
My questions are as follows
1. Can I manage my engine till the end of the year and get a new engine at once despite the bad crankshaft .
2. Should I accept that other customers engine and allow him to rings it for me ?
3. Should I allow him to remove that customer crankshaft and replace it with my own ?
These are all the options I have and am beginning to be confused .
And if anyone has the price of the actual cost of a 2007 Hyundai Elantra can put me on notice pls ...
Thanks for your advice guys .
Re: Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by Conner44: 7:28am On Jul 11, 2021
that engine is very pricey. try to avoid getting a new one if you can.

what makes an engine smoke is usually bad piston rings in the cylinder or bad valve seals in the head.

the crankshaft is an easy one off part to change in an engine. you should only need new gaskets, coolant and the replacement crankshaft for the job.

since the engine is not a cast iron type but aluminium you will need an expert hands in opening and closing it up according to strict manufacturer clearances and specification.

if you leave the bad crankshaft invthe engine it will affect your liftersband valves and affect engine power/performance greatly and a botched job will mean you buy a replacement engine sooner.

1 Like

Re: Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by EkoErrands: 7:33am On Jul 11, 2021
Bro as long as the car isn't smoking...dont touch the engine...just do your regular oil changes and continue to use the car until the engine breaks then you change it. Dont ever go into trying to repair an engine. Never do that.

4 Likes

Re: Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by Kewtt: 7:34am On Jul 11, 2021
romityl:
Good morning Everyone ,I have a serious issue I need an opinion to make a decision .I got a car last week a Hyundai Elantra 2007 model and went to show my mechanic .have not noticed smoke from the engine ,but the mechanic said my crankshaft is bad ,that I should bring my engine so he will replace it with another customer who got a new engine because his engine was smoking....
My questions are as follows
1. Can I manage my engine till the end of the year and get a new engine at once despite the bad crankshaft .
2. Should I accept that other customers engine and allow him to rings it for me ?
3. Should I allow him to remove that customer crankshaft and replace it with my own ?
These are all the options I have and am beginning to be confused .
And if anyone has the price of the actual cost of a 2007 Hyundai Elantra can put me on notice pls ...
Thanks for your advice guys .
How did he know that your crankshaft is bad. What are your specific symptoms?

1 Like

Re: Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by romityl: 7:43am On Jul 11, 2021
@ corner44 how much is the cost of the engine if I may ask
Re: Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by romityl: 7:45am On Jul 11, 2021
Ekoerran noted ...
Re: Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by romityl: 7:46am On Jul 11, 2021
@kewtt he said he is hearing a korkor noise when he gives it fire ...n he said it the crankshaft ...
Re: Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by Kewtt: 8:08am On Jul 11, 2021
romityl:
@kewtt he said he is hearing a korkor noise when he gives it fire ...n he said it the crankshaft ...
Are you hearing the korkorkor too?
Re: Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by MARKone(m): 9:53am On Jul 11, 2021
romityl:
@kewtt he said he is hearing a korkor noise when he gives it fire ...n he said it the crankshaft ...

Better go for a second opinion from another Mechanic, which one be korkor noise.

2 Likes 1 Share

Re: Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by chillex8(m): 10:10am On Jul 11, 2021
romityl:
@ corner44 how much is the cost of the engine if I may ask
Over 600k, If its the 1.6L engine.

Less than 200k, if its the 2.0L engine.

Choose your poison
Re: Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by romityl: 3:01pm On Jul 11, 2021
@ chillex I just discovered mine is the 2.0ltr engine which they say has iron block ...am sure it the 1.6ltr that is aluminium ...so happy so anyday engine vex I can go for a direct engine ...have sent the pic to some few dealers a few have agreed on 180k for a first grade ..
Re: Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by romityl: 3:02pm On Jul 11, 2021
@ mark one me tire for the guy oh
Re: Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by romityl: 3:03pm On Jul 11, 2021
Kewtt me I no hear like that o
Re: Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by Kewtt: 3:37pm On Jul 11, 2021
romityl:
Kewtt me I no hear like that o
Carry your car run.
Re: Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by nurey(m): 10:21am On Jul 12, 2021
romityl:
@ mark one me tire for the guy oh

You are a very wi ked, selfish and self-centered human being, how will the mechanic celebrate the Salah holidays if you refuse to change cranshaft?
Re: Bad Crankshaft And Bad Rings Which Is Better by Kewtt: 12:39pm On Jul 12, 2021
nurey:


You are a very wi ked, selfish and self-centered human being, how will the mechanic celebrate the Salah holidays if you refuse to change cranshaft?
You're hilarious

(1) (Reply)

Camry Muscle 08 For Sale / 2007 Camry Le / Opel Astra 1.6 For Sale

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 20
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.