₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,370 members, 8,522,649 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 November 2026 at 06:04 PM

Toggle theme

30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime - Politics (4) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime (31911 Views)

1 2 3 4 5 6 Reply (Go Down)

Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by sapientia(m): 12:21pm On Sep 10, 2021
I don't get it ..

Is FIRS not FG?

Why are they ranting?

This is a disgrace
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by egoldman(m): 12:22pm On Sep 10, 2021
DubaiLandLord:
FIRS should just renogotiate with the major states. For example, Lagos State, FCT, Rivers and the rest of the states can keep 50-60% of what she generates, why the rest of the 40% will be shared among the 36 stayed and the FCT equally.

There can be a timeline, It can be till 2030. Between 2021 and 2030, the rest of the states go don dey work hard, towards creating a conducive environment for business to be establish in each State.


This will be a win win situation for the states and FG.
Story, so by 2030 kano religiois police would stop destroying southern businesses in the name of sharia? Can u now see the stupidity of trying to impose sharia along secular constitution in a democracy?
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by LegalWolf: 12:24pm On Sep 10, 2021
chiedu7:
As Zamfara enjoys its Gold, let the states in the South Enjoy their own resource
Lol, less than 3 out of 17 states are viable. See, I agree that many Northern states are unviable but the same thing applies to the South. Simple! A huge chunk of southern people/state will suffer as much as Northerners
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by egoldman(m): 12:26pm On Sep 10, 2021
Nothern Nigeria can now see how sharia is setting back while other make progress.

You now now wants to survive with VAT collected from heathen states abi?
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by LegalWolf: 12:28pm On Sep 10, 2021
Anaerobi:
Lol... This is getting interesting.

From the Chart above, those are the state with least VAT collection. But even at that, Bayelsa have 8 local government, Jigawa 27, Adamawa 21, Niger 25, Yobe 17.

Those state have x2 of Bayelsa, yet Bayelsa collects more taxs than them...

But if you check well, they get more FG allocation than Bayelsa.....


It's obvious that the South, West and East are the people sustaing this country.

The north are just parasite.



Mod if u like, ban me like you usually do whenever I say the truth.... But that's just the gospel truth...
FG allocation or VAT allocation? Most of you are more sentimental than rational. You express opinions based on emotions rather than thinking. The stats here pertains to VAT and the structure of sharing was well articulated, yet in order to say 'north is a parasite, you muddled up the issue
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by LegalWolf: 12:29pm On Sep 10, 2021
vinceyinnovation:
Will this VAT change the of garri in the market?

I will be watching...

Good news anyways for those who will be able to loot the VAT...
It actually will in Rivers state ooo. Small businesses were not exempted from VAT in the Rivers State Law unlike what is applicable under the VAT Act and the Finance Acts
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by Nobody: 12:31pm On Sep 10, 2021
SEGLIZ:
I'm in support of this, real sense in this. the fellowship in Nigeria needs learn sense by fire by force.

let such state collapse and merge or return to its mother state where it was carve out from.

the creation of state was for Nigeria to be manageable but the reverse is now our case. mind you those that created many states did for the reasons we are experiencing today (divide and rule). a system where we won't see ourselves as one.
I don't know why some Nigerians cannot acknowledge this option as a legitimate way out. Unviable States should simply merge with others to survive and thrive.

Is it by force to be a State, for the sake of that alone, that local government areas in Lagos , like Surulere, are richer than?
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by Decency2020(f): 12:32pm On Sep 10, 2021
Nobody is going bankrupt if they shun embezzlement and fat salaries to law makers, if people who are knowledgeable are allowed to manage the states and not the likes of Masari that is paying the bandits from vat money collected from the southern states
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by meccuno: 12:33pm On Sep 10, 2021
DubaiLandLord:
FIRS should just renogotiate with the major states. For example, Lagos State, FCT, Rivers and the rest of the states can keep 50-60% of what she generates, why the rest of the 40% will be shared among the 36 stayed and the FCT equally.

There can be a timeline, It can be till 2030. Between 2021 and 2030, the rest of the states go don dey work hard, towards creating a conducive environment for business to be establish in each State.


This will be a win win situation for the states and FG.
Rubbish talk. Vote wisely grin
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by vinceyinnovation: 12:34pm On Sep 10, 2021
LegalWolf:
It actually will in Rivers state ooo. Small businesses were not exempted from VAT in the Rivers State Law unlike what is applicable under the VAT Act and the Finance Acts
Hmmm
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by onuman: 12:36pm On Sep 10, 2021
cocolacec:
https://dailytrust.com/30-states-risk-bankruptcy-as-lagos-rivers-set-for-new-vat-regime
Good morning to Lagos and Rivers state.

Is it not Too late for VAT going to the states where VAT is sourced;
after more than 40 years north used its military dictators to proliferate 19 states in the old northern region, purposely to rob the southern regions of their VAT and other proceeds accruing from the mineral resources in the south? Many northern states destroy alcohol beverages from where loads of VAT money accrue to the National purse, but come monthly to Abuja to get federal allocations partly derived from VAT.
After proliferating states in the north, with accruing political over representation in the National Assembly, southerners ask for political restructuring, northerners tell southerners to come to the National Assembly for political restructuring, knowing full well that the National Assembly is overpopulated by northern legislators who will never vote for the sort of political restructuring asked for by southerners.

In no other country formed by different regions was land mass or population ever used as yardstick to proliferate too many new states or regions in the area with larger land mass or population, except in Nigeria.

Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by Nobody: 12:40pm On Sep 10, 2021
LegalWolf:
Lol, less than 3 out of 17 states are viable. See, I agree that many Northern states are unviable but the same thing applies to the South. Simple! A huge chunk of southern people/state will suffer as much as Northerners
You are still missing what is very obvious. Na by force to be a "State"? If you cannot afford private schooling for your child, does that mean you will let that child remain illiterate at home rather than send them to a government School?

Mindless vanity is the problem of the black man. Unviable States, whether Northern or Southern, should merge with bigger States to drastically lessen the financial burden some unfeasible States are carrying currently.

When the going gets tough the tough get going.
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by jacoik(m): 12:44pm On Sep 10, 2021
Amperes:
Positive change is always painful, this is exactly what we need to move forward as a nation. every state should hustle for its own money, same thing should happen with oil, i dont care if the oil producing states get all the oil money. zamfara mines gold and keeps all the proceeds to themselves, but they will be quick to share oil money from Delta state. most of the countries nigerians now run to are very small countries with strong economy. Singapore is smaller than Lagos state yet Lagos is the smallest state in Nigeria. Lagos makes more money than all the northern states combined. it is not by creating 44 local governments in Kano state just so you can have a lion share of money coming from Rivers. The exploitation has to stop.
may our ancestors bless you more for this bitter truth bro
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by mema900: 12:44pm On Sep 10, 2021
techwaya:
I said it earlier,this tax formulae will not work some States will just collapse,this is more like resources control.
When their is a problem, people are forced to think. If those states collapse, they will be forced to find a way out
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by Sleekfingers: 12:46pm On Sep 10, 2021
cocolacec:
https://dailytrust.com/30-states-risk-bankruptcy-as-lagos-rivers-set-for-new-vat-regime
That's good news.....they can't be sharing money generated from lagos, rivers , Kaduna and delta to all those useless godforsaken states , especially northern states.....they are totally useless....... especially sokoto, kogi, taraba, kebbi, borno, yobe, katsina , benue, niger, plateau states......

And also these useless states in the south..... especially Bayelsa, ebonyi , ekiti , abia , cross rivers and akwa ibom.....


Lagos should do the necessary, cuz we need the money more in lagos....we are over 25million people in lagos. And those useless states that not generating or contributing anything to be benefiting from our sweat......bunch of parasites......
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by jacoik(m): 12:47pm On Sep 10, 2021
arthurwillia:
Bayelsa with their problem

Abeg so what will FIRS now do if they stop collecting t VAT?
so many other work dey for them to do. After all Lagos gutter is very dirty, maybe they will start from there
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by onuman: 12:49pm On Sep 10, 2021
Amperes:
Positive change is always painful, this is exactly what we need to move forward as a nation. every state should hustle for its own money, same thing should happen with oil, i dont care if the oil producing states get all the oil money. zamfara mines gold and keeps all the proceeds to themselves, but they will be quick to share oil money from Delta state. most of the countries nigerians now run to are very small countries with strong economy. Singapore is smaller than Lagos state yet Lagos is the smallest state in Nigeria. Lagos makes more money than all the northern states combined. it is not by creating 44 local governments in Kano state just so you can have a lion share of money coming from Rivers. The exploitation has to stop.
Oil? Telling north to give up revenues from oil, is like pushing Arewa to actualize Sovereign Arewa Islamic Sharia Republic which political and religious leaders created its boundary between 1999-2001, when unconstitutional Islamic Sharia criminal laws were adopted by Arewa leaders.
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by Tonytonex(m): 12:52pm On Sep 10, 2021
Thermodynamics:
States de collect VAT Lagos sef wan still de collect VAT, Lagos when the whole Nigeria de feed. Lagos is a metropolitan city that was built by the entire Country. There is nothing special about the place, if not for sea port, Lagos for be like Ogun or Abia, there are sea ports in Calabar, Warri and Port Harcourt, but in a bid to make Lagos the center of attraction, the federal government refuse to grant license to the sea ports in Niger Delta.

I support that each start should collect their VAT but Lagos nor join, Lagos is for the entire Country. The state nor even get any resources, unlike Rivers State which has an intrinsic value.
you seems to forget that Lagos was once the capital of this country. And also its geological location and or/features.
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by nuruajao: 12:53pm On Sep 10, 2021
arthurwillia:
Bayelsa with their problem

Abeg so what will FIRS now do if they stop collecting t VAT?
Good question that need answers sharply
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by Nobody: 12:54pm On Sep 10, 2021
onuman:
Good morning to Lagos and Rivers state.

Is it not Too late for VAT going to the states where VAT is sourced;
after more than 40 years north used its military dictators to proliferate 19 states in the old northern region, purposely to rob the southern regions of their VAT and other proceeds accruing from the mineral resources in the south? Many northern states destroy alcohol beverages from where loads of VAT money accrue to the National purse, but come monthly to Abuja to get federal allocations partly derived from VAT.
After proliferating states in the north, with accruing political over representation in the National Assembly, southerners ask for political restructuring, northerners tell southerners to come to the National Assembly for political restructuring, knowing full well that the National Assembly is overpopulated by northern legislators who will never vote for the sort of political restructuring asked for by southerners.
Brilliant. Someone who gets the whole picture. Many States were not created to improve the overall administrative efficiency and productivity of Nigeria.

Many of the most recently created States of Nigeria are vanity projects delivered to deliberately aid an agenda of political/administrative robbery and injustice.

If, predictably, they are not viable today then why not merge them with the States they were excised from to improve the economic and administrative prospect of Nigeria?

This is why Nigerians deserve their scam kingpin image. We are a group of people always happy to scam everyone including ourselves. Many States were created to perpetrate scams and support fraudulent claims to the money coming from the center.

We must make the center unattractive by all means. That is the only way out for Nigeria. To make the center unattractive, States must be empowered aggressively at the expense of the Federal Government.

This will mean that States that cannot function well ,after gaining more autonomy, had no business being States in the first place. They should simply merge with bigger and viable States asap.

If Nigeria ends up with 18 workable States then so be it.
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by chiedu7: 12:54pm On Sep 10, 2021
LegalWolf:
Lol, less than 3 out of 17 states are viable. See, I agree that many Northern states are unviable but the same thing applies to the South. Simple! A huge chunk of southern people/state will suffer as much as Northerners
The southern states can raise revenue themselves, they have real population that u can count, unlike the Norths fictitious numbers .
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by Sleekfingers: 12:58pm On Sep 10, 2021
Thermodynamics:
States de collect VAT Lagos sef wan still de collect VAT, Lagos when the whole Nigeria de feed. Lagos is a metropolitan city that was built by the entire Country. There is nothing special about the place, if not for sea port, Lagos for be like Ogun or Abia, there are sea ports in Calabar, Warri and Port Harcourt, but in a bid to make Lagos the center of attraction, the federal government refuse to grant license to the sea ports in Niger Delta.

I support that each start should collect their VAT but Lagos nor join, Lagos is for the entire Country. The state nor even get any resources, unlike Rivers State which has an intrinsic value.
Wetin your useless state governor dey do or don do for your state? Nobody force anybody to come to lagos...stay in your useless state and develop it.....na by force to come to lagos?

Wetin you expect....lagos was the formal capital of this country and also the commercial centre ....and do you expect the FG to not do anything? Since the capital have been moved to Abuja....the FG have abandoned most structures......most of them are decaying or all ready decayed......

From 1999 till date , na FG still dey develop lagos abi? Wetin your useless governors dey use the money dem dey collect from FG purse dey do? Or the peanut your state is generating do?
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by kindlyheart: 1:02pm On Sep 10, 2021
I am 100% in support of rivers and Lagos. people will start voting their state governors wisely, not based on sentiments or emotions. if a governor can't use his brain, then he is in for a very long hungry tenure.
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by oyatz(m): 1:03pm On Sep 10, 2021
Ekakamba:



This is what happens when you get married to an intellect (both gender). I think Gov. Wike's wife with the help of her colleagues notifies her husband about these VAT loopholes and how to turn them around for the State's benefit.

I might be wrong though. grin tongue
They have been legal fireworks since 2011 about VAT in this country when LASG took the matter to court.
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by ojsmscom(m): 1:03pm On Sep 10, 2021
Even the just concluded petroleum industry act is one of the reasons to tell you to bite the north whenever you have the opportunity.. imagine how the whole southerners were crying and begging national assembly to reversed the 3% for oil communities and 30% for nothern states, they didn't even do as if the crying southerners are human being, they went ahead and bass the bill and ask the complaining southerners to go to hell...
Just wait,some southern states are preparing to pass bill and control their resources by themselves..we don't know anything about the 1999 constitution we are governed by any law made by our state assembly.the 1999 constitution is for the north,the Southern state assembly law is what the southern states participated in making.we did not participate in making the 1999 constitution if you want one Nigeria let us sit on one table and discuss the kind of law we want to govern us not the 1999 constitution that is written with tribal hatred...
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by SweetiliciousD: 1:04pm On Sep 10, 2021
BKayy:
You people really believe Nigerian statistics?
If you do then shame on you, you don't use your brain.
If we are to go with Nigerian statistics, the states that should have been complaining is SE states but somehow, those the statistics favour, ie those that are population and financial hubs of the country are chewing their tongue.
What does that mean? Those statistics have been wrong all these while.
You think Ebonyi is broke?
Why is the Governor not complaining?
This VAT is exposing the fraud in Nigeria.
All hail Biafra.

Bifra is here
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by Tareq1105: 1:05pm On Sep 10, 2021
techwaya:
I said it earlier,this tax formulae will not work some States will just collapse,this is more like resources control.
Exactly what it is.
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by oyatz(m): 1:08pm On Sep 10, 2021
Thermodynamics:
States de collect VAT Lagos sef wan still de collect VAT, Lagos when the whole Nigeria de feed. Lagos is a metropolitan city that was built by the entire Country. There is nothing special about the place, if not for sea port, Lagos for be like Ogun or Abia, there are sea ports in Calabar, Warri and Port Harcourt, but in a bid to make Lagos the center of attraction, the federal government refuse to grant license to the sea ports in Niger Delta.

I support that each start should collect their VAT but Lagos nor join, Lagos is for the entire Country. The state nor even get any resources, unlike Rivers State which has an intrinsic value.
The Lagos House of Assembly have passed the VAT law. You can challenge this law in court
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by genii96(m): 1:12pm On Sep 10, 2021
Do oil and gas reflect on VAT?
Re: 30 States Risk Bankruptcy As Lagos, Rivers Set For New VAT Regime by Geeman2006: 1:14pm On Sep 10, 2021
Mossadd:
Any lazy state that want to go bankruptcy should not hesitate to go, if their citizens suffer for 4 years they will learn how to vote for an intelligent candidate that will work for the people not the one that is just opportune to have money to buy votes without nothing to offer
Well said! Everyone should carry their cross. Everyone must get sense by force.
1 2 3 4 5 6 Reply

As 30 States Propose N8 Trillion, Only Lagos, Rivers, Anambra Can Fund Budget • Report Rates 30 States In Nigeria Dirty, 7 Clean • Which States Will Oppose The New VAT Ruling? • 2 • 3 • 4

You May Lose In 2023, Wike Tells Atiku • Nigeria Military Seize Apc And Three Vehicles From Insurgents • Fani Kayode’s Former Girlfriend Cries Out Over Alleged Threat To Life