₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,064 members, 8,520,919 topics. Date: Wednesday, 18 November 2026 at 02:54 PM

Toggle theme

Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer (1164 Views)

1 Reply (Go Down)

Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by Paraman(op): 9:06pm On Oct 08, 2023
A senior lawyer, Paul Erokoro, SAN, has said that tendering additional evidence at the Supreme Court is an uphill task that requires a great deal of effort.

According to him, the rules admitting fresh evidence at the Supreme Court are very stringent.

Erokoro stated this on Sunday in Abuja in an interview with the News Agency of Nigeria.

He said the general rule is that additional evidence is not encouraged at the apex court.

“The general rule is that additional evidence at the Supreme Court or any Court of Appeal is not encouraged at all, but that doesn’t mean that it is totally forbidden.

“However, the rules for admitting it are very stringent.

“The first is that such evidence is going to be extremely material to the resolution of the issues in the case. That’s one of the hurdles to be crossed.

“The second hurdle is that such evidence could not have been procured during the trial at the trial court by reasonable diligence.
“So it is either the evidence was not available at the time of the trial or it could not, by any kind of due diligence or any reasonable effort, be made available.

“For evidence to be admissible at the Supreme Court or in any Court of Appeal, it has to, at a very minimum, satisfied those two conditions,” he said.

On whether there are provisions in the constitution allowing a party to tender additional evidence at the apex court, the senior lawyer noted, “Most of these rules are case laws and the Evidence Act does not specifically make these provisions.”

He stressed that it is only backed by the rules of the court.

“In the case of election petition, the constitution requires that the proceeding be concluded within 180 days at the election tribunal which, in the case of the presidential election, is the Court of Appeal.

“So the Court of Appeal which may have the power to admit additional evidence cannot have any jurisdiction if the jurisdiction of the trial court has expired.

“For instance, if a Court of Appeal has within six months to hear and conclude a presidential election matter and the six months have expired, even if the Supreme Court wanted to admit additional evidence, it doesn’t seem to me that it would be able to admit such evidence after the expiration of the six months,” he added.

According to him, if such evidence becomes available, it is very likely that it cannot be admitted on appeal.

“This is because it may not meet the jurisdictional requirement which is that a court which has jurisdiction to do it, will it have done it at this time?

“And if the period available for the trial court has expired, there is nothing the Appeal Court, in this case, the Supreme Court, can do,” he said.

Erokoro said that the Supreme Court or any appellate court in the country had 60 days within which to hear and conclude election matters.


He said even though the Supreme Court has jurisdiction to hear the appeal, it would have jurisdiction only in relation to the appeal.

“The fact that the Supreme Court has only two months within which to hear the appeal will not revive the jurisdiction of the trial court,” he added.

On whether there is a period within which a Supreme Court can admit additional evidence, Erokoro said, “Except when it is dealing with matters that have come before it under its original jurisdiction, the Supreme Court doesn’t, generally, admit evidence.

“It is an appeal court and its function is to see whether the matter was properly tried at the trial court, and not to admit additional evidence.

“It’s just that there are few exceptions to the rules regards that and those exceptions, I have already explained to you.

“But outside that, the Supreme Court, generally, doesn’t like to admit additional evidence because it is not fair to the trial court which did not hear that.

“Two, you will not give the other party the chance to, maybe, gather evidence that could have contradicted that one.

“So that is why the rules are very strict and that’s why you don’t see it happening all the time.”

He said though the move could succeed, he described it as “an uphill task.”

When asked about grounds that an already decided case can be reviewed at the Supreme Court, he said though the grounds are not determined by law, there are rules of trial that are universal in Nigeria.

“One of them is whether due process was followed, admissible evidence rejected or inadmissible evidence admitted, if the trial court failed to act fairly to both sides if the lower court made a mistake as regards the law to be applied, etc.
“So there are so many possibilities that the grounds of appeal can be built around,” he said.

Erokoro said though it was reported in the media that Alhaji Atiku Abubakar, the Peoples Democratic Party presidential candidate in the Feb. 25 poll, planned to file new evidence at the apex court, it was still in the realm of speculation.

“This is actually within the realm of speculation because I have not seen the evidence beyond what the press has reported and I don’t know whether those who issued the documents are prepared to come to court, otherwise, there is a risk of what is called, ‘documentary hearsay,’” he said.

NAN reports Abubakar on Friday sought the leave of the Supreme Court to bring in fresh additional evidence to prove that President Tinubu submitted a forged certificate to the Independent National Electoral Commission in aid of his qualification for the presidential election.

The documents Atiku sought to tender are Tinubu’s academic records, which were handed over to him by Chicago State University on Monday, October 2, 2023.

The 32-page documents were released to the former Vice President on the orders of Judge Nancy Maldonado of the District Court of Illinois, Eastern Division, Illinois, U.S.


https://punchng.com/certificate-saga-presenting-fresh-evidence-at-supreme-court-difficult-lawyer/?utm_source=telegram&utm_medium=social
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by Taylor92: 9:07pm On Oct 08, 2023
grin
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by Dpen11(f): 9:07pm On Oct 08, 2023
Wow
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by gift2xl: 9:15pm On Oct 08, 2023
Fruitless efforts
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by koiki4bat: 9:17pm On Oct 08, 2023
Paraman:
A senior lawyer, Paul Erokoro, SAN, has said that tendering additional evidence at the Supreme Court is an uphill task that requires a great deal of effort. According to him, the rules admitting fresh evidence at the Supreme Court are very stringent.

Erokoro stated this on Sunday in Abuja in an interview with the News Agency of Nigeria. “However, the rules for admitting it are very stringent.

1 “The first is that such evidence is going to be extremely material to the resolution of the issues in the case. That’s one of the hurdles to be crossed.

2 “The second hurdle is that such evidence could not have been procured during the trial at the trial court by reasonable diligence.
“So it is either the evidence was not available at the time of the trial or it could not, by any kind of due diligence or any reasonable effort, be made available.

“For evidence to be admissible at the Supreme Court or in any Court of Appeal, it has to, at a very minimum, satisfied those two conditions,” he said.
God works in mysterious ways who would have thought cheesy fortunately Atiku's forgery evidence certifies both conditions listed by learned SAN here! cheesy

The CSU deposition is extremely material to prove Tinubu's forgery as evident in the transcript, the deposition could not also be obtained on time as it was only the grace of her honour Judge Maldonado in Chicago that the disposition was obtained. In fact the judge specifically instructed and mentioned that CSU must swear under oath to the deposition before the 5th of October, in order to allow the evidence to be submitted to Nigeria's supreme court.

These social media batstards don't understand there's nothing that can upturn the will of the people, that's why it is called the will of God. See that batant below me grin grin grin grin
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by yarimo(m): 9:23pm On Oct 08, 2023
grin grin grin grin

Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by koiki4bat: 9:26pm On Oct 08, 2023
angry
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by socialmediaman:
PDP imploded due to corruption, so will APC

PO told you that he will be president, he sees what’s coming grin grin grin
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by Aufbauh(m): 10:02pm On Oct 08, 2023
The quest or pursuit of Tinubu's mandate to be disqualify is an exercise in futility

There's no evidence anywhere talk more of it admissibility. The principle of nothing can stand on nothing!
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by Phantom233: 11:06pm On Oct 08, 2023
Aufbauh:
The quest or pursuit of Tinubu's mandate to be disqualify is an exercise in futility

There's no evidence anywhere talk more of it admissibility. The principle of nothing can stand on nothing!
shun mkpurubiri, topic like this is not for lunatics
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by delpee(f): 11:24pm On Oct 08, 2023
Lawyers are cashing out big time....
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by Raskimonojendor: 11:25pm On Oct 08, 2023
I wish the supreme court to accept it so that Atiku can suffer another round of humiliation 😂
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by Lumarstone: 2:59am On Oct 09, 2023
The bitter truth is that Tinubu attended and graduated at CSU, to escape arrest after final exam based on his illegal drug related business which he forfeited $461 thousand US dollars, he came down here in Yaba and printed a prototype of his would be certificate. He equally short himself at his two legs when he sworn an affidavit that he lost all original of his certificates during the military inversion of his residence in 1994, thank God for CSU Registera who's clarification made us to understand that his original certificate is still in his file uncollected. Again the secondary school he sat for his GCE A level in 1970 at Lagos was established in the year 1974. He equally has multiple names like BOLA, AHMED, ADEKUNLE, TINUBU. at the same time in various certificates, he was admitted to the CSU as a female student. He has multiple date of birth. The one he used to gain admission at CSU is different from the one in the INEC record. Tinubu is a legendary extra ordinary certificate forger and greatest politician of all time in Nigeria political history!!! I respect him in a bigger way. CASE CLOSED!!!
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by Godfullsam(m): 3:10am On Oct 09, 2023
socialmediaman:
PDP imploded due to corruption, so will APC

PO told you that he will be president, he sees what’s coming grin grin grin
I doubt if he will be president. Even if he contest in the next election, he won't get more than half the votes he got this year.

Reason is because many non igbos who voted for him will not try it again. The headless mobs aka Obidient have given PO a very bad name.
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by Godfullsam(m): 3:12am On Oct 09, 2023
delpee:
Lawyers are cashing out big time....
It is their season

Their cocoa don ripe grin
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by Godfullsam(m): 3:15am On Oct 09, 2023
Lumarstone:
The bitter truth is that Tinubu attended and graduated at CSU, to escape arrest after final exam based on his illegal drug related business which he forfeited $461 thousand US dollars, he came down here in Yaba and printed a prototype of his would be certificate. He equally short himself at his two legs when he sworn an affidavit that he lost all original of his certificates during the military inversion of his residence in 1994, thank God for CSU Registera who's clarification made us to understand that his original certificate is still in his file uncollected. Again the secondary school he sat for his GCE A level in 1970 at Lagos was established in the year 1974. He equally has multiple names like BOLA, AHMED, ADEKUNLE, TINUBU. at the same time in various certificates, he was admitted to the CSU as a female student. He has multiple date of birth. The one he used to gain admission at CSU is different from the one in the INEC record. Tinubu is a legendary extra ordinary certificate forger and greatest politician of all time in Nigeria political history!!! I respect him in a bigger way. CASE CLOSED!!!
You respect a man with these attributes?

waoh!
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by socialmediaman: 3:31am On Oct 09, 2023
Godfullsam:
I doubt if he will be president. Even if he contest in the next election, he won't get more than half the votes he got this year.

Reason is because many non igbos who voted for him will not try it again. The headless mobs aka Obidient have given PO a very bad name.
Are you speaking for the non Igbos who voted for him or are you one of them?
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by Godfullsam(m): 3:39am On Oct 09, 2023
socialmediaman:
Are you speaking for the non Igbos who voted for him or are you one of them?
I am too smart to vote Obi, Atiku or Tinubu.

In fact, the caliber of people attracted to Obi are far below my level.
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by KanwuliaExtra: 3:48am On Oct 09, 2023
Only difficult in a SHYTEHOLE! wink
The fact still remains. . . . a forger is a forger! wink

How was the world to know that babablu never went to primary school? grin
Did the US courts not provide fresh evidence?
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by Amumaigwe: 4:36am On Oct 09, 2023
Godfullsam:
I doubt if he will be president. Even if he contest in the next election, he won't get more than half the votes he got this year.

Reason is because many non igbos who voted for him will not try it again. The headless mobs aka Obidient have given PO a very bad name.
You wish PO has a bad name like druggie. Good name cannot be bought even with all the Lagos state treasury.
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by ozo13(m): 4:48am On Oct 09, 2023
Make them better teach them ooo before supreme court break someone's heart again
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by Godfullsam(m): 2:41pm On Oct 09, 2023
Amumaigwe:
You wish PO has a bad name like druggie. Good name cannot be bought even with all the Lagos state treasury.
Tinubu is a full filled man. His life long ambition (according to him) is to become the president of Nigeria and he has gotten it albeit through a very controversial means.

By the way, who is talking about balablu here?

For your mind, anyone who doesn't sing the praise of obi is automatically Batified.

Dey play..
Re: Certificate Saga: Presenting Fresh Evidence At Supreme Court Difficult — Lawyer by Globad(f): 2:49pm On Oct 09, 2023
socialmediaman:
PDP imploded due to corruption, so will APC

PO told you that he will be president, he sees what’s coming grin grin grin
He will be president from when?
1 Reply

Atiku To Supreme Court: Reject Technicality, overrule Tinubu on fresh evidence • Peter Obi Tenders Results Of 8 More States In Evidence At The Tribunal • With Today's Ruling, Is There Any Hope For Peter Obi At Supreme Court? • 2 • 3 • 4

N5.6bn Wheat Project Scam: Ex-NIRSAL Boss Arrested 11 Months After Sacking • When Will Igbos Come To D Economic Rescue Of Nigeria • Nothing Can Stop Me From Completing My Tenure- Gov Fubara Vows