₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,345,967 members, 8,520,426 topics. Date: Tuesday, 17 November 2026 at 07:41 PM

Toggle theme

On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy (577 Views)

1 Reply (Go Down)

On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by Welcum(op): 7:31pm On Jul 03, 2024
A few days ago, the 2023 Labour Party Presidential Candidate Mr Peter Obi in an interview made the following exact statement which Premium Times and Mr Reno Omokri clearly took out of context:

“I don't see anything,” said Mr Obi with a deep shrug, “why his continued detention. Quite frankly. Especially as the law, the courts have granted him bail. Government must obey the law. Rule of law is an intrinsic asset that we must cherish and live with. And I've said I'm going to discuss with every agitator. And I use this opportunity to pray the government to ensure that all those who are in similar conditions are released and discussed with. We are a democratic government. We shouldn't be doing things that are arbitrary and not within the law”.

Not long after that, Mr Omokri posted the following statement on his X page:

“The 'Release Nnamdi Kanu Now' statement by Peter Obi is the obituary of Peter Obi's Presidential ambition. By calling for the release of a man who made public broadcasts asking his supporters to kill Nigerian military and paramilitary forces wherever they find them and has neither apologised nor repented of that order, Peter Obi just showed his allegiance to the flag behind him in this photo and which he used for his Hero beer logo!

And by the way, anybody or group of people or movement that thinks they can intimidate me and prevent me from saying what I really believe at any point in time obviously does not know me. My body does not secrete the fear hormone!
#TableShaker”

Premium Times also published a fact-check result in which the online news medium concluded that “the claim by Mr Obi that the Nigerian Government was detaining Mr Kanu against a court order is factually incorrect and misleading. This is because the Supreme Court overturned the ruling of the lower court in December 2023”.

See How Misleading These Statements By Premium Times And Omokri Are

The exact statements are laid out above so that we can all analyze them together.

Obi vs Omokri

Obi started by saying, “I don't see anything why his continued detention especially as the law, the courts have granted him bail”. But Omokri called this a “release Nnamdi Kanu now statement” which makes it sound like an order in the first place. Then, in the second place, Omokri forced an entirely different meaning on what Obi actually said.

For one thing, by saying “I don't see anything… why his continued detention”, Obi is clearly expressing a personal opinion on the matter rather than commanding anyone to do what he said. But, Omokri misleadingly called this a “release Nnamdi Kanu now statement”.

Even Obi's body language (such as his shrugs) shows it's a personal opinion he is expressing. And, who is not entitled to have opinions? Yet Omokri made it look like Obi issued a categorical statement on the matter. And many Nigerians are already sheepishly believing him. Hence, this rebuttal.

Omokri has been building other arguments on this false foundation via his X Page. But, we shall have the occasions to respond to those.


SEE ALSO: "Obi Obsession" - How Reno Omokri Unwittingly Asked To Be Rejected By His Southern Nigerian Community


Obi vs Premium Times

Then, toeing a similar thinking style as Omokri, the Premium Times writers claimed that Obi had said that “the Nigerian Government was detaining Mr Kanu against a court order”. In another statement of Omokri's being quoted online but which we couldn't find on his X wall (it has probably been deleted or wrongly quoted), he is said to be challenging Obi to produce a “subsisting court order”, therefore implying wrongly that Obi used that phrase.

Let the public beware that Obi mentioned neither a court order nor a subsisting court order. Legal terms should never be used out of context and, as a lawyer and as a media house, Omokri and Premium Times should respectively have known better.

So, against the claims of either a “court order” or “a subsisting court order”, let it be on record that what Obi said is that (as a person) his frank opinion is that he does not “see” the reason for Kanu's continued detention “especially as the court has granted him bail”.

The use of the word “especially” by Obi clearly shows that he already said something before modifying it with an adverbial phrase. But both Premium Times and the words being attributed to Omokri, carefully avoided the main statement and instead laid stress on its modification, thereby giving it a protrudingly over-bloated meaning.

And, to show that this deviation is deliberate, you can see Omokri turning the modification of an already given personal opinion by Obi into a command, and Premium Times using a different phrase (court order) than Obi used which is “bail”.

Thus Both Premium Times And Omokri Are Seen To Be Using A Strawman Fallacy To Deceive The Public

A Strawman Fallacy occurs when someone misrepresents, exaggerates, or distorts another person's argument, and then responds to the distorted version instead of the original argument. This creates a misleading impression that they have addressed the original point, when in fact they have not.

It's like responding to a different statement while appearing to respond to the original statement. This fallacy is often used to avoid engaging with the actual argument, and instead, creates an easier target to attack.

As you can see from the above analysis, this is exactly what both Premium Times and Omokri have done. And, it is obviously deliberate.

Clarifying What Obi Actually Said

Given Mr Peter Obi's busy schedule, he may not have the time to respond to all whims and caprices calling his attention. Again, given his position, he was apparently trying to be politically correct in his word use.

So, based on our principle as a media outfit that insists on truth and justice, we take up the task of clarifying what Obi obviously meant in the short response he made verbally in the live TV interview.

First off, apart from the first part of the words at issue here (which has been attended to above), let's remember that Obi also said that “government must obey the law. Rule of law is an intrinsic asset that we must cherish and live with. And I've said I'm going to discuss with every agitator. And I use this opportunity to pray the government to ensure that all those who are in similar conditions are released and discussed with. We are a democratic government. We shouldn't be doing things that are arbitrary and not within the law”.

The entire statement should be analyzed together. Otherwise taking it apart would be like taking a dissected rat as a live pulsating rat. So, let's start with the statement that “the law, the courts” have granted Nnamdi Kanu bail. Is this not true?

Of course it is true. Even Premium Times and Omokri have acknowledged this too.

For example, below is a screenshot of a tweet Omokri shared only last year in February (kindly permit the placement. It's to make it clear enough on mobile).



Also, in its fact-check result, Premium Times agreed that “the Court of Appeal, Abuja, on 13 October 2022, held that the IPOB leader was extraordinarily renditioned to Nigeria and that the action was a flagrant violation of the country's extradition treaty and breach of his fundamental human rights”. From this, Premium Times further admitted that “the court therefore struck out the terrorism charges filed against Mr Kanu by the Nigerian government and ordered his release from the facility of the State Security Service”.

“But about one week later,” Premium Times further admitted, “the government, through the office of the Attorney-General of the Federation, appealed the court ruling and subsequently obtained a Supreme Court order staying its execution”

The question is, what happened during the “about one week” between the Court of Appeal ruling and the time the Federal Government appealed the ruling and got a stay of execution? Answer: the Federal Government actually disobeyed an order of the Court of Appeal for a whole week or more going by Premium Times' own words.

So, what Obi was careful not to say out loud, and what Premium Times and Omokri were afraid he meant is what actually happened: The Federal Government refused to obey a competent court for a whole week and then had the time to turn the hand of justice. As a result, everything else that followed (such as the stay of execution obtained from the Supreme Court) clearly lacks legality.

Therefore, when Obi would say that “government must obey the law”, the Government actually failed to obey the law. Again, when Obi would say that “we are a democratic government (state). We shouldn't be doing things that are arbitrary and not within the law”, it is actually true that the Federal Government arbitrarily acted against democratic principles by disobeying the Court of Appeal for a whole week.

This is besides the utter arbitrariness of the extraordinary rendition based on which the Court of Appeal gave its order and the attack on Kanu's house by Federal Government soldiers while a competent court gave him sick leave. And there are more of such cases of the Federal Government going arbitrarily outside democratic norms as regards Kanu's case.

Then Comes The Dirty Hands Principle

There is a principle in jurisprudence called "Clean Hands Doctrine" or "Dirty Hands Doctrine" depending on where it is applied. In this case, it is Dirty Hands Doctrine. And, it's all a part of the law.

This doctrine states that a government or authority that violates the law or acts unethically cannot enforce the law or punish someone else for similar violations. The idea is that the government or authority lacks the moral authority and credibility to enforce the law when they themselves have failed to comply with it.

In other words, if the government has "dirty hands" by violating the law, they cannot accuse someone else of having "dirty hands" for doing the same thing.

Now, as you can see, even within the context of the Nigerian legal system, the Nigerian Government lost the right to hold Kanu as soon as it disobeyed one of Nigeria’s competent courts in regard to Kanu. Then, beyond the Nigerian legal system, the Nigerian Government lost the moral right to hold Kanu as soon as it disobeyed its own extradition treaty as enshrined in international law. So, who says that Peter Obi was wrong for implying that the Nigerian Government disobeyed a court ruling and arbitrarily flouted democratic principles in relation to Kanu?

We are open to discuss this right here below in an absolutely transparent manner. Thank you beloved Nigerians.
SOURCE

Nlfpmod
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by helinues: 7:32pm On Jul 03, 2024
The negotiations table can only be opened if

1. Kanu renounced Biafra
2. dissolve Ipob as a group

May be
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by Okwyjesus(m): 7:32pm On Jul 03, 2024
Obi rode on the storm .

Smart move...
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by kettykin: 7:35pm On Jul 03, 2024
Nigeria is such an illogical country, everything is just nit following logic
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by mrvitalis(m): 7:45pm On Jul 03, 2024
helinues:
The negotiations table can only be opened if

1. Kanu renounced Biafra
2. dissolve Ipob as a group

May be
Lmaooo see as this one talk am like he has a say on the matter... Lol

Internet and giving bunch of nobodies sense of being something
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by helinues: 7:46pm On Jul 03, 2024
mrvitalis:
Lmaooo see as this one talk am like he has a say on the matter... Lol

Internet and giving bunch of nobodies sense of being something
Who dah hell is this?
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by Welcum(op): 7:46pm On Jul 03, 2024
helinues:
The negotiations table can only be opened if

1. Kanu renounced Biafra
2. dissolve Ipob as a group

May be
That isn't what this is about though.
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by helinues: 7:48pm On Jul 03, 2024
Welcum:
That isn't what this is about though.
I sometimes have comprehension problem.

Could please tell me what this thread is all about?
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by mrvitalis(m): 7:49pm On Jul 03, 2024
helinues:
Who dah hell is this?
Someone greater than your whole generation
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by helinues: 7:50pm On Jul 03, 2024
mrvitalis:
Someone greater than your whole generation
Hahaha, no be you dey look for ordinary receptionist job the other time.

Embrace some shame boy.
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by mrvitalis(m): 7:51pm On Jul 03, 2024
helinues:
Hahaha, no be you dey look for ordinary receptionist job the other time.

Embrace some shame boy.
One million naira for you if you provide proof

I double dare you... If u know u are not a coward take the challenge
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by helinues: 7:54pm On Jul 03, 2024
mrvitalis:
One million naira for you if you provide proof

I double dare you... If u know u are not a coward take the challenge
Go and dash the money to bambiala.
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by mrvitalis(m): 7:57pm On Jul 03, 2024
helinues:
Go and dash the money to bambiala.
Don't be a coward..... Provide proof and I would donate it to who ever you wish

Don't run ooh u must provide evidence
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by Welcum(op): 8:00pm On Jul 03, 2024
helinues:
I sometimes have comprehension problem.

Could please tell me what this thread is all about?
Fools are those who respond to what they didn't understand. Mind you, I haven't said anyone is a fool ohhhhh!
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by gidgiddy: 8:06pm On Jul 03, 2024
Reno Omokiri only cares about one thing, 2027. For him, Peter Obi is the major stumbling block to PDP returning to power. Therefore, he will do everything he can to demarket Obi including twisting Obi's words, misrepresenting Obi amongst others

Let's not forget that this same Reno Omokiri was someone who was full of praises for both Peter Obi and Nnamdi Kanu in 2018.

He only realised that they were devil's 2023 elections?

Reno Omokiri is a treminder of why you should never trust a typical politician, they will say anything to gain political milage
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by Roboto11: 8:10pm On Jul 03, 2024
Kanu should be decapitated.
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by 10mobile: 8:12pm On Jul 03, 2024
gidgiddy:
Let's not forget that this same Reno Omokiri was someone who was full of praises for both Peter Obi and Nnamdi Kanu in 2018.
2018? But the post up here shows he was defending Nnamdi Kanu only last year, even saying more than what he is accusing Obi of.

Nlfpmod Dominique Sissy3 if you pushed what Omokri and Premium Times said to FP, it's only fair you should push this too to let the public have a balanced info on this.
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by mrvitalis(m): 8:12pm On Jul 03, 2024
gidgiddy:
Reno Omokiri only cares about one thing, 2027. For him, Peter Obi is the major stumbling block to PDP returning to power. Therefore, he will do everything he can to demarket Obi including twisting Obi's words, misrepresenting Obi amongst others

Let's not forget that this same Reno Omokiri was someone who was full of praises for both Peter Obi and Nnamdi Kanu in 2018.

He only realised that they were devil's 2023 elections?

Reno Omokiri is a treminder of why you should never trust a typical politician, they will say anything to gain political milage
Reno has left PDP.. Reno is working 100% for Tinubu

Did you see atiku include him in his campaign team last elections?

In an interview he was asked that if in 2027 atiku contest against Tinubu who would he vote for.. He said it would be hard to vote against Tinubu
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by Dpharisee: 8:23pm On Jul 03, 2024
helinues:
The negotiations table can only be opened if

1. Kanu renounced Biafra
2. dissolve Ipob as a group

May be
You are here already?
Re: On Obi Call For Kanu Release: Premium Times & Omokri Guilty Of Strawman Fallacy by Welcum(op): 9:44pm On Jul 03, 2024
Dpharisee:
You are here already?
🤣
1 Reply

Peter Obi: Call For My Arrest, Prosecution Baseless – Lai Mohammed • ‘it’s Deceitful’ – Soludo Replies Obi’s Call For Anambra To Vote LP Lawmakers • Floods: Bode George Re-Echoes Obi’s Call To Halt Campaigns • 2 • 3 • 4

RE: Judges Top List Of Bribe Recipients -A Sad Grimming Reality In Nigeria • Just In: Edo Politics Goes Bloody, Apc Governorship Candidate Escapes Assassina • Nothing Good Will Come Out Of Your Protest, Sudanese Cleric Warns Nigerians