₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,429 members, 8,523,113 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 06:25 PM

Toggle theme

Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. - Sports (10) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Entertainment › Sports › Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. (63871 Views)

1 2 3 ... 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 ... 15 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 11:31am On Aug 03, 2024
KushLyon:
Micheal Phelps produces less lactic acid than the average human, how is that not an anomaly? He also has hypermobile joints which makes him have a greater range of motion, as well as having a disproportionately long wingspan, and all these gives him a huge advantage against other swimmers, I don't see y'all raising the "it is not fair" card against that one but one white girl gets punched too hard and hypocrites starts screaming foul
So with all your Micheal Phelps possess this or that? are they not male features? and it's male competing against male.
We humans beings don't have to have the same exact features afterall if you want to be a basketballer , height is an advantage. .all these features are his features others too may have other normal attributes that work for them...are you just watching sports? Both male and female categories are full of varieties of features within a normal range, slight difference here and there , these features don't make them other gender ..it may work or may not work for them and no sports authority has raised issues over this before, but this intersex is great issue especially in female sports which can expand the range in different abilities so high and can make someone who is virtually male compete against female.
If we make it all comers affair, there are so many individuals with just openings, what we may call vagina but other parts are masculine features (of course powered by Y chromosomes in them), muscle, hair , voice , bones , strength e.t c should we encourage those ones to compete freely in female sports? No.
Don't bring politics into this, it's not about race or colour, the issue of intersex is a special case worth the attention, that's the problem you emotional ones have.
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 11:36am On Aug 03, 2024
Lawag3:
Just having the xy chromosome is enough to make a person intersex?
Yes now! Don't you know what the XY chromosome is? Is the source of those NATURAL(PERMANENT) male characteristics you find in female and render them intersex.
Infact xy chromosome is the origin of intersex in female.
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by Lawag3: 11:41am On Aug 03, 2024
yinkabeauty:
Yes now! Don't you know what the XY chromosome is? Is the source of those NATURAL(PERMANENT) male characteristics you find in female and render them intersex.
Infact xy chromosome is the origin of intersex in female.
So males with xx chromosome are women. Even if they don't have female Instruments and can't give birth or have a uterus.


Same with females with xy who don't have a penis and or testicles. So these females are actually male even though they have a female reproductive organs and can basically carry out birth?
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by KushLyon(m): 11:51am On Aug 03, 2024
yinkabeauty:
So with all your Micheal Phelps possess this or that? are they not male features? and it's male competing against male.
We humans beings don't have to have the same exact features afterall if you want to be a basketballer , height is an advantage. .all these features are his features others too may have other normal attributes that work for them...are you just watching sports? Both male and female categories are full of varieties of features within a normal range, slight difference here and there , these features don't make them other gender ..it may work or may not work for them and no sports authority has raised issues over this before, but this intersex is great issue especially in female sports which can expand the range in different abilities so high and can make someone who is virtually male compete against female.
If we make it all comers affair, there are so many individuals with just openings, what we may call vagina but other parts are masculine features (of course powered by Y chromosomes in them), muscle, hair , voice , bones , strength e.t c should we encourage those ones to compete freely in female sports? No.
Don't bring politics into this, it's not about race or colour, the issue of intersex is a special case worth the attention, that's the problem you emotional ones have.
Height is an advantage, so is having a high level of testosterone, and as you said, both male and female categories have varieties, case closed.
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by KushLyon(m): 11:55am On Aug 03, 2024
lexy2014:
I actually thought it was a simple and straightforward issue. thank you for your input. very apt.

kushlyon and folake4u, see below IAAF ruling on Caster Semenya (I hope you know who she is) on this same issue
Does the boxing federation have such rules? If it is the case that they have a rule restricting females with high levels of testosterone from competing, then it's fine. Elite athletes always have some sort of advantage against others, in the case of Imane, it is her high testosterone, and that itself doesn't make her undefeatable because she has lost to 9 other females, Carini is just a crybaby who can't take a punch. Below is one of the women that defeated Imane

Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by Judolisco(m): 11:56am On Aug 03, 2024
yinkabeauty:
Yes, but there is a range .

But a potential range like night and day is bad.
I think d girl was treated unjustly.... There is no category for her type yet.... She was treated as if she is transgender or even a hermaphrodite.... There was a time they started investigating Micheal Phelps they found out his lung was twice the size of an average man and dat gave him an edge over others..... Should he go and cut his lungs?
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 12:16pm On Aug 03, 2024
Lawag3:
So males with xx chromosome are women. Even if they don't have female Instruments and can't give birth or have a uterus.


Same with females with xy who don't have a penis and or testicles. So these females are actually male even though they have a female reproductive organs and can basically carry out birth?
You have to use the correct term of Intersex and understand what it stands for, which is the situation where individual possess both male and female genes and characteristics, and not outright male or female but intersex. I.e inter(in-between) , sex(sex).

So back to your question males with xx chromosomes are intersex.
They will have male characteristics but will lack male characteristics in some form e.g production of viable sperms amongst other defects, they may appear feminine e.t.c.

Also female with XY chromosome are intersex, apart from the female characteristics, they also share male characteristics ranging from muscle, hairy body , voice ,strength and Instruments e.t.c as the case may be.

So in this case such individual is neither outrightly male nor female but share characteristics from both sexes.

So to summarize intersex individuals are not your typical or normal male or female they come with characteristics from both sexes.
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by Lawag3: 12:28pm On Aug 03, 2024
yinkabeauty:
You have to use the correct term of Intersex and understand what it stands for, which is the situation where individual possess both male and female genes and characteristics, and not outright male or female but intersex. I.e inter(in-between) , sex(sex).

So back to your question males with xx chromosomes are intersex.
They will have male characteristics but will lack male characteristics in some form e.g production of viable sperms amongst other defects, they may appear feminine e.t.c.

Also female with XY chromosome are intersex, apart from the female characteristics, they also share male characteristics ranging from muscle, hairy body , voice ,strength and Instruments e.t.c as the case may be.

So in this case such individual is neither outrightly male nor female but share characteristics from both sexes.

So to summarize intersex individuals are not your typical or normal male or female they come with characteristics from both sexes.
What makes a person a woman?


Please just answer the question I'm getting somewhere.
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by Jeboy(m): 12:40pm On Aug 03, 2024
The IBF (international boxing federation) used testosterone levels as cut off while the Intl Olympics Committee (IOC) just used what is on your passport.

The difference in cut-off requirements is the problem we have now. Imane Khelif shouls just handpick the sports events that recognized her as female afterall she didnt create herself intersex and she has lost to other female boxers in time past.

Aemann33:
Are you aware that there is a required level of testosterone that must not be exceeded in order to participate in female sports esp boxing, she failed the test twice before this competition but was overlooked by the IOC
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 12:54pm On Aug 03, 2024
Judolisco:
I think d girl was treated unjustly.... There is no category for her type yet.... She was treated as if she is transgender or even a hermaphrodite.... There was a time they started investigating Micheal Phelps they found out his lung was twice the size of an average man and dat gave him an edge over others..... Should he go and cut his lungs?
Yes there is no category for her yet and people are clamouring for the introduction of this category to end controversy.

Transgender is not a problem, it's just a feeling of aligning to the other sex aside the one you were given at birth., so is just a feeling and a normal person without serious biological defects can feel it.

The problems are transexual and intersex, I will talk about hermaphrodites later on.

Transexual is a Transgender that matches feeling with action and changes his/her gender from one to another via surgeries, so if these ones want to compete in sports of the other gender especially trans woman who has transformed from male , this will serve as cheating, if no gender check for inner qualities is conducted.

The other intersex , is when an individual is possesing both male and female genes and characteristics, that's the situation of this athlete we are discussing,she is actually an intersex with male attributes and advantage.

Hermaphrodite and Intersex are similar but not exactly the same, intersex are socially and erroneously described as hermaphrodite but it's not correct.

Hermaphrodite occur mainly in some lower animals it's when an organism possess both male and female gametes ( sperm and ovum) e.g mollusca/snails 🐌, Earthworms e.t.c

While both intersex and hermaphroditism are possession of both male and female characteristics in one organism, hermaphroditism restrict these qualities to both sex gametes alone while intersex is any characteristics at all from male and female appearing in the same organism. be it muscle, hair, voice , Instruments, hormones e.t.c.

So the lady is intersex.

Micheal Phelps and any other athletes may have attributes here and there, but they are still competing against their gender, others will also have some attributes, that may work or not work for them.


In boxing 🥊 there are different categories ranges from feather, light, banter heavyweight e.t.c, this is categorisation and come to think of it these people are still of the same gender oo but they still categorize them to prevent undue advantage but intersex in female sports is bad, it will open room for all sorts.

But I don't want anyone to be subjected to humiliation for what is beyond them, but at the same time I call for categorisation for i;ntesex and transexual.
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 1:06pm On Aug 03, 2024
Lawag3:
What makes a person a woman?


Please just answer the question I'm getting somewhere.
No problem, you can ask questions..

A woman is an adult female...with essentially female sexual (xx) chromosomes, because this is essential and the most important part of her that will give rise to all female characteristics.
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by Lawag3: 1:15pm On Aug 03, 2024
yinkabeauty:
No problem, you can ask questions..

A woman is an adult female...with essentially female sexual (xx) chromosomes, because this is essential and the most important part of her that will give rise to all female characteristics.
OK so a person that can get pregnant have a uterus ovaries and Instruments of a woman might not necessarily be a woman because such a person has xy chromosome which makes that person intersex.


If an intersex person should give birth to a child will that intersex person be called a mother.


And if she is to be called a mother are all human mothers not women / female.
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 1:17pm On Aug 03, 2024
KushLyon:
Height is an advantage, so is having a high level of testosterone, and as you said, both male and female categories have varieties, case closed.
Height is advantage, not an anomaly, the same gender.
Within the same gender, male for example testosterone levels are not the same but there is a benchmark, range from this level to this level ( cut off points) but that cannot be said of virtually male/ intersex competing in female sports, the range/benchmark/ cut off points have been expanded, with the intersex one far higher than they are averagely.
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 1:48pm On Aug 03, 2024
Lawag3:
OK so a person that can get pregnant have a uterus ovaries and Instruments of a woman might not necessarily be a woman because such a person has xy chromosome which makes that person intersex.


If an intersex person should give birth to a child will that intersex person be called a mother.


And if she is to be called a mother are all human mothers not women / female.
Don't you know by having xy chromosome by a female in the first place is an issue, that's the sex chromosomes, that give rise to sexual characteristics.
The xy chromosome is not a decoration, it will bring on its effect, although the other x will bring female characteristics but the y part also will bring male, unlike normal xx chromosomes in female.
You are speaking as if it's straight forward that intersex female will just conceive easily like other normal females, in some cases there are no even channels for birth., some cases scrotum will appear instead of labia majora or minora, you can have a womb, breast but instead of vagina, what you get is penis., in some cases no menstruation, other features outside reprodu.ctive are.as include body muscle, hairy body, voice, strength, these cases outside genita.lia are still favourable ...
There are exceptional or assisted cases where intersex female can be pregnant if ovaries are present , you know intersex in female for example don't exhibit exact features but what is certain is you will definitely find male characteristics, so depending on the luck, if ovaries are not tampered with pregnancy can occur but all this by chance cases are caused by the abnormal xy chromosomes in the first place, and no comparison should be drawn of this against normal woman.
Exception is not standard

any living thing that can give rise to another either by surgical, invitro /in vivo fertilization is still a mother.

All mothers are women/females but all "females/women" are not mothers and can never be mothers because genetic anomaly, intersex has dealt with them, how can you have babies without ovaries and menstruation 🩸?
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 2:07pm On Aug 03, 2024
etrange:
You can’t make this comment and still be against gender transitioning. What you’re claiming here is that she was born man in a woman’s body, but when trans people say this, you people say they’re delusional. This makes me wonder if people like you actually have a stand or just jump on anything to discriminate a certain group of people.
Is not about claim of someone, it has been published and in public domain, she is intersex, an individual with both male and female genetics/characteristics .
Not transgender people who claimed they are born in gender that were not assigned to them, claims which are often not accosted or driven by any biological proof.
INTERSEX is different from transgender (feeling) and transexual (actual transitioning).
INTERSEX is actual biology of having both male and female characteristics.


Pjtech
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 2:17pm On Aug 03, 2024
viodemus:
That's how people spread propaganda about the lgbt in America and the Democrats.


Understanding the lgbt in America, in summary:

It's all about life, freedom, and finances.
Before now, if two homo people are together and one dies, they did not recognize the partner if the person is not opposite sex. So, in a way, the govt or some relative that the dead person did not acknowledge might take over the property or finances.

Then, in the not distance past, the lgbt people were kpaied at will when others found out about them.

If you know anything about American laws and constitution, you will find out that it is 99% written in blood. It's almost like it takes death for a law to be passed.


And also, it could be an opening for enemies outside of America to take advantage of disgruntled citizens in the society.

I respect American decision to face it head on.


For me, I will not support having a different sex compete in a game or competition that might favor one person due to sex genetic advantages. Am very glad, they clarified this specific case.



As brutal as America was in the past, and very rugged on the world stage now, one thing you can say about them, they have a conscience. Something that many Nigerians and 3rd world countries seriously lack.


This protest in Nigeria as of today, is really a lack of conscience protest against the gov.

She is an intersex, someone with both male and female characteristics and so this is still an undue advantage, anyway the case will be sorted out after olympics.
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 2:20pm On Aug 03, 2024
Vyzz:
She's female..

Stop trying to bend things.

The other woman no strong
You are not informed, she is an intersex, carries both male and female characteristics.


Pjtech
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 2:30pm On Aug 03, 2024
KushLyon:
The countries, race and people that person mentioned all have an "unfair" advantage in their respective sports. Using the Ethiopians as example, they are genetically more efficient at oxygen utilization because of their terrain which makes them excel at long distance races (marathon race), that itself is an unfair advantage to any other country competing against them which is the same thing as a woman having elevated testosterone levels, it's an unfair advantage against women who don't. And the truth is that there will always be women who have higher testosterone levels in such sports.

FYI: I see no reason why you had to write such long epistle when you're clearly the one that doesn't know the meaning of an argument
All those variables has been existing in sports in time immemorial, everyone or region enjoy it in one form or the other.

This is different from a virtual male/intersex competing in female sports...

Normal women may not have the same testosterone level, but the ranges are not far apart but for intersex female the testosterone level is way higher beyond the benchmark.


lexy2014
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by Lawag3: 2:39pm On Aug 03, 2024
yinkabeauty:
Don't you know by having xy chromosome by a female in the first place is an issue, that's the sex chromosomes, that give rise to sexual characteristics.
The xy chromosome is not a decoration, it will bring on its effect, although the other x will bring female characteristics but the y part also will bring male, unlike normal xx chromosomes in female.
You are speaking as if it's straight forward that intersex female will just conceive easily like other normal females, in some cases there are no even channels for birth., some cases scrotum will appear instead of labia majora or minora, you can have a womb, breast but instead of vagina, what you get is penis., in some cases no menstruation, other features outside reprodu.ctive are.as include body muscle, hairy body, voice, strength, these cases outside genita.lia are still favourable ...
There are exceptional or assisted cases where intersex female can be pregnant if ovaries are present , you know intersex in female for example don't exhibit exact features but what is certain is you will definitely find male characteristics, so depending on the luck, if ovaries are not tampered with pregnancy can occur but all this by chance cases are caused by the abnormal xy chromosomes in the first place, and no comparison should be drawn of this against normal woman.
Exception is not standard

any living thing that can give rise to another either by surgical, invitro /in vivo fertilization is still a mother.

All mothers are women/females but all "females/women" are not mothers and can never be mothers because genetic anomaly, intersex has dealt with them, how can you have babies without ovaries and menstruation 🩸?
I get your point. The Algerian lady has children. That's what I want to point out to you she's in has proven herself to be a woman. That is some intersex person can have children like normally.
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 2:41pm On Aug 03, 2024
LadyExcellency:
Stop this nonsense you put up there. She can't be pregnant. The International Boxing Association disqualified her in 2023 from competing in women's category. Tell me why IOC should accept her.
Infact, she and other Asian lady shouldn't have competed in this Olympics if not that those who authorized such gender testing are having corruption problem at the moment and they have been abandoned with their work and therefore not in charge of boxing 🥊 in this Olympics, their gender case will be revisited holistically after the Olympics.




Botragelad
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by GreatVocalist: 2:50pm On Aug 03, 2024
Botragelad:
I'd say it can lead to variations in cellular function, this does not necessarily equate to impairment.

Tell you what, many examples of mosaicism result in enhanced physiological function.
Plus, the body adapts for cellular differences, this way it ensures that physiological function remains intact.

Let me give you an illustration, picture a skilled orchestra, where individual musicians (cells) may play slightly different melodies (mosaicism), yet the overall rhyme (physiological function) remain cohesive. Did you get that?
Yeah, I got it.

I have my reservations though, but thanks for the clarifications.
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 3:22pm On Aug 03, 2024
Lawag3:
I get your point. The Algerian lady has children. That's what I want to point out to you she's in has proven herself to be a woman. That is some intersex person can have children like normally.
Which Algerian lady are you talking about of having children? Can you give his children link ? Are you talking imane. Khalif?
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 3:26pm On Aug 03, 2024
Meteng:
She should even go and fight a man sef, since she has more male teresterone
She is bigger female but less than male.
They should take her and her likes to the middle and open their categories for them.



Pjtech
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 3:39pm On Aug 03, 2024
Maski87:
If she is xy tell how come she has a vagina
It's not a must you won't have vagina with xy chromosomes but what is certain is that you will express some male features or characteristics.
You may lack vagina , ovaries, breasts have hairy bodies, muscle, higher testosterone ,testes, strength,voice e.t.c
So what iam saying in excess female intersex don't suffer the same specific fate but what is common is they will all express male characteristics....one may have vagina but no ovary , no Breast, another on the hand may have no vagina but has breast, hairy bodies e.t.c it's not a must you must not have vagina since they exhibit different male features.


Pjtech
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty:
pocohantas:
Lmao!

Has she been killed in the past by fellow women? She is not trans from this writeup. They say she no be woman. Wetin she come be?
She is INTERSEX :
having of both male and female genetics 🧬 and characteristics.


Izzou
CrownedPhoenix
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 3:59pm On Aug 03, 2024
Love800:
Nothing of such though.
As far she has only vagina(female reproductive organ), she is a woman even with the high tetesterones.
Who told you that? Have you been following sports as at all?


brain54
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 4:14pm On Aug 03, 2024
Omotaday:
You lots are confused.

Will it also be okay to tell males in the same condition to compete in female sport?

Conservatives say there are only two genders and male should be male, female should be female. I agree


But here is a born female and you lots are trying to force her to change her gender and also telling her to go compete with the opposite sex.


This is madness!
You are getting whole thing mixed up , your head is not calm at all.

If we have a weak male in such condition your common sense should tell you that such "weak male" should not go to female sports because as "weak" as he is as a man , it will be a disadvantage to the ladies because he is a man.

Also nobody says she should go to male sports because as stronger as she may be in female sports, if she goes to male sports, she will be destroyed there as well.

What people are saying is no undue advantage should be allowed, she won't change her gender, athletes in this situation can suppress their hormones or they are disqualified or authority should even open categories for intersex and transexual athletes to end this controversy.

Pour cold water on your head and eat Eba in the evening.



Pjtech
Botragelad
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 4:23pm On Aug 03, 2024
Botragelad:
Just another confused guy who refused to read! Lol
You are not well, drlateef is absolutely correct 💯%
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 4:51pm On Aug 03, 2024
Love800:
Xy chromosomes does not have the final say.
We have only three genders, which are male with usual reproductive organ, female with the usuall reproductive organ and the one that has both(have forgotten the name).

But the above is what i know.
What has the final say ? If not sex chromosomes xy & xx....the third one intersex (in human ) what they call hermaphrodites ( in animals ).

brain54
Re: Algerian Boxer Imane Khelif Is Not Trans. by yinkabeauty: 4:56pm On Aug 03, 2024
eepeepook:
Why aren’t intersex people as talked about as trans ones? Imagine if Michael Jackson never had vitiligo, Africans would lynch people with the condition, claiming they were witches.
INTERSEX is what they see most of the times and they term it transgender, hence the suppression of the term intersex.
1 2 3 ... 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 ... 15 Reply

Italian Boxer, Carini Apologises To Khelif • Biography Of Imane Khelif: Parent, Husband, Kids And More • Fethi Nourine: Algerian Quits Olympics Rather Than Take On Israeli In Judo Match • 2 • 3 • 4

Samuel Eto’o Involved In Car Accident In Cameroon, Suffers Head Injury • Don't Have Dinner With Cristiano Ronaldo - Patrice Evra Warns Messi • Yağmur Aşık, Wife Of Emre Aşık Paid Hitman $1.3m To Kill Him