₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,345,868 members, 8,519,899 topics. Date: Tuesday, 17 November 2026 at 02:55 AM

Toggle theme

Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita - Politics (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita (2070 Views)

1 2 3 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by mrvitalis(m): 8:56am On Nov 09, 2024
helinues:
You guys don't have to be aggressive when debating with others

GDP, Gross Domestic Product which is a measurement of transacted goods and services within a territory.

IGR, Internally Generated Revenue which is measurement of tax collected from the transacted goods and services.

The more transacted goods and services, the more IGR.

How many businesses are in South East that you are expecting to generate more revenue ( IGR) compared to South West littered with different business activities?
Oh mine... See who I dey follow debate since 😤😤😤😤 Vitalis u done Fvck up

This ignorance is too much for me

Yes bro IGR is better to determine wealth... No wonder world Bank use it to rate economy
Lmao
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by helinues: 8:57am On Nov 09, 2024
mrvitalis:
Oh mine... See who I dey follow debate since 😤😤😤😤 Vitalis u done Fvck up

This ignorance is too much for me

Yes bro IGR is better to determine wealth... No wonder world Bank use it to rate economy
Lmao
Why not dispute instead of trying to derail
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by mrvitalis(m): 8:57am On Nov 09, 2024
helinues:
You can see that your colleague diverted which i quickly corrected him
Bro your ignorance on the topic is sicking honestly

You are above your level this time
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by Bestmanfornow: 8:57am On Nov 09, 2024
richmond500:
This is the mentality that keeps you where u are.
Every country needs foreign investors to grow their economy
We are doing great mention infrastructure being funded by state governor in Ogun state let me list Anambra state with low IGR🤣🤣
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by richmond500(op): 8:58am On Nov 09, 2024
Bestmanfornow:
Let compare Infrastructure going on in Anambra state and Ogun that what we should be debating not fabricated IGR that doesn't reflect in Ogun state
Mention top ten projects going on in Ogun let me mention that of Anambra state, remember Anambra still maintained low debt profile and the state governor is yet to borrow since he became governor
I am not from Ogun state.
But why don't u ask why foreign investors prefer Ogun state?
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by helinues: 8:58am On Nov 09, 2024
mrvitalis:
Bro your ignorance on the topic is sicking honestly

You are above your level this time
It's when one don't have valid arguments, they resort to tantrums.

Noted
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by mrvitalis(m): 8:59am On Nov 09, 2024
helinues:
Why not dispute instead of trying to derail
Dispute what?

Show me 1 just one world ratings agency that has ranked economies based on IGR and get 300k this morning

Bro this topic is beyond you

Google, go to YouTube n learn
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by richmond500(op): 9:00am On Nov 09, 2024
mrvitalis:
Oh mine... See who I dey follow debate since 😤😤😤😤 Vitalis u done Fvck up

This ignorance is too much for me

Yes bro IGR is better to determine wealth... No wonder world Bank use it to rate economy
Lmao
GDP is not realistic in Nigeria.
We can all agree that the average Nigerian does not have up to N3m.

It could be realistic in other nations which I don't know but the people I see on the streets daily in Nigeria barely have N1m
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by Bestmanfornow: 9:03am On Nov 09, 2024
richmond500:
I am not from Ogun state.
But why don't u ask why foreign investors prefer Ogun state?
Now you are now from Ogun🤣🤣
Please ask those you are defending to list major projects currently going on in Ogun since their IGR is bigger than all the southeast states put together I don't think is hard to find since Ogun is swimming in wealth, make Una get small sense
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by mrvitalis(m): 9:04am On Nov 09, 2024
helinues:
It's when one don't have valid arguments, they resort to tantrums.

Noted
GDP is the Total of what a place produce n sales... So bigger GDP means bigger business n economic activity....

If people leave their contribution to GDP goes with them

IGR is just how much revenue government can or choose to collect it has nothing or little to do with the business activities of a place

None GDP contributors can contribute to IGR
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by helinues: 9:04am On Nov 09, 2024
mrvitalis:
Dispute what?

Show me 1 just one world ratings agency that has ranked economies based on IGR and get 300k this morning

Bro this topic is beyond you

Google, go to YouTube n learn
Discuss this logically without referring to the economists
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by helinues: 9:05am On Nov 09, 2024
mrvitalis:
GDP is the Total of what a place produce n sales... So bigger GDP means bigger business n economic activity....

If people leave their contribution to GDP goes with them

IGR is just how much revenue government can or choose to collect it has nothing or little to do with the business activities of a place

None GDP contributors can contribute to IGR
How would have increase in IGR if the volume of the transactions ( GDP) are declining or remain the same?
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by mrvitalis(m): 9:06am On Nov 09, 2024
helinues:
Discuss this logically without referring to the economists
So if you want to measure wealth or business activities of a nation by IGR

How can you measure business activities of a tax free state or tax heaven like Monaco or Dubai... Is their low revenue from tax a reflection of their economic state?
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by helinues: 9:06am On Nov 09, 2024
mrvitalis:
So if you want to measure wealth or business activities of a nation by IGR

How can you measure business activities of a tax free state or tax heaven like Monaco or Dubai... Is their low revenue from tax a reflection of their economic state?
Isn't that the volume of GDP transacted?
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by mrvitalis(m): 9:08am On Nov 09, 2024
helinues:
How would have increase in IGR if the volume of the transactions ( GDP) are declining or remain the same?
Increase or decrease in GDP do not translate to increase in IGR

Taxing buildings housing tax can increase IGR without increase in GDP

Having a tax break policy can reduce IGR but increase GDP... There is absolutely no correlation... How is this basic economics difficult for you guys is beyond me
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by FACE(m): 9:08am On Nov 09, 2024
richmond500:
GDP is the sum total of ur assets multiplied by its value.

IGR is an indication of what enters ur hand at the end of the day.
U can have a high GDP yet a very low IGR.
U are not economically viable if u look only at ur GDP and not increase ur IGR
Abeg go and read up GDP. What you just described is your gross worth. Take away liabilities and you will have your net worth. Yes, you can have a high GDP and low IGR, which is simply tax and royalties. The size of IGR will depend on how much of the GDP is captured and taxed. The private or informal sector will hide as much money as possible from the tax man.
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by Bestmanfornow:
helinues:
Discuss this logically without referring to the economists
Ogun among list most indebted states with nothing to show, and it's not bothering you guys, all you guys care is IGR chai, that's why you guys messed up the economy.
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by mrvitalis(m): 9:09am On Nov 09, 2024
helinues:
Isn't that the volume of GDP transacted?
What do you mean ... Isn't what the GDP transacted? Be clear oga
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by Bestmanfornow: 9:09am On Nov 09, 2024
mrvitalis:
So if you want to measure wealth or business activities of a nation by IGR

How can you measure business activities of a tax free state or tax heaven like Monaco or Dubai... Is their low revenue from tax a reflection of their economic state?
Only in Yorubaland IGR is being used to measure economy this guys are something else
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by helinues: 9:10am On Nov 09, 2024
Bestmanfornow:
Ogun among list most indebted states with nothing to show, and it's not bordering you guys, all you guys care is IGR chai, that's why you guys messed up the economy.
If you are not trusted by the loan facilitators, you can't have such high debt profile, you must definitely have potentials
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by Bestmanfornow: 9:11am On Nov 09, 2024
mrvitalis:
What do you mean ... Isn't what the GDP transacted? Be clear oga
Tax collectors end up in owanbe, northerners are smarter than these noise makers
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by mrvitalis(m): 9:11am On Nov 09, 2024
Bestmanfornow:
Only in Yorubaland IGR is being used to measure economy this guys are something else
So Monaco or Dubai with their low revenue to GDP ratio would be poor abi?
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by Bestmanfornow: 9:12am On Nov 09, 2024
helinues:
If you are not trusted by the loan facilitators, you can't have such high debt profile, you must definitely have potentials
Going to ten years now you have been defending nonsense Nigeria's economy sinking everyday
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by Bestmanfornow: 9:13am On Nov 09, 2024
mrvitalis:
So Monaco or Dubai with their low revenue to GDP ratio would be poor abi?
Common sense far from these guys
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by helinues: 9:16am On Nov 09, 2024
mrvitalis:
What do you mean ... Isn't what the GDP transacted? Be clear oga
Let me make it simple for you using South East and South West.

In South East, one business man can employ 10 people for his business, the more people work for him, the more money he makes, only that one person will be remitting tax on behalf of the rest of the 10. His own wealth would be shared with the remaining 10 based on GDP

In South West, one business man can go for 3 people to run his business while at least 3 from the remaining seven would be involved in all this mechanics, Tailor earning independently just like the one business man from South East.

When you use the above analogy to measure the wealth of the region, South East wealth is concentrated on few people which was used as per GDP per income, while in South West where there are more independent business, wealth is spread .

Taxing one business vs taxing 3 business, which one will generate more wealth for the state?
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by helinues: 9:17am On Nov 09, 2024
Bestmanfornow:
Going to ten years now you have been defending nonsense Nigeria's economy sinking everyday
Again leave personality and debate logically
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by Bestmanfornow: 9:19am On Nov 09, 2024
helinues:
Let me make it simple for you using South East and South West.

In South East, one business man can employ 10 people for his business, the more people work for him, the more money he makes, only that one person will be remitting tax on behalf of the rest of the 10. His own wealth would be shared with the remaining 10 based on GDP

In South West, one business man can go for 3 people to run his business while at least 3 from the remaining seven would be involved in all this mechanics, Tailor earning independently just like the one business man from South East.

When you use the above analogy to measure the wealth of the region, South East wealth is concentrated on few people which was used as per GDP per income, while in South West where there are more independent business, wealth is spread
All I need from you now is videos of top ten mega projects going on in Ogun let compare to Anambra projects not writing long epistle, since Ogun is making so much as they claimed let see mega projects in that state
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by Bestmanfornow: 9:20am On Nov 09, 2024
helinues:
Again leave personality and debate logically
The debate should be infrastructure right?
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by mrvitalis(m): 9:24am On Nov 09, 2024
helinues:
Let me make it simple for you using South East and South West.

In South East, one business man can employ 10 people for his business, the more people work for him, the more money he makes, only that one person will be remitting tax on behalf of the rest of the 10. His own wealth would be shared with the remaining 10 based on GDP

In South West, one business man can go for 3 people to run his business while at least 3 from the remaining seven would be involved in all this mechanics, Tailor earning independently just like the one business man from South East.

When you use the above analogy to measure the wealth of the region, South East wealth is concentrated on few people which was used as per GDP per income, while in South West where there are more independent business, wealth is spread .

Taxing one business vs taxing 3 business, which one will generate more wealth for the state?
Firstly you don't understand wealth measurements that is where you are getting it wrong

You don't understand GDP that's where you are also getting it wrong


Taxing 1 business can generate more than taxing 20 what matters is their capacity and net profit

And whatever you wrote up there is just your mere assumption


Una really get problem with economics... Now I get why tinubu kee getting it wrong
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by Kukutente23: 9:32am On Nov 09, 2024
richmond500:
I saw a post about how poor Nigeria is and another on how Ogun IGR doesn't define their wealth.
Actually real wealth is measured in IGR which is the same as cashflow.

Let me explain using Nigeria as an example,
1.) The GDP per Capita of Nigeria is almost N3m this mean the average Nigerian has 3m as net worth yet almost half the country is living in multi dimensional poverty, this does not make a single sense. I could assure you that 90% of the people that will see this post doesn't have up to N3m as net worth

2. most wealth calculation are in average and not median. Taking Nigeria as an example again, the dichotomy between the rich and the poor is so wide that average is not a real representation of wealth, the likes of the ultra rich like Dangote, Elumelu, Tinubu will influence the average wealth that GDP per Capita can make the average person 10times richer on paper while u are realistically wretched grin and in a solidly corrupt country, it can even make u 20 times richer. If we have 1000 people and 10 of them are worth 100m, while the other 990 are worth just 100k, the average of their wealth is N1m, of cos this is because the ultra rich which are very few has distorted the result. Median is a better representation but no country uses median in GDP per Capita.

3 IGR gives you a more realistic number of how much comes into a country or state, it is called cashflow, with this you can know how your worth and wealth.
If your household cashflow or salary is 150k monthly yet u have a N20m house, ur GDP or networth is N20m but you know u you are suffering.

I'll make a quote from Robert Kiyosaki who says, "real wealth is what comes into ur pocket and not what u have"

In summary, let us stop using GDP as a measure of wealth
This is the problem with bigots. They end up confusing themselves with the little they know. All over the world, GDP is used to measure a country's wealth but here's an agbado hustler turning economics upside down with his full chest all because he wants talking points for bigotry.
It is shameful and Okadigbo was right that if education does not cure you of bigotry then education is a waste.
You're a shining example.
What you're describing in terms of GDP per Capita is what is called income disparity and inequality. It does not mean GDP can't measure wealth appropriately because such phenomenon exists in third world countries like Nigeria where might is right.
IGR is subjective. It is even commonsense. IGR is a function of tax laws and collection efficiency not economic activity or wealth creation.
A state can decide to lower tax as a means of increasing income for its citizens and corporate while another may choose to increase tax in a drive to build infrastructure and help the ease of doing business and thus grow its GDP.
To make a comparison between IGR and GDP is a poor attempt. Bigotry is the cause of all this miseducation
Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by Obaaderemi2: 9:59am On Nov 09, 2024
richmond500:
I saw a post about how poor Nigeria is and another on how Ogun IGR doesn't define their wealth.
Actually real wealth is measured in IGR which is the same as cashflow.

Let me explain using Nigeria as an example,
1.) The GDP per Capita of Nigeria is almost N3m this mean the average Nigerian has 3m as net worth yet almost half the country is living in multi dimensional poverty, this does not make a single sense. I could assure you that 90% of the people that will see this post doesn't have up to N3m as net worth

2. most wealth calculation are in average and not median. Taking Nigeria as an example again, the dichotomy between the rich and the poor is so wide that average is not a real representation of wealth, the likes of the ultra rich like Dangote, Elumelu, Tinubu will influence the average wealth that GDP per Capita can make the average person 10times richer on paper while u are realistically wretched grin and in a solidly corrupt country, it can even make u 20 times richer. If we have 1000 people and 10 of them are worth 100m, while the other 990 are worth just 100k, the average of their wealth is N1m, of cos this is because the ultra rich which are very few has distorted the result. Median is a better representation but no country uses median in GDP per Capita.

3 IGR gives you a more realistic number of how much comes into a country or state, it is called cashflow, with this you can know how your worth and wealth.
If your household cashflow or salary is 150k monthly yet u have a N20m house, ur GDP or networth is N20m but you know u you are suffering.

I'll make a quote from Robert Kiyosaki who says, "real wealth is what comes into ur pocket and not what u have"

In summary, let us stop using GDP as a measure of wealth
Its

Re: Wealth Is Not Measured In GDP Per Capita by Georgry(m): 10:10am On Nov 09, 2024
helinues:
Discuss this logically without referring to the economists
Bro you're literally being schooled.


Gdp of Anambra is the totality of all economic activities in the state over that year, that's simply the total value they created via goods and services produced, it has nothing to do with the big empty houses or abandoned hotels, the key word is the total "VALUE" created.

GDP = private consumption + gross private investment + government investment + government spending + (exports – imports)

Since you guys really love politics and politics goes hand in hand with economics I will advise you to read basic microeconomics and microeconomics to understand how all these things work.
1 2 3 Reply

Nigeria’s GDP Per Capita By Successive Governments 1999 - 2027 • NBS To Include Prostitution, Other Illegal Activities In GDP Calculation • Development Is Not Measured Using IGR But HDI. David Hundeyin Tackles Tinubu Fan • 2 • 3 • 4

Peter Obi Restricted From Traveling Abroad By Nigeria Government • Jiba Hails President Tinubu At Birthday, Lauds "Renewed Hope" Vision ​ • Why 50% Of 103 Million Registered Voters Must Vote In 2027 - Peacepro