₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,226 members, 8,521,851 topics. Date: Friday, 20 November 2026 at 07:24 AM

Toggle theme

How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista - Politics (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista (3480 Views)

1 2 Reply (Go Down)

Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by Blackdisciple(m): 3:28pm On Dec 19, 2024
Talk to the hands
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by GetSenseNow: 3:39pm On Dec 19, 2024
OlujobaSamuel:
I wonder ooo
During the last PEPT, instead for the opposition parties to put up arguments on how figures were changed or incorrect from evidences presented by their agents, they were talking about how the declared winner wasn't eligible, how he has a criminal case outside the country, how he never had ⅔ in Abuja, etc
For instance, I was expecting a case like that of Rivers where some claimed the result declared at LGA level is different from State level, such should have been presented with evidence.
Even if everything is done online from A-Z, most of all this politicians and their supporters won't accept the result
If this is the case, I think you guys should support making everything 100% automated. This way, no one will try to claim another person's mandate in whatever way
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by Umuinyioku: 3:43pm On Dec 19, 2024
9jatriot:
In Nigeria and at least in Africa, INEC remains the best electoral body so far. They try to come up with very innovative ideas every election, which some other African countries try to copy.

That losers of elections start crying foul play does not mean that the elections were not credible.

The real bias electoral bodies in NIgeria are the state electoral bodies. It is state electoral bodies that handle LGA elections in NIgeria and on every election cycle it is always the ruling party's party that wins all the positions in that state.

River's state took it a step further by officially adopting a particular party loyal to him and they also cleared virtually all the local governments.
Why derailing the topic?

He is suggesting South Africa model. But you are saying a different thing.

You are opposing it because your Principal can't win in a fair and free election. Where things are properly put in place.

You prefer thuggery and assaults.
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by Okiton: 3:46pm On Dec 19, 2024
angry

TonyeBarcanista Is a political bird, he sings whenever and wherever it favours him. I never take him serious and his cock and bull stories
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by samuel1981(m): 3:47pm On Dec 19, 2024
INEC and integrity has nothing in common, and under Tinubu, it will surely get worse check all the election that has been conducted under this regime and tell me what you have seen.

2027 will surely be a joke of election.
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by TonyeBarcanista(op): 3:48pm On Dec 19, 2024
Nigeria has 176,974 Polling units. How is it feasible to challenge manipulated results for 80,000 Polling units, and present witnesses for each of them within the 4 months time frame? Have you considered the logistics that would require? By automating the collation centrally, you drastically reduce any chance for manipulation. At worst there may be few instances of incorrect collation which can be reconciled using manual records. This will also eliminate the challenge of ballot stuffing, ballot box snatching and hijack.

Mention any country that uses intermediary collation centres during election beside Nigeria.


OlujobaSamuel:
I wonder ooo
During the last PEPT, instead for the opposition parties to put up arguments on how figures were changed or incorrect from evidences presented by their agents, they were talking about how the declared winner wasn't eligible, how he has a criminal case outside the country, how he never had ⅔ in Abuja, etc
For instance, I was expecting a case like that of Rivers where some claimed the result declared at LGA level is different from State level, such should have been presented with evidence.
Even if everything is done online from A-Z, most of all this politicians and their supporters won't accept the result
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by Image123(m): 3:50pm On Dec 19, 2024
TonyeBarcanista:
Ignorance!

Aside Nigeria, mention any country that has intermediary collation centres
Education!
Help me with countries that use livestream for democracy and how it has helped their government to be better. Thanks.
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by israelmao(m): 3:52pm On Dec 19, 2024
9jatriot:
In Nigeria and at least in Africa, INEC remains the best electoral body so far. They try to come up with very innovative ideas every election, which some other African countries try to copy.

That losers of elections start crying foul play does not mean that the elections were not credible.

The real bias electoral bodies in NIgeria are the state electoral bodies. It is state electoral bodies that handle LGA elections in NIgeria and on every election cycle it is always the ruling party's party that wins all the positions in that state.

River's state took it a step further by officially adopting a particular party loyal to him and they also cleared virtually all the local governments.
You can sing praises of INEC but about the corruption and fraudulence in INEC is indestructible.For you do nothing against the truth but for the truth.
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by aswani(m): 3:52pm On Dec 19, 2024
TonyeBarcanista:
Mention any country, including your so-called saner climes, where they have intermediary collation centres.
Are you sure you are responding to my post?
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by TonyeBarcanista(op): 4:03pm On Dec 19, 2024
aswani:
Are you sure you are responding to my post?
Precisely! Especially when you started with "what's wrong with the present system"

What is wrong with the present system is the multiplicity of collation intermediaries:

Polling Unit to Ward Collation to LGA to States and then to the Central for Presidential election

Polling Unit to Ward Collation to LGA to States for Gubernatorial and Legislative elections.

Why not:
Polling Unit to Central Collation for the respective election? Party agents, observers and other election stakeholders will still have signed manual copies of results of Polling Unit for query and reconciliation or litigation in case of dispute?

Forgive me if I misunderstood your earlier post.
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by rinzaugustine: 4:04pm On Dec 19, 2024
Lol. It will not happen in Nigeria with the current thieves led by mandate thief. Imagine contravening electoral act that mandated electronic voting to go ahead and switch off servers manually transferring results to tinubu and still refused inspection access to other political parties as was mandated by Electoral Act. Only a fool believes Nigeria will get better with this current system. It will not get better even in the next 20 years and will get worse

Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by aylipple: 4:18pm On Dec 19, 2024
Is it really INEC/the system that’s the problem here or politicians and their supporters who have learnt to circumvent the electoral process over time?

Case in point was the last presidential elections where INEC declared one candidate winner but two other candidates both claimed to have won the same elections & this is aside the declared winner; the question would be, who between the first runner-up & second runner-up actually “won” since both candidates purportedly had party agents across the Polling Units nationwide?

Would either of them be sincere enough to even acknowledge that they lost the election because irrespective of who INEC declared as winner, we had an election where three contestants claimed they’ve empirical evidence that they won?

In summary, even if the elections were to Ben uploaded real time on giant screens as large as stadium, as long as the political players don’t have any iota of truth in them, once a winner emerges, there will be claims by another contestant that they won, then they’ll allege the election transmission was “hacked” & then we’ll have election tribunals settling the matter and the cycle continues .

If it’s not broken, don’t fix it!
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by Lamasta(m): 4:18pm On Dec 19, 2024
INEC is a disappointment to anything called electoral integrity in this country
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by healthkknatural(m): 4:31pm On Dec 19, 2024
Tonye , Stop Wasting your Time.

INEC is Not Interested in Organizing any Credible Elections.

How Possible is for a President to Appoint INEC head and You expects him to Acts Against His Boss
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by casualobserver:
TonyeBarcanista:
'Tonye Barcanista
there is nothing wrong with the currrent system, the only problem we have are sore losers who instead of looking inwards and analysing where they went wrong blame the system. No system can prevent rigging or infractions and I have said this many times, the current system will leave evidence of any malpractice. The election is Rivers was rigged but it didnt alter the material result otherwise the clear evidence of rigging would have beeen presented because the evidence was there. Secondly, the governorship election in Imo was massively rigged but even if you cancelled all the contentious rigged results, it didnt affect who won...this was attested to by Osita Chidoka and his NGO who did a critical analysis on the recent elections.

The system you propose on the other hand is flawed, how many intermediaries will you need at the central collation centers to handle the barage of results coming in from 176,000 polling units? Do you have collation centers big enough to handle the number of people in one location? have you considered the confusing with so many people in one location collating different PU results?

This is a knee jerk reaction to sore losers who have bought into the INEC bashing propaganda. INEC has very robust system, if there is any rigging, you will always leave evidence. Every party agent and the police has a copy of the authentic PU result. BVAS has a record of the voters who voted. ANy alterations you make afterward leaves a verifiable trail.

Focus on getting your election strategies right. PDP and LP lost the election because they split their 14M votes, PDP lost Edo because they tried to impose a candidate that was not popular. These things are not INECs fault. It is the samne INEC system that caught evidence of rigging and installed Adeleke as governor!

The only way a centralised system can work is if it is electronic and that introduces its own challenges like hacking, network availability etc. ultimately every election (even in the USA and UK) relies on a verifiable paper trail of actual paper ballots.

Rigging happens but it has been greatly eleimnated. However for the few cases where rigging does happen, there is always evidence. You can pinpoint down to the INEC officer or ad-hoc staff who enabled any rigging. This is clearly displayed in the video by Osita Chidoka. The reason people do not produce the evidence is because they know they lost despite the rigging. When the rigging affects the results the evidence is there like the Adeleke case. It is a shame that instead of praising INEC some are scapegoating INEc for their electoral strategy failures.

It suggests a failure of intellect to parrot the narrative that our electoral system is a sham. It is IMHO as fool proof a system as you will find anywhere in the world. As someone who has voted in the UK and is aware of voting in the US, we have a better system than those 2 countries. As some one once told me in relation to DSTV cards, sometimes it takes a nation of crooks to develop the most robust systems. Their electoral systems run on trust, ours was designed to counter our propensity for criminality as such it is more robust than theirs.

There is a good reason why all the challengers of the presidential election result produced ballot boxes for show but did not present a single evidence of rigging and instead centered their cases on disqualification. Because although they had evidence of whatever rigging happened, meaning the system worked as intended, it did not change the outcome of the result!


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qD7VhxgKTbs?si=HwS2IEFB_nq9T2mi
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by aswani(m): 5:35pm On Dec 19, 2024
TonyeBarcanista:
Precisely! Especially when you started with "what's wrong with the present system"

What is wrong with the present system is the multiplicity of collation intermediaries:

Polling Unit to Ward Collation to LGA to States and then to the Central for Presidential election

Polling Unit to Ward Collation to LGA to States for Gubernatorial and Legislative elections.

Why not:
Polling Unit to Central Collation for the respective election? Party agents, observers and other election stakeholders will still have signed manual copies of results of Polling Unit for query and reconciliation or litigation in case of dispute?

Forgive me if I misunderstood your earlier post.
Ah, now I understand where my post came in, including the misunderstood part.

My point though is, especially with rural areas and polling officer incompetency, we can't automate any further right now.

Look at blurred pictures on IREV at the last one, in fact there was a picture of someone bathing before the data was cleaned. And don't forget the menace of hackers as well.

If we agree that hard copies still need to be lodged with INEC, and I am not saying you do, the current system of Unit to Ward to LGA to State etc seems apt. I can't think of a better alternative.

Hopefully we will eventually get to your suggestion of a central Collation centre being the next step for the dáta after the polling unit but, based on elections so far, I am not sure we are ready for that. In fact, that scares me a lot.
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by themanderon: 6:30pm On Dec 19, 2024
Inec has no intentions to improve any kind of integrity. They have none to protect since they are the ones that simply break electoral rules with their shoddiness.
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by UpaIweka: 7:08pm On Dec 19, 2024
When pdp n labour return to the presidency then we can stop the president from appointing the
INEC Chairman.
Racoon:
Stop president from appointing INEC chairman or RECs.
-Institute electoral reforms including electronic voting system.
-Direct transmission of election results to national server.
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by OlujobaSamuel: 7:17pm On Dec 19, 2024
TonyeBarcanista:
Nigeria has 176,974 Polling units. How is it feasible to challenge manipulated results for 80,000 Polling units, and present witnesses for each of them within the 4 months time frame? Have you considered the logistics that would require? By automating the collation centrally, you drastically reduce any chance for manipulation. At worst there may be few instances of incorrect collation which can be reconciled using manual records. This will also eliminate the challenge of ballot stuffing, ballot box snatching and hijack.

Mention any country that uses intermediary collation centres during election beside Nigeria.
@your last paragraph, @Tonye, like seriouslyhuh You are more exposed than that Na.
The Mail Ballot System in the US is what? Can't you see the human interference through the movement of such votes?
On your point of presenting a case of about 80k PU, that's like having discrepancy in 1 of every 2PU which is highly unlikely as such will result to nationwide violence
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by OlujobaSamuel: 7:30pm On Dec 19, 2024
GetSenseNow:
If this is the case, I think you guys should support making everything 100% automated. This way, no one will try to claim another person's mandate in whatever way
I'm all for an automated system, but the issue is no system will work until our politicians are committed to make it work.
The politicians I know will recruit people that will actively work round the clock to find a way to bypass the system
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by TonyeBarcanista(op):
OlujobaSamuel:
@your last paragraph, @Tonye, like seriouslyhuh You are more exposed than that Na.
The Mail Ballot System in the US is what? Can't you see the human interference through the movement of such votes?
Maybe you don't really understand mail ballot.

In Mail ballot, the voters don't go to Polling station, they request for their ballot paper via mail and have it delivered. They cast their vote and return to local office. The votes are recorded and inputed in a central portal. There is no Polling units.

People that goes to Polling units automatically have their votes transmitted to the central server. The State's collate and announce results. The Federal don't organise, collate, announce or declare results in the United States. There is no multilayer collation centre.
On your point of presenting a case of about 80k PU, that's like having discrepancy in 1 of every 2PU which is highly unlikely as such will result to nationwide violence
That's not how the law works. Kindly read the Evidence Act!


What we are saying is that there will definitely be human involvement (it is the human PU Presiding Officers that will transmit results to the central portal), but there should be no manually multilayer collation.

Now let me tell you how the present system works:

You vote at Polling Unit
They collate results
They take all PUs results to Ward Collation centres
They take all collated results in each wards to the LG Collation center
They do same to State Collation Centre.
Then they carry the results from States to National Collation Centre.

Why not transmit directly to the Centre like it's done in every other place?
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by eepeepook(f): 10:37pm On Dec 19, 2024
This boy never ready to wise.
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by OlujobaSamuel: 11:16pm On Dec 19, 2024
TonyeBarcanista:
Maybe you don't really understand mail ballot.

In Mail ballot, the voters don't go to Polling station, they request for their ballot paper via mail and have it delivered. They cast their vote and return to local office. The votes are recorded and inputed in a central portal. There is no Polling units.

People that goes to Polling units automatically have their votes transmitted to the central server. The State's collate and announce results. The Federal don't organise, collate, announce or declare results in the United States. There is no multilayer collation centre.

That's not how the law works. Kindly read the Evidence Act!


What we are saying is that there will definitely be human involvement (it the human PU Presiding Officer ) that will transmit results to the central portal, but there should be no manually multilayer collation.

Now let me tell you how the present system works:

You vote at Polling Unit
They collate results
They take all PUs results to Ward Collation centres
They take all collated results in each wards to the LG Collation center
They do same to State Collation Centre.
Then they carry the results from States to National Collation Centre.

Why not transmit directly to the Centre like it's done in every other place?
The micro layer or phase is easy to challenge than having to challenge multilayer of results
Eg, I'm present as a Party Agent at PU002, if the result isn't same with what was presented on site, I get to know soon enough and know who the culprit is and challenge it immediately.
The central system you want means it all goes back to Abuja first before coming back to States just as we have during Maurice Iwu's days.
Remember that we can't do away with paper collation for now till we discard the current military constitution
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by Sundaymessi: 11:35pm On Dec 19, 2024
TonyeBarcanista:
'Tonye Barcanista
When people prioritize dishonesty, even simple things becomes difficult.
Says the wife of a former governor.
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by TonyeBarcanista(op): 1:46am On Dec 20, 2024
OlujobaSamuel:
The micro layer or phase is easy to challenge than having to challenge multilayer of results
Eg, I'm present as a Party Agent at PU002, if the result isn't same with what was presented on site, I get to know soon enough and know who the culprit is and challenge it immediately.
The central system you want means it all goes back to Abuja first before coming back to States just as we have during Maurice Iwu's days.
Remember that we can't do away with paper collation for now till we discard the current military constitution
No!

All results go straight to central portal that is accessible by all. States declare gubernatorial and legislative results and return winners elected, Abuja announce Presidential result and declare the winner elected. Nobody is taking result from Abuja to States or States to Abuja, everyone simply have access to the uploaded results. There are no multiple layers.

Kindly re-read the original post
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by BluntCrazeMan: 6:12am On Dec 20, 2024
TonyeBarcanista:
'Tonye Barcanista
Alternatively,, why won't INEC develop an E-collation System where all these various collation centers have their own dedicated independent servers, thus there won't be only one single back-end server,, BUT A SYSTEM OF MANY SERVERS.??

Thus, a particular BVAS-device would have to simultaneously (but separately) transmit the data within it to all the specifically concerned servers in its upline at all the required levels of the collation system..

...
Thus, there is supposed to be a minimum of 9,621 independent servers in the e-collation system of the Presidential Election alone (that-is 8,809 + 774 + 37 + 1 = 9,621), and an additional 1,491 servers that would serve as the final collation servers for those other contestable positions.

All the servers in the system must be independent, and can only assess the data that is necessary for its operations (that-is, the down-line data from the lower-level servers and the data transmitted directly from the BVAS Devices at the polling units).

WITH SUCH A DECENTRALIZED E-COLLATION SYSTEM,, THE DATA CANNOT BE EASILY MANIPULATED -- BECAUSE THE AUTHENTIC ORIGINAL DATA WAS TRANSMITTED AND STORED IN VARIOUS UNCONNECTED BACK-END SERVERS,, AND NOT JUST ONE BIGG MIGHTY SERVER WHICH COULD JUST BE TAMPERED WITH, AND IT WOULD AFFECT THE WHOLE RESULTS EVERYWHERE.!!
Re: How INEC Can Improve The Integrity Of Our Elections - TonyeBarcanista by QuestLINKsPrpty(f): 11:16am On Dec 20, 2024
DeepSight:
Only a detestable crook can say something like this.
1 2 Reply

Betta Edu: When Obasanjo, Yar'adua Were Presidents - TonyeBarcanista • Court Rules That INEC Can Determine How Election Results Are Transmitted • Court Ruled In January That INEC Can Use Any Method For Results Transmission • 2 • 3 • 4

There Can Never Be Peace In Nigeria Until. . . • JTF Warns Of A Possible Boko Haram Attack In Kano During Easter Holiday • It Is Time For Awoists To Stop Living In Denial : : Francis Adewale