Why Job Interviews Are Pointless? - Jobs/Vacancies - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Jobs/Vacancies › Why Job Interviews Are Pointless? (741 Views)
| Why Job Interviews Are Pointless? by Blazing111(op): 2:13am On Dec 24, 2024 |
Let me start with this: I’ve always found job interviews strange. I mean, think about it. You sit in a room with a stranger, answer some questions that may or may not have anything to do with the job, and somehow, from that conversation, they decide if you’re good enough. Does that make any sense? To me, it doesn’t. Here’s the thing about interviews: they’re like trying to guess the weather by looking at the sky for two minutes. Sure, you might be able to tell if it’s sunny or cloudy, but that doesn’t mean you know if it’s going to rain next week. Interviews are too short, too fake, and honestly, just bad at figuring out who’s right for the job. I know what you’re thinking. “But interviews are important! How else will companies know who to hire?” Well, I have thoughts on that, too. But first, let’s talk about why interviews just don’t work. Also Read → How I Negotiated a 50% Salary Increase Using These Strategies 1. People Are Always Faking It Here’s the thing. Nobody goes into a job interview acting like their true self. People dress up in clothes they’d never wear on a normal day, practice answers to questions they think the interviewer will ask, and spend hours trying to look confident. It’s not real. Think about it. When you’re in an interview, you’re not being yourself—you’re being the version of yourself that you think they want to see. And guess what? The person interviewing you is doing the same thing. They’re also pretending. They’re pretending to be friendly, pretending to listen closely, and pretending they know how to judge you. If both people are faking, how can that ever lead to a good decision? You’re not hiring the real person. You’re hiring their “interview persona.” 2. Weird Questions Don’t Prove Anything Have you ever been asked, “Where do you see yourself in five years?” Or maybe, “What’s your biggest weakness?” These questions are ridiculous. Nobody knows where they’ll be in five years. Life changes too fast. And asking someone about their weaknesses? Please. Nobody is going to tell the truth. They’ll say something fake, like “I care too much” or “I work too hard.” And then there are those companies that ask random questions like, “If you were an animal, what would you be?” or “How many tennis balls fit in a bus?” What does that even mean? How does my answer to that tell you if I can do the job? These questions don’t test your skills. They just test how good you are at answering silly questions. 3. It’s All About First Impressions Here’s a secret about interviews: most decisions are made in the first few minutes. If the interviewer likes you, they’ll look for reasons to keep liking you. If they don’t, it’s game over. This is called “confirmation bias.” It’s when people make up their minds quickly and then look for evidence to support their decision. In an interview, this means that if you stumble over your first answer, you’re probably out of luck. But what if you’re just nervous? What if you’re not great at talking to strangers but you’re amazing at the job? Too bad. Interviews only care about that first impression. Also Read → I Started as an Intern and Ended Up as a Manager – Here’s How I Did It 4. Interviews Don’t Test Real Skills Imagine this: you’re hiring a chef. Would you sit them down in a chair and ask them about their weaknesses? Or would you ask them to cook something? Of course, you’d ask them to cook. That’s the only way to know if they’re good. But when it comes to most jobs, we don’t do that. We don’t test people on the actual work they’ll be doing. Instead, we ask them to talk about their work. Talking about work is not the same as doing work. Just because someone can explain how they’d solve a problem doesn’t mean they can actually solve it. But interviews treat these two things like they’re the same, and they’re not. 5. Bias Ruins Everything Here’s the truth: interviewers are biased, even if they don’t mean to be. Maybe they prefer people who look like them. Or people who went to the same school. Or people who have the same hobbies. Even the way you talk or the tone of your voice can affect their opinion. Bias isn’t fair, but it’s everywhere. And in interviews, it’s a big problem. A good candidate can get rejected just because the interviewer doesn’t “click” with them. And someone less qualified might get hired because the interviewer likes their vibe. Is that how we should choose who gets a job? I don’t think so. 6. Experience Doesn’t Always Mean Better Another thing about interviews is they focus too much on experience. If you’ve done the same job before, you’re more likely to get hired. But is that fair? What about people who are new to the field but full of fresh ideas? Or people who don’t have fancy resumes but are hardworking and willing to learn? Experience is important, but it’s not everything. And interviews don’t give people without experience a fair chance to prove themselves. Also Read → How I Used AI to Automate Tasks and Free Up 10 Hours a Week 7. It’s a Waste of Time Let’s be honest. Interviews take forever. You have to prepare, travel, and sit through awkward conversations. And for what? Most interviews don’t even lead to a job offer. For companies, it’s even worse. They spend hours interviewing people, only to hire someone who might not even work out. It’s a lot of time and effort for very little payoff. What’s the Alternative? So, if interviews are so bad, what should we do instead? I have a few ideas. Tryouts: Instead of interviews, give people a small task related to the job. If it’s a writing job, ask them to write something. If it’s a tech job, give them a coding challenge. Let their work speak for itself. Blind Hiring: Remove names, photos, and other personal info from resumes. Focus only on skills and qualifications to avoid bias. Team Activities: Bring candidates into a group setting and see how they work with others. This shows you how they’ll fit into the team. Probation Periods: Hire people for a trial period. Let them do the job for a few weeks and see how they perform. It’s better than guessing based on an interview. Final Thoughts Job interviews are like playing the lottery. Sometimes you get lucky, but most of the time, it’s just a waste of time. They’re not fair, they’re not accurate, and they don’t test what really matters. It’s time to stop pretending interviews are the best way to hire people. We can do better. And until we do, we’ll keep missing out on amazing talent just because they didn’t answer some silly question the “right” way. |
| Re: Why Job Interviews Are Pointless? by budaatum: 2:46am On Dec 24, 2024 |
My sister told me about an interview for a job she had. After she left, she was ashamed at how many times her answers to question included what she had learnt from her mother, and she thought, better luck next time. Then she got home and got a call asking when she could start please. She was so surprised that she actually asked the employer if they were sure. And the employer was so surprised that she did not know how well she had aced the interview. My point is, a lot can be told about your psychology and philosophy to work from just your attitude and the choice of words you use to express yourself. And don't forget we already will have your application form that says quite a lot about you. |
| Re: Why Job Interviews Are Pointless? by Love800(m): 6:48am On Dec 24, 2024 |
Both of you are correct. How you speak can tell alot about your abilities. And the OP is also correct on the alternatives to the usual interviews! budaatum: |
| Re: Why Job Interviews Are Pointless? by Alusiizizi(m): 12:52pm On Dec 24, 2024 |
The only sort of jobs that I can think of where interviews would be important are jobs that require inter-personal skills, like receptionist or customer service. For correct jobs in fields like engineering/tech interviews are utterly useless and a waste of time. |
| Re: Why Job Interviews Are Pointless? by lacasera14(m): 2:01pm On Dec 24, 2024 |
I've always thought they are pointless, absolutely and ridiculous. Why will you be asking if I see a better job will I leave? If that's not a trap to screen me out? If you have my CV already and it says a lot about me and my experience, what else do you want to hear from my mouth again? Is the job a public speaking role or one that demands me expressing myself all the time? What if I'm not good with people skills and my role is coding which doesn't require it? Why use a people-based yardstick to measure me when that's not my field. Scrap interviews already, the op took the words out of me. That's why I'll continue to work from home. |
| Re: Why Job Interviews Are Pointless? by tensazangetsu20(m): 3:37pm On Dec 24, 2024 |
Alusiizizi:How are tech interviews a waste of time? |
| Re: Why Job Interviews Are Pointless? by Alusiizizi(m): 5:17pm On Dec 24, 2024 |
tensazangetsu20:There is a study that I read which seemed to indicate that coding ability was inversely correlated with interview success(which would make sense from personal experience). Now I know that this example is just from a narrow field of coding and comp. sci. but I suspect that this also obtains for most tech fields. |
| Re: Why Job Interviews Are Pointless? by tensazangetsu20(m): 5:23pm On Dec 24, 2024 |
Alusiizizi: ![]() |
| Re: Why Job Interviews Are Pointless? by Karleb(m): 6:33pm On Dec 24, 2024 |
When you become a CTO just employ anybody. You hear? ![]() |
| Re: Why Job Interviews Are Pointless? by Suicideboy: 3:51am On Dec 25, 2024 |
job interviews are pointless especially for engineering or programming roles best way to hire - give them a problem to solve , correct answer gets job - have them contribute to a repo a meaningful PR that's not updating readme Best way I would hire would be for stalk GitHub profile of potential engineer , if you're forking multiple repo and not getting feedback, red flag no stars at all , no issues by actual people, no PR, red flag |
Job Interviews And The State Of Education In Nigeria • This Is How Job Interviews Are Supposed To Be. • 5 Deadly Sins To Avoid At Job Interviews • 2 • 3 • 4
EXXONMOBIL Job And Internship Opening 2025 • Medical Career! • Urgent Employment For Abuja Residents.
