Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati - Politics - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati (1297 Views)
| Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by helinues(op): 8:22pm On Jan 07, 2025 |
Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamation Of Evangelist Ebuka Obi, Says High Court Lacks Jurisdiction SaharaReporters reports that Ijele's case has been ongoing since April 2024, when he was detained at Ikoyi Prison in Lagos on allegations of cybercrime. Human rights lawyer, Femi Falana (SAN) has faulted the continued detention of Chizorom Harrison Ofoegbu, popularly known as Ijele by Evangelist Ebuka Obi, the spiritual director of Zion Movement Outreach Ministry located in Lagos State. SaharaReporters reports that Ijele's case has been ongoing since April 2024, when he was detained at Ikoyi Prison in Lagos on allegations of cybercrime. Despite meeting his bail conditions, his release has been hindered due to another case filed against him in Awka, Anambra State. But reacting to the continued incarceration of the social media influencer, Falana explained that the Federal High Court has ruled that by the Community reading of Section 251 (1) (S), (3) of the CFRN and Section 7 (1) and (2) of the Federal High Court Act, it has no jurisdiction to try the offence of defamation. According to the senior lawyer, the court also ruled that the offence of using social media handle to make online publications with the intention to cause hatred and damage the reputation of any person is no longer provided for under the existing law. According to him, the court however ruled that it has jurisdiction to try the offence of cyberstalking vide online publication against the person of the evangelist which put him to fear of death under sections 24 (2) (c) (i) (ii) and (3) of the Act as amended. He said, "The section provides for the offence of cyberstalking where a person knowingly or intentionally sends a message by means of computer systems or network that is pornography or which he knows to be false for the purpose of causing a breakdown of law and order, posing a threat to life or causing such message to be sent and where a person knowingly or intentionally transmits or causes the transmission of any communication through a computer system or network to bully, threaten or harass another person, where such communication places another person in fear of death, violence or bodily harm to another person." Count 1 of the charges against Ijele reads: “Conspiracy to commit the offence of using social media handle to make online publication with the intention to cause hatred and damage the reputation of the Evangelist which is not provided for under the existing law." Regarding this, Falana said, "It has been argued for the Defendant that the offence of using social media handle to make false online publication against the person of Evangelist Ebuka Obi, with the intention to cause hatred and damage to the reputation of the Evangelist is not known to law and that the Defendant cannot be accused of conspiring to commit a non-existent offence. "No doubt, the alleged offence in Count one (1) of the Amended Charge is conspiracy to commit the offence of using social media handle to make online publication with the intention to cause hatred and damage the reputation of the Evangelist which is not provided for under the existing law. "The alleged offence in Count one (1) of the Amended Charge is conspiracy to commit the offence of using social media handle to make online publication with the intention to cause hatred and damage the reputation of the Evangelist which is not provided for under the existing law. "Section 24(1) (b) of the Cybercrimes (Prohibition, Prevention etc.) Act, 2015 which mentions or talks about causing hatred has been amended in the 2024 Amendment where such words have been removed. The law is that one cannot be successfully accused of conspiracy to commit a principal offence that is non-existent.” Falana further noted that on whether a person can be charged with conspiracy to commit an offence which is unknown to the law, the appellate court in Alao-Akala v. FRN (2021) LPELR - 56126 (CA) pp. 33-34, para F held as follows: “’What Section 22(4) of the I.C.P.C Act criminalized as an offence is award of contract without budget provision, approval and cash backing and not awarding contract without budget provision simpliciter. The offence the Appellant is charged with is unknown to the law. "The Charge of conspiracy in this case cannot stand because what was alleged to have been agreed upon is not an offence under any law. Therefore, I am of the view that the Appellant cannot be lawfully and properly charged for conspiracy since no unlawful act was established and no agreement to do an illegal act was established by the Prosecution. "On the footing of the foregoing, I hold that count one (1) in the Amended Charge is incompetent – Aluko J.'" Count 2 reads: “Offence of Cyberstalking vide on-line publication against the person of the Evangelist which put him to fear of death." "'On Count 2, this relates to the offence of Cyberstalking vide on-line publication against the person of the Evangelist which put him to fear of death. This offence can well be placed within the provision of Section 24 (1) (a) (b) and 2(a) of the Cyber Crimes (Prohibition, Prevention, etc.) Act, 2015 (As Amended) 2024. “’The above provision of the Act provides for the offence of Cyber stalking where a person knowingly or intentionally sends a message by means of computer systems or network that is pornography or which he knows to be false for the purpose of causing a breakdown of law and order, posing a threat to life or causing such message to be sent and where a person knowingly or intentionally transmits or causes the transmission of any communication through a computer system or network to bully, threaten or harass another person, where such communication places another person in fear of death, violence or bodily harm to another person. The offence under Count 2 is punishable under sections 24 (2) (c) (i) (ii) and (3) of the Act,’ – Aluko J. Regarding Count 3, he said, “On criminal allegation of defamation by publication with the intention to annoy, expose the Evangelist to hatred, contempt, ridicule, to disparage, lower his estimation and damage his reputation before the right thinking members of the public; offence was charged pursuant to Sections 373 and 374 of the Criminal Code Act. "The main gist and summary of the offence under Count 3 of the Amended Charge is a criminal allegation of defamation by publication with the intention to annoy, expose the Evangelist to hatred, contempt, ridicule, to disparage, lower his estimation and damage his reputation before the right-thinking members of the public. "I agree with the senior counsel that this offence particularly as it relates to defamation by whatever means is not one of the offences over which is court can exercise its criminal jurisdiction. "Defamation is not one of the items over which jurisdiction is conferred on his Court vide Section 251(1) of CFRN or in respect of which the National Assembly can be said to have conferred this court with such jurisdiction. "Therefore, by the Community reading of Section 251 (1) (S), (3) of the CFRN and Section 7 (1) and (2) of the Federal High Court Act, this Court has no jurisdiction to exercise over the offence of defamation. "'Even in civil cases, there are a plethora of judicial pronouncements to the effect that this Court cannot exercise its jurisdiction over claims of torts of defamation. See Omon & Ors v. Ekpa (2019) LPELR - 47978 (CA) pp. 15 - 19, para A. To the extent of the foregoing, Count 3 in the Amended Charge is incompetent,' – Aluko J." SaharaReporters |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by helinues(op): 8:24pm On Jan 07, 2025 |
MoltenSage:He's still there oo I saw the updates on one thread and decided to post it |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by immortalcrown(m): 8:24pm On Jan 07, 2025 |
Naija. |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by santopelele(m): 8:34pm On Jan 07, 2025 |
He should remain there and answer for his crimes, i thought that he was forming untouchable the time he was posting all sorts of propagandas and supporting the killings in south east here on naira land and Facebook, noow hand don touch him. Social media influencer indeed, His coming out from the dungeon is very far than expected. |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by NATIONALPASTOR: 8:47pm On Jan 07, 2025 |
Yorubas that used him to destroy Igboland are asking the court to Release him as part of their agreement. We all remember when the terrorist was playing video games with lives of Igbo youths. Ijele of Yorubas, we've thrown Keystone your prison room into the Atlantic. May you die a slow and painful death. |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by Racoon(m): 10:27pm On Jan 07, 2025*. Modified: 9:31am On Jan 08, 2025 |
Like that yeye pastor Okezie on twitter, APC has happened to Ijele speaks. Used and dumped unlike sacred crows e.g. Lai Mohammed, Nasir El-Rufai, MC Oluomo who can say their own shit and get away with it easily. |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by helinues(op): 10:36pm On Jan 07, 2025 |
santopelele:Same way Kanu will remain for prison for long |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by nedu666: 12:34am On Jan 08, 2025 |
When he was threatening ebuka obi. Mofo forgot buhari was no longer president |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by Bobloco: 2:36am On Jan 08, 2025 |
We warned Ijele, but he didn't listen. Those who egged him on to his doom have since abandoned him. 'If you sell your brother, even the buyer won't trust you.' – African proverb |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by SmartPolician: 5:54am On Jan 08, 2025*. Modified: 8:58am On Jan 08, 2025 |
nedu666:Evangelist Ebuka Obi isn't the person keeping him in prison. Someone else he offended filed a case against him. Dude offended several people. |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by helinues(op): 6:03am On Jan 08, 2025 |
nedu666:Same way Kanu was warned but refused to listen |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by Hopebringer: 6:35am On Jan 08, 2025 |
helinues:I remember you, you were working with that ijele fellow. I know for a fact that some people are actually looking for you. ![]() You think because you sneak in and out you won't be caught. I will post your topic here the day you are apprehended. You will be in jail like that your ibo brother ijele. Don't worry you will be caught one day. All your atrocious comments are documented |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by helinues(op): 6:37am On Jan 08, 2025 |
Hopebringer:Where did you see me blackmailing or threatening others? Hahaha, una hero Kanu is languishing in cell just like Ijele. Both from your region.. |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by Hopebringer: 6:39am On Jan 08, 2025 |
helinues:My region? I am not from iboland like your guys. I am a bini man. But I know you very well on this forum. I remember for years how you abused insulted cursed and degenerated their tribe. I know for a fact some people have launched a manhunt for you.. I know for a fact you will stand trial to defend all your comments that are documented. I know for a fact you will be imprisoned. It is not if but when |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by Paraman: 7:40am On Jan 08, 2025 |
Atiku wey ijele dey support no even say anything about him |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by Nnamdipapa(m): 7:55am On Jan 08, 2025 |
nedu666:Wtf is Ebuka Obi? Why do we celebrate rifrafs in Igbo land? |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by MadPolitician: 7:58am On Jan 08, 2025 |
helinues:He should be allowed to kpai dia.. When you excuse the extra judicial annihilation of a people because of pecuniary interests, if you find yourself in dangerous waters, it is only fair for you to be allowed to stew in your on juice.. Next topic, pls.. |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by helinues(op): 8:06am On Jan 08, 2025 |
MadPolitician:Same way Nnamdi Kanu will pkai for where is being incarcerated |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by nedu666: 8:52am On Jan 08, 2025 |
Nnamdipapa:Ebuka we know Obi we know Wtf is this nonentity quoting me |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by nedu666: 8:56am On Jan 08, 2025 |
helinues:There is no difference between you and Kanu. Kanu is wasting away in prison, while you are wasting away on Nairaland. No sane human being can comprehend why you have 105k comments. Don't you have a wife or gf |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by Nnamdipapa(m): 9:03am On Jan 08, 2025 |
nedu666:Tell us what is Ebukas work? What value does he contribute to the society? What is is value? |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by helinues(op): 9:17am On Jan 08, 2025 |
nedu666:What's your definition of wasting away? N70-N80k minimum wage was one of the accurate analysis I had on this forum, one out of many. Tell us about half of what you have supported/analysed on this forum that came close to reality |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by MadPolitician: 12:30pm On Jan 08, 2025 |
helinues:Kanu is not Abiola Get sense.. |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by helinues(op): 12:32pm On Jan 08, 2025 |
MadPolitician:Of course, Kanu can never be Abiola even in his afterlife. Abiola is not a terrorist like Kanu The Yoruba's allowed Abiola to fight his fight without paralyzing the economy activities of their region because of him being arrested. Can same be said about you? You come online daily t blow grammar why you dare not step outside on Monday in your region on the order is some illiterate kids Pheew |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by MadPolitician: 12:45pm On Jan 08, 2025 |
helinues:I have never complained to you that Kanu, IPOB, ESN or Ekpa are disturbing me. I have lost a very close friend to the extra judicial killings going on in the east, my brother has been kidnapped before, but i have never complained to you. Yet, it is you that wail and cry more than me about the socalled security situation in the east. You will leave your uncles and aunties at Benin republic IDP camps where fulani herdsmen have chased them to, only to be busy here wailing and moaning about "what ipob is doing to igbos in Eastern Nigeria". Why don't you wail your wail and allow me to wail my wail too, bikonu!? You don't cry about the bad federal roads or the non existent federal infastructures in the east, No. All you want is Nnamdi kanus head on a spike! So I want to know; will a dead kanu wake up a dead Abiola? |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by helinues(op): 1:00pm On Jan 08, 2025 |
MadPolitician:When you are done with your drooling, let's know. What brought Abiola into this discussion to start with? |
| Re: Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Nigerian Blogger Ijele For Alleged Defamati by MadPolitician: 1:42pm On Jan 08, 2025 |
helinues:The same thing that brought Kanu into the discussion |
Court Denies Complicity In Prolonged Detention Of Former First Lady’s Ex-workers • Nnamdi Kanu’s Prolonged Detention Is Unfair - Senator Shehu Sani • Falana Faults Prolonged Detention Of Ijele For Alleged Defamation Of Ebuka Obi • 2 • 3 • 4
2027: Kwankwaso Rejects Atiku As Running Mate • Borishade: Education 2 Aviation 2 Culture & Information: Must He Be There? • Ribadu´s Interview By Weekly Trust
