₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,405 members, 8,522,898 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 09:41 AM

Toggle theme

Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity - Islam (6) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Islam › Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity (3336 Views)

1 2 3 4 5 6 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by ShaheedBinAliyu(m): 6:08pm On Feb 05
Kobojunkie:
.⚉ Mary was not a descendant of Aaron, nor is there any record that her mother was a "chaste" woman. 🥱🥱

If you have ever read the Bible, you would know that it doesn't always matter one's lineage, parents, or the supposed chasteness of one's mother when it comes to those who are chosen as righteous by YHWH. (Maybe Mohammed's Allah did not tell him that one of the prophets of YHWH was married by YHWH to a prostitute— she continued prostituting herself even while married to the prophet in question.) But I can tell that, like Mohammed, your ideas about the book's content also come from religious regurgitation. 🥱🥱
Subhanalaah. You'll see yourself in grave. I won't say more than that
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by Kobojunkie: 6:21pm On Feb 05
ShaheedBinAliyu:
✓ Subhanalaah. You'll see yourself in grave. I won't say more than that
How can I see myself in the grave and I will be dead -- from dust I was and to dust I return after I am dead? 🤔

Or do you not believe the sleep is death idea pedaled by Mohammed where he claimed everything you sleep, Allah takes your soul away only to put it back in again when it is time for you to wake up, unless he chooses not to. That myth, is actually taken from the Jewish book of commentaries called the Mishnah and the Talmud, books that were written by those whom the prophets of Israel referred to as the Lying Scribes . Mohammed took most of his claims regarding the Prophets of Israel from those texts. 🤔

Or would you rather we believe that since Islam has been around since the beginning, those texts took their lies from Islam? 🤔
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by Kobojunkie: 6:28pm On Feb 05
ShaheedBinAliyu:
✓ That's according to your conjectures as usual. It's all in the Qur'an. Go read
It is claimed in the Quran. So many things are claimed in the Quran that are not evidenced by any others circle that is the Quran and it's Hadiths. It is almost like the Quran was written as some sort of Isekai/other world novel to exist only in the minds of those who subscribe to its contents. 🤔

Anyways, no one before Mohammed heard anything of Islam only Mohammed came claiming it the case...the unsubstantiated claims of one unlearned man against the realities of billions before him. All he had to do was provide evidence but he died never providing even one to his followers. 🤔
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by honesttalk21: 6:38pm On Feb 05
Kobojunkie:
How can I see myself in the grave and I will be dead -- from dust I was and to dust I return after I am dead? 🤔

Or do you not believe the sleep is death idea pedaled by Mohammed where he claimed everything you sleep, Allah takes your soul away only to put it back in again when it is time for you to wake up, unless he chooses not to. That myth, is actually taken from the Jewish book of commentaries called the Mishnah and the Talmud, books that were written by those whom the prophets of Israel referred to as the Lying Scribes . Mohammed took most of his claims regarding the Prophets of Israel from those texts. 🤔

Or would you rather we believe that since Islam has been around since the beginning, those texts took their lies from Islam? 🤔
Kobojunkie:
. Yet no one ever heard or breathed anything about Islam until after Mohammed showed off and carried out at least 80 military campaigns (27 of which he took part in), all in a span of the last 23 years of his life, to conquer and force Islam down the throats of people who otherwise would not have considered him much as recorded right there in his Quran and the many Hadiths that accompany it. Come on now! 🥱🥱
Kobojunkie:
.⚉ Mary was not a descendant of Aaron, nor is there any record that her mother was a "chaste" woman. 🥱🥱

If you have ever read the Bible, you would know that it doesn't always matter one's lineage, parents, or the supposed chasteness of one's mother when it comes to those who are chosen as righteous by YHWH. (Maybe Mohammed's Allah did not tell him that one of the prophets of YHWH was married by YHWH to a prostitute— she continued prostituting herself even while married to the prophet in question.) But I can tell that, like Mohammed, your ideas about the book's content also come from religious regurgitation. 🥱🥱
Reliance on linguistic literalism, historical oversimplification, and selective standards hinders understanding the Qur’anic reference to Mary as sister of Aaron.This phrase is a well-established Semitic idiom that signifies lineage or spiritual connection rather than literal siblinghood similar to how the Bible uses terms like sons of David or daughter of Zion. Luke affirms Mary’s righteousness, meaning the claim of ignorance fails under basic biblical literacy.

The portrayal of Islam as spreading through forced conversion is both historically inaccurate and textually false. The Qur’an clearly states, there is no compulsion in religion (2:256) and had your Lord willed, all would have believed (10:99). Muhammad pbuh’s military campaigns took place within a 7th-century tribal context characterized by warfare, treaties, and political survival; conquest does not equal forced belief, and Islam’s legal tradition prohibits coerced faith.

Accusations of plagiarism from Jewish sources misunderstand the shared religious language of the Near East. The metaphor of sleep as death appears throughout the Bible (Job 14:12; Psalm 13:3; John 11:11–14). This shared imagery reflects a common Semitic worldview rather than borrowing unless one is prepared to accuse the Bible itself of plagiarism.

You obviously have no good response to:
honesttalk21:
On Ka'ba-ye Zartosht: I never stated that no one visited it; rather, I pointed out that archaeological evidence lacks any indication of religious worship. Schmidt (Persepolis III, 1970) and Stronach (Pasargadae, 1978) found no fire altars, cult objects, ash deposits, votive offerings, or signs of pilgrimage. Just because it is near Persepolis does not turn the absence of evidence into proof of worship.

On pre-Islamic Mecca sources: Since you are researching, here are some primary sources:
Diodorus Siculus, Bibliotheca Historica 3.42 (1st c. BCE), describes an Arabian sacred sanctuary. Ptolemy's Geography (2nd c. CE) references Macoraba, which likely refers to Mecca. Abraha's Sabaean inscription CIH 325 (6th c. CE) documents his campaign against Mecca. Muallaqat (pre-Islamic Arabic poetry) mentions the pilgrimage to Mecca.
Procopius, History of the Wars (6th c.) notes the Hijaz trade routes.

On transformation versus continuity:
Keeping the form of circumambulation while removing polytheistic content indicates transformation, not mere rebranding. Early Christianity adopted Roman basilica architecture without embracing Roman theology. Consider this: could pagans have altered an originally monotheistic practice that Islam later restored?

On multiple Kaabas destroyed: You have claimed this five times without providing a single citation. No verse from the Quran or authentic hadith supports this assertion. Documented destructions involved idols and illegitimate shrines, not a general category of Kaabas. Please provide one textual reference or acknowledge that this claim is unfounded.

On Black Stone veneration: Islam explicitly states that the Stone neither benefits nor harms (ʿUmar, Sahih Bukhari 1610). Ritual respect does not equate to worship. By your reasoning, Jews worship the Western Wall, Catholics revere relics, and Americans salute flags. The distinction between veneration in ritual and deification exists across all traditions.

On social identity: Every culture uses appearance to establish group identity denying this even in Islamic countries overlooks basic sociological principles. However, this does not speak to theological origins. Your original assertion was that grooming practices indicate Islam borrowed from others; I demonstrated that grooming serves as a marker of cultural identity and is irrelevant to doctrinal lineage.

Your argument relies on conjecture (Zoroastrian worship lacking evidence), unjustifiable claims (destroyed Kaabas with no sources), and redefined terms (veneration equating to worship). Without concrete evidence, these remain assertions rather than sound arguments.

Unless you present verifiable evidence for your main assertions, this conversation cannot progress beyond your speculation compared to documented history.
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by Kobojunkie:
honesttalk21:
➜ Reliance on linguistic literalism, historical oversimplification, and selective standards hinders understanding the Qur’anic reference to Mary as sister of Aaron.This phrase is a well-established Semitic idiom that signifies lineage or spiritual connection rather than literal siblinghood similar to how the Bible uses terms like sons of David or daughter of Zion. Luke affirms Mary’s righteousness, meaning the claim of ignorance fails under basic biblical literacy.
➜The portrayal of Islam as spreading through forced conversion is both historically inaccurate and textually false. The Qur’an clearly states, there is no compulsion in religion (2:256) and had your Lord willed, all would have believed (10:99).
➜ Muhammad pbuh’s military campaigns took place within a 7th-century tribal qcontext characterized by warfare, treaties, and political survival; conquest does not equal forced belief, and Islam’s legal tradition prohibits coerced faith.
1. Like the many tales most of you Islamics love to trade, there exists no such historic Semitic idiom out there anywhere. Aaron and his sister, along with their brother Moses, were not Jews — Semitics — that you would suggest a connection between them and idioms used specifically by Jews. 🥱🥱

2. WOW... this is the second time today someone has tried 419-ing folks into believing Islam by presenting a lie about Islam. Is it me, or are you Mohammedians just adept at lying to yourselves? God has no religion, yet the same verse you quote specifically states that Allah has a religion and it is Islam, which he gave only to Mohammed, and seems to have everyone else worship since they have to call upon the name of Mohammed to access said religion. 🥱
256. Let there be no compulsion in religion, for the truth stands out clearly from falsehood.1 So whoever renounces false gods and believes in Allah has certainly grasped the firmest, unfailing hand-hold. And Allah is All-Hearing, All-Knowing.
257. Allah is the Guardian of the believers—He brings them out of darkness and into light. As for the disbelievers, their guardians are false gods who lead them out of light and into darkness. It is they who will be the residents of the Fire. They will be there forever.- Quran 2 vs 256 - 257
Right there in the very context of the verse you pretended to quote is the insinuation that the only valid religion is Allah's religion. All those who don't believe in it are condemned to burn in Mohammed's Hell. So, what the heck is with the meaningless soundbites that Islamics now trade? 🥱🥱

Anyways, the portrayal of Islam as a religion spread by force, as the above passage explains, comes from Mohammed's Quran and Hadiths —in Quran 9 vs 1- 6 & Quran 9 vs 26 - 33. This is further expanded on in Bukari 1:2:25...Bukari 88:12:6930... Sunan ibn Majah 20: 2: 2535 ...Bukari 84:9:6922...Buhkari 87:9:6878. The information is literally right in front of us all, and the source is Islam claimed holy book. 🥱🥱

Mohammed, a man who was a merchant, switched careers to become a prophet and then upgraded himself to becoming a political warlord and then Caliph— ruler over lands and those who are forced to become his followers(his ummah) and the dhimmis who paid Jizyah to him. Mohammed definitely claimed power everywhere he could, and somehow, he is an innocent? What an attempt at a cute narrative. 😂😂😂
Mohammed literally ordered at least 80 military campaigns, and most of those were offensive attacks on people who were either slaughtered or forced to join his group. And this is all within a span of a decade or just over that. undecided
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by Kobojunkie: 7:51pm On Feb 05
honesttalk21:
➜ Accusations of plagiarism from Jewish sources misunderstand the shared religious language of the Near East. The metaphor of sleep as death appears throughout the Bible (Job 14:12; Psalm 13:3; John 11:11–14). This shared imagery reflects a common Semitic worldview rather than borrowing unless one is prepared to accuse the Bible itself of plagiarism.
➜You obviously have no good response to:
1. Absolutely nothing of what is contained in the context of the verses you quoted there comes any close to what Mohammed has in his Quran regarding daily sleep being the death of the soul.

⚉Job 14 vs 12 does not describe a relationship between sleep and death. Rather, it refers to the rising from the dead to take place at the time of resurrection alone, not before.
11 Like a lake that goes dry or a river that loses its source,
12 so people lose their lives, never to live again. The skies will all pass away before they rise from death. The skies will all disappear before anyone wakes up from that sleep! - Job 14 vs 11 vs 12
⚉ Psalm 13 vs 1 - 3 obviously has nothing to do with any relationship between sleep and death.
1. How long will you forget me, Lord? Will you forget me forever? How long will you refuse to accept me?[a]
2 How long must I wonder if you have forgotten me? How long must I feel this sadness in my heart? How long will my enemy win against me?
3 Lord my God, look at me and give me an answer. Make me feel strong again, or I will die. - Psalm 13 vs 1 - 3
⚉John 11 vs 11 - 14 - here, again, Jesus Christ of Israel did not suggest that a relationship of the kind posed by Mohammed in his Quran exists between sleep and death. Rather, Jesus Christ of Israel applied here an idiom that was typically used of the righteous men of old to suggest that they sleep in death and are thus expected to be raised from the dead on the day of resurrection; the unrighteous folks of Israel are not raised back to life and hence do not sleep in death.
11 Then Jesus said, “Our friend Lazarus is now sleeping, but I am going there to wake him.”
12 The followers answered, “But, Lord, if he can sleep, he will get well.”
13 They thought Jesus meant that Lazarus was literally sleeping, but he really meant that Lazarus was dead.
14 So then Jesus said plainly, “Lazarus is dead.
15 And I am glad I was not there. I am happy for you because now you will believe in me. We will go to him now.”
16 Then Thomas, the one called “Twin,” said to the other followers, “We will go too. We will die there with Jesus.” - John 11 vs 11 - 14
Jesus Christ of Israel is recorded in the Injeel to have raised Lazarus from the dead, not from sleep. 🥱🥱

2. I already explained to you that I am not here to argue with you but to state the facts. You rare egurgitating the same religious nonsense you previously threw at me and failed with means simply that you have run out of things to say. 🥱
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by honesttalk21: 7:52pm On Feb 05
Kobojunkie:
1. Like the many tales most of you Islamics love to trade, there exists no such historic semitic idiom out there anywhere. Aaron and his sister, along with their brother Moses, were not Jews -- semitics -- that you would suggest a connection between them and idioms used specifically by Jews. 🥱🥱

2. WOW... this is the second time today someone has tried 419-ing folks into believing Islam by presenting a lie about Islam. Is it me, or are you Mohammedians just adept at lying to yourselves? God has no religion, yet the same verse you quote specifically states that Allah has a religion and it is Islam, which he gave only to Mohammed, and seems to have everyone else worship since they have to call upon the name of Mohammed to access said religion. 🥱
Right there in the very context of the verse you pretended to quote is the insinuation that the only valid religion is Allah's religion. All those who don't believe in it are condemned to burn in Mohammed's Hell. So, what the heck is with the meaningless soundbites that Islamics now trade? 🥱🥱

The portrayal of Islam as a religion spread by force comes from Mohammed himself in Quran 9 vs 1- 6 & Quran 9 vs 26 - 33. This is further expanded on in Bukari 1:2:25...Bukari 88:12:6930... Sunan ibn Majah 20: 2: 2535 ...Bukari 84:9:6922...Buhkari 87:9:6878.

Mohammed, a man who was a merchant, switched careers to become a prophet and then upgraded himself to becoming a political warlord and then Caliph— ruler over lands and those who are forced to become his followers(his ummah) and the dihmis who are pay Jizyah to him. Mohammed definitely claimed power everywhere he could, and somehow he is an innocent? What an attempt at a cute narrative. 😂😂😂
Mohammed literally ordered at least 80 military campaigns, and most of those were offensive attacks on people who were either slaughtered or forced to join his group. And this is all within a span of a decade or just over that. undecided
The statement no Semitic idiom is inaccurate. The phrase brother/sister of X as a marker of lineage or religious affiliation is common in Biblical Semitic language (for example, sons of Aaron, daughter of Zion brothers of David). Aaron, Moses, and Mary all belong to the Semitic prophetic tradition, regardless of later labels such as Jew. Luke connects Mary to a priestly lineage so your objection stems from a misunderstanding of language rather than from scholarly insight.

In Semitic cultures, the term for "brother" or "sister" can extend beyond blood relations to include close relatives or even friends, reflecting a strong emphasis on familial bonds. This usage highlights the importance of kinship and community ties, where individuals may refer to each other as siblings even without direct blood connections.

Islam does not equate to the worship of Muhammad pbuh and is only your imagination. The Qur’an clearly condemns the elevation of prophets (3:79, 18:110). Mentioning Muhammad pbuh in prayer is an invocation, not an act of worship, similar to blessing Abraham (2:285). Referring to this as accessing God through Muhammad represents a fundamental misunderstanding.

The idea that there is only one true religion does not mean forced conversion. The Qur’an declares that Islam is about submission to God (2:131; 3:67) while also prohibiting coercion (2:256). Claiming exclusivity of truth does not imply compulsion Christianity makes the same assertion (John 14:6).

Surah 9 outlines laws regarding warfare, not enforced belief. This chapter deals with breaches of treaties and active combat while explicitly exempting non-combatants and those pursuing peace (9:4, 9:6). Jizyah applies to political subjects rather than forced converts conversion nullifies this tax.

The claim of 80 campaigns reflects misleading statistics. Expeditions do not equal battles; many did not involve fighting. There are no credible reports indicating that Muhammad pbuh compelled anyone to believe. This stands in stark contrast to post-biblical Christian state violence.

Your statement hinges on linguistic denial, historical inaccuracies, and an incorrect merging of empire with theology. Polemics do not constitute evidence just as your Iranian Kaaba and fictitious numerous other Kaaba.
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by honesttalk21: 7:57pm On Feb 05
Kobojunkie:
1. Absolutely nothing of what is contained in the context of the verses you quoted there comes any close to what Mohammed has in his Quran regarding daily sleep being the death of the soul.

⚉Job 14 vs 12 does not describe a relationship between sleep and death. Rather, it refers to the rising from the dead to take place at the time of resurrection alone, not before.

⚉ Psalm 13 vs 1 - 3 obviously has nothing to do with any relationship between sleep and death.

⚉John 11 vs 11 - 14 - here, again, Jesus Christ of Israel did not suggest that a relationship of the kind posed by Mohammed in his Quran exists between sleep and death. Rather, Jesus Christ of Israel applied here an idiom that was typically used of the righteous men of old to suggest that they sleep in death and are thus expected to be raised from the dead on the day of resurrection; the unrighteous folks of Israel are not raised back to life and hence do not sleep in death.
Jesus Christ of Israel is recorded in the Injeel to have raised Lazarus from the dead, not from sleep. 🥱🥱

2. I already explained to you that I am not here to argue with you but to state the facts. You rare egurgitating the same religious nonsense you previously threw at me and failed with means simply that you have run out of things to say. 🥱
Obviously you mix things up because it misrepresents both texts. The Qur’an does not equate sleep with death; it states that God takes souls during sleep and returns them (Q 39:42) a metaphor for dependence and mortality, not resurrection. The Bible employs a similar semantic field saying sleep represents a state of unconsciousness, contrasted with the final awakening (Job 14:12), and sleep of death serves as a poetic expression (Psalm 13:3). Jesus also refers to death as sleep before clarifying that Lazarus had indeed died (John 11:11–14). Refusing to acknowledge this shared metaphor doesn’t disprove Islam; it merely reveals a selective literalism. The disagreement lies in theological interpretation, not fact versus fiction.
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by Kobojunkie: 8:34pm On Feb 05
On the topic of sleep amounting to temporary death each night, this is what the Quran and Hadith say.
41. Indeed, We sent down to you the Book for the people in truth. So whoever is guided – it is for [the benefit of] his soul; and whoever goes astray only goes astray to its detriment. And you are not a manager over them.
42. Allah takes the souls at the time of their death, and those that do not die [He takes] during their sleep. Then He keeps those for which He has decreed death and releases the others for a specified term. Indeed, there are signs for a people who give thought. - Quran 39 vs 41 - 42
This is from the Hadith related as related.
Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "When the Day of Resurrection approaches, the dreams of a believer will hardly fail to come true, and a dream of a believer is one of forty-six parts of prophetism, and whatever belongs to prothetism can never be false." Muhammad bin Seereen said, "But I say this." He said, "It used to be said, 'There are three types of dreams: The reflection of one's thoughts and experiences one has during wakefulness, what is suggested by Satan to frighten the dreamer, or glad tidings from Allah. So, if someone has a dream which he dislikes, he should not tell it to others, but get up and offer a prayer." He added, "He (Abu Huraira) hated to see a Ghul (i.e., iron collar around his neck in a dream) and people liked to see fetters (on their feet in a dream). The fetters on the feet symbolizes one's constant and firm adherence to religion." And Abu `Abdullah said, "Ghuls (iron collars) are used only for necks." - Sahih Al Bukari:7017


Now, this is what is taken from [b]the Book, the Mishnah [/b]
They are: Fire, honey, Shabbat, sleep, and a dream....The Gemara elaborates: Our fire is one-sixtieth of the fire of Gehenna; honey is one-sixtieth of manna; Shabbat is one-sixtieth of the World-to-Come; sleep is one-sixtieth of death; and a dream is one-sixtieth - Berakhot 57b:13
⚉“The Lord God cast [ hipil ] a deep slumber” – Rabbi Yehoshua of Sikhnin said in the name of Rabbi Levi: The beginning of downfall [ mapala ] is sleep....
⚉Rav said: There are three slumbers: the slumber of sleep, the slumber of prophecy, and the slumber of a trance. The slumber of sleep – “the Lord God cast a deep slumber upon the man, and he slept.”...
⚉Rabbi Ḥanina bar Yitzḥak said: There are three microcosms; sleep is a microcosm of death; a dream is a microcosm of prophecy; Shabbat is a microcosm of the World to Come....
⚉Rabbi Avin adds another two: The orb of the sun is a microcosm of the supernal light; Torah is a microcosm of the supernal wisdom. 15 Too much sleep is a recipe for ruin. - Bereshit Rabbah 17:5
...
“It was as the sun was setting, [and a slumber fell]” – Rabbi Yehoshua of Sikhnin said in the name of Rabbi Levi: The beginning of downfall is sleep, as when one sleeps one does not toil in Torah study...Rav said: There are three kinds of slumber – the slumber of sleep, the slumber of prophecy, and the slumber of a trance....The slumber of sleep – “The Lord God cast a slumber upon the man, and he slept” . The slumber of prophecy – “It was as the sun was setting, and a slumber fell upon Abram” ....Rabbi Ḥanina bar Yitzḥak said: There are three microcosms: sleep is a microcosm of death; a dream is a microcosm of prophecy; Shabbat is a microcosm of the World to Come. - Bereshit Rabbah 44:17
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by Kobojunkie: 9:33pm On Feb 05
honesttalk21:
➜ Surah 9 outlines laws regarding warfare, not enforced belief. This chapter deals with breaches of treaties and active combat while explicitly exempting non-combatants and those pursuing peace (9:4, 9:6). Jizyah applies to political subjects rather than forced converts conversion nullifies this tax.
The claim of 80 campaigns reflects misleading statistics. Expeditions do not equal battles; many did not involve fighting. There are no credible reports indicating that Muhammad pbuh compelled anyone to believe. This stands in stark contrast to post-biblical Christian state violence.
Your statement hinges on linguistic denial, historical inaccuracies, and an incorrect merging of empire with theology. Polemics do not constitute evidence just as your Iranian Kaaba and fictitious numerous other Kaaba
.
Anywho🥱🥱, still on the topic of Islam. the excerpt below is taken from Remarks on the words "Pope" and "Patriarch" in the Christian religion and on the word "Kohen" used by the Jews. in the book Muqqualdimah that was written by Ibn Khaldun, a man respected(and claimed by the Islamics at one point). Maybe after this, he will be disavowed by you. 🥱🥱

In the excerpt, Ibn Khaldun clearly states, "In the Muslim community, the holy war is a religious duty, because of the universalism of the (Muslim) mission and (the obligation to) convert everybody to Islam either by persuasion or by force. Therefore, caliphate and royal authority are united in (Islam), so that the person in charge can devote the available strength to both of them 408 at the same time."

Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by honesttalk21: 10:38pm On Feb 05
Kobojunkie:
Anywho🥱🥱, still on the topic of Islam. the excerpt below is taken from Remarks on the words "Pope" and "Patriarch" in the Christian religion and on the word "Kohen" used by the Jews. in the book Muqqualdimah that was written by Ibn Khaldun, a man respected(and claimed by the Islamics at one point). Maybe after this, he will be disavowed by you. 🥱🥱

In the excerpt, Ibn Khaldun clearly states, "In the Muslim community, the holy war is a religious duty, because of the universalism of the (Muslim) mission and (the obligation to) convert everybody to Islam either by persuasion or by force. Therefore, caliphate and royal authority are united in (Islam), so that the person in charge can devote the available strength to both of them 408 at the same time."
Kobojunkie:
On the topic of sleep amounting to temporary death each night, this is what the Quran and Hadith say.

This is from the Hadith related as related.



Now, this is what is taken from [b]the Book, the Mishnah [/b]


...
The Qur’anic statement that Allah takes the souls during sleep and at death (Q 39:42) differentiates between temporary withdrawal and permanent death; it does not equate sleep with resurrection or final death. This distinction reflects a well-known semitic metaphor found in Jewish rabbinic literature, where sleep is referred to as one-sixtieth of death (Berakhot 57b; Bereshit Rabbah 17:5, 44:17). Thus, the Qur’an is not introducing a new doctrine but expressing a commonly understood Near-Eastern conceptual framework that had already been established in Jewish theology centuries before. Shared metaphysical language does not imply plagiarism.

The hadith regarding dreams supports this framework by categorizing dreams phenomenologically rather than metaphysically; it asserts no literal connection between sleep and death, only that both involve a partial suspension of conscious agency. The accusation is on what isn't there because it targets a position that Islam does not endorse.

Regarding Ibn Khaldun, your selectively citing him can be misleading. He was a 14th century sociologist rather than a lawgiver, discussing historical political theory instead of Qur’anic doctrine. His observations reflect the realities of medieval empires rather than suggesting any divine mandate for forced conversion.
Ibn Khaldun's perspective does not align with Qur’anic doctrine; rather, it reflects his 14th-century sociological observations on the historical expansion of states. He is discussing political theory instead of delivering a divine command. Throughout the Muqaddimah, he differentiates between religion and royal authority, consistently asserting that religion cannot thrive without social power, which is an analytical assertion rather than a theological one. When he refers to persuasion or force, the term force pertains to overcoming hostile political entities, not to compelling individual belief, as belief obtained through force is invalid in Islam by consensus. The Qur’an explicitly prohibits coercion in belief (2:256; 10:99; 18:29), and classical Islamic law distinguishes between political conflict and religious coercion.

The analogy between sleep and death is a shared Semitic metaphor rather than an invention of Islam; Ibn Khaldun’s analysis is descriptive rather than prescriptive. The argument fails because it confuses metaphor with dogma and history with revelation.
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by honesttalk21: 11:15pm On Feb 05
@ Kobojunkie

Think I got a glimpse of what you posted before the system took it away.

That statement was grossly incorrect because it goes against basic historical methods. The Mishnah and Talmud are later compilations, but the traditions they preserve were passed down orally centuries prior. That is a well established fact of late antique Judaism. To deny this is not scholarly.

Rejecting interpretation represents a theological objection rather than a historical one; Judaism after the Second Temple operated through interpretive law, regardless of personal approval. Stating it has no connection to the Torah or Injil merely changes the subject. Post-biblical Judaism functioned through interpretation, and this fact is historically recorded, regardless of one's theological stance.

Dismissing an early Arab historian by labeling him a mere sociologist does not undermine his testimony it merely indicates discomfort with the actual content of the sources.

History should be debated based on evidence and chronology, not polemics.
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by Kobojunkie: 11:44pm On Feb 05
1. Mohammed, as you clearly acknowledged, endorsed myths and packed interpretations, aka lies written by the Lying Scribes of Israel in their Mishnah and Talmud, both of which are books compiled without prophetic revelation. We are finally getting somewhere near the facts with you. 🥱🥱

2. A framework that has absolutely nothing to do with the Torah and the Injeel as those books cited are instead a compilation of interpretations of the Law which were warned against by the YHWH of Israel who commanded His own not to add to, change or remove from the laws and statutes which he had given to His people(Interpretations fall under either one of these three)? OK! However, you are suddenly going to retract from this in a moment, as I have come to expect of Mohammedians. Oh, the lies! 🙄🙄🙄

3. WOW.... A well-respected Arab scholar, historian, and philosopher is now suddenly tagged as a mere sociologist, all because they aptly described the religion of Islam from as far back as their own time, which was around the time of Mohammed himself. This is so funny! 🤣🤣🤣
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by honesttalk21: 12:02am On Feb 06
Kobojunkie:
1. Mohammed, as you clearly acknowledged, endorsed myths and packed interpretations, aka lies written by the Lying Scribes of Israel in their Mishnah and Talmud, both of which are books compiled without prophetic revelation. We are finally getting somewhere near the facts with you. 🥱🥱

2. A framework that has absolutely nothing to do with the Torah and the Injeel as those books cited are instead a compilation of interpretations of the Law which were warned against by the YHWH of Israel who commanded His own not to add to, change or remove from the laws and statutes which he had given to His people(Interpretations fall under either one of these three)? OK! However, you are suddenly going to retract from this in a moment, as I have come to expect of Mohammedians. Oh, the lies! 🙄🙄🙄

3. WOW.... A well-respected Arab scholar, historian, and philosopher is now suddenly tagged as a mere sociologist, all because they aptly described the religion of Islam from as far back as their own time, which was around the time of Mohammed himself. This is so funny! 🤣🤣🤣
honesttalk21:
@ Kobojunkie

Think I got a glimpse of what you posted before the system took it away.

That statement was grossly incorrect because it goes against basic historical methods. The Mishnah and Talmud are later compilations, but the traditions they preserve were passed down orally centuries prior. That is a well established fact of late antique Judaism. To deny this is not scholarly.

Rejecting interpretation represents a theological objection rather than a historical one; Judaism after the Second Temple operated through interpretive law, regardless of personal approval. Stating it has no connection to the Torah or Injil merely changes the subject. Post-biblical Judaism functioned through interpretation, and this fact is historically recorded, regardless of one's theological stance.

Dismissing an early Arab historian by labeling him a mere sociologist does not undermine his testimony it merely indicates discomfort with the actual content of the sources.

History should be debated based on evidence and chronology, not polemics.
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by Kobojunkie: 12:06am On Feb 06
honesttalk21:
➜Think I got a glimpse of what you posted before the system took it away.
That statement was grossly incorrect because it goes against basic historical methods. The Mishnah and Talmud are later compilations, but the traditions they preserve were passed down orally centuries prior. That is a well established fact of late antique Judaism. To deny this is not scholarly.
➜ Rejecting interpretation represents a theological objection rather than a historical one; Judaism after the Second Temple operated through interpretive law, regardless of personal approval. Stating it has no connection to the Torah or Injil merely changes the subject. Post-biblical Judaism functioned through interpretation, and this fact is historically recorded, regardless of one's theological stance.
Dismissing an early Arab historian by labeling him a mere sociologist does not undermine his testimony it merely indicates discomfort with the actual content of the sources.
➜ History should be debated based on evidence and chronology, not polemics.
Oh, the Mishnah and the Talmud were not passed down orally. They were written by those referred to as Jeremiah, the Lying Scribes, and yes, they were definitely religious leaders. (YHWH never had his people's religion, but a state complete with the Law as a framework by which the people were to live and govern themselves within the given state.)

Yes, the scripts were later compiled into what became known as th Mishnah and the Talmud — 300 - 500 AD — only a couple of years before Mohammed came up with Islam. 🥱🥱

2. Why did Allah insist that the Torah and the Injeel are both inspired, preserved, and authorized by him— Quran 3 vs 1 - 5, Quran 3 vs 45 - 48... Quran 3 vs 60 - 68....Quran 5 vs 65 - 69...Quran 5 vs 109-112...Quran 9 vs 111... if he would also do the same for books that directly contravene all that was formerly declared by him in the Torah and the Injeel? You mean to say that Allah holds on to the truths and lies at the same time? 🥱🥱

How could the Quran, which claims ideas contrary to the Torah and the Injeel, also be considered a protector for them, as stated in Quran 5 vs 44 - 48? 🥱🥱

What you are literally accusing Mohammed's Allah of doing is claiming ownership of the books that were revealed by YHWH to his prophets all while supporting the books written by those whom YHWH taught his people to distance themselves from as liars who turn his word into falsehoods by way of their lies. (Allah seems not so concerned with truth but with that which would further his cause and religion.) If what you have here is the case, why then did Mohammed insist that his Allah condemned the Jews and Christians for following their interpretations rather than what is contained in the Torah and the Injeel? This is clearly hypocritical?🥱🥱

3. His evidence as expressed in that book is not good enough because it does not pander to your particular bias towards Islam... right... right! I get it!🥱🥱🥱
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by honesttalk21: 12:14am On Feb 06
Kobojunkie:
Oh, the Mishnah and the Talmud were not passed down orally. They were written by those referred to as Jeremiah, the Lying Scribes, and yes, they were definitely religious leaders. (YHWH never had his people's religion, but a state complete with the Law as a framework by which the people were to live and govern themselves within the given state.)

Yes, the scripts were later compiled into what became known as th Mishnah and the Talmud — 300 - 500 AD — only a couple of years before Mohammed came up with Islam. 🥱🥱

2. Why did Allah insist that the Torah and the Injeel are both inspired, preserved, and authorized by him— Quran 3 vs 1 - 5, Quran 3 vs 45 - 48... Quran 3 vs 60 - 68....Quran 5 vs 65 - 69...Quran 5 vs 109-112...Quran 9 vs 111... if he would also do the same for books that directly contravene all that was formerly declared by him in the Torah and the Injeel? You mean to say that Allah holds on to the truths and lies at the same time? 🥱🥱

How could the Quran, which claims ideas contrary to the Torah and the Injeel, also be considered a protector for them, as stated in Quran 5 vs 44 - 48? 🥱🥱

What you are literally accusing Mohammed's Allah of doing is claiming ownership of the books that were revealed by YHWH to his prophets all while supporting the books written by those whom YHWH taught his people to distance themselves from as liars who turn his word into falsehoods by way of their lies. (Allah seems not so concerned with truth but with that which would further his cause and religion.) If what you have here is the case, why then did Mohammed insist that his Allah condemned the Jews and Christians for following their interpretations rather than what is contained in the Torah and the Injeel? This is clearly hypocritical?🥱🥱

3. His evidence as expressed in that book is not good enough because it does not pander to your particular bias towards Islam... right... right! I get it!🥱🥱🥱
The Mishnah and Talmud were compiled long after the Torah but effectively preserve centuries of oral Jewish law and practice, as historians have well established. Their dates of compilation do not retroactively alter or negate the traditions they document.

The Qur’an’s assertion of preserving the Torah and Injil does not imply it aligns with every rabbinic or Christian interpretation; rather, it acknowledges the divine origins of these scriptures while rejecting human alterations, which is why it critiques misinterpretations. This reflects textual consistency rather than hypocrisy.

Rejecting historical evidence just because it conflicts with a favored narrative is a form of bias, not genuine critique. Facts should be evaluated based on their timeline, sources, and methodology, rather than whether they align with one's expectations.
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by honesttalk21: 12:18am On Feb 06
Kobojunkie:
3. WOW.... A well-respected Arab scholar, historian, and philosopher is now suddenly tagged as a mere sociologist, all because they aptly described the religion of Islam from as far back as their own time, which was around the time of Mohammed himself. This is so funny! 🤣🤣🤣
You know Khaldun lived 700 years after Muhammad pbuh,examined religion and politics through empirical analysis, and never asserted divine authority. Referring to him as a sociologist isn’t derogatory. It accurately reflects his approach. His insights are analytical rather than theological, making it misleading to cite him as a supporter of Qur’anic doctrine.
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by Kobojunkie: 12:42am On Feb 06
honesttalk21:
✓ You know Khaldun lived 700 years after Muhammad pbuh, examined religion and politics through empirical analysis, and never asserted divine authority. Referring to him as a sociologist isn’t derogatory. It accurately reflects his approach. His insights are analytical rather than theological, making it misleading to cite him as a supporter of Qur’anic doctrine.
It's derogatory to refer to a historian and philosopher who lived through what most Mohammedians dream of today as merely a sociologist. 🤔🤔

The world also saw the theological aspects of Islamic rule so there was no reason to repeat any of that. He simply chose to state what we all now know of Islam and it's mission. 🤔🤔
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by honesttalk21: 12:54am On Feb 06
Kobojunkie:
It's derogatory to refer to a historian and philosopher who lived through what most Mohammedians dream of today as merely a sociologist. 🤔🤔

The world also saw the theological aspects of Islamic rule so there was no reason to repeat any of that. He simply chose to state what we all now know of Islam and it's mission. 🤔🤔
Too bad that Ibn Khaldun (27 May 1332 – 17 March 1406, 732–808 AH) was an Arab scholar, historian, philosopher, and sociologist.He is widely acknowledged to be one of the greatest social scientists of the Middle Ages, and is considered by a number of scholars to be a major forerunner of historiography,

Can we have another false claim from you?
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by Kobojunkie: 1:19am On Feb 06
honesttalk21:
✓ Too bad that Ibn Khaldun (27 May 1332 – 17 March 1406, 732–808 AH) was an Arab scholar, historian, philosopher, and sociologist.He is widely acknowledged to be one of the greatest social scientists of the Middle Ages, and is considered by a number of scholars to be a major forerunner of historiography,
Can we have another false claim from you?
Are you sure you are OK at all? 🥱🥱

Anyways, you are already many comments into doing exactly what I have come to expect which is arguing in circles regarding the meaningless to distract from the main which is that the man in question lived and put together an accurate analysis of the differences between Islams approach to power and rulership compared to other religions of his time. The Quran and Hadiths all validate his claim. Even the Islamic Caliphate of his days were testament to this fact regarding Islam. 🥱🥱
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by honesttalk21: 1:40am On Feb 06
Kobojunkie:
Are you sure you are OK at all? 🥱🥱

Anyways, you are already many comments into doing exactly what I have come to expect which is arguing in circles regarding the meaningless to distract from the main which is that the man in question lived and put together an accurate analysis of the differences between Islams approach to power and rulership compared to other religions of his time. The Quran and Hadiths all validate his claim. Even the Islamic Caliphate of his days were testament to this fact regarding Islam. 🥱🥱
Without my saying so is Ibn Khaldun classified as a sociologist or not? Is sociology or being called a sociologist derogatory? What accurate analysis after you have inaccurately stated is not a sociologist. Then the statement you attribute to him please recheck if he actually said or stated what you claim.
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by Kobojunkie: 1:48am On Feb 06
honesttalk21:
✓ Without my saying so is Ibn Khaldun classified as a sociologist or not? Is sociology or being called a sociologist derogatory? What accurate analysis after you have inaccurately stated is not a sociologist. Then the statement you attribute to him please recheck if he actually said or stated what you claim.
The man was more than a sociologist.. he was also a history and a philosopher respected across the Islamic world during his time and ours. 🥱🥱

Your only issue with h steps from him aptly describing Islamic rule both as described in the Quran and Hadiths as well throughout over almost 700 years of its existence by the time he came alone. You are mad he didn't spin a tale to throw the Quran and Hadiths under the rug like you have consistently done all through this and many other discussions. 🥱🥱

The end. 🥱🥱
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by honesttalk21: 2:44am On Feb 06
Kobojunkie:
The man was more than a sociologist.. he was also a history and a philosopher respected across the Islamic world during his time and ours. 🥱🥱

Your only issue with h steps from him aptly describing Islamic rule both as described in the Quran and Hadiths as well throughout over almost 700 years of its existence by the time he came alone. You are mad he didn't spin a tale to throw the Quran and Hadiths under the rug like you have consistently done all through this and many other discussions. 🥱🥱

The end. 🥱🥱
Running away?

Ibn Khaldūn is widely recognized as an esteemed historian and philosopher, earning significant respect in the Muslim world. The matter at hand pertains to attribution, rather than Islam itself. There is no definitive Arabic text where Ibn Khaldun asserts or suggests that Islam requires converting individuals by persuasion or by force. I figure that's why you are running since you cannot prove your claim. That expression is a modern interpretation rather than an authentic quote. Ibn Khaldun explored the ways religion influences social unity and political power, not as a theological reiteration of the Qur’an and Hadith, nor as a claim advocating universal forced conversion. As a Muslim, his work analytically examines Islam’s role in society without taking a polemical stance.

honesttalk21:
Too bad that Ibn Khaldun (27 May 1332 – 17 March 1406, 732–808 AH) was an Arab scholar, historian, philosopher, and sociologist.He is widely acknowledged to be one of the greatest social scientists of the Middle Ages, and is considered by a number of scholars to be a major forerunner of historiography,

Can we have another false claim from you?
Simply present the reality of where you manufactured

Kobojunkie:
In the excerpt, Ibn Khaldun clearly states, "In the Muslim community, the holy war is a religious duty, because of the universalism of the (Muslim) mission and (the obligation to) convert everybody to Islam either by persuasion or by force. Therefore, caliphate and royal authority are united in (Islam), so that the person in charge can devote the available strength to both of them 408 at the same time."
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by Kobojunkie: 2:49am On Feb 06
honesttalk21:
✓ Running away?
Ibn Khaldūn is widely recognized as an esteemed historian and philosopher, earning significant respect in the Muslim world. The matter at hand pertains to attribution, rather than Islam itself. There is no definitive Arabic text where Ibn Khaldun asserts or suggests that Islam requires converting individuals by persuasion or by force. I figure that's why you are running since you cannot prove your claim. That expression is a modern interpretation rather than an authentic quote. Ibn Khaldun explored the ways religion influences social unity and political power, not as a theological reiteration of the Qur’an and Hadith, nor as a claim advocating universal forced conversion. As a Muslim, his work analytically examines Islam’s role in society without taking a polemical stance.
Simply present the reality of where you manufactured
Storyland! 🥱🥱🥱
Re: Islam Was Originally A Sect Of Christianity by honesttalk21: 3:00am On Feb 06
Kobojunkie:
Storyland! 🥱🥱🥱
Questionable story teller. Go find the gullible ones you deceive.
1 2 3 4 5 6 Reply

Ahmad Amadi, Muslims Leader Denounces Islam, Converts To Christianity (Photos) • Why Only One Sect Out Of 73 Will Enter Paradise? • Abdulrahman Yahaya Threatens Kadaria Ahmed For Converting To Christianity • 2 • 3 • 4

How Do You Dispose Torn Pages Of Holy Quran? • Why Are Muslims So Intolerant To Criticism • The Importance Of Jumuah Friday Prayer