₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,433 members, 8,523,160 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 08:33 PM

Toggle theme

Why Jewish Talmud Book Of Gittin 57a Describes Jesus As Burning In Excrement (pi - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Why Jewish Talmud Book Of Gittin 57a Describes Jesus As Burning In Excrement (pi (730 Views)

1 Reply (Go Down)

Why Jewish Talmud Book Of Gittin 57a Describes Jesus As Burning In Excrement (pi by PHYTECH(op): 2:44pm On Mar 12
The Structure of the Passage

The narrative is part of a larger aggadic (non-legal) section describing the destruction of the Temple. Onkelos, a figure seeking to convert to Judaism, uses necromancy to summon three figures from the dead to understand the fate of Israel and the punishment of the wicked .

The text proceeds in a clear tripartite structure:


1. Titus: Onkelos summons Titus, the destroyer of the Second Temple. Titus reports that he is punished by being burned to ashes daily, only to be reconstituted and scattered across the seven seas, repeating this process forever .
2. Balaam: Onkelos then summons Balaam, the non-Jewish prophet from the Torah who sought to curse Israel. When asked about his punishment, Balaam replies that he is judged with "boiling hot semen" ("שכבת זרע רותחת"wink . Rashi's commentary on this passage explicitly states this is measure-for-measure punishment for causing Israel to engage in licentiousness with the daughters of Moab through his counsel .
3. Yeshu (Jesus): Onkelos then summons "Yeshu ha-Notzri" (Jesus the Nazarene) . Jesus tells Onkelos that Israel is most important and that one should seek their welfare. Then Onkelos asks the direct question: "What is the punishment of that man? "—a euphemism for Jesus himself.

The Specific Punishment


Jesus's answer is explicit and unadorned:

"He is punished with boiling excrement ("בצואה רותחת"wink" .

The text then immediately supplies the legal reasoning. It cites a general principle stated by "the Master": "Anyone who mocks the words of the Sages will be sentenced to boiling excrement" . The Gemara then applies this specifically to Jesus: "And this was his sin, as he mocked the words of the Sages" .

Rashi's commentary on this line clarifies the source of this principle. He traces it to Eruvin 21b, which derives from a verse in Ecclesiastes (12:12) that one who mocks ("malig"wink the words of the Scribes (the rabbis) is punished with "weariness of the flesh," interpreted here as boiling excrement .

The Internal Distinction

The passage concludes with a stark editorial judgment by the Gemara itself:

"Come and see the difference between the sinners of Israel and the prophets of the nations of the world. As Balaam, who was a prophet, wished Israel harm, whereas Jesus the Nazarene, who was a Jewish sinner, sought their well-being" .

The text categorizes Jesus explicitly among the "sinners of Israel" ("פושעי ישראל"wink, distinguishing him from foreign figures like Balaam . The punishment—boiling excrement—is the designated penalty for a specific category of transgression: internal Jewish heresy in the form of mocking rabbinic authority. Balaam's punishment of boiling semen is different and tied to sexual immorality .

The Logic of the Punishment

The text operates on the principle of midah keneged midah (measure for measure). The crime is intellectual and spiritual—rejecting the authority of the Oral Law and the Sages who expound it. The punishment is physical and visceral—immersion in the ultimate symbol of filth and degradation.

Thierry Murcia's analysis of this passage notes that the text reflects a perception of Christianity as a resurgence of ancient idolatry, which was implicitly associated with excrement . The punishment is not arbitrary grotesquerie but a precise symbolic statement about the nature of the transgression.

Re: Why Jewish Talmud Book Of Gittin 57a Describes Jesus As Burning In Excrement (pi by PHYTECH(op): 5:32pm On Mar 12
Despicable and blasphemous to jesus
Re: Why Jewish Talmud Book Of Gittin 57a Describes Jesus As Burning In Excrement (pi by gidgiddy: 6:48pm On Mar 12
PHYTECH:
Despicable and blasphemous to jesus
Its one of the differences between Christianity and Islam. In Christianity, nothing is considered blasphemous
Re: Why Jewish Talmud Book Of Gittin 57a Describes Jesus As Burning In Excrement (pi by Kalashnikov49: 6:51pm On Mar 12
In Christianity apart from sinning against the HOLY GHOST any other thing being said is forgivable.

So look for another angle.. grin


PHYTECH:
Despicable and blasphemous to jesus
Re: Why Jewish Talmud Book Of Gittin 57a Describes Jesus As Burning In Excrement (pi by Kalashnikov49: 6:52pm On Mar 12
Imagine a religion that fights for its god. When all power belongs to the same god grin


gidgiddy:
Its one of the differences between Christianity and Islam. In Christianity, nothing is considered blasphemous
1 Reply

Police Weep Over Killing Of 2 DPOs, Officer’s Beheading, Burning Of 11 Stations • Nigeria Policemen Protest: "Stop Killing Us, Stop Burning Police Stations" • Lagos Enters Guiness Book Of Record By Producing Largest Logo With Cupcakes • 2 • 3 • 4

Dino Melaye appointed to announce 2027 Presidential Election Winner • Attempts To Damage Your President Globally Will Hurt You More • How Crowd Booed Tinubu At APC Campaign Flag-off In Kaduna - Daily Trust