₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: RegisterLoginWith GoogleTrendingRecentNew

Stats: 3,328,918 members, 8,437,954 topics. Date: Thursday, 02 July 2026 at 04:53 PM

Toggle theme

Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland ForumNairaland GeneralPoliticsCourt Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s (4348 Views)

1 2 Reply (Go Down)

Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by treesun(op): 12:56pm On Jun 16
The Federal High Court in Abuja on Tuesday awarded a fine of one million Naira against the African Democratic Congress (ADC) and its embattled National Secretary, Ogbeni Rauf Aregbesola, over the application seeking the judge’s withdrawal from the suit.

The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that ADC and Aregbesola had, in separate motions, asked Justice Peter Lifu to recuse himself from the suit filed by an aggrieved party member, Nafiu-Bala Gombe, citing alleged bias.

Delivering a ruling on Tuesday, Justice Lifu held that the motions lacked merit and were devoid of credible evidence aimed at frustrating the order of the Supreme Court for an accelerated hearing of the case.

The judge held that the reasons advanced in the affidavits by the applicants were extraneous.

According to him, the court has painstakingly considered all three processes by parties and by affidavit evidence; there is no iota of bias found.

“There is no element of bias being painted by the applicants as alleged,” he said.

The judge recalled that the motions for recusal were filed even when the court had yet to assume jurisdiction on the case.

“Where then is the element of bias in the motions for recusal?’ he asked.

The judge, who described the applications as “an abuse of court process”, said the motions were fundamentally defective.

“The law is settled that allegations of bias are grave allegations which are not made lightly.

‘Whoever alleges bias must provide clear evidence.

“It becomes apparent that the applicants have failed completely to prove the allegations.

“It is a cheap attempt to blackmail and intimidate the court.

“As I said, nobody can intimidate the court,” he said.

Justice Lifu held that judges should be careful to “accede to such baseless allegations so that they don’t allow litigants to choose judges that suit them.”

He further described the applications as “forum shopping”.

He said the applicants made the allegations so that the case could be assigned to another judge that would do their bidding.

Parties cannot choose which court they should be heard in.

“Matters are assigned to judges by the administrative head of the court, and no applicant can choose who to hear and determine their matters.

“A judge must be firm in doing justice and not dance to the whims and caprices of counsel.

“No court worth its salt should allow this,” the judge said.

Justice Lifu, who said the entire application was based on speculation, said if allowed, lawyers could use this as a tool against the court when they know a case would not favour them.

According to him, if this application is granted in the absence of credible evidence, it will set a dangerous precedent.

“On the whole, I found no merit in the application, and it is hereby dismissed with N500,000 cost each against the applicants and in favour of the plaintiff,” the judge ruled.

Earlier when the case was called, a lawyer, Kalu-Kalu Agu, who appeared for Nkemakolam Ukandu, the National Welfare Secretary of ADC, challenged the judge from delivering the ruling, having ordered the deregistration of ADC in his judgement on Monday.

NAN reports that Agu, on behalf of Ukandu, had filed a motion seeking to be joined in Gombe’s suit.

The lawyer reminded the judge of his previous day’s judgment directing the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to deregister ADC, having failed to meet the constitutional threshold.

“My lord, the clerk of this court did mention the matter is slated for a ruling today.

“In view of your lordship’s ruling and the continuous existence of the 1st defendant (ADC) in this matter, and having been declared dead, I don’t see any reason why this ruling should continue.

“In your judgment, this court ordered INEC to deregister the 1st defendant. So in the eye of the law, the 1st defendant is not existing,” Agu submitted.

“Are you a party in this suit?” Justice Lifu asked.

“Yes, I am my lord,” Agu responded.

“Who joined you, or did you join yourself in your chambers?” the judge asked.

In his reaction, Gombe’s lawyer, Robert Emukpoeruo, SAN, disagreed with Agu’s submission that he was a party in the suit.

Emukpoeruo said he was yet to read the judgement mentioned by Agu; hence, it had no relevance in the instance proceedings.

He said by Order 9 Rule 14(4) of the court, until Ukandu is joined by the judge, he is yet to be a party.

When Agu attempted to respond to Emukpoeruo’s submission, the judge threatened to invoke the powers of the court on him.

Realwan Okpanachi, who appeared for Aregbesola; Suleiman Usman, SAN, lawyer to Sen. David Mark; and Peter Oyewole, who represented Chief Ralph Nwosu, also made their respective submissions.

In his ruling, Justice Lifu said the instant case was distinct from Monday’s matter, where a judgement was delivered against ADC.

After the ruling, the case was adjourned until June 23 for hearing of all pending applications.

NAN reports that Gombe, in the suit, is seeking an order restraining Sen. Mark, the embattled National Chairman of ADC; Ogbeni Rauf Aregbesola, the National Secretary; and members of their interim National Working Committee (NWC) from parading themselves as the party’s leaders.

He had argued that the emergence of Mark, Aregbesola and other NWC members as the party’s leaders breached the provisions of the party’s constitution and the Electoral Act.

Gombe had sued ADC, Mark, Aregbesola, the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) and Ralph Nwosu as the 1st to 5th defendants, respectively, in the suit marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1819/2025.

Nwosu was the former ADC National Chairman who stepped down for David Mark’s leadership of the party
https://www.vanguardngr.com/2026/06/court-fines-adc-aregbesola-n1m-over-application-for-judges-recusal-in-gombes-suit/

Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by cyril10(m): 12:59pm On Jun 16
This Judge is really out to deal with ADC, this Man may be in the pay roll of Wike.
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by Ofunaofu: 1:03pm On Jun 16
The same justice lifu
Truly, A rogue judge
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by givedemwotowoto: 1:05pm On Jun 16
When you realize that this group of people supporting Tilumbu who are ready to be used for anything have infiltrated every sector of the system.

Nigerians have a fierce fight on their hands to reclaim their country
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by AMINDA: 1:08pm On Jun 16
givedemwotowoto:
When you realize that this group of people supporting Tilumbu who are ready to be used for anything have infiltrated every sector of the system.

Nigerians have a fierce fight on their hands to reclaim their country
Let them continue. This can only end one way.
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by IJAYA001(m): 1:21pm On Jun 16
Why strangulating opposition in Democracy.
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by marlow1962(m): 2:37pm On Jun 16
Adc should just fold and disband, because the kind of fuckry they're onto these days.
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by emkz:
Aregbesola fell off badly.

The case against ADC newcomers is very strong. Either they settle Bala Gombe amicably or they may end up not eligible for the 2027 elections. The person who caused this Bala Gombe crisis has abandoned the party. Let Atiku meet the guy and Dumebi Kachikwu and settle with them to withdraw all court cases. They are critical stakeholders in ADC. Carry them along.

David Mark and Rauf Aregbesola have not granted a single interview since last year.

Why?

Rotimi Amaechi has also not accepted his nomination as Atiku's running mate.

Why?

By the way, APC is not responsible for the crisis in any opposition party. If the house rat does not tell the street rat where the loopholes are, no outsider can exploit it.
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by fredoooooo: 2:42pm On Jun 16
Baba kabiru .. Aregbe se madaru grin cheesy
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by McLizbae:
Carry your two legs go court with your documents, only to chop fine again! If eh nor be mumu, an juju.
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by fredoooooo:
IJAYA001:
Why strangulating opposition in Democracy.
Instead of you to blame the worst opposition ever in Nigeria politics, An opposition without proper planning but noise and emotional politics. You dey blame APC.
So APC should supporr them abi ?
I remember very well when all these started , they warm them aviator the consequences but no o .. na Naija we dey we go use stro g head do am ..
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by DMCA: 2:46pm On Jun 16
Nigeria has no opposition party grin
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by Obaofaba: 2:46pm On Jun 16
Very good.

They must no be allowed to ridicule our judicial system.

I know they will appeal the fines instead of pursuing their original case.

Gombe just got a million effortlessly 😂.
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by vanitybutiwanti: 2:47pm On Jun 16
grin grin
They are pressing Atikus neck
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by anonimi: 2:51pm On Jun 16
marlow1962:
Adc should just fold and disband, because the kind of fuckry they're onto these days.
The kind of fuckry done by APC's Twitter Amupitan's INEC and Wike's courts? Or what other type of fuckry is there huh

iwaeda:
Wike Boasts Of Helping APC Use Judiciary To Kill Osun LG Funds Case, Warns Party Leaders Against Ingratitude

Minister of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT), Nyesom Wike, has openly boasted that he assisted certain elements within the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC) in deploying the judiciary to frustrate the Osun State local government allocation lawsuit.

In a video now circulating widely on social media and obtained by SaharaReporters, Wike made the claim while addressing a crowd in Port Harcourt, Rivers State.

The former Rivers governor accused the APC National Secretary, Senator Ajibola Basiru, of benefitting from judicial actions against the Osun State Government without knowing those who did the work behind the scenes.

The suit in question led to the withholding of local government funds in Osun State, a development widely seen as targeting the administration of Governor Ademola Adeleke as opposition in the state.

Wike, who spoke angrily, suggested that the court action supporting the APC’s position against the Osun government did not happen by chance, boasting that powerful political forces worked quietly to ensure the outcome.

“Don’t take our support for Mr President for granted,” Wike warned, in an apparent message to APC leaders defending Rivers State Governor Siminalayi Fubara. “You have to be careful about the statements you make. You have to be very careful.”

He accused Basiru of political ingratitude, claiming the APC was enjoying in Osun State without understanding who engineered their advantage.

“Today, you are enjoying in Osun. You don’t know those who did the work,” Wike said. “You are opening your mouth to talk about Rivers State.”

https://saharareporters.com/2026/01/08/wike-boasts-helping-apc-use-judiciary-kill-osun-lg-funds-case-warns-party-leaders

Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by anonimi: 2:54pm On Jun 16
vanitybutiwanti:
grin grin
They are pressing Atikus neck
Tinubu and APC are the ones pressing the neck of 200 million Nigerians with their cluelessness and incompetence extreme poverty and insecurity shege.

anonimi:
May 1, 2025

May Day: Hunger, unemployment, insecurity real— Tinubu

According to him: “The theme demands our collective attention and serves as a stark reminder of the need to create an environment where every worker feels safe, valued, and empowered to contribute to the growth and prosperity of our nation. As your President, I assure you that this administration is committed to creating such an environment for the common good.”

On the economic hardship, he noted that while it is a global phenomenon, its effects on Nigerians are particularly severe.

Tinubu said: “I am aware of the peculiarities of the economic hardship Nigerians face—rising living costs, hunger, insecurity, unemployment, and the loss of livelihoods. These challenges are real and demand definitive solutions, which I am poised to address as your President.

https://www.vanguardngr.com/2025/05/may-day-hunger-unemployment-insecurity-real-tinubu/
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by Obaofaba: 2:55pm On Jun 16
That's their way.

All eyes on the judiciary crew 😂.

Justice Lifu is already a strong contender to being the best Judge of 2026.
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by anonimi: 3:00pm On Jun 16
DMCA:
Nigeria has no opposition party grin
How is that something worthy of exposing your 32 outside huh
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by Obaofaba: 3:01pm On Jun 16
givedemwotowoto:
When you realize that this group of people supporting Tilumbu who are ready to be used for anything have infiltrated every sector of the system.

Nigerians have a fierce fight on their hands to reclaim their country
I thought you claimed you have the majority by your side?

Body go tell you soon.

It's called structure and structure win election.
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by OgwuEgo: 3:01pm On Jun 16
Same werey Judge that ordered the deregistration of ADC yesterday, you will soon be suspended by NJC if you continue this rascally Judgement.
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by Greenodds: 3:03pm On Jun 16
Okay, so what the judge is saying is that he must judge by force. Maybe the judge should recurse and then file a suit grin
This our borrow justice system sef embarassed
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by Banter1(m): 3:03pm On Jun 16
Question; what's the faith of Atiku Abubakar?

Is ADC going to appeal or that's it for them?
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by Obaofaba: 3:03pm On Jun 16
OgwuEgo:
Same werey Judge that ordered the deregistration of ADC yesterday, you will soon be suspended by NJC if you continue this rascally Judgement.
The question is, what did the Constitution say?

Unless he breached the law, nothing can happen to him.

I love his doggedness.

He's a man iron balls.

God bless him and justice omotosho, they are our heroes.
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by OgwuEgo: 3:05pm On Jun 16
Inyang Ekwo just finished serving one year suspension without pay recently, he should continue.
Obaofaba:
The question is, what did the Constitution say?

Unless he breached the law, nothing can happen to him.

I love his doggedness.

He's a man iron balls.

God bless him and justice omotosho, they are our heroes.
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by DMCA: 3:19pm On Jun 16
anonimi:
How is that something worthy of exposing your 32 outside huh
Yes grin
u want to count them? grin
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by fergie001(mod): 3:20pm On Jun 16
Na NJC I just dey watch.

A very puerile body
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by Obaofaba: 3:20pm On Jun 16
OgwuEgo:
Inyang Ekwo just finished serving one year suspension without pay recently, he should continue.
What's the offense of justice Lifu?

Interpreting the constitution rightly ?
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by Samogloby: 3:41pm On Jun 16
Justice Peter Lifu, this man is the most,.... Please help me complete it
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by Mitsurugi(m): 3:50pm On Jun 16
Obaofaba:
What's the offense of justice Lifu?

Interpreting the constitution rightly ?
That's what Inyang Ekwo thought once upon a time
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by Penguin2: 5:01pm On Jun 16
fergie001:
Na NJC I just dey watch.

A very puerile body
You expect NJC that is in Tinubu and Wike’s pocket to discipline Lifu?

Meanwhile, I think I know why he did not give judgement on the matter today as initially scheduled.

If he gave judgement today, ADC would have merged it with yesterday own and file a consolidated appeal which would have fastracked the two cases.

But in delaying judgement in this case, by the time Appeal Court might be giving some relief to ADC regarding deregisteration, he would likely hit them with handing over the party to Gombe Bala which would become an entirely new round of court circus again.

Lifu has removed all veil of pretense.
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by AcadaWriter0: 5:12pm On Jun 16
Just another day in Gombe. Let’s that one be enough to make it look legit.
Re: Court Fines ADC, Aregbesola N1m Over Application For Judge’s Recusal In Gombe’s by DomPerignon: 5:16pm On Jun 16
Bala Gonbe case is what will put the final nail on the usurpers led by Atiku who attempted to hijack a party.

Nwosu nah real guy man to have cashed out at the expense of Atiku and co for he knew ADC was in serious wahala
1 2 Reply

Sowore Remanded At Kuje Prison As Court Rejects Recusal BidBoko Haram Demands $500,000 Ransom For Judge’s Wife, Driver, OrderlySupreme Court Fines Afe Babalola, Olanipekun N60 Million234

Obasanjo Tears Yar'adua's Family Apart !A Must Watch Video: An Interview With A Nigerian Drug Dealer In ThailandInvestigation By The Nigerian Merchant Navy By Commodore Allen Benson Edema