Why 7 Books Were Removed From The Bible And What Different Churches Say - Christianity Etc - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Why 7 Books Were Removed From The Bible And What Different Churches Say (352 Views)
| Why 7 Books Were Removed From The Bible And What Different Churches Say by chatinent(op): 11:38pm On Jun 20 |
(c) chatinent Why 7 Books Were Removed From the Bible and What Different Churches Say About It Good morning, Happy Sunday to you all. If you look at the Bible you carry to church today, especially if you attend a Pentecostal or Protestant church, it has exactly 66 books. But if you take a close look at a Catholic Bible, you will notice something different: it contains 73 books. Many people believe a massive conspiracy theory that a secret group sat down in the dark to maliciously delete parts of the word of God. Others think some hidden truths were buried to keep Christians in the dark. Let us drop all sentiments today and look at the actual history behind this. We will look at it like we are auditing an old database. When you look at how these 7 books, which are called the Deuterocanon by Catholics and the Apocrypha by Protestants, left the mainstream Bible, it was not a magical event. It was a massive structural split that happened during the Protestant Reformation in the 1500s. Let us dive into the real reasons why books like Tobit, Judith, Wisdom of Solomon, Sirach, Baruch, 1 Maccabees, and 2 Maccabees were separated from your everyday Bible. 1. The Language Crisis: Greek Copies vs. Hebrew Copies The first major reason for this split comes down to the language the ancient manuscripts were written in. This created a serious verification problem back in the day. The Greek Database (The Septuagint): Around 250 years before Jesus was born, Jewish scholars in Egypt translated the Hebrew scriptures into Greek. This translation was called the Septuagint. Because Greek was the global language at the time, this version included these 7 extra books because Greek-speaking Jews read them regularly. In fact, the early Christian Church and the New Testament writers used this Greek version as their main Old Testament. The Hebrew Standard Reset: Centuries later, mainstream Jewish rabbis in Israel decided to officially lock and finalize their own Hebrew Bible. They set a strict rule: any book that was not originally written in Hebrew, or was written outside Israel, would be blocked. Because these 7 books were primarily preserved in Greek, they failed this specific Hebrew validation test and were left out of the official Jewish scriptures. The Protestant Filter Rule: In 1534, a man named Martin Luther started the Protestant Reformation. When he wanted to translate the Bible into German, he decided that if the Jewish rabbis did not accept those 7 books in their Hebrew library, then Christians should not treat them as divine laws either. He pulled them out of the main Old Testament and put them in a separate section at the back called the Apocrypha. He labeled them as books that are good to read but not equal to holy scripture. By the 1800s, printing societies stopped printing that middle section entirely just to save production costs, and that is how the 66-book Bible became the standard for most of us today. 2. The Doctrinal Clashes: Why Specific Verses Created Serious Arguments Apart from the language barrier, the actual things written inside these books caused massive theological disagreements between the early Reformers and the Catholic Church. 2 Maccabees and the Purgatory Argument: In 2 Maccabees chapter 12, the text describes soldiers making sacrifices and praying for dead people so their sins could be forgiven. For Catholics, this is a major foundation for the belief in Purgatory and praying for the dead. But for Protestant reformers who preached that salvation is strictly by personal faith while you are alive, this idea caused a massive clash. They argued that you cannot change a dead person's destiny with prayers or offerings. Tobit and Giving Alms: In Tobit chapter 12 verse 9, the text says that giving alms saves a person from death and purges away all sins. This statement became a major issue for Protestants. They believe firmly that only the blood of Jesus can wash away sins, not giving money or charity to the poor (or so that all the tithes and offerings can come to the church owners). Historical Consistency Issues: Books like Judith contain some historical and geographical mix-ups. For instance, Judith chapter 1 verse 1 describes King Nebuchadnezzar as the ruler of the Assyrians in the city of Nineveh. However, established historical records show that Nebuchadnezzar was actually the King of the Babylonians in Babylon. Mainstream critics argued that a book inspired directly by God could not contain these kinds of data errors. What Different Popular Churches Say About These Books Today: The Catholic Church: The Catholic Church strongly maintains that these 7 books are 100 percent holy, inspired by God, and authoritative. At the Council of Trent in 1546, they passed an official decree confirming that these books have always been part of the true Christian Bible since the beginning. They view the Protestant removal of these books as an unauthorized, modern alteration of sacred history. Mainstream Protestants and Pentecostals (RCCG, Winners, Christ Embassy, etc.): Evangelical and Pentecostal churches completely reject these books as the Word of God. They point out that Jesus and the apostles never explicitly quoted from any of these 7 books in the New Testament using phrases like: It is written. They treat them strictly as historical books that are interesting to read but hold zero spiritual authority over a Christian's life. Jehovah's Witnesses (JWs): Jehovah's Witnesses completely reject these books and stick strictly to the 66-book boundary. They argue that the internal evidence proves they do not have God's spirit. JWs point to the historical mistakes in Judith and the superstitious practices described in Tobit, like using a fish liver to cast out demons in Tobit chapter 6, as absolute proof that these texts were written by uninspired men. They believe these books have no business being inside the holy scriptures. So have you ever research beyond what you have been told all your life? |
| Re: Why 7 Books Were Removed From The Bible And What Different Churches Say by CodeTemplar: 12:37am On Jun 21 |
C n P. You try no be small oo. |
| Re: Why 7 Books Were Removed From The Bible And What Different Churches Say by SafariHunter(m): 3:10am On Jun 21 |
Better topic for Sunday. Make I first chop finish |
| Re: Why 7 Books Were Removed From The Bible And What Different Churches Say by adeoyekay(m): 5:43am On Jun 21 |
@Chatinent, thanks for this |
| Re: Why 7 Books Were Removed From The Bible And What Different Churches Say by paxonel(m): 5:53am On Jun 21 |
chatinent:were all these books documented in the old testament? |
| Re: Why 7 Books Were Removed From The Bible And What Different Churches Say by Passionnn: 7:13am On Jun 21 |
Funny enough, though curious, I've not thought of finding out why they were removed. All I was told was that they were not inspired by God. I hope to download and read someday. Thank you |
| Re: Why 7 Books Were Removed From The Bible And What Different Churches Say by AntiChristian: 9:23am On Jun 21 |
Why do you think only 7 were removed? Ethiopian Bible has between 81-88 Books, eastern orthodox 79-80 books, Catholics 73 and protestants 66 books! |
| Re: Why 7 Books Were Removed From The Bible And What Different Churches Say by Kobojunkie: 12:50pm On Jun 21 |
AntiChristian:If you have ever actually read the books in the Ethiopian Bible, the Eastern Orthodox, as well as the Catholic bible, you would come to see that the reason why those that did not make it were considered not valuable are pretty much the same. The messages in the books do not meld at all with the stories in the other Hebrew texts of the Old Testament (or the Greek texts of the Gospel), as explained ![]() |
| Re: Why 7 Books Were Removed From The Bible And What Different Churches Say by Kobojunkie: 12:51pm On Jun 21 |
Passionnn:They are good to read, so you understand for yourself why they shouldn't even make the cut at all beyond the so-called religious reasons given. ![]() |
Disobedience To Husband And Issue Of Attending Different Churches • China Will Rewrite The Bible And The Quran To 'reflect Socialist Values' • 7 Different Churches In One Building in Lagos, See Nigerians' Reactions • 2 • 3 • 4
Theology Should Be Taught To Children Instead Of Religion • Spiritual Digest For The Day 14th Of October 2015 • 메가888카지노\\【【gmc420.com】】\\메가888카지노
