₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,345,834 members, 8,519,742 topics. Date: Monday, 16 November 2026 at 05:32 PM

Toggle theme

The State Police Mirage: Ignoring The Real Causes Of Insecurity - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › The State Police Mirage: Ignoring The Real Causes Of Insecurity (174 Views)

1 Reply (Go Down)

The State Police Mirage: Ignoring The Real Causes Of Insecurity by Bobloco(op): 7:23pm On Jun 27
The hype around state police sounds eerily familiar. It's the same hype we heard about local government financial autonomy. We were told it would be the best thing since sliced bread, that it would finally bring development to the grassroots.

So, where are the results?

Nearly two years later, several local governments are still struggling. In Osun State, for example, local government allocations have been withheld by the Tinubu administration for almost two years, starving councils of funds needed for development and even the payment of salaries. So much for autonomy.

Now we're being sold another miracle cure: state police. The same administration that has presided over one of the country's worst security crises now wants Nigerians to believe that creating another police structure controlled by state governors is the magic wand that will fix everything.

Yet they continue to ignore the drivers of insecurity: deepening hardship, soaring inflation, unemployment, the collapse of the naira's purchasing power, the Tinubu draconian policies mascurading as economic reforms that have made life significantly harder for millions. Treating the symptoms while ignoring the disease has never solved anything.

The existing police force is already understaffed, undertrained, poorly equipped, and poorly paid. The military is deployed internally. The Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps exists. States fund vigilante groups. There's the regional security outfits like Amotekun Corps in the south west. Despite all these security outfits, insecurity has continued to worsen.

Now we're expected to believe that state police will suddenly succeed where every other security arrangement has struggled?

Nigerians have seen this before especially under the Tinubu regime, Every new policy is marketed as the best thing since sliced bread. Then reality arrives, implementation fails, accountability disappears, and the public is left bearing the brunt

Until the underlying economic and governance failures are addressed, and until there are credible safeguards against governors turning state police into political enforcers, many Nigerians will see this less as a security reform and more as another overhyped promise.
Re: The State Police Mirage: Ignoring The Real Causes Of Insecurity by Ttalk: 8:36pm On Jun 27
Bobloco:
The hype around state police sounds eerily familiar. It's the same hype we heard about local government financial autonomy. We were told it would be the best thing since sliced bread, that it would finally bring development to the grassroots.

So, where are the results?

Nearly two years later, several local governments are still struggling. In Osun State, for example, local government allocations have been withheld by the Tinubu administration for almost two years, starving councils of funds needed for development and even the payment of salaries. So much for autonomy.

Now we're being sold another miracle cure: state police. The same administration that has presided over one of the country's worst security crises now wants Nigerians to believe that creating another police structure controlled by state governors is the magic wand that will fix everything.

Yet they continue to ignore the drivers of insecurity: deepening hardship, soaring inflation, unemployment, the collapse of the naira's purchasing power, the Tinubu draconian policies mascurading as economic reforms that have made life significantly harder for millions. Treating the symptoms while ignoring the disease has never solved anything.

The existing police force is already understaffed, undertrained, poorly equipped, and poorly paid. The military is deployed internally. The Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps exists. States fund vigilante groups. There's the regional security outfits like Amotekun Corps in the south west. Despite all these security outfits, insecurity has continued to worsen.

Now we're expected to believe that state police will suddenly succeed where every other security arrangement has struggled?

Nigerians have seen this before especially under the Tinubu regime, Every new policy is marketed as the best thing since sliced bread. Then reality arrives, implementation fails, accountability disappears, and the public is left bearing the brunt

Until the underlying economic and governance failures are addressed, and until there are credible safeguards against governors turning state police into political enforcers, many Nigerians will see this less as a security reform and more as another overhyped promise.
You better start mobilising your people to call out on your governor.

What the bill seek to address is to remove state police from Exclusive list down to concurrent so that both Federal and states have power to establish and legislate on state police in their state.

I don't know how that now becomes a problem to the Obidients.

I thought Southern Nigeria especially the SE claimed to love restructuring since they can't get Biafra, why are they now getting jittery at the mention of state police

Does their own type of restructuring only end with removal of indigenous status in favour of residential status.

What then define Federalism if some section of the country in deed and in action are trying to unify a diverse nation that even the colonial masters respect our diversity and gave us a regional arrangement that was later truncated by same people who don't want state police
Re: The State Police Mirage: Ignoring The Real Causes Of Insecurity by favor914: 9:10pm On Jun 27
Bobloco:
The hype around state police sounds eerily familiar. It's the same hype we heard about local government financial autonomy. We were told it would be the best thing since sliced bread, that it would finally bring development to the grassroots.

So, where are the results?

Nearly two years later, several local governments are still struggling. In Osun State, for example, local government allocations have been withheld by the Tinubu administration for almost two years, starving councils of funds needed for development and even the payment of salaries. So much for autonomy.

Now we're being sold another miracle cure: state police. The same administration that has presided over one of the country's worst security crises now wants Nigerians to believe that creating another police structure controlled by state governors is the magic wand that will fix everything.

Yet they continue to ignore the drivers of insecurity: deepening hardship, soaring inflation, unemployment, the collapse of the naira's purchasing power, the Tinubu draconian policies mascurading as economic reforms that have made life significantly harder for millions. Treating the symptoms while ignoring the disease has never solved anything.

The existing police force is already understaffed, undertrained, poorly equipped, and poorly paid. The military is deployed internally. The Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps exists. States fund vigilante groups. There's the regional security outfits like Amotekun Corps in the south west. Despite all these security outfits, insecurity has continued to worsen.

Now we're expected to believe that state police will suddenly succeed where every other security arrangement has struggled?

Nigerians have seen this before especially under the Tinubu regime, Every new policy is marketed as the best thing since sliced bread. Then reality arrives, implementation fails, accountability disappears, and the public is left bearing the brunt

Until the underlying economic and governance failures are addressed, and until there are credible safeguards against governors turning state police into political enforcers, many Nigerians will see this less as a security reform and more as another overhyped promise.
Tinubu Tinubu Tinubu, u made no mention of the states, & local governments huh.

Abi are u not aware that u practice a three tier system of government in your country?
Re: The State Police Mirage: Ignoring The Real Causes Of Insecurity by Bobloco(op): 9:22pm On Jun 27
Ttalk:
You better start mobilising your people to call out on your governor.

What the bill seek to address is to remove state police from Exclusive list down to concurrent so that both Federal and states have power to establish and legislate on state police in their state.

I don't know how that now becomes a problem to the Obidients.

I thought Southern Nigeria especially the SE claimed to love restructuring since they can't get Biafra, why are they now getting jittery at the mention of state police

Does their own type of restructuring only end with removal of indigenous status in favour of residential status.

What then define Federalism if some section of the country in deed and in action are trying to unify a diverse nation that even the colonial masters respect our diversity and gave us a regional arrangement that was later truncated by same people who don't want state police
It's remarkable how you managed to write all that without addressing a single substantive point I raised.

When will you ever comment objectively without dragging "Obidients" into every discussion? This constant we vs them political bickering and ethnic baiting has become a substitute for engaging with facts.

I specifically highlighted the root causes of insecurity, rising poverty, inflation, unemployment, declining purchasing power, and poor governance. You ignored all of that and went off on a tangent about restructuring, Biafra, and Obidients. That's not a rebuttalt's a distraction.

And since you're so eager to defend every new policy, what happened to the hype around local government financial autonomy? Nigerians were told it would transform grassroots governance overnight. So where are the results? What has become of the promised autonomy when several councils have struggled to function, with funding disputes and implementation challenges leaving many unable to deliver services effectively?

No serious person is saying states shouldn't have the constitutional power to establish state police. The concern is about implementation and safeguards. In a country where governors are already accused of influencing local institutions, it's perfectly legitimate to ask what mechanisms will prevent state police from becoming political enforcers.

Supporting reforms shouldn't mean suspending critical thinking. If a policy is good, it should withstand scrutiny without resorting to Obidients this, Obidient that and South East that. Debate the argument, not imaginary political enemies.
Re: The State Police Mirage: Ignoring The Real Causes Of Insecurity by franchasofficia: 9:39pm On Jun 27
Bobloco:
The hype around state police sounds eerily familiar. It's the same hype we heard about local government financial autonomy. We were told it would be the best thing since sliced bread, that it would finally bring development to the grassroots.

So, where are the results?

Nearly two years later, several local governments are still struggling. In Osun State, for example, local government allocations have been withheld by the Tinubu administration for almost two years, starving councils of funds needed for development and even the payment of salaries. So much for autonomy.

Now we're being sold another miracle cure: state police. The same administration that has presided over one of the country's worst security crises now wants Nigerians to believe that creating another police structure controlled by state governors is the magic wand that will fix everything.

Yet they continue to ignore the drivers of insecurity: deepening hardship, soaring inflation, unemployment, the collapse of the naira's purchasing power, the Tinubu draconian policies mascurading as economic reforms that have made life significantly harder for millions. Treating the symptoms while ignoring the disease has never solved anything.

The existing police force is already understaffed, undertrained, poorly equipped, and poorly paid. The military is deployed internally. The Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps exists. States fund vigilante groups. There's the regional security outfits like Amotekun Corps in the south west. Despite all these security outfits, insecurity has continued to worsen.

Now we're expected to believe that state police will suddenly succeed where every other security arrangement has struggled?

Nigerians have seen this before especially under the Tinubu regime, Every new policy is marketed as the best thing since sliced bread. Then reality arrives, implementation fails, accountability disappears, and the public is left bearing the brunt

Until the underlying economic and governance failures are addressed, and until there are credible safeguards against governors turning state police into political enforcers, many Nigerians will see this less as a security reform and more as another overhyped promise.
You are even going too far.


Have you forgotten how Amotekun was celebrated after it was founded? It was claimed that Amotekun will bring an end to insecurity in Southwest especially Fulani herdsmen menace. They brandished their lion abi tiger uniforms and claimed they will be operating with Yoruba traditional charms to make sure they will secure SW region from all forms of criminality.



It's over 3 years now and nobody hears about Amotekun again after all the initial noise and bragging.


Same fate awaits State Police if we don't address key issues aiding insecurity in Nigeria.


Based on several intelligence reports of several years, many communities in different states in Nigeria have always said that Nigerian army authority in their state always come to protect Fulani herdsmen and their settlements after they carry out attacks on communities. Some claim military checkpoints are usually within a walking distance from where Fulani kidnappers kidnap people in their community, all these reports ought to be put into consideration.


I remember when some Mopol guys accused army of protecting the Fulani militants that attacked a community in Plateau state, they were so angry they called on government to withdraw army from the community and allow the Mopol handle the security there.



What these point to sabotage, sympathy and intentional abeiting of crime by people that ought to defend the people irrespective of tribe.


Now what stops the President from trying something new to solve this by making sure every Commanding Officer of every army cantonment in any Nigeria state is an indigene of that state?



Do same for federal commissioner of Police and other heads of tactical Police teams
Re: The State Police Mirage: Ignoring The Real Causes Of Insecurity by obiekunie01: 12:05pm On Jun 28
DomPerignon:
You Ibos will not say the truth on why you are against state policing.
You always refer to 'Igbo' as 'Ibo' insulting a whole tribe and yet they don't ban you.

But let me just mention your tribe derogatorily like you are doing my tribe and i will be banned instantly for years.
1 Reply

Senator Abaribe: Perpetrators Of Insecurity In Igbo Land May Have Been Imported • SSS Arrests Usman Bugaje For Criticising Buhari’s Handling Of Insecurity • Ganduje: I Think El-rufai Doesn’t Understand The Issue Of Insecurity • 2 • 3 • 4

The Truth Behind The G15 Rally Postponement: Why Kwara APC Stakeholders Reject • VDM Meets Oluwo, Backs LG Autonomy, Eyes Grassroots Politics • Olaleye Extols Legacy Of Late Rt. Hon. Emmanuel Soyemi Coker