If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? - Christianity Etc (4) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? (2889 Views)
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Truthseeker10: 2:11pm On Jul 28 |
JoyfulSoul:But you've already claimed that a genuine believer cannot fall away. If that was also the stand of the writer, is it not logical that Hebrews 6:4-6 was addressing only those who were not genuine believers? Below is the position that you have taken as regards Hebrews 6:4-6 in your earlier submission. "The better way to understand Hebrews 6 is that it describes people who have been deeply exposed to the blessings and power of the new covenant community. If, after all of that, they reject Christ and return to trusting the Law, there is no other sacrifice left for them because they have rejected the only Saviour." |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by JoyfulSoul: 2:18pm On Jul 28 |
Truthseeker10:No, because you're assuming the audience can only be one or the other. That isn't how the New Testament epistles are written. Hebrews was written to a congregation of professing Jewish Christians. The writer addresses the whole church because he, as a human author, could not infallibly know who was truly regenerate and who was merely professing faith. The warning is therefore given to everyone. Those who are truly Christ's will heed the warning and persevere because God preserves them. Those who ultimately reject Christ demonstrate that they were never truly born again, despite all the privileges and experiences they had. Notice that after giving this severe warning, the writer immediately says: "But, beloved, we are persuaded better things of you, and things that accompany salvation..." (Hebrews 6:9). That statement is significant. It shows that the experiences listed in verses 4-6 are not the same as "things that accompany salvation." If they were, verse 9 would make no sense. So my question remains: if verses 4-6 describe people who unquestionably possessed salvation, why does the writer distinguish them from "things that accompany salvation" only three verses later? |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Truthseeker10: 2:46pm On Jul 28 |
JoyfulSoul:So according to your statement in bold above, the writer of Hebrews 6:4-6 was warning everyone, but those who are true Christians are only those that God himself chooses to preserve? |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by JoyfulSoul: 3:08pm On Jul 28 |
Truthseeker10:Yes, the warning is given to everyone in the visible church because no human being knows with certainty who is genuinely born again. God's elect will heed the warning because He preserves them, while those who finally reject Christ reveal that they never truly belonged to Him (1 John 2:19). But that still doesn't answer my question about Hebrews 6:9. How do you explain why the author says "better things...things that accompany salvation" if verses 4–6 already describe people who possessed salvation? |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Truthseeker10: 3:34pm On Jul 28 |
JoyfulSoul:I don't get. are you saying that "things that accompany salvation" in Hebrews 6:9 are different from the experiences listed in Hebrews 6:4, 5? |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by JoyfulSoul: 3:56pm On Jul 28 |
Truthseeker10:I'm saying the writer deliberately makes a distinction. Hebrews 6:4-6 describes people who have experienced extraordinary spiritual privileges: they were enlightened, tasted the heavenly gift, shared in the Holy Spirit, tasted the goodness of God's word and the powers of the age to come. Then in verse 9, immediately after giving the warning, he says: "But, beloved, we are persuaded better things of you, yes, things that accompany salvation." My question is this: if the experiences in verses 4-6 are themselves the things that accompany salvation, why does the writer immediately distinguish them by saying he is convinced of better things that accompany salvation? I'm not denying that the experiences in verses 4-6 are real. They are. What I'm saying is that the writer does not explicitly identify them as the evidences of genuine salvation. Instead, he appears to distinguish them from "things that accompany salvation." So I'll ask again: How do you understand that distinction in verse 9? If verses 4-6 already describe people who unquestionably possessed salvation, what are the "better things" that accompany salvation in verse 9? |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Truthseeker10: 4:07pm On Jul 28 |
JoyfulSoul:I am not going to give an answer to a question that you are not sure of as shown in your bolded statement above. Does the writer in Hebrews 6:4-6 make a distinction between the experiences listed there and the "things that accompany salvation" In Hebrews 6:9? Yes or no? |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by JoyfulSoul: 4:19pm On Jul 28 |
Truthseeker10:Yes, I believe the writer is making a distinction. Hebrews 6:4-6 lists a series of extraordinary spiritual experiences. Then, in verse 9, the author immediately says: "But, beloved, we are persuaded better things of you, yes, things that accompany salvation." The conjunction "but" introduces a contrast, and the phrase "better things" qualifies what follows as "things that accompany salvation." So my conclusion is not based on uncertainty but on the flow of the passage. If the experiences in verses 4-6 were themselves the things that accompany salvation, why would the writer immediately distinguish them by saying he is persuaded of better things that accompany salvation? Now I'll ask you the same question again: What are the "better things" in verse 9 if the experiences in verses 4-6 already constitute the things that accompany salvation? Please explain the author's contrast from the text rather than simply asking me for a yes-or-no answer. |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Truthseeker10: 4:31pm On Jul 28 |
JoyfulSoul:You are actually the one teaching me here. Do you agree with the information in the screenshot below?
|
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by JoyfulSoul: 4:43pm On Jul 28 |
Truthseeker10:I agree that that interpretation is possible. My point has never been that it's impossible. The question is which interpretation best fits the immediate context and the rest of Scripture. I agree that "better things" could refer to fruit, perseverance and faithful service. In fact, verse 10 explains some of those things. But that's precisely my point. If verses 4–6 describe people who were genuinely saved, then the author is warning that genuinely saved people can irrevocably lose salvation. Yet elsewhere the same book says: Hebrews 7:25 – Christ is able to save completely those who come to God through Him. Hebrews 10:14 – By one offering He has perfected forever those who are being sanctified. Hebrews 13:20–21 – God Himself works in believers to do His will. Likewise Jesus says, "I give them eternal life, and they shall never perish" (John 10:28), and Romans 8:30 says that all whom God justified He also glorified. So the question isn't simply, "Is another reading possible?" The question is, which reading harmonises with the whole of Scripture? That's why I understand Hebrews 6 as describing people who have experienced extraordinary covenant privileges and exposure to the work of God, but whose final apostasy shows they were never truly regenerate. The warning is real, and God uses it to preserve His people, but it does not require the conclusion that a genuinely justified believer can lose salvation. I appreciate your response, and I agree that your interpretation is one possible reading of the passage. My point has never been that it's impossible. The question is which interpretation best harmonises with the immediate context and the rest of Scripture. I also want to be clear that I'm not trying to be confrontational or argumentative. My desire is that we both sharpen one another as we study God's Word. Sound biblical exegesis is critical for every believer because our theology should arise from the text itself, not from assumptions we bring to it. Sadly, careful exegesis is something that is often lacking in many Nigerian churches, and I hope discussions like this encourage all of us to examine the Scriptures more carefully. One question I'd genuinely like your thoughts on is this: Do you believe Hebrews 6 teaches that someone who has genuinely lost salvation can never be restored again? Because verse 6 doesn't merely say they fall away—it says "it is impossible to renew them again to repentance." If your interpretation is that a genuine believer can lose salvation, do you also believe that person can never repent and be restored? If not, how do you explain the author's use of the word "impossible"? I'm asking because I think that's one of the central questions this passage raises, and any interpretation of Hebrews 6 should account for it. I'm interested to hear how you understand that part of the text. |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Truthseeker10: 5:05pm On Jul 28 |
JoyfulSoul:Below is your statement in bold in your earlier submission while you were trying to trap me. "That statement is significant. It shows that the experiences listed in verses 4-6 are not the same as "things that accompany salvation." If they were, verse 9 would make no sense." Do you agree with the screenshot below?
|
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by JoyfulSoul: 5:20pm On Jul 28 |
Truthseeker10:That's a fair observation regarding my wording. I probably expressed it too strongly. A better way to state my position is: "Hebrews 6:9 is best understood as distinguishing the experiences in verses 4-6 from the things that accompany salvation." My conclusion isn't based on verse 9 alone. It's based on reading Hebrews 6 in light of the whole of Hebrews and the rest of Scripture, particularly passages such as John 10:28-29, Romans 8:30, Hebrews 7:25 and Hebrews 10:14, which teach the perseverance and security of those who are truly in Christ. That said, I also feel the discussion is becoming more about finding a statement to trap me with than engaging the substance of the argument. If my wording wasn't as precise as it could have been, I'm happy to clarify or even correct it. That's part of honest Bible study. But I hope we're both more interested in discovering what the text actually teaches than in trying to score debating points. I'm not trying to trap you, and I'd appreciate the same courtesy. My desire is that we both sharpen one another as we carefully handle God's Word. Sound exegesis is essential because our doctrine must come from Scripture itself, not merely from the conclusions we've already reached. So I'd still appreciate your thoughts on this question: Do you believe Hebrews 6 teaches that someone who has genuinely lost salvation can never be restored again? Verse 6 doesn't merely say they fall away; it says "it is impossible to renew them again to repentance." If you believe a genuine believer can lose salvation, do you also believe that person can never repent and be restored? If not, how do you understand the word "impossible" in its context? |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Truthseeker10: 5:33pm On Jul 28 |
JoyfulSoul:Alright. Do you agree with the screenshot below?
|
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Truthseeker10: 5:34pm On Jul 28 |
JoyfulSoul:
|
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by JoyfulSoul: 5:44pm On Jul 28 |
[quote author=Truthseeker10 post=140170144][/quote]I don't think we're making progress because we've moved away from discussing the text itself. I fully accept that sincere Christians have arrived at different conclusions on these passages. My argument has never been that no other interpretation exists. My argument is that one interpretation best harmonises with the immediate context and the rest of Scripture. What I keep noticing is that whenever I ask how your interpretation explains a particular part of the text, the discussion shifts to whether my interpretation is the only possible one. Those are two different questions. So let me ask what I think is the central exegetical question: Do you believe Hebrews 6 teaches that a genuinely saved person who falls away can never be restored? Verse 6 says it is impossible to renew such a person again to repentance. If your answer is yes, then your position is that a true believer can lose salvation and can never be brought back. If your answer is no, then I'd genuinely like to know how you understand the word "impossible" in that context. I'm not asking this to trap you. I'm asking because every interpretation of Hebrews 6 has to account for the severity of that statement. |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Truthseeker10: 5:48pm On Jul 28 |
JoyfulSoul:Do you agree that the statement below is your personal opinion? "My argument is that one interpretation best harmonises with the immediate context and the rest of Scripture.", Yes or no? |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by JoyfulSoul: 5:57pm On Jul 28 |
Truthseeker10:Yes, it is my conclusion from studying the text. But I wouldn't call it a mere personal opinion. Every one of us comes to the text and reaches an interpretation. The question is not whether it's my opinion or your opinion. The question is: which interpretation best explains the passage in its immediate context and harmonises with the rest of Scripture? That's the task of biblical exegesis. We've both offered interpretations of Hebrews 6. Instead of reducing the discussion to whose opinion it is, let's evaluate which interpretation best accounts for the author's words, the context of Hebrews, and the whole counsel of Scripture. I'd still be interested in your answer to the question you've consistently avoided: If Hebrews 6 teaches that a genuinely saved person can lose salvation, do you also believe that such a person can never be restored again, since verse 6 says it is "impossible to renew them again to repentance"? I think every interpretation of Hebrews 6 must answer that question. So I will be interested if you can answer the question as I haven't avoided answering yours. |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Truthseeker10: 6:02pm On Jul 28 |
JoyfulSoul:Can you show me in this discussion where I offered a personal interpretation of Hebrews 6 since you claimed that we've both offered interpretations of Hebrews 6? |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by JoyfulSoul: 6:11pm On Jul 28 |
Truthseeker10:I will answer your question but first answer mine as I have been answering you but you've been avoiding answering my question. If Hebrews 6 teaches that a genuinely saved person can lose salvation, do you also believe that such a person can never be restored again, since verse 6 says it is "impossible to renew them again to repentance"? |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Truthseeker10: 6:14pm On Jul 28 |
JoyfulSoul:You must come with clean hands before i answer your question since you made a claim that involves me. You claimed that we've both offered interpretation of Hebrews 6. Kindly provide the evidence to prove that the statement is true. |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by JoyfulSoul: 6:18pm On Jul 28 |
Truthseeker10:I will answer you but you need to answer first as I have been answering you but you have been avoiding my question. So please answer mine first so we can move forward and I'll address your question. |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Truthseeker10: 6:23pm On Jul 28 |
JoyfulSoul:We cannot move forward without providing the evidence for your claim that involves me. You must come with clean hands before i answer your question since you made a claim that involves me. You claimed that we've both offered interpretation of Hebrews 6. Kindly provide the evidence to prove that the statement is true. Your next response without the evidence of your claim would prove that you are not sincere and that you are an Hypocrite and that would result in a BLOCK from me. |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by JoyfulSoul: 7:06pm On Jul 28 |
Truthseeker10:Wow. Unfortunately, this response shows that you are no longer willing to have a sincere discussion about the biblical text. Nevertheless, I will answer your question, even though you repeatedly declined to answer mine and have now accused me of hypocrisy. The evidence that we have offered different interpretations of Hebrews 6 is found throughout this discussion. My interpretation is that Hebrews 6:4–6 describes people who experienced profound spiritual privileges within the covenant community but were not genuinely regenerate. From your repeated objections to that interpretation, and from your insistence that the descriptions must refer to genuine believers, it is reasonable to conclude that you understand the passage differently. That is all I meant by saying we had offered different interpretations. There was nothing dishonest or hypocritical about that statement. The question you repeatedly avoided was important because it tests the consistency of your interpretation. If Hebrews 6:4–6 refers to genuinely saved Christians who subsequently lose their salvation, then you must also account for the writer’s statement that it is impossible to renew them again to repentance. That does not merely say that they sinned, backslid or temporarily struggled with unbelief. It describes a decisive apostasy from Christ and says that restoration is impossible. Therefore, the passage cannot simply be used to teach that Christians lose salvation whenever they sin or fail. No professing Christian is sinlessly perfect. As 1 John 1:8 says: “If we claim to be without sin, we deceive ourselves and the truth is not in us.” I am sure that, during the course of this discussion, both of us may have spoken or responded imperfectly. That is very different from the deliberate and final rejection of Christ described in Hebrews 6. I am not interested in continuing a discussion based on threats, accusations and attempts to catch one another out. Biblical exegesis requires humility, patience and a willingness to allow the immediate context and the whole of Scripture to shape our conclusions. I will therefore leave you to reconsider the passage carefully. Rather than arguing around the difficult parts of the text, examine the author’s full argument and allow Scripture to interpret Scripture. A genuine truth seeker should be willing not only to question another person’s interpretation, but also to submit his own interpretation to the same scrutiny. |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Truthseeker10: 7:59pm On Jul 28 |
JoyfulSoul:Kindly attach a screenshot evidence of your acclaimed objection or interpretation that I made in this discussion before I block you. |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Dtruthspeaker: 11:05am On Jul 30 |
CALCULUS16:So karma just comes on its own abi? Plus what is the purpose of karma? Boy you are confused |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by MiddleDimension: 2:17pm On Jul 31 |
tekzone:If your position is true, what then is the message you propose that Jesus was trying to pass across when he said ''he who sets his hands on the plough and looks back is not fit for the kingdom''? |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Truthseeker10: 6:22pm On Jul 31 |
tekzone:So can a "new creature" sin? |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by CALCULUS16: 9:47am On Aug 08 |
Dtruthspeaker:Keep believing your hell and heaven... Karma isn't punishment, it's the reward for your deed on earth.. Your comment shows you still need to grow up. If your kind of person will be more in your heaven, it will be full of rude people |
| Re: If A Person Is Saved, Is He Or She Forever Saved? by Dtruthspeaker: 10:47am On Aug 08 |
CALCULUS16:See yourself, you say its "reward for your deed", whereas hell is the reward people get for their bad acts, so isn't it clear that you are confused? What is rude in clearing out a person's confusion? |
Why Once Saved Always Saved Is Not A License To Sin • "Once Saved, Forever Saved": Wrong And Unscriptural! • If You Were Born Into A Christian Home, You Are Forever Saved, Except • 2 • 3 • 4
Why Do We Serve The God Of Our Oppressors? • These Links Can Change Your Life Forever • Surprising Things You Should Know Or Want To Share About The Bible.