Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares - Investment - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Investment › Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares (3966 Views)
| Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by lawani(op): 4:35pm On Aug 02 |
Effects of a public company buying back it's shares. Microsoft Inc and Apple Inc as examples The effect of a public company buying back it's shares is reflected in the price of the shares and hence the market valuation of the company. Like with any other thing being traded, the higher the demand, the higher the price will be. Therefore the price of one unit of any company will be higher if the board is doing a share buyback. By how much it will be higher than it should be will be determined by how aggressive the share buy back is amongst other factors. Therefore the market value of a company will always be higher than it should be when the company board is doing a share buy back or a share mop up. It may be by 5, 10, 20 percent and etc. The exact margin of increase or inflation in this case will depend on the level of aggression of the buy back or mop up. The increase in valuation of the company that it will cause is inflationary as any unwarranted growth is. However, the actual or legitimate aim of the board of any company should be to increase its market share and the evidence for this is not in the market valuation of the company. It is in revenue. A market share growth or even an aggregate growth can only manifest via a revenue growth. If we now compare Apple Inc that does share buy backs and Microsoft Inc that does not do share buy backs, we will discover that Microsoft Inc has increased it's revenue overtime more than Apple Inc despite not ploughing back it's profits into share buy backs or shares mop ups like Apple Inc. Apple Inc is however more valuable on paper. No one can argue against the fact that no matter their valuation on paper, Microsoft Inc in reality is more valuable than Apple Inc if it pays out more dividends over twenty years than Apple Inc. Conclusion Share buy backs or share mop ups creates an opportunistic market valuation for public corporations while corporations whose board do not do it have valuations that is more aligned with an ideal market. My definitions of Opportunistic and ideal markets are discussed in an unsolicited Economics paper I sent to the university of St Petersburg in Russia years ago. Recommendation A public company should ideally share all it's profits to it's shareholders regularly and not be using it to increase the demand for its own shares thereby increasing it's market valuation because any increase in the valuation of a company not tied clearly to more productivity and more revenue is inflationary. Inflationary growth should not be the standard. References List of US companies by market capitalization https://www.getchip.uk/knowledge-hub/biggest-companies-in-the-usa-by-market-cap
|
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by Dowhatisright: 11:02am On Aug 03 |
FTC. Vote for Character and competence... AAA |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by ceejay80s(m): 11:02am On Aug 03 |
Since tinubu name wasnt mentioned on headline, i have nothing to say |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by Kingpele(m): 11:04am On Aug 03 |
U are right whenever a company is buying back their shares it could be they're introducing new innovations that could attract more investors |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by Kingpele(m): 11:04am On Aug 03 |
U are right whenever a company is buying back their shares it could be they're introducing new innovations that could attract more investors...certainly |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by ppogba: 11:05am On Aug 03 |
I remember the first time the issue of an organization buying back its own share became prominent first in Nigeria during the era of HAKEEM BELO- OSAGIE as chairman of UBA then. Corporate gbajue na soldier come, soldier go. |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by skydancer: 11:05am On Aug 03 |
Many people don't know Apple would not exist today if not for Microsoft that rescued them when they almost went bankrupt. Apple is still riding on the foundation it built years ago by building its own ecosystem end to end but with AI that foundation has become shaky and NVIDIA or OpenAI may eventually take over. |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by NaijaHelper1(m): 11:09am On Aug 03 |
It's not as black and white as you make it sound Organic revenue growth like Microsoft and synthetic ones like Apple are both strategies in the same playbook. It depends on your market position and needs. A company like Apple is operating in a highly saturated market with heavy competition from China, and South Korea for it's core value proposition being mobile gadgets. It's not the same for Microsoft that has just three other serious competitors in the whe world for it's core product. Combined with the fact that Apple has grown so big that revenue growth that'll make another company barely moves the lever for their books, you'll see why it's important for them to prop up their shares while waiting for the next big tech revolution that'll blow people away and restore organic growth. |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by epainos: 11:10am On Aug 03*. Modified: 11:43am On Aug 03 |
skydancer:Its not that they may, but they will. Apple died with Job Steve. This is the truth. And its not just the Microsoft thing that brought Apple back, but the return of Job Steve. It is very likely that Apple would have held patents and created a monopoly in AI if Job was alive. He was an early adopter. He shipped new things faster than anyone. He detected gems first too. The man lived in gems inside research papers. He was a good scout. He provided solutions with hidden and abandoned gems. It was hard for Samsung to catch up with him. But after he died, that was it. His death even held us back a bit. This is the truth. But it paved way for the likes of Elon Musk, Sam Altman, and Jensen Huang. |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by hucknall: 11:18am On Aug 03 |
comment reserved 5 more characters needed |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by hucknall: 11:19am On Aug 03 |
To break this down into very simple terms using a market analogy: Imagine two bus owners (Apple and Microsoft) running transport businesses. 1. Apple's Strategy (Share Buybacks): Apple takes a lot of its daily profit and uses it to buy back its own buses from the road. Because there are now fewer buses available for people to buy or rent, the price of each remaining bus goes up on paper. It looks more expensive and valuable, but the actual number of passengers they carry or trips they make hasn't automatically grown just from buying back buses. The author calls this an "inflationary" or artificial boost in price. 2. Microsoft's Strategy (Organic Growth): Microsoft takes its profits and invests them directly into building better terminals, upgrading engines, and expanding routes to get more passengers (revenue growth). Even though they don't spend as much time buying back their own buses, their actual business and earnings grow stronger and more real over time. Buying back your own shares inflates your price on paper like a gimmick, whereas truly growing your revenue and sales is the real measure of business success |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by Taich(m): 11:51am On Aug 03 |
lawani:In summary, buy companies that their growth is determined by their revenue and profits and not some financial engineered share price. |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by hammedroyabat(m): 12:33pm On Aug 03 |
Then the Burst on Apple is imminent. Boom boom Burst |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by Yampotatocarrot(m): 1:46pm On Aug 03 |
hucknall:Damnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn you're good... Na this explanation make me understand all the epistle wey OP write |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by lawani(op): 2:02pm On Aug 03 |
Taich:Determined by regular dividends payout not mere profits used for share buy backs. The recommendation is that public companies should be compelled to always pay dividends |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by lawani(op): 2:06pm On Aug 03 |
Kingpele:The way to bring in more public funds is via an IPO |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by lawani(op): 2:13pm On Aug 03*. Modified: 2:31pm On Aug 03 |
NaijaHelper1:I did not say Apple Inc isn't doing well but their market valuation will not be that high if not for their share buy backs and the same is true for Meta, Tesla and etc. Those stocks are up to three times higher than they should be by NYSE standards if you compare them with Microsoft and judge by dividends payout though you can't judge by only that |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by safetyboot: 4:12pm On Aug 03 |
It's an indication that the shares value would appreciate very well. |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by commoditiesnig(m): 4:12pm On Aug 03 |
Informative piece.. I’ve always wondered why some companies buy back their shares. |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by safetyboot: 4:15pm On Aug 03 |
A sign that the stock will perform well |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by sacajawea(m): 5:49pm On Aug 03 |
ppogba:What year? Hakeem Bello Osagie...? what year, years are you speaking of? |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by Oba1ni(m): 5:51pm On Aug 03 |
ADC is the goal. 8 more characters needed Dowhatisright: |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by ppogba: 5:55pm On Aug 03 |
sacajawea:2002 2003 circa. Want to bring it on? |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by sacajawea(m): 5:58pm On Aug 03 |
ppogba:Was he not head in the late 80s, 90s? Not early 2000s |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by ppogba: 6:06pm On Aug 03 |
sacajawea:OSAGIE was no where near UBA in the 80s and 90s. As at then, Kuforiji Olubi was UBA Chairman. Osagie was Chairman even till 2003- 04 before the " highjack" from him by the wolves. I can say will all certainty he was Chairman at least between 97- 2003,4. KINDLY NOTE, I DO NOT CONSULT GOOGLE. |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by Vifx: 5:29am On Aug 04 |
epainos:If Steve Jobs was that powerful, we'd have to rewrite history and call him the patron saint of every tech company. 🤣 Apple didn't die with Jobs. It stopped surprising people as often. There's a difference. And Musk, Sam Altman, and Jensen Huang didn't become who they are because Jobs died they built on decades of research, timing, and execution. Great men leave big shoes, not a frozen industry. |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by CrownedPhoenix: 5:34am On Aug 04 |
Yampotatocarrot:If you didn't understand what the OP wrote then how did you know this explanation you praised is correct? At topic, classic Nigerian example is MTN and Airtel. |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by Taich(m): 6:12am On Aug 05 |
lawani:. But they don’t always do that. E.g UBA said they used their profit to pay off debt which has many shareholders fuming. |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by gogogreatnick: 10:05am On Aug 10*. Modified: 11:36am On Aug 13 |
Your buyback critique makes sense, but dividends aren’t the only honest way to return value. Apple’s buybacks helped when cash piled up faster than good reinvestment ideas. Still, you’re right that paper growth can fool people. For checking real value against price, I use IntrinsicAlpha.com, which gives clear evidence-based valuations. It’s helped me avoid overpaying for hype and focus on actual earnings strength. |
| Re: Microsoft Inc & Apple Inc: Effects Of A Public Company Buying Back It's Shares by lawani(op): 10:26am On Aug 10 |
gogogreatnick:The company that generates the most income for the shareholders is the best company or what is your definition of a good company? One whose shareholders gain nothing until they lose ownership? |
Nigerian Stock Exchange Completes Conversion To Public Company (PLC) • The Possible Effects Of Cryptocurrency Banning In Nigeria • The Effects Of Online Betting On Nigerian Youths • 2 • 3 • 4
Cost $3k But Here For FREE (change Your Forex Life) • My Friend Was Just Scammed With Fake Bitcoin • Is This Legitimate? Text From Mtn And Mansard Insurance- Life Insurance