Why Do Nigerians Lack Respect Across All Cultures? - Culture - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Culture › Why Do Nigerians Lack Respect Across All Cultures? (263 Views)
| Why Do Nigerians Lack Respect Across All Cultures? by Fridud234(op): 4:12pm On Aug 09 |
**Why Does Respect Seem So Complicated Across Nigerian Cultures?** One thing I’ve been thinking about lately is the way we understand and show **respect in Nigeria**. We often say Nigerians are respectful people, but sometimes it feels like our definition of respect depends heavily on where you come from, your age, your gender, your class in the society, and even the language you speak. Take Yoruba culture, for example. Traditionally, girls may be expected to kneel when greeting elders, while boys are expected to prostrate. There are also terms like *Aunty*, *Uncle*, *Boda* and *Sister* that are used to acknowledge age or seniority. But here is where I sometimes find it confusing: **how exactly are you supposed to know who is older than you?** You meet someone who looks your age, or even younger, and suddenly you're wondering whether you should call them *Aunty* or simply use their name. You don't want to appear disrespectful, but you also don't want to start calling everyone *Aunty* and *Boda* simply because they look slightly older. Then you have Igbo culture, where people may not necessarily use *Aunty* and *Boda* in the same way. Yet, of course, there are still strong expectations around respecting elders and people in positions of authority. And when those expectations aren't followed, it can equally be interpreted as disrespect. Then look at some Western cultures. Someone can be significantly older than you and you may simply call them by their first name. Yet that doesn't automatically mean you don't respect them. Respect can be shown through your behaviour, your words, consideration, and how you treat the person. So this got me wondering: **Have Nigerians sometimes confused respect with obedience, fear, age hierarchy, or traditional gestures?** Is someone automatically disrespectful because they didn't kneel or prostrate? Is calling an older person by their first name necessarily disrespectful? And why do we sometimes demand respect based on age even when we haven't necessarily shown the younger person any respect ourselves? Personally, I think there is a difference between **respecting someone and performing respect**. You can kneel, prostrate and call someone *Aunty*, while secretly having no respect for them whatsoever. On the other hand, someone can call you by your first name and still treat you with genuine courtesy, consideration and dignity. Maybe the bigger question isn't *“Why don't young Nigerians respect elders anymore?”* but rather: **“What should respect actually look like in modern Nigeria?”** And should there be one standard of respect across Nigeria, or should every culture be allowed to maintain its own traditions? I'd genuinely like to hear different perspectives, especially from Yoruba, Igbo, Hausa and other Nigerian cultures. **What does respect mean in your culture, and where do you draw the line between respect and unnecessary hierarchy?** |
| Re: Why Do Nigerians Lack Respect Across All Cultures? by lawani(m): 7:26pm On Aug 10*. Modified: 5:37am On Aug 14 |
Fridud234:. With Yoruba there is automatic and excessive respect for old age and also for seniority of any kind. You use a special pronoun like in French to address someone that outranks you and if you meet a stranger you can both use it for each other. The normal pronoun is for juniors or contemporaries that you grew up with. You don't call anyone that outranks you by their real names. You use an alias. Nowadays you can add something like Bro, Uncle, Aunty, Sister etc. Even if they are your employee and they senior you by age, you are still expected to do this. A married woman is junior to anyone that was married into her husband's family before her and also junior to every child born before she married into the family and she can't call them by their real names even if the person is a baby. However if they are junior to her in age, they will also respect her in return. As a man, You prostrate flat to greet your parents and those who rank as your parents. As a woman you go down on your two knees. I think that is everything about the Yoruba respect culture. |
| Re: Why Do Nigerians Lack Respect Across All Cultures? by domeinhorn(m): 2:11am On Aug 14 |
Interesting thread, and I'll answer as an outsider with one relevant qualification: I speak six languages, and the thing that struck me hardest when learning them is that some languages make it impossible to speak without declaring a relationship, while others let you avoid it entirely. In French I must choose tu or vous before I can say anything at all. German has du and Sie the same way. English has neither, which is why an American can call his professor "Bob" without it meaning what it would mean elsewhere. Vietnamese goes further than any of them: there is no neutral "you", so you must address someone as older brother, younger sister, uncle, and so on. You literally cannot form a sentence without placing yourself relative to the other person. Yoruba's Aunty, Boda and the greeting postures work on that same logic. Which is why your question about not knowing someone's age is not a small awkwardness, it's a structural feature of every language built this way. Vietnamese speakers have exactly this problem and solve it with a rule I find rather elegant: when uncertain, guess in the direction that flatters, then let the person correct you. Being called older than you are is a mild compliment in a seniority system; being called younger is the insult. So err upward. On your main question, I think you've answered it yourself and correctly. Performing respect and holding it are different things, and every culture with elaborate respect forms produces people fluent in the performance who feel nothing. But the reverse trap is real too, and English speakers fall into it constantly: dropping the forms doesn't automatically produce genuine respect, it just removes the visible test. What you get is not a more sincere society, but one where you cannot tell, which has its own costs. The honest answer is probably that forms are cheap and useful, like a handshake, and the mistake is treating them as evidence of anything more than manners. Judge the treatment, keep the forms. |
| Re: Why Do Nigerians Lack Respect Across All Cultures? by Fridud234(op): 8:01pm On Aug 17 |
lawani:I honestly do not want to dabble into your archaic belief system or your diversion into “married women,” because that has taken my conversation into an entirely different topic — one that, frankly, amounts to the absolute degradation and subjugation of women. Notice how your patriarchal mindset did not allow you to stay focused on the actual subject of my post: **what respect means and where the line is between respect and unnecessary hierarchy.** Instead, you diverted the conversation to the position of a married woman in her husband’s family, including the idea that she is expected to submit to people based on when they entered the family, even when those people may be children. And what is particularly telling is that you mentioned absolutely **nothing** about a married man being expected to assume a similarly subordinate position in his wife’s family. That is exactly the kind of gendered hierarchy I was questioning in the first place. My post was about whether respect should be based on genuine dignity, courtesy and mutual consideration, or whether it should be enforced through age, seniority, obedience and social hierarchy. So bringing in rules about how a married woman must position herself in her husband’s family does not answer my question. If anything, it illustrates my point about how certain traditional structures can turn “respect” into **subjugation**, particularly when applied disproportionately to women. You have explained the Yoruba hierarchy, and that's fine. But explaining a tradition does not automatically make that tradition immune from criticism or examination. My question remains: **when does respect stop being respect and become unnecessary hierarchy and subjugation?** |
| Re: Why Do Nigerians Lack Respect Across All Cultures? by Fridud234(op): 8:38pm On Aug 17*. Modified: 9:51pm On Aug 17 |
domeinhorn:Domeinhorn, I find your response very thoughtful, and I understand your perspective perfectly, especially because I haven't been living in Nigeria for a while and I now have the opportunity to look at some of these things from a little distance. However, as someone who actually grew up in Nigeria and experienced the reality of these cultural expectations firsthand, my perspective is also shaped by what I went through. I grew up stressed out by the absolute disrespect that can exist in everyday Nigerian interactions, the unrest and constant tension, and the unending chaos that can come from someone disrespecting you, damaging your entire day, sometimes for absolutely no reason other than the perception that they are somehow better than you, older than you, or just some sort of reason. And that brings me to the classism aspect of it. Sometimes what is presented as “respect” is really about making someone else feel inferior because of their age, social class, position, wealth, family background or perceived status. You can literally encounter someone who believes they are entitled to speak to you anyhow simply because they believe they rank above you in some way. Then there is the compulsory subjugation that can come with marriage traditions, particularly for women, the endless “ẹ” and “o,” and all these little expectations that can become sources of unnecessary conflict and strife between people and families. To correlate that, is the statement made by @ “Lawani” above “A married woman is junior to anyone that was married into her husband's family before her and also junior to every child born before she married into the family and she can't call them by their real names even if the person is a baby. However if they are junior to her in age, they will also respect her in return”. —This right here is the mentality of an average Nigerian male. So while I appreciate your argument that forms of respect can function as social tools, I think there is another side to this that someone who hasn't spent significant time living within the Nigerian environment may not fully understand. A culture existing for centuries does not automatically mean every aspect of it remains valid or beneficial today. Traditions should be allowed to evolve, and we should be able to revisit, question and assess them without being accused of disrespecting the culture itself. I think you would understand this perspective even more if you spent 1–2 years actually living in Nigeria, particularly within Yoruba communities, and experienced these expectations not as an interesting linguistic or anthropological concept, but as something that affects your everyday life and interactions. For me, that's the distinction. **It is very easy to appreciate a cultural system intellectually when you're observing it from the outside. Living under the system is a completely different experience.** Lastly, I actually agree with your point that forms of respect can be useful and that removing them doesn't automatically make people more respectful. But where I differ is in the idea that we should simply “judge the treatment, keep the forms.” My concern is that some of these forms are not always harmless expressions of manners. In the Nigerian context, some have become mechanisms for enforcing hierarchy, obedience and even subjugation. Once a form becomes compulsory and refusing to perform it is itself considered disrespectful, I think we have to question what exactly we are preserving. Perhaps the better approach is: keep the forms that genuinely promote courtesy and social cohesion, but be willing to discard or modify forms that have become vehicles for humiliation, entitlement or unnecessary hierarchy. |
| Re: Why Do Nigerians Lack Respect Across All Cultures? by lawani(m): 1:38am On Aug 18*. Modified: 4:59am On Aug 18 |
Fridud234:Your speech is a ramble. I only pointed out what occurs among the Yoruba. If you speak Yoruba and you step outside that norm you will be looked upon as an idiot that lacks home training. That is the issue and I don't support your idea that all cultures should be the same. I also don't see anything wrong with what obtains among the Yoruba as it is just their culture while others have theirs And of course no matter how a culture is fashioned it will not stop bad people from existing. Then the Yoruba culture isn't patriarchal as such. A child belongs to both the father's compound and the mother's compound. He or she is accepted in both but pre eminence is given to the father's compound. However if you have a right to a title through your mother you can contest for it which means you have transferred your allegiance there. Married women are however considered to have joined the family of their husband and anyone that joined before them rank as their senior including wives of their husband's male relatives that got married before them and children born before they were married. However the society itself does not stop women from becoming anything while they also have things that are left for them without any man contesting it with them like market leadership and etc. The system isn't patriarchy as you want to brand it. In Ibadan, Efunsetan Aniwura was the most powerful individual in the nineteenth century with probably the biggest household and she was a woman. Madam Tinubu was the richest in Lagos too and also a woman. A number of Ijesa monarchs, one Ife monarch and one Oyo monarch etc were women and it is nowadays that the society is becoming more patriarchal not the olden days. |
| Re: Why Do Nigerians Lack Respect Across All Cultures? by laiperi: 3:31pm On Aug 20 |
OP, you asked question pretending you want to learn but refuses to. Many languages, cultures and norms have been pointed to you but still refused. NdiIgbo say though age is respected, achievement is revered. You missed your target of criticism by a wide margin. The English and American many of you adhere to as examples of modern cultures compared to "archaic" culture is misplaced. Sometimes you may call your colleagues or senior colleagues by their first name Bob. Any colleague or bosses above that, you show utmost respect if you want to keep your job. This notion of Igbo have no king also has a limit. They have constituted authorities very few dare disrespect. Take some learning you have been given here and stop fidgeting around. |
| Re: Why Do Nigerians Lack Respect Across All Cultures? by lindqvistbergst(m): 8:46pm On Oct 02 |
lawani:They have none, not any respect at all. You think you can run around telling everyone to get on their gut on the floor for you. You like to lord over everyone. Age does not mean you get to treat people like dogs. You think? Do you hear yourself? You think the entire world and everyone in it revolves around you. You will destroy lives over it. And plenty of times those people have deleted others over it. |
| Re: Why Do Nigerians Lack Respect Across All Cultures? by lawani(m): 9:08pm On Oct 02 |
lindqvistbergst:It is among themselves. They never expect non members to align and even they themselves may not align when not in the right settings. There is a proverb Kaka ka dobale fun Gambari ka roju ka ku. meaning 'Rather than prostrate for a Hausa man it is better to brace up and die!'. This would be because the Hausa themselves don't do such. |
| Re: Why Do Nigerians Lack Respect Across All Cultures? by lindqvistbergst(m): 11:20pm On Oct 02 |
lawani:Are you seriously saying that? Nearly all Nigerians from all tribes FORCE THEIR DAMN CULTURES ONTO EVERYONE. and try to export it out of the country. Its one reason why south Africans got fed up with you. |
Respect The Olubadan Stool Or Face Consequences - Ibadan Stakeholders To Alaafin • Why Do Nigerians Bear English Words As Names • Abdulfatai Coker: Yoruba Monarchs In North Not Accorded Respect • 2 • 3 • 4
Accelerationism-an Ideology Of Social Theory • Trade Nigeria • CAC Registrations