The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. - Politics - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. (6849 Views)
| The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by chicfarmer(op): 9:11am On Aug 26 |
I fully support a return of fuel subsidy to Nigeria. Here is how I'll explain it to a primary six pupil. If you don't understand this, then our politicians will just keep sharing our wealth amongst themselves while we wallow in poverty. Imagine that you had a big Mango tree in your compound and that tree produced much mangoes. You decide to pluck and sell the mangoes but you have kids and family members living with you, you'll definitely put some aside for your household consumption and then take the rest to the market for sale. In the same way, Nigeria produces about 2m barrels per day of crude. Government should remove say 500,000 barrels for local refining and consumption and sell that to dangote at 50% while they export the remaining 1.5m barrels at international prices for foreign exchange. Dangote then refines the 500,000 barrels set aside for local consumption and then sells/distributes it locally at 50% of the current prices of petrol and other products derived therefrom. Simple. Anybody telling you that this model is not possible is simply trying to deceive you so that they can continue sharing and chopping our money. The only thing the common man benefits from Nigerian government is subsidy. A mother that harvests her mangoes and takes everything to the market without setting some aside for her children is a bad mother. As oil producers, we must derive direct benefits from our resources. Anything Short of this is corruption and grand deception. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by Mynd44(mod): 11:05am On Aug 26 |
The first flaw in your argument is thinking Nigeria owns the oil it drills. The crude oil are joint venture businesses with oil companies and they will not be interested in giving their own when they can sell at international price |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by Mattswaggz: 11:06am On Aug 26*. Modified: 11:28am On Aug 26 |
I've said it here countless times that fuel subsidy is by far one of the only reasonable things Nigerians benefits from this government......most Nigerians produce their own electricity, water, housing etc...some even contribute to build their local roads and contribute to repair government stuffs like transformers when they get spoilt...some even provide their own security by themselves.....and yet they still pay different form of taxes daily without seeing the benefits of all the taxes they are paying....same way we aren't seeing the the effects of the monies they claimed to save from the subsidy removal. Even countries like Iran that have been living under sanctions with their huge population subsidize fuel for their citizens so don't even bring the population excuse here. After all the sweet talks of how removing subsidy will take the country to greater heights all we can see now is increased debts ,increased insecurity, lower purchasing power, inflation etc.....so what exactly was the point of removing the subsidy.....IF WE CAN'T SEE THE GAINS THEN BRING IT BACK..SIMPlE since it doesn't make any difference....at least the citizens can see and feel the effects of subsidy in their lives and the country at large but since the subsidy has been removed....things have gotten worse for the citizens instead of better and on the flip side, the leaders are living large. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by Mattswaggz: 11:07am On Aug 26 |
Mynd44:Why can't Nigeria own it then.....why make deals that won't favor your own growth and development and prioritize the interest and welfare of your citizens?. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by Zionmdde: 11:08am On Aug 26 |
The problem is not subsidy removal The problem is that masses are now paying for the fattening of politicians' pockets. Reason why it is very easy for governors and LGA chairmen to rather threaten Voters than see tinubu defeated No subsidy No defending Naira Yet we are borrowing more than any other government Ask questions now, they will tell you coastal highway and sokoto badagry GEJ only partially removed subsidy and everybody felt it. But this regime, Evil!!!! |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by Gotocourt: 11:08am On Aug 26 |
chicfarmer:Seems like you are confused in your submission. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by lordm(m): 11:08am On Aug 26 |
You have no idea how crude oil ownership is. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by Musty112: 11:09am On Aug 26 |
The first comment highlight the first problem. The second problem is that you assume that the crude oil and its exploration comes about at zero cost. Like from the ground with magic/air into the barrel. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by Mynd44(mod): 11:09am On Aug 26 |
Mattswaggz:We have oil in the ground, we don't have the tech, machinery and investments to bring them out. So Mobil, shell, Chevron comes to invest billions to drill for oil and then pay taxes and share the profits with us. So the oil doesn't belong to the government, what belongs to the government is the shares NNPC have, taxes, royalties etc. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by callthefred: 11:09am On Aug 26 |
chicfarmer:Where will govt get the 500k bbls to give Dangote? We produce 1.6m bbls daily, govt is entitled to about 1m bbls and we've collect like advance money from like half so we have like 500k left. If that means, it means we won't have money to share again. The koko is govt must do more to bring competition to the industry that's the only organic solution that is sustainable. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by prinsam30: 11:10am On Aug 26 |
Subsidy or no subsidy people wey go share money go still share |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by Gotocourt: 11:10am On Aug 26 |
Dollar should be subsidised 💯 |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by yemre: 11:10am On Aug 26 |
Mynd44:He lacks the basic knowledge of how the whole thing works |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by callthefred: 11:11am On Aug 26 |
Mattswaggz:It's simple. Nigeria doesn't have the expertise and the cash to invest in exploration. Imagine it would cost us another $20b in investment to double our oil production. Where do we get the $20b? |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by Mynd44(mod): 11:12am On Aug 26 |
callthefred:$20billion will only increase by about 400k |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by helinues: 11:13am On Aug 26 |
You people are on your own. How developed was Nigeria when we were still paying the fuel subsidy? The same Nigeria that the governors and FG were borrowing to pay ordinary salary. Forward ever, backward never |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by ElevationD: 11:13am On Aug 26*. Modified: 1:32pm On Aug 26 |
Mynd44:Who owns the oil? When partnership agreements are reached, how can you not insert clauses that favor you? How are the middle east nations able the run their countries with ease and some citizens not even paying taxes? The same foreign companies operate in Saudi Arabia and the entire Middle East. There is subsidy on petrol in Saudi Arabia and the citizens do not pay personal income tax. How do they run their nation successfully, making life better for their citizens? Yes, you may take off subsidy, but you must ensure that life is better for the citizens in the end. Unfortunately your party makes the rich get richer and the poor depend on handouts daily. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by AndroBlaze: 11:15am On Aug 26*. Modified: 11:32am On Aug 26 |
chicfarmer:This is a primary 6 explanation back to you: No one is saying that introducing subsidy is not possible, the main question you should be asking yourself is what would be the benefit of re-introducing it now? What will Nigerians gain? If you still don't understand, we don't eat or drink fuel. Fuel is not a necessity and it is what it does to other prices we should be talking about. So again to simplify, if fuel goes back to N200 today: Transport fares will reduce a bit but not even come close to where they were before subsidy. Food prices will reduce only slightly. Rent and school fees will not reduce...thus those who provide services (mechanics, carpenters, labourers etc) will not reduce their fees. NEPA will also not reduce, in fact they will definitely remove the subsidy on that. Also wages might fall, as some unscrupulous employers will use the fact that transport is lower to reduce the transport component of salaries. Cement and other building product prices will remain high. So the only people that will gain are those who drive around everyday to work and more importantly those who will feast on the corruption that subsidies encourage ( this is a basic fact in economics everywhere in the world, not just Nigeria). So Mr Mango tree, I hope this is simple enough for you to understand logically, why those who are educated and experienced are wondering what spirit has come over Atiku. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by jmoore(m): 11:15am On Aug 26 |
Please delete this. Who told you that all crude oil belongs to NNPC? |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by helinues: 11:15am On Aug 26 |
People didn't know that the Benin coup, the Nigeria subsidy removal was part of what influenced it. The FG was busy paying ghost subsidy on fuel that don't make it back to Nigeria. How come the daily consumption of fuel reduced after the subsidy was removed? That's to tell you it has been mostly ghost payment to the oil marketers |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by Mattswaggz: 11:15am On Aug 26 |
Mynd44:And even using it to collect loans in advance.....if this keeps up then the country will still be going backwards regardless of the presence of fuel subsidy or not....so why make fuel subsidy the culprit while turning a blind eye to the years of bad governance even up till now?. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by JoshTim: 11:15am On Aug 26 |
Alot of flaws... Where do you put: 1. debt settlement in oil 2. Hoarding, export and sale of subsidized fuel outside the country? 3. How do you police the border and corrupt custom and immigration officials. 4. How do you work out the modalities around number of units subsidised and also being able to remove corruption....number of units consumed Vs total subsidy payments. 5. How do you generate enough revenue to pay off the subsidies....presently in the power sector, subsidy debts are accumulated on a monthly basis These are the problems with the old system. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by nairalanda1(m): 11:16am On Aug 26 |
chicfarmer:The problem with your analogy is that Dangote selliing fuel at 50% of the current prices of petrol means he is going to lose money, and thus not be able to run his refinery properly Also, a government that is refuing to pay electricity subsidy in full, and is even severely underpaying the subsidy, is suddenly going to find money to pay 50% of dangote cost? Plus if crude oil prices rise, the cost of that 50% of monies not paid to dangote is going to rise. Honestly, this is the best argument I have seen against subsidy, and it is also the most flawed way of explaining subsidy to a primary school student. HERE IS A BETTER WAY TO EXPLAIN SUBSIDY USING YOUR MANGO TREE ANALOGY You pluck mangoes, and you take 75% of your mangoes to market, while you keep 25% of your mangoes at home for consumption. Since those 25% of mangoes are not making any money, the way you sell your 75% mangoes must make back the money spent on growing them, plus the money spent on growing the 25% that you did not sell Government then comes in, says that you are charging too much for mangoes, and offers to pay you 50% of the price at which you are selling the mangoes , while you sell the mangoes at half price, and pays you the difference...that is the subsidy. But because government is struggling to get revenues for subsidy payments due to low tax to gdp and reliance on oil, the subsidy payments do not come as and when due MEANING YOU LOSE MONEY ON SELLING YOUR MANGOES...so thus you sell them on the black market to make back the cost of growing all your mangoes. Nigerians self. The explanatuion is flawed, and the analogy is flawed. The mangoes that you are keeping back ARE NOT MAKING ANY MONEY...FOR EFF'S SAKE...unless you are selling mangoes to your kids at half the price. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by chicfarmer(op): 11:17am On Aug 26 |
callthefred:Those who collected loans with our oil should account for the loans. There must be consequences for actions. Something is wrong somewhere if we're collecting loans and we're not seeing results. Again, a country that produces crude cannot, and should not, buy petrol at similar prices as other nations who do not. Let politicians who have mismanaged those loans go to jail otherwise this suffering would never end. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by trtola(m): 11:17am On Aug 26 |
Instead of saying he lacks basic knowledge of how it works, come up with your own argument in defence. That's what debates are for. My question to you is if Dubai, Saudi and Co lacks the basic understanding of how oil exploration works. Do your research and come back to debate yemre: |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by Mattswaggz: 11:17am On Aug 26 |
yemre:It isn't rocket science to know that the leaders do not prioritize the growth and development of the country.....the countries that have achieved such feats didn't have aliens as leaders. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by Mynd44(mod): 11:18am On Aug 26 |
ElevationD:Sauidi has 37 million people UAE has 12 million people, are you seeing the problem? |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by VeeVeeMyLuv(f): 11:19am On Aug 26 |
As usual you guys are making excuses and trying to justify the rabbish!!! 😞😥 I hope you guys are collecting billions for this? Otherwise ...pity |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by Love800(m): 11:19am On Aug 26 |
Wow. Thanks for dis eye opening. Mynd44: |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by chicfarmer(op): 11:20am On Aug 26 |
nairalanda1:Read my commentary again. We will sell to dangote at 50% of international oil prices. He will in turn give us refined products at 50% of what we're currently buying. He loses NOTHING. |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by Nwaokunkpara: 11:21am On Aug 26 |
It is as simple as this but Nigerians have been brainwashed by politicians into confusion that they no longer know what this subsidy is all about |
| Re: The Primary Six Pupil's Guide To Fuel Subsidy. by fmlala: 11:21am On Aug 26 |
chicfarmer:Nigeria economy and how things work in a situation like this is broader than this primary school analysis you are dishing out to the people. |
IGP Adamu Seeks N24.8bn To Fuel Vehicles, Motorcycles • Atiku Abubakar Reacts To Fuel Price Hike • PDP Asks Oshiomhole To Present Primary Six Certificate • 2 • 3 • 4
PDP Chairmanship: Adeniran Picks Form, Restates Commitment To Reposition The Par • Breaking: Ipob Releses Biafra Fundamental Principles And Policy • PDP Abandoned 116 Water Projects Before Leaving Office In 2015