₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,345,985 members, 8,520,526 topics. Date: Wednesday, 18 November 2026 at 12:24 AM

Toggle theme

Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra (3382 Views)

1 2 Reply (Go Down)

Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by treesun(op): 5:05pm On Sep 12
The Presidency has said that Atiku Abubakar’s plan to subsidise crude for local refineries failed when it implemented under former President Olusegun Obasanjo’s administration.

Otega Ogra, Senior Special Assistant to President Bola Tinubu on digital and new media, made the point while reacting to the proposal by the former vice-president for a production subsidy for local refineries.

Ogra wrote on X (Twitter): “Excuse me, sir. Nigeria already tried your production-subsidy to local refineries idea while you were Vice President. We know the shambolic results of that production subsidy. You know it too.”

Ogra said Warri refinery’s utilisation fell to 14.27 percent in 2003 and 9.1 percent in 2004, while Kaduna refinery recorded 15.96 percent and 26 percent, respectively.

He said Port Harcourt refinery’s utilisation also dropped from 60.73 percent in 2001 to 31.04 percent in 2004.

“Meanwhile, price of petrol more than tripled by 2004 and nearly quadrupled by the time you left office despite your production subsidy to local refiners.

“On October 9, 2003, your same administration cancelled the discount itself through Presidential directive PRES/158.

“President Obasanjo ordered NNPC to pay full international price for refinery crude. Your production subsidy was tried, failed and scrapped, with you as Vice President.

“So, before selling Nigerians this failed production subsidy policy again, answer one simple question.

“I know there are many Nigerians who were too young to know what was happening then. But if you may tell them, where is the evidence that it worked the first time?

“It’s still the same theory you practiced then, and we haven’t changed country yet.

“One thing we already have, are the failed results of that experiment, Alhaji.”
https://www.vanguardngr.com/2026/09/atikus-subsidy-plan-failed-under-obasanjo-presidency/

Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by AWONEYAN(m): 5:09pm On Sep 12
You guys are given this Atiku Subsidy undue attention.

It's DOA
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by Putinofrussia: 5:10pm On Sep 12
Over to you sir,baba Atiku. cheesy
Are you selling a failed subsidy methodology?
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by AMINDA: 5:23pm On Sep 12
AWONEYAN:
You guys are given this Atiku Subsidy undue attention.

It's DOA
Go outside and touch grass. If the presidency isn't getting the feelers from the streets on how the "Atiku Subsidy Plan" has penetrated the grassroots, they won't be releasing press statements after press statements. Even the staunchest APC-supporting data boy will not vote against their economic realities on election day. That doesn't mean they wouldn't earn their money from the paid gig. This is one of them below.

Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by emkz:
Most of Atiku's interventions and ambitions failed catastrophically.

His privatisation of government assets ended up ruining workers of NITEL and Nigerian Airways. It is Tinubu who is now paying their pensions.

In 2023, his presidential elections petitions failed. He went to Chicago to prove Tinubu never graduated. He failed again.


In 2026, he contracted a certan von Okeke Ikemefuna to bring FBI files on Tinubu. Ikemefuna has been failing to produce the files. Daily, he tweets on those he is reporting Tinubu too. With $1.2million, Ikemefuna has failed to give Atiku diplomatic immunity to enter America.

In his NYSC court case against Tinubu, Atiku is failing so badly that it is shameful. Here are AI-enhanced image of Tinubu's university certificate, and NYSC certificate. I also include the source documents. Atiku contends that the A in the university certificate is Ahmed and it is not Adekunle as contained in the NYSC certificate.

Dear Atiku, what exactly is wrong with you?

And yes, the subsidy plan Atiku designed failed. The refineries owned by government collapsed under Atiku and Obasanjo. If Atiku ever becomes president, he will fail.

NOTE: The AI version contains some errors. The main message is the readability of the original.

Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by Freshtruth(m): 6:26pm On Sep 12
Atiku please please be ruthless this time around pls step down for peter obi is the turn of the south pls let obi and tinubu rule a term a piecee
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by helinues: 6:27pm On Sep 12
Atiku is confused jare
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by helinues: 6:29pm On Sep 12
Freshtruth:
Atiku please please be ruthless this time around pls step down for peter obi is the turn of the south pls let obi and tinubu rule a term a piecee
Why should he step down for Obi? Is Obi no longer popular than both Atiku and Tinubu to defeat them on the ballot? Or perhaps Obi's popularity end online
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by micheal004: 6:36pm On Sep 12
These guys have been jittery since Atiku came up with this plan.
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by treesun(op): 1:41pm On Sep 13
Nlfpmod!
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by Kukutente23:
And has this subsidy removal experiment not failed?
Where are the refineries and jobs that you guys claimed will spring up from subsidy removal after 3 years in the wilderness

Pls before any zombie will quote me with Dangote refinery, note that Dangote refinery was licensed and fully constructed with subsidy still in place. In fact, it got subsidized dollars while the construction was ongoing
Even now, it's been getting import waivers upon import waivers from Mr Subsidy is gone

And the refineries they claimed they resuscitated with billions failed after subsidy removal. So APC should tell us another story
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by Nwaokunkpara: 2:42pm On Sep 13
What is too hard for the present administration to make our existing refineries to work and provide them with crude oil which will reduce the price of fuel and on the long run reduce the price of other goods and services?
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by nairalanda1(m): 2:42pm On Sep 13
Meanwhile tinubu and his people are running away from telling us that in 2012, they helped rally Nigerians to maintain the same subsidy that they are now defending with all their might.

When you confront them with that fact, they would say that people can change their mind...lol

So, why are they bashing atiku for changing his mind, while defending their hero for changing his mind?

Thanks in part to tinubu and buhari and the ojota people, our debt is high, and the degredation of our refineries continued...
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by Eba50: 2:44pm On Sep 13
Y not mention obasanjo name. Atiku na v.p.cowards
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by nairalanda1(m): 2:44pm On Sep 13
Nwaokunkpara:
What is too hard for the present administration to make our existing refineries to work and provide them with crude oil which will reduce the price of fuel and on the long run reduce the price of other goods and services?
You guys don't get it...those refineries are scrap.

Decades of subsidy killed them, because they were not making enough profit to make upgrades as and at when due.

Had there been no subsidy, they would have made profits to expand and upgrade when needed

All they are good for is scrap.

It is like asking why someone has not revived his old 1950 citroen car so that it can be driven on the road today.
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by Greenbirth: 2:46pm On Sep 13
Yes it failed but fuel was as cheap as water. One thing is certain. No matter how you defend bad thing,one day it must surely come to your door step,who ever that sees White and called it black must enter six feet where everything will be dark and will no more deceive any more.

Apc as a party is just like a movie called Yoruba Demon.
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by MEGAWATCH: 2:48pm On Sep 13
I will only believe this if it's coming from someone from a neutral point of view and not one of Tinubu's foot soldiers.



🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by anonimi: 2:48pm On Sep 13
AWONEYAN:
You guys are given this Atiku Subsidy undue attention.

It's DOA
Is it DOA because the master strategist of a-looter propaganda politics is still paying subsidy illegally to his Malta blending plant fuel importers?

Do you know why petrol is so expensive despite his illegal payment of subsidy to importers, in his continuing attempt to destroy Dangote’s PDP licensed private refinery?

Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by nairalanda1(m): 2:49pm On Sep 13
Greenbirth:
Yes it failed but fuel was as cheap as water. One thing is certain
And if you noticed...

Ogra said Warri refinery’s utilisation fell to 14.27 percent in 2003 and 9.1 percent in 2004, while Kaduna refinery recorded 15.96 percent and 26 percent, respectively.

He said Port Harcourt refinery’s utilisation also dropped from 60.73 percent in 2001 to 31.04 percent in 2004.
The refineries were degrading while there was a subsidy.

You are missing the problem...in 1994, tam on the refineries stopped and was not resumed till 2009. As a result the refineries started degrading. What you are seeing, even though that is not the intention of the Tinubu pr man, is a snapshot of the degradation of our refineries over time...because subsides meant they could not make a profit, and move forward.
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by iwaeda: 2:51pm On Sep 13
Fuel is N1450 today, please what is the money saved from subsidy removal. All oil producing countries subsidised for citizens. grin grin grin grin
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by anonimi: 2:52pm On Sep 13
Putinofrussia:
Over to you sir,baba Atiku. cheesy
Are you selling a failed subsidy methodology?
How is Tinubu subsidy removal a success if roads are worse than when PDP gave us cheap petrol and less debt burden?





What Tinubu and APC can’t destroy does not exist.
11 years of change and 3 years of reform with subsidy removal TWICE along with huge debt cum tax burden on people, why should we have roads worse than when PDP gave us cheap petrol and cheap dollars without piling up debt?


givedemwotowoto:
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by FSBoperator: 2:52pm On Sep 13
AMINDA:
Go outside and touch grass. If the presidency isn't getting the feelers from the streets on how the "Atiku Subsidy Plan" has penetrated the grassroots, they won't be releasing press statements after press statements. Even the staunchest APC-supporting data boy will not vote against their economic realities on election day. That doesn't mean they wouldn't earn their money from the paid gig. This is one of them below.
Atiku is dangling an unrealistic and an unfulfillable policy to the masses just to get them to vote him into office.

Atiku is so invested in his soothsayers that he pays to tell him he will be President one day .

How is he going to subsidize crude to local refineries that do not exist outside Dangote ?

Is he going to re establish the crude for refined products deal that saw to off shoring of refining Nigerian crude to foreign refineries and then placing waivers on importing the refined crude and then paying the subsidies on it all over again thereby creating the same corrupt ladden system that gulped trillions to personal accounts ?

Even Atiku knows he won't implement his subsidy regime under any guise

Subsidy is gone forever .

Tell your state governors to use the windfall from it which they are collecting via FAAC every month to subsidize education, health and agriculture.
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by Jayhome24: 2:56pm On Sep 13
Guys stop listening to atiku he is already in dementia level 3 only 2 level left for him to be taken to care home in Elele.

Ask him his almanjiri problem solving America University he claimed he built for almanjiri pls ask him how can almanjiri pay N5.8m per session and the Uni is for almanjiri? Ask him to first remove fees subsidy in his useless university and make tuition free for all student then let's see how far. Only a fool will listen to tiku.

Mr or Chief atiku pls where is our $600m you collected from selling our national assets and ran to Dubai, oga we need our money back.

Mr or Chief atiku pls where is the $16billion electrification fund which you are the committe chairman, this billions you stole soiled your relationship with your boss Obj, sir we need that money back and we will surely collect all back cus it's a national money not Adamawa money...
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by anonimi: 2:59pm On Sep 13
Nwaokunkpara:
What is too hard for the present administration to make our existing refineries to work and provide them with crude oil which will reduce the price of fuel and on the long run reduce the price of other goods and services?
The present administration CLAIMED that NNPC refineries have been operating since 2015, and one of them has been exporting fuel since December 2024.

Tinubu even tried to ridicule Obasanjo by inviting him to the refinery.

A-looter Propaganda Congress, APC is a band of evil people led by Satan in human form as Jagaban of Borgu.




https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dheYiWKegok?si=8AY-Ic6vVpJhjpDG
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by uhange: 3:02pm On Sep 13
Otega Ogra, we know you guys are the capitalist that are making life difficult for ordinary Nigerians because of your selfish and primordial interest. I ask you a simple question, even with your subsidy removal, how much is price of fuel today? 1500 Naira per liter, Cement 13k, what nonsense and foolish analysis are you giving us, with your failed president.
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by nairalanda1(m): 3:03pm On Sep 13
Jayhome24:
Guys stop listening to atiku he is already in dementia level 3 only 2 level left for him to be taken to care home in Elele.

Ask him his almanjiri problem solving America University he claimed he built for almanjiri pls ask him how can almanjiri pay N5.8m per session and the Uni is for almanjiri? Ask him to first remove fees subsidy in his useless university and make tuition free for all student then let's see how far. Only a fool will listen to tiku.

Mr or Chief atiku pls where is our $600m you collected from selling our national assets and ran to Dubai, oga we need our money back.

Mr or Chief atiku pls where is the $16billion electrification fund which you are the committe chairman, this billions you stole soiled your relationship with your boss Obj, sir we need that money back and we will surely collect all back cus it's a national money not Adamawa money...
You can bash atiku for many tings, but not for the university fees.

Private universities in nigeria have to pay staff at the same rate as government universites, without government funding. (Oyedepo said as much when he joked at the opening of another university that the only thing government helped with in covenant university was in smoothing the land acusistion process...from their end. He still had to pay the owner of ze land).

If they do not charge high fees, or if they charge N5000 so that almajiri children can attend, lol...that means that they would have to be paying staff salaries of N20000 monthly, professors included.

Even that money you mentioned is scanty by global standards. Proper world class unviersites charge world class fees. In saner climes students take massive loans to pay for fees. Even those who live in countries where university is free...like Germany and Denmark...their parents have been paying half their income in tax for the privilege....and the fees do not include living expenses. (Students studying in Germany have to find accomodation for themselves...which can cost 450 euro a month in rent..lol).

Atiku has no choice. Even when he was VP , government was not paying money to help with funding for his private university. So, funds for staff salaries, buildings, hostels (yes hostels) and taxes, had to come from the fees. That's why.

No private universty can afford to reduce fees for the poor. At best the poor can hope that someone offers them scholarships, or sponsorships (which happen. Atiku's uni has also sponsored some chibok girls to study in the university in the past).
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by anonimi: 3:03pm On Sep 13
FSBoperator:
Atiku is dangling an unrealistic and an unfulfillable policy to the masses just to get them to vote him into office.
Atiku is so invested in his soothsayers that he pays to tell him he will be President one day .
How is he going to subsidize crude to local refineries that do not exist outside Dangote ?
Is he going to re establish the crude for refined products deal that saw to off shoring of refining Nigerian crude to foreign refineries and then placing waivers on importing the refined crude and then paying the subsidies on it all over again thereby creating the same corrupt ladden system that gulped trillions to personal accounts ?
Even Atiku knows he won't implement his subsidy regime under any guise

Subsidy is gone forever .

Tell your state governors to use the windfall from it which they are collecting via FAAC every month to subsidize education, health and agriculture.
If subsidy is gone forever then why are the 36 governors’ 23% share of the FAAC of less value than when PDP paid subsidy legitimately and gave us cheap petrol?

Why is Tinubu borrowing more than PDP presidents, if subsidy is truly gone forever? Why are roads in a worse condition all over Nigeria?
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by Tenses: 3:04pm On Sep 13
Southwesterners!

Na wa oooo!

One would think Atiku was the president and not Obasanjo.
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by FSBoperator: 3:09pm On Sep 13
anonimi:
If subsidy is gone forever then why are the 36 governors’ 23% share of the FAAC of less value than when PDP paid subsidy legitimately and gave us cheap petrol?

Why is Tinubu borrowing more than PDP presidents, if subsidy is truly gone forever? Why are roads in a worse condition all over Nigeria?
Because Nigeria has grown .

The Federal and state govt wage bill 20ys ago is not the same today.

Your population has grown and so govt provides FX to importers to bring in food .

We are spending more on security than we did in 1999-2015.

Dollar which our crude is priced and sold in, has also lost its purchasing power in the inflated global economy of today compared to 20ys ago
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by Maj196(m): 3:10pm On Sep 13
Removal of subsidy have done more harm than good
Re: Atiku’s Subsidy Plan Failed Under Obasanjo – Otega Ogra by anonimi: 3:16pm On Sep 13
FSBoperator:
Because Nigeria has grown .
The Federal and state govt wage bill 20ys ago is not the same today.
Your population has grown and so govt provides FX to importers to bring in food .
We are spending more on security than we did in 1999-2015.
Dollar which our crude is priced and sold in, has also lost its purchasing power in the inflated global economy of today compared to 20ys ago
Which one of these things is the same thing as Tinubu failing to make a dollar exchange for N300 in the short term before making it N200/$1 by May next year?
1 2 Reply

Nigeria Clear All Debt Owed To IMF — Otega Ogra Hails Major Milestone! • Yacht Spotted In France With Nigerian Flag: Tinubu's Aide, Otega Ogra Disowns It • 2023: Rotational Presidency Failed Under Obasanjo, Yar’Adua – Yahaya Bello • 2 • 3 • 4

"If Tinubu Saved Economy, APC Deceived Nigerians For 8 Years"- ADC To Shettima • The Meaning Of Biafra • Pius Ayim Pius Appointed As New Secretary To Thel Government Of Federation (sgf)