₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,345,990 members, 8,520,547 topics. Date: Wednesday, 18 November 2026 at 04:05 AM

Toggle theme

Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS - Politics (3) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS (8900 Views)

1 2 3 4 5 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by FSBoperator: 11:11am On Sep 18
Babangidapikin:
I am still trying to understand what he said, he didn't give a precise yes/no answer ... Nigeria might leave the membership or elevate the membership to the highest level ..(Abi I didn't hear well) base on National Interest.
That's what statesmanship is .

You don't rush to speak for speaking sake.

You don't pull useless statistics and string irrelevant analogies when responding to issues.

You speak tactfully by presenting to the public that you understand fully well the changing geopolitical environment while expressing a view that you are still studying the situation and in soonest time in the future , make your decision.

That's how public figures are supposed to compose themselves .

It's not by telling us about china and to go and verify the existence of a non existing legacy project in Anambra
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by tollyboy5(m): 11:11am On Sep 18
givedemwotowoto:
In contrast, this was Tinubu's response when asked about insecurity

Too much intelligence wan kill am 😂😂
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by bamasite2: 11:14am On Sep 18
Give it to him. This is so brilliant!
AnonPoet:
🇮🇳India asked 🇳🇬Nigeria, during a meeting with Vice President Shetimma, if Nigeria is interested in becoming a full BRICS member

Here is his response:

Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by thedio(m): 11:15am On Sep 18
tuoyoojo:
Balablu speaks intelligently?

Pls humour me

He was asked about the security of the nation

Did you listen to his response

Before I start discussion, I ask myself "Does this person have the ability to hold an intellectual discussion based on facts"

You said tulumbu is a first class graduate " how does the nigerian economy look. Does it look like something a first class graduate is leading

The first class that was probably forged.

The same way he forged his primary and secondary schooling

A man who planted 80 yams but lied than he planted 200 would reap 80 yams and 120 lies

If it didn't dey, it didn't dey
Bro just try and get a clip of Tinubu talking at international stage u will understand why he is called Jagaban.
About that response let us try and always be objective that clip should be on Salah day and he was relating importance of human life to the Salah celebration
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by Nadingo: 11:20am On Sep 18
This man is undoubtedly too intelligent to deputize a Tinubu.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by Nadingo: 11:24am On Sep 18
Oju4190:
Dis baba look intelligent and vast in knowledge..

Before now i was........
He's a bibliophile. He has always been one.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by GothamCities: 11:33am On Sep 18
tuoyoojo:
Thank you kind sir for volunteering to school me on the economy

I like you already!!


Let's discuss like adults without throwing insults

Kindly give me microeconomics indices bothering on our inflation rate,unemployment rate, exchange rate and security elucidating how the first class accountant has improved the life of the average Nigerian in the last 3 years

While you are at that, kindly comment on our poverty rate, public borrowing habits, health in terms of nutrition and child mortality rates, life expectancy , school attendance and basic standards of living during the tinubu lead APC government and juxtaposing it with how other government other governments in power fared to give it context

Since you said food prices are not yard stick of measuring the economy, in your own accessment give facts and figures to show the life of the average man on the street is better with your first class accountant using other indicators

Since you said the video of him rambling when asked about insecurity is editted, kindly provide the "unedited" video

I humbly wait for your kind rebuttal

Like I said , let facts and statistics speak no just mere verbosity

P.S

While you are at that, kindly chill with this short clip of ur president mocking the statistics that you would be desperately trying to use to defend him

Mr obident, this is the kind of debate I like. No insults, no propaganda. Just facts.

But let us also be careful about what the facts are actually saying.

You asked me for inflation, unemployment, exchange rate, security, poverty, borrowing, nutrition, child mortality, life expectancy, school attendance and standard of living. Fine. Let's take them one by one.

1. INFLATION

I never said inflation is good, but there's no disputing the fact that it has improved under this regime. The prices of foods in the market is not due to inflation but due to the exchange rate. And the exchange rate is the way it is because dollar is no longer being subsidized. How can you be borrowing dollars to subsidize dollar, petrol and electricity? Do you know how Benin Republic, Cameroon and Niger were protesting our subsidy removal? How can we be subsidizing for all those nations - and with loans!

I have said that you cannot use the present price of food in the market to conclude that the economic indicator has deteriorated.

The World Bank says Nigeria's inflation fell from 33.2% in 2024 to 23.0% in 2025. The IMF's 2026 assessment puts the average 2025 CPI at 23.0%, compared with 33.2% in 2024, and says the disinflation process continued into 2026 before renewed external food and fuel pressures. Yes, 23% inflation is still high but the improvement from 33% is highly commendable. The direction of inflation has changed. And that distinction matters.

[World Bank — Nigeria Development Update](https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/nigeria/publication/nigeria-development-update-ndu)

https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/nigeria/publication/nigeria-development-update-ndu

[IMF — 2026 Nigeria Article IV](https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria)

https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria

2. EXCHANGE RATE

Here again, let's deal with facts rather than emotions.

Tinubu inherited a heavily distorted FX system. On June 14, 2023, the CBN moved to a willing-buyer/willing-seller framework and unified the previously segmented FX market.

Was the immediate consequence painful? Absolutely.

Did the naira initially lose enormous value? Absolutely. And that's because its initial value was fake. Subsided value is fake value. 

But the question is whether the reform subsequently produced a more functional FX market.

The IMF says the exchange-rate liberalization, together with the other reforms, improved FX market functioning, rebuilt external buffers and resumed portfolio inflows.

And something very interesting happened in 2025: according to the IMF, the official end-of-year naira rate actually appreciated from about ₦1,535/$ at the end of 2024 to ₦1,435/$ at the end of 2025. It currently stands at ₦1,333.

So if somebody tells you the naira has simply been in an uninterrupted free fall since Tinubu came into office, that is not the truth. If Tinubu was defending the naira as previous administrations did, the value would have certainly look improved but the country itself would be drawing nearer to its grave.

[CBN — FX Structure and Management](https://www.cbn.gov.ng/intops/FXStructureAndManagement.html)

https://www.cbn.gov.ng/intops/FXStructureAndManagement.html

[IMF — Nigeria 2026 Article IV Report](https://www.imf.org/en/publications/cr/issues/2026/06/08/nigeria-2026-article-iv-consultation-press-release-staff-report-and-statement-by-the-576681)

https://www.imf.org/en/publications/cr/issues/2026/06/08/nigeria-2026-article-iv-consultation-press-release-staff-report-and-statement-by-the-576681

3. UNEMPLOYMENT

This one needs honesty.

The NBS reported unemployment at 5.3% in Q1 2024, compared with 5.0% in Q3 2023. In Q2 2024 it fell to 4.3%.

So I am not going to stand here and tell you Tinubu has magically solved unemployment.

He hasn't.

But there is another important issue: Nigeria changed its labour-force measurement methodology, so you cannot casually take the old unemployment numbers from previous administrations and put them beside the new ones as though they were generated under exactly the same methodology.

The NBS itself is the place to check the numbers, not Twitter.

[NBS — Nigeria Labour Force Survey Q1 2024](https://www.nigerianstat.gov.ng/pdfuploads/NLFS_Q1_2024_Report.pdf)

https://www.nigerianstat.gov.ng/pdfuploads/NLFS_Q1_2024_Report.pdf

[NBS — Nigeria Labour Force Survey Q2 2024](https://www.nigerianstat.gov.ng/pdfuploads/NLFS_Q2_2024.pdf)

https://www.nigerianstat.gov.ng/pdfuploads/NLFS_Q2_2024.pdf

And again, 3 years is not enough to fix unemployment. However, there evidence that the government is gradually resolving the issue. Unemployment is a global issue, not a Nigerian thing. 

4. ECONOMIC GROWTH

This is where your argument becomes difficult.

The World Bank reported that Nigeria's GDP grew 3.4% in 2024, with Q4 growth of 4.6%. It described 2024's full-year growth as the strongest since 2014, excluding the COVID rebound years.

The IMF estimates real GDP growth at about 4.0% in 2025.

Again, nobody should pretend 4% growth suddenly makes Nigeria Switzerland. But it is growth, and it is happening alongside a substantial improvement in the government's fiscal position.

[World Bank — Building Momentum for Inclusive Growth](https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2025/05/12/afw-nigeria-building-momentum-for-inclusive-growth)

https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2025/05/12/afw-nigeria-building-momentum-for-inclusive-growth

[IMF — Nigeria 2026 Article IV](https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria)

https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria

5. GOVERNMENT REVENUE AND FISCAL POSITION

This one is particularly interesting.

According to the World Bank, Nigeria's consolidated fiscal deficit fell from 5.4% of GDP in 2023 to 3.0% in 2024.

At the same time, Federation revenues rose from approximately ₦16.8 trillion in 2023 to ₦31.9 trillion in 2024.

That is not a small movement.

You may argue about how the government spends the additional revenue. Fair argument.

But you cannot honestly argue that nothing changed in the government's fiscal position.

The World Bank documented the improvement.

[World Bank — Nigeria Development Update, May 2025](https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2025/05/12/afw-nigeria-building-momentum-for-inclusive-growth)

https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2025/05/12/afw-nigeria-building-momentum-for-inclusive-growth

**6. FOREIGN RESERVES**

The IMF says Nigeria's gross international reserves increased from approximately **$40 billion at the end of 2024 to $46 billion at the end of 2025**, while net international reserves increased from $23 billion to $35 billion.

That is important because reserves are one of the buffers protecting a country against external shocks.

Again, these aren't Tinubu's campaign statistics.

These are IMF numbers.

[IMF — Nigeria 2026 Article IV](https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria)

https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria

7. PUBLIC BORROWING

Here I will agree with you that Nigeria's debt problem deserves scrutiny.

I am not going to pretend otherwise.

But again, debt stock by itself doesn't tell the entire story. You have to look at debt-to-GDP, interest costs, revenue, maturity structure and what the borrowing is financing.

The IMF estimates Nigeria's public gross debt at **39.3% of GDP in 2024 and 36.1% in 2025**.

But it simultaneously flags something very serious: interest payments remain extremely high relative to Federal Government revenue.

So this is not an area where I will tell you "Tinubu has solved it."

He hasn't.

The more accurate statement is that the fiscal position has improved in some dimensions while debt-service pressure remains a major problem.

[IMF — Nigeria 2026 Article IV Report](https://www.imf.org/en/publications/cr/issues/2026/06/08/nigeria-2026-article-iv-consultation-press-release-staff-report-and-statement-by-the-576681)

https://www.imf.org/en/publications/cr/issues/2026/06/08/nigeria-2026-article-iv-consultation-press-release-staff-report-and-statement-by-the-576681

And the Debt Management Office publishes the actual debt stock year by year, so anybody can check it.

[Debt Management Office — Nigeria Public Debt](https://www.dmo.gov.ng/debt-profile/total-public-debt)

https://www.dmo.gov.ng/debt-profile/total-public-debt

8. POVERTY

You cannot blame Tinubu for increased poverty in the land because there's no way anyone will introduce economic reforms without the reforms bringing in temporal side effects. Real individual wealth is not measured by subsidies enjoyed by the individual citizens of a nation. Real wealth stands unchallenged when your purchasing power is tied to the value you can provide and not to the subsidies you enjoy.

Yes, the World Bank estimates that about **63% of Nigerians were below the national poverty line in 2025**, up from about 61% in 2024.

The IMF also cites 63%.

And 61% to 63% is a minimal negative change compared to the overall positive effects the economic reforms are already delivering. Just last month, the German government testified that Nigeria has suddenly become investable again. Goldman Sachs and several other financial institutions around the world have praised the current elevation of Nigeria's economy within the international economic community.

This administration has tried. Yes, people are still poor. The effects of reforms can take years to materialize, but everyone must understand that **four years is not enough to undo the structural errors of many decades**.

You cannot spend decades building distortions into an economy and expect three years of restructuring to immediately put money back into every household.

The World Bank itself makes essentially this distinction: macroeconomic stabilization has improved, but household incomes have not yet recovered sufficiently and poverty remains high.

That is not me talking. That is the World Bank.

[World Bank — Nigeria](https://www.worldbank.org/ext/en/country/nigeria)

[IMF — Nigeria 2026 Article IV](https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria)

https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria

9. CHILD MORTALITY, NUTRITION AND EDUCATION

Now this is where your question actually exposes a problem with trying to attribute every social indicator to whoever happens to be president for three years.

UNICEF's data show Nigeria's under-five mortality rate has been declining over the long term: from about **207.6 deaths per 1,000 live births in 1990 to 115.6 in 2024**.

So are you seriously suggesting that Tinubu personally caused the entire decline from 1990?

Of course not.

Likewise, Nigeria's nutrition and education problems did not begin in 2023.

UNICEF's 2024 assessment says Nigeria has made progress in areas including child mortality and immunization, while simultaneously documenting serious continuing problems in nutrition, education and poverty.

For example, about 40% of children under five are stunted and 8% are wasted.

Those are enormous problems, but they are structural Nigerian problems, not problems that suddenly appeared on May 29, 2023.

[UNICEF — State of Nigeria's Children 2024](https://www.unicef.org/nigeria/reports/updated-situation-analysis-nigeria-2024)

https://www.unicef.org/nigeria/reports/updated-situation-analysis-nigeria-2024

[UNICEF — Nigeria child mortality data](https://data.unicef.org/country/nga/)

https://data.unicef.org/country/nga/

10. SECURITY

Nigeria still has a serious security problem but in all honesty, there has been a drastic decline. Previously, news of Fulani Herdsmen, Bandits, Boko Haram, Lukarawa, ISWAP, etc graced the headlines virtually EVERY DAY. No week ever passed without some bad news happening in multiple places. That situation has changed today. How many bad news have you heard this month or even this week, today being Friday already.

Yes, security is still one of the major remaining risks to economic activity. However, it would be dishonest for anyone to say the situation has not changed at all.

But there is another question: did insecurity begin with Tinubu?

Obviously not.

Boko Haram, banditry, kidnapping, Fulani Herdsmen and communal violence existed under Jonathan and Buhari and, in different forms, long before them without declining.

The proper question is therefore whether the security situation has improved or deteriorated over specific periods and regions, using a consistent dataset.

That's a much more serious debate than throwing one viral video at each other.

[ACLED — Nigeria data](https://acleddata.com/country/nigeria)

https://acleddata.com/country/nigeria

11. LIFE EXPECTANCY

Same principle.

Life expectancy is a long-term population-health indicator. It is not a sensible instrument for declaring that one president has transformed Nigeria after three years.

The same applies to maternal mortality, child mortality, nutrition, school attendance and basic sanitation.

You have to examine the long-term trajectory, the baseline inherited by the administration, and the specific policies being implemented.

Otherwise every president gets credit for every improvement and blame for every deterioration that occurs during his tenure.

That isn't serious statistical analysis.

---

And finally, your video.

You asked me for the unedited video of Tinubu's response on insecurity.

Fair enough.

I am not going to manufacture an "unedited" video just to win an argument.

The widely circulated 2026 clip is available in longer form here:


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r4q9uDhKXO0

And Nairaland itself has the discussion and the embedded video here:

https://www.nairaland.com/8680111/tinubus-answer-reporters-insecurity-question

If somebody has a longer original recording from the event, let's put both versions side by side and establish exactly what was removed.

That's how facts work.

---

And one final point.

You asked me to demonstrate that the average Nigerian is better off.

I cannot honestly demonstrate that across every household-level measure. The World Bank itself says household incomes have not yet recovered fully and poverty remains high. Rome was not built in a day.

But neither can you take those facts and conclude that every reform has failed.

The international evidence is actually much more nuanced:

The macroeconomic foundation has improved substantially, while the social benefits of that stabilization have not yet reached enough Nigerians.

That is precisely why the World Bank says Nigeria now has an opportunity to convert stabilization into broader improvements in livelihoods.

And that, my friend, is the part of this debate I think you are missing.

Nigeria didn't arrive at this point in 2023.

The structural problems accumulated over decades.

You don't reverse decades of fiscal distortion, FX distortion, weak revenue collection, infrastructure deficits, insecurity, human-capital deficits and dependence on oil in three years.

Four years is not enough to undo the errors of many decades.

But three years is enough to tell whether a government has begun changing the direction of the machinery.

And on that particular question, the IMF and World Bank are already documenting substantial changes.

Let's continue with the figures.No insults.No propaganda.Just verifiable numbers.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by Bankowner: 11:42am On Sep 18
AnonPoet:
Clearly he did his assignment in this. He knew what the question ❔ was and his answer was precise and devoid of any ignorance.
I am surprised you are not aware that the questions the interviewer asked had been provided ahead to the VP. Reason he was prepped with the figures and answers he gave.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by Fujiyama: 11:52am On Sep 18
GothamCities:
Tinubu also speaks intelligently. Far above Obi. It's not as if his speeches are not on the Internet. Tinubu himself is highly intelligent and that justifies the fact that he graduated university as a first class student.
^^^
grin

Error.

Error!
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by casualobserver: 11:53am On Sep 18
AnonPoet:
🇮🇳India asked 🇳🇬Nigeria, during a meeting with Vice President Shetimma, if Nigeria is interested in becoming a full BRICS member

Here is his response:

Response “to” not response “on”
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by Fujiyama: 11:55am On Sep 18
GothamCities:
There are thousands of speeches Tinubu has made on the Internet. An edited security question speech cannot be the standalone speech that gives him his whole intellectual identity.
^^^
There was nothing edited about that exchange.

He gave a terrible answer to a very relevant question. Just admit he goofed.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by Galapagous(m): 11:56am On Sep 18
FSBoperator:
Even with BH, Bornu still remains far better than any state in your SE.

Ask any of your people who have been living in Bornu and they will tell you that business opportunities in Bornu dwarf your entire SE combined
Just shut up, Cos it is clear you haven't been to borno. Try their motor park for a start and see the number of almanjiri flooding the park for peanut.
Because you are paid to exercise graded inequality does not mean you should ignore the truth when you see it. I don't care where our Savior is going to come from, I am certain it isn't this fuel unaccountable(fuel subsidy), drug baron(western controlled) and power drunk(funsho Williams death) piece of shit
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by GothamCities: 11:56am On Sep 18
Fujiyama:
^^^
There was nothing edited about that exchange.

He gave a terrible answer to a very relevant question. Just admit he goofed.
You mean that was the whole Chattam house video? You cannot claim he gave a terrible answer without the whole context.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by Fujiyama: 11:59am On Sep 18
symbianDON:
Why did he keep saying 'in the poolness of time'?? What's that??
^^^
He has a lisp.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by Ubanz: 12:00pm On Sep 18
That's a very sound intellectual representation.
No wonder they always send him to the toughest war front.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by Fujiyama: 12:03pm On Sep 18
GothamCities:
You mean that was the whole Chattam house video? You cannot claim he gave a terrible answer without the whole context.
^^^
No.

The video isn't about Chatham House.

Although the Chatham House episode was also a calamity, the video shows BAT's response to a question on security - asked by a journalist here in Lagos. BAT's response was very poor.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by Smartguyboy(m): 12:04pm On Sep 18
AnonPoet:
🇮🇳India asked 🇳🇬Nigeria, during a meeting with Vice President Shetimma, if Nigeria is interested in becoming a full BRICS member

Here is his response:

Very educated man not the first time I am hearing him speak .

He love reading unlike Pablo
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by FSBoperator: 12:04pm On Sep 18
Bankowner:
I am surprised you are not aware that the questions the interviewer asked had been provided ahead to the VP. Reason he was prepped with the figures and answers he gave.
Rubbish
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by GothamCities: 12:07pm On Sep 18
Fujiyama:
^^^
No.

The video isn't about Chatham House.

Although the Chatham House episode was also a calamity, the video shows BAT's response to a question on security - asked by a journalist here in Lagos. BAT's response was very poor.
It's not the entire response. The video was longer than that.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by Fujiyama: 12:18pm On Sep 18
thedio:
Bro just try and get a clip of Tinubu talking at international stage u will understand why he is called Jagaban.
^^^
No.

There are quite a few clips of BAT on the international stage. He is a poor public speaker, full stop. There is nothing to argue about there. Trying to hype him will only make things worse.


thedio:
About that response let us try and always be objective that clip should be on Salah day and he was relating importance of human life to the Salah celebration
^^^
grin

Indeed.

I have seen several presidents and heads of state come and go. All of them combined have not needed other people to clarify and explain their remarks the way BAT has.

We all heard the man say what he said and you are giving us lectures about humanity and Salah celebration. cheesy
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by Fujiyama: 12:22pm On Sep 18
GothamCities:
It's not the entire response. The video was longer than that.
^^^
It doesn't matter.

BAT was asked a simple, direct question about insecurity in the country he leads.

His response was bad. Completely off topic. undecided

Nobody should try to spin this. It will only make things worse.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by GothamCities: 12:42pm On Sep 18
Fujiyama:
^^^
It doesn't matter.

BAT was asked a simple, direct question about insecurity in the country he leads.

His response was bad. Completely off topic. undecided

Nobody should try to spin this. It will only make things worse.
You can't make that conclusion without having the entire context. A video that was cut off from his entire context cannot be the basis for sound judgement. That's not all.he said on the issue.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by Fujiyama: 12:52pm On Sep 18
GothamCities:
You can't make that conclusion without having the entire context. A video that was cut off from his entire context cannot be the basis for sound judgement. That's not all.he said on the issue.
^^^
Share the full video then.

Since you want us to go there, we will.

The man was asked a direct question and he gave a very unsatisfactory response. Where does 'context' come in here? Haven't we learned anything from Daniel Bwala's misadventure? undecided

If you keep dragging this matter it is only going to get worse.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by Omoboricash(m): 12:53pm On Sep 18
FreeStuffsNG:
He is absolutely brilliant!
Can we say the same thing about packaged fraud , chief lamba of Angulu
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by GothamCities: 1:11pm On Sep 18
Fujiyama:
^^^
Share the full video then.

Since you want us to go there, we will.

The man was asked a direct question and he gave a very unsatisfactory response. Where does 'context' come in here? Haven't we learned anything from Daniel Bwala's misadventure? undecided

If you keep dragging this matter it is only going to get worse.
What's going to get worse? That's really funny! Getting worse as if we're not seeing the improvement in security, or because those are the only words Tinubu ever spoke online?

Here's the full video here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yq___9Cc4D0?si=IdFjPJQuvK1S-M_F
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by Galapagous(m): 1:15pm On Sep 18
GothamCities:
Mr obident, this is the kind of debate I like. No insults, no propaganda. Just facts.

But let us also be careful about what the facts are actually saying.

You asked me for inflation, unemployment, exchange rate, security, poverty, borrowing, nutrition, child mortality, life expectancy, school attendance and standard of living. Fine. Let's take them one by one.

1. INFLATION

I never said inflation is good, but there's no disputing the fact that it has improved under this regime. The prices of foods in the market is not due to inflation but due to the exchange rate. And the exchange rate is the way it is because dollar is no longer being subsidized. How can you be borrowing dollars to subsidize dollar, petrol and electricity? Do you know how Benin Republic, Cameroon and Niger were protesting our subsidy removal? How can we be subsidizing for all those nations - and with loans!

I have said that you cannot use the present price of food in the market to conclude that the economic indicator has deteriorated.

The World Bank says Nigeria's inflation fell from 33.2% in 2024 to 23.0% in 2025. The IMF's 2026 assessment puts the average 2025 CPI at 23.0%, compared with 33.2% in 2024, and says the disinflation process continued into 2026 before renewed external food and fuel pressures. Yes, 23% inflation is still high but the improvement from 33% is highly commendable. The direction of inflation has changed. And that distinction matters.

[World Bank — Nigeria Development Update](https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/nigeria/publication/nigeria-development-update-ndu)

https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/nigeria/publication/nigeria-development-update-ndu

[IMF — 2026 Nigeria Article IV](https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria)

https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria

2. EXCHANGE RATE

Here again, let's deal with facts rather than emotions.

Tinubu inherited a heavily distorted FX system. On June 14, 2023, the CBN moved to a willing-buyer/willing-seller framework and unified the previously segmented FX market.

Was the immediate consequence painful? Absolutely.

Did the naira initially lose enormous value? Absolutely. And that's because its initial value was fake. Subsided value is fake value. 

But the question is whether the reform subsequently produced a more functional FX market.

The IMF says the exchange-rate liberalization, together with the other reforms, improved FX market functioning, rebuilt external buffers and resumed portfolio inflows.

And something very interesting happened in 2025: according to the IMF, the official end-of-year naira rate actually appreciated from about ₦1,535/$ at the end of 2024 to ₦1,435/$ at the end of 2025. It currently stands at ₦1,333.

So if somebody tells you the naira has simply been in an uninterrupted free fall since Tinubu came into office, that is not the truth. If Tinubu was defending the naira as previous administrations did, the value would have certainly look improved but the country itself would be drawing nearer to its grave.

[CBN — FX Structure and Management](https://www.cbn.gov.ng/intops/FXStructureAndManagement.html)

https://www.cbn.gov.ng/intops/FXStructureAndManagement.html

[IMF — Nigeria 2026 Article IV Report](https://www.imf.org/en/publications/cr/issues/2026/06/08/nigeria-2026-article-iv-consultation-press-release-staff-report-and-statement-by-the-576681)

https://www.imf.org/en/publications/cr/issues/2026/06/08/nigeria-2026-article-iv-consultation-press-release-staff-report-and-statement-by-the-576681

3. UNEMPLOYMENT

This one needs honesty.

The NBS reported unemployment at 5.3% in Q1 2024, compared with 5.0% in Q3 2023. In Q2 2024 it fell to 4.3%.

So I am not going to stand here and tell you Tinubu has magically solved unemployment.

He hasn't.

But there is another important issue: Nigeria changed its labour-force measurement methodology, so you cannot casually take the old unemployment numbers from previous administrations and put them beside the new ones as though they were generated under exactly the same methodology.

The NBS itself is the place to check the numbers, not Twitter.

[NBS — Nigeria Labour Force Survey Q1 2024](https://www.nigerianstat.gov.ng/pdfuploads/NLFS_Q1_2024_Report.pdf)

https://www.nigerianstat.gov.ng/pdfuploads/NLFS_Q1_2024_Report.pdf

[NBS — Nigeria Labour Force Survey Q2 2024](https://www.nigerianstat.gov.ng/pdfuploads/NLFS_Q2_2024.pdf)

https://www.nigerianstat.gov.ng/pdfuploads/NLFS_Q2_2024.pdf

And again, 3 years is not enough to fix unemployment. However, there evidence that the government is gradually resolving the issue. Unemployment is a global issue, not a Nigerian thing. 

4. ECONOMIC GROWTH

This is where your argument becomes difficult.

The World Bank reported that Nigeria's GDP grew 3.4% in 2024, with Q4 growth of 4.6%. It described 2024's full-year growth as the strongest since 2014, excluding the COVID rebound years.

The IMF estimates real GDP growth at about 4.0% in 2025.

Again, nobody should pretend 4% growth suddenly makes Nigeria Switzerland. But it is growth, and it is happening alongside a substantial improvement in the government's fiscal position.

[World Bank — Building Momentum for Inclusive Growth](https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2025/05/12/afw-nigeria-building-momentum-for-inclusive-growth)

https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2025/05/12/afw-nigeria-building-momentum-for-inclusive-growth

[IMF — Nigeria 2026 Article IV](https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria)

https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria

5. GOVERNMENT REVENUE AND FISCAL POSITION

This one is particularly interesting.

According to the World Bank, Nigeria's consolidated fiscal deficit fell from 5.4% of GDP in 2023 to 3.0% in 2024.

At the same time, Federation revenues rose from approximately ₦16.8 trillion in 2023 to ₦31.9 trillion in 2024.

That is not a small movement.

You may argue about how the government spends the additional revenue. Fair argument.

But you cannot honestly argue that nothing changed in the government's fiscal position.

The World Bank documented the improvement.

[World Bank — Nigeria Development Update, May 2025](https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2025/05/12/afw-nigeria-building-momentum-for-inclusive-growth)

https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2025/05/12/afw-nigeria-building-momentum-for-inclusive-growth

**6. FOREIGN RESERVES**

The IMF says Nigeria's gross international reserves increased from approximately **$40 billion at the end of 2024 to $46 billion at the end of 2025**, while net international reserves increased from $23 billion to $35 billion.

That is important because reserves are one of the buffers protecting a country against external shocks.

Again, these aren't Tinubu's campaign statistics.

These are IMF numbers.

[IMF — Nigeria 2026 Article IV](https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria)

https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria

7. PUBLIC BORROWING

Here I will agree with you that Nigeria's debt problem deserves scrutiny.

I am not going to pretend otherwise.

But again, debt stock by itself doesn't tell the entire story. You have to look at debt-to-GDP, interest costs, revenue, maturity structure and what the borrowing is financing.

The IMF estimates Nigeria's public gross debt at **39.3% of GDP in 2024 and 36.1% in 2025**.

But it simultaneously flags something very serious: interest payments remain extremely high relative to Federal Government revenue.

So this is not an area where I will tell you "Tinubu has solved it."

He hasn't.

The more accurate statement is that the fiscal position has improved in some dimensions while debt-service pressure remains a major problem.

[IMF — Nigeria 2026 Article IV Report](https://www.imf.org/en/publications/cr/issues/2026/06/08/nigeria-2026-article-iv-consultation-press-release-staff-report-and-statement-by-the-576681)

https://www.imf.org/en/publications/cr/issues/2026/06/08/nigeria-2026-article-iv-consultation-press-release-staff-report-and-statement-by-the-576681

And the Debt Management Office publishes the actual debt stock year by year, so anybody can check it.

[Debt Management Office — Nigeria Public Debt](https://www.dmo.gov.ng/debt-profile/total-public-debt)

https://www.dmo.gov.ng/debt-profile/total-public-debt

8. POVERTY

You cannot blame Tinubu for increased poverty in the land because there's no way anyone will introduce economic reforms without the reforms bringing in temporal side effects. Real individual wealth is not measured by subsidies enjoyed by the individual citizens of a nation. Real wealth stands unchallenged when your purchasing power is tied to the value you can provide and not to the subsidies you enjoy.

Yes, the World Bank estimates that about **63% of Nigerians were below the national poverty line in 2025**, up from about 61% in 2024.

The IMF also cites 63%.

And 61% to 63% is a minimal negative change compared to the overall positive effects the economic reforms are already delivering. Just last month, the German government testified that Nigeria has suddenly become investable again. Goldman Sachs and several other financial institutions around the world have praised the current elevation of Nigeria's economy within the international economic community.

This administration has tried. Yes, people are still poor. The effects of reforms can take years to materialize, but everyone must understand that **four years is not enough to undo the structural errors of many decades**.

You cannot spend decades building distortions into an economy and expect three years of restructuring to immediately put money back into every household.

The World Bank itself makes essentially this distinction: macroeconomic stabilization has improved, but household incomes have not yet recovered sufficiently and poverty remains high.

That is not me talking. That is the World Bank.

[World Bank — Nigeria](https://www.worldbank.org/ext/en/country/nigeria)

[IMF — Nigeria 2026 Article IV](https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria)

https://www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/06/09/pr26190-nigeria-imf-executive-board-concludes-2026-article-iv-consultation-with-nigeria

9. CHILD MORTALITY, NUTRITION AND EDUCATION

Now this is where your question actually exposes a problem with trying to attribute every social indicator to whoever happens to be president for three years.

UNICEF's data show Nigeria's under-five mortality rate has been declining over the long term: from about **207.6 deaths per 1,000 live births in 1990 to 115.6 in 2024**.

So are you seriously suggesting that Tinubu personally caused the entire decline from 1990?

Of course not.

Likewise, Nigeria's nutrition and education problems did not begin in 2023.

UNICEF's 2024 assessment says Nigeria has made progress in areas including child mortality and immunization, while simultaneously documenting serious continuing problems in nutrition, education and poverty.

For example, about 40% of children under five are stunted and 8% are wasted.

Those are enormous problems, but they are structural Nigerian problems, not problems that suddenly appeared on May 29, 2023.

[UNICEF — State of Nigeria's Children 2024](https://www.unicef.org/nigeria/reports/updated-situation-analysis-nigeria-2024)

https://www.unicef.org/nigeria/reports/updated-situation-analysis-nigeria-2024

[UNICEF — Nigeria child mortality data](https://data.unicef.org/country/nga/)

https://data.unicef.org/country/nga/

10. SECURITY

Nigeria still has a serious security problem but in all honesty, there has been a drastic decline. Previously, news of Fulani Herdsmen, Bandits, Boko Haram, Lukarawa, ISWAP, etc graced the headlines virtually EVERY DAY. No week ever passed without some bad news happening in multiple places. That situation has changed today. How many bad news have you heard this month or even this week, today being Friday already.

Yes, security is still one of the major remaining risks to economic activity. However, it would be dishonest for anyone to say the situation has not changed at all.

But there is another question: did insecurity begin with Tinubu?

Obviously not.

Boko Haram, banditry, kidnapping, Fulani Herdsmen and communal violence existed under Jonathan and Buhari and, in different forms, long before them without declining.

The proper question is therefore whether the security situation has improved or deteriorated over specific periods and regions, using a consistent dataset.

That's a much more serious debate than throwing one viral video at each other.

[ACLED — Nigeria data](https://acleddata.com/country/nigeria)

https://acleddata.com/country/nigeria

11. LIFE EXPECTANCY

Same principle.

Life expectancy is a long-term population-health indicator. It is not a sensible instrument for declaring that one president has transformed Nigeria after three years.

The same applies to maternal mortality, child mortality, nutrition, school attendance and basic sanitation.

You have to examine the long-term trajectory, the baseline inherited by the administration, and the specific policies being implemented.

Otherwise every president gets credit for every improvement and blame for every deterioration that occurs during his tenure.

That isn't serious statistical analysis.

---

And finally, your video.

You asked me for the unedited video of Tinubu's response on insecurity.

Fair enough.

I am not going to manufacture an "unedited" video just to win an argument.

The widely circulated 2026 clip is available in longer form here:


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r4q9uDhKXO0

And Nairaland itself has the discussion and the embedded video here:

https://www.nairaland.com/8680111/tinubus-answer-reporters-insecurity-question

If somebody has a longer original recording from the event, let's put both versions side by side and establish exactly what was removed.

That's how facts work.

---

And one final point.

You asked me to demonstrate that the average Nigerian is better off.

I cannot honestly demonstrate that across every household-level measure. The World Bank itself says household incomes have not yet recovered fully and poverty remains high. Rome was not built in a day.

But neither can you take those facts and conclude that every reform has failed.

The international evidence is actually much more nuanced:

The macroeconomic foundation has improved substantially, while the social benefits of that stabilization have not yet reached enough Nigerians.

That is precisely why the World Bank says Nigeria now has an opportunity to convert stabilization into broader improvements in livelihoods.

And that, my friend, is the part of this debate I think you are missing.

Nigeria didn't arrive at this point in 2023.

The structural problems accumulated over decades.

You don't reverse decades of fiscal distortion, FX distortion, weak revenue collection, infrastructure deficits, insecurity, human-capital deficits and dependence on oil in three years.

Four years is not enough to undo the errors of many decades.

But three years is enough to tell whether a government has begun changing the direction of the machinery.

And on that particular question, the IMF and World Bank are already documenting substantial changes.

Let's continue with the figures.No insults.No propaganda.Just verifiable numbers.
You forgot one key ingredient, the IMF and world bank cannot be a tool for African liberation. Their policy was what put us here in the first place. Same IMF and world bank who gave an advice on their website and quickly removed it.
If you understand imperialism and neocolonialism, you will obviously find another source to verify everything that comes from them.
It's a playbook that have been ran countless of time, take Thomas Sankara of burkina faso as an example who achieve sovereignty outside load and borrowing and what they did to his administration. Gandafi in Libya, and the countless death trap on traore and the sahel.

Tinubu is dancing to their tune(floating the currency, devaluate the Naira and extreme borrowing), he has to, they've gotten his drug case history with them, so they have all means to put these up, I don't have to tell you, most of these loan comes with agreement not available to the public and to be paid back by generations to come.

I am not saying obi is a saint, neither is atiku and his money laundering history using his wife name in the past. Truth is, I don't even see anyone preaching breaking away from neocolonialism. But I am sure tinubu ain't doing anything substantial and nothing can convince me the economy wouldn't have been navigated better btw 2024 and now. If you need fact I could provide them, outside the wall of world bank and the IMF.

Like you said, no insult, just pure dialogue.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by yemre: 1:15pm On Sep 18
helinues:
Shettima, it wasn't by mistake for suggesting him as the vice to president Tinubu without even considering the same fate ticket.

Shettima alone sound intellectually better than all the opposition we have in Nigeria

People should go and watch Shettima's jabs to Osinbajo, even if you are an Osibanjo supporters, you cNt get angry because the jabs was just so mature
Send us the link pls
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by GothamCities: 1:21pm On Sep 18
Galapagous:
You forgot one key ingredient, the IMF and world bank cannot be a tool for African liberation. Their policy was what put us here in the first place. Same IMF and world bank who gave an advice on their website and quickly removed it.
If you understand imperialism and neocolonialism, you will obviously find another source to verify everything that comes from them.
It's a playbook that have been ran countless of time, take Thomas Sankara of burkina faso as an example who achieve sovereignty outside load and borrowing and what they did to his administration. Gandafi in Libya, and the countless death trap on traore and the sahel.

Tinubu is dancing to their tune(floating the currency, devaluate the Naira and extreme borrowing), he has to, they've gotten his drug case history with them, so they have all means to put these up, I don't have to tell you, most of these loan comes with agreement not available to the public and to be paid back by generations to come.

I am not saying obi is a saint, neither is atiku and his money laundering history using his wife name in the past. Truth is, I don't even see anyone preaching breaking away from neocolonialism. But I am sure tinubu ain't doing anything substantial and nothing can convince me the economy wouldn't have been navigated better btw 2024 and now. If you need fact I could provide them, outside the wall of world bank and the IMF.

Like you said, no insult, just pure dialogue.
I have not discussed anything that supports making world bank or IMF as tools for Nigerian or African liberation. They hold accurate stats for the economy of all nations, and any reference to their stats should be separated from their policies.

And no, Tinubu is not dancing to their tunes. They didn't decide the economic direction or reforms that this administration has embarked on. Tinubu has NEVER been a puppet. Right from the very days of the military Juntas whom Obi served, Tinubu has always had his own voice and ways.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by rossipki: 1:26pm On Sep 18
Jaybuoy:
Gotta hand it to him… He’s an intelligent man.
Who, Shettima??

Shettima is a highly intelligent and well educated man who knows the world he lives in. He doesn't talk much, but when he talks, you know he's a sensible man with brains.

I like Shettima.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by rossipki: 1:31pm On Sep 18
Bankowner:
I am surprised you are not aware that the questions the interviewer asked had been provided ahead to the VP. Reason he was prepped with the figures and answers he gave.
SHUT UP THERE.

Shettima does not need any prepping for anything. This must be your first time of hearing him speak for you to say that nonsense.

He is a well-educated, exposed man with vast geopolitical awareness.

He can lecture you.

So SHUT UP.
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by GABRIEL6036: 1:37pm On Sep 18
V.p shetima is endowed with wisdom 😳, see how he tactically and diplomatically answer the question without being boxed 🤭😎.
Good job from the vice president 👏 👍
Re: Shettima's Response On If Nigeria Will Fully Join BRICS by qtx(m): 1:43pm On Sep 18
DMCA:
Tinubu until 2031 cool
Shettima from 2031 to 2039 cool
Impressive cool
And then after that Seyi BAT right?
1 2 3 4 5 Reply

Nigeria & 12 Other Nations Join BRICS As Partners (Photos) • Nigeria Set To Join BRICS, May Start Trading Crude Oil In Naira • Fool You Don't Know Anything: Kashim Shettima Response Obi • 2 • 3 • 4

The Challenges Of Security In Nigeria • Obama Calls Ghana ‘model For Africa’ • Probe Salami For Nominating Akeredolu As Ondo ACN Guber Candidate:srln