Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? - Investment - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Investment › Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? (15511 Views)
| Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by Distribusiness(op): 10:21am On Sep 27 |
Good evening Nairalanders, My name is Oluwamuyiwa Olusanya, a car wash operator at Dugbe, Ibadan since May 4, 2025. I write an Investment4Business blog. I want to share a real comparison I did for Fixed Deposit vs Mutual Funds Money Market Fund in 2026, because many people are confused. I tested with ₦100,000 for 90 days: A. FIXED DEPOSIT: - Rate in September 2026: 10-13% for ₦100k (Access Bank 11%, First Bank 10.5%, Stanbic 12% if you have ₦1m+) - Interest formula: Principal x Rate x Days / 365 - ₦100,000 x 11% x 90 / 365 = ₦2,712 gross - Withholding Tax 10% = ₦271.2 - Net you receive = ₦2,440.8 - Lock: 90 days, if you break before, you lose interest. B. MUTUAL FUNDS (Money Market Fund): - Rate in September 2026: Stanbic IBTC Money Market 15.2%, Cowrywise Money Market 15%, PiggyVest Flex Dollar - Interest: Compounding daily, not simple - ₦100,000 x 15% x 90 / 365 = ₦3,698 (approximate, daily compounding adds small extra) - No 10% WHT deducted upfront, fund pays after - Liquidity: Withdraw within 24-48 hours, no penalty - Risk: Not insured by NDIC like Fixed Deposit, but invested in Treasury Bills and Commercial Papers My Result: Mutual Funds paid ₦1,257 more than Fixed Deposit for the same ₦100k for 90 days. When to choose which? - Choose Fixed Deposit if you want NDIC insurance up to ₦500k and you will not touch money. - Choose Mutual Funds if you want higher return and flexibility to withdraw for emergencies. I am not selling anything. Just sharing what I learned saving ₦10k monthly with ₦334 daily from car wash. What do you use? Fixed or Mutual Funds? Thank you. |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by Royal30: 10:55am On Sep 27 |
You used the wrong Fixed deposit... Do a deeper research. Fixed deposit beat MMF, Treasury bill, Bond etc. For example, Check Risevest naira vault fix deposit compounding features . There are more... Distribusiness: |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by tommykiwi(m): 11:00am On Sep 27 |
Let me take front seat and learn from experts |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by Naturalgbola(m): 11:03am On Sep 27 |
Shatap, don't derail the thread. Which pays most? Single answer needed. Royal30: |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by herald9: 11:03am On Sep 27 |
Mutual funds returns are better when you invest substantial sum. For instance, my Stanbic IBTC Mutual funds gives me at least a 100k monthly |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by FSBoperator: 11:03am On Sep 27 |
The bank will never pay you interest more than inflation rate or that set by CBN as lending rates. Invest your money in mutual funds preferably with a Pension manager like Stanbic Pension Fund/investment managers. Their returns are far higher than what you will get letting your money lose value in a bank deposit. |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by Hezzyluv: 11:03am On Sep 27*. Modified: 5:08pm On Sep 27 |
Na people wey get plenty money this tin dey make sense for pass. Just imagine you have 50m with 20% interest p.a, you roughly have 10m interest. Around 27k per day with your money saved. |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by tspun(m): 11:04am On Sep 27 |
Fixed deposit is better but with that little amount is better u used any.of the finteck app that offers 18%pa |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by Naturalgbola(m): 11:04am On Sep 27 |
With how much capital? Hun herald9: |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by anytexy: 11:06am On Sep 27 |
A beg is it the Banks that run the mutual deposit too? |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by Sphinx419(m): 11:09am On Sep 27 |
herald9:For how much capital boss ? So you dey tell me to lock my 7.5m for 9ja bank and in return I get 100k every long 30dayss oo not even 2wks. Man abeg go collect your money.. start baron business and get that 7.5m in a week. That kind investment na nonsense 100k every 30days. I frown to such ![]()
|
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by Parachoko: 11:09am On Sep 27 |
If you fix 100k in a bank, you might not even get up to 5k |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by Parachoko: 11:12am On Sep 27 |
Distribusiness:Anybody that wants to fix or invest in Mutual funds should start from at least #15m to get back good returns |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by ogolemati: 11:12am On Sep 27 |
herald9:
|
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by oneMalik: 11:14am On Sep 27 |
your brain is working ! someone can not just come forward to tell people he/she earn 100K/months just like that ... without justification/explanation . Naturalgbola: |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by ogolemati: 11:15am On Sep 27 |
tspun:
|
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by JGreg(m): 11:15am On Sep 27 |
herald9:with how much investment |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by ogolemati: 11:17am On Sep 27 |
Sphinx419:
|
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by oneMalik: 11:17am On Sep 27 |
That's still laziness too ! how I go lock 15meter somewhere ? to get how much exactly ? Nigerians na wah o ! Parachoko: |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by oneMalik: 11:19am On Sep 27 |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by thesolutions(m): 11:21am On Sep 27 |
It still depends. Some fix deposit offers up to 20% when fixed for longer period. But someone doing actual business can get that profit in few days. I got my phone 180k online. I wanted to sell 200k To profit 20k but i found out that the wholesale price from my plug is above 250k, i decided to use it. Real business man can sell it for 230k and make 50k in one sale. |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by ogolemati: 11:23am On Sep 27 |
|
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by zenburster: 11:24am On Sep 27 |
What do you mean by "pays"? With the reduction of MPR by the CBN from 26% to 23.5% means automatically that rates across all fixed income instruments goes down. Now compare the rate and tenure vis a viz the inflation rate currently. And you will see that investing that #100k in pounded yam and ogbono is the best course of action. Eat and enjoy yourself. Na who dey alive dey invest. #100k is nothing in the grand scheme of things. Nigeria is a 💩 hole ATM |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by mycar: 11:24am On Sep 27 |
anytexy:Approach your bank first and if they don't have section that offers such services, you can approach another bank |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by sacajawea(m): 11:25am On Sep 27 |
Which of the Mutual Funds? Cos the answer is obvious... |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by olamike: 11:27am On Sep 27 |
herald9:How much did you invest sir? Thank you sir. |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by Blaizeless: 11:28am On Sep 27 |
Abeg, explain "Baron business" for me bro. Sphinx419: |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by LagbajaTheBEREAN: 11:29am On Sep 27 |
Omo, na experts just full this thread, everybody with him gbas and gbos up and down. Wo, make I go find 10 minutes draw fess take confirm something. |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by Parachoko: 11:33am On Sep 27*. Modified: 6:29pm On Sep 30 |
oneMalik:No dey speak for every Nigerian base on your own condition and understanding. People dey lock #30m,#50m, #1b etc for their account. Person fix him money no mean say e no get other investment Spend and invest your money in whatever you want, nah your money |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by Gotocourt: 11:35am On Sep 27 |
Distribusiness:Mutual funds pay better👌💯. Fixed deposit makes banks richer. Follow this thread and ask questions ✨️ https://www.nairaland.com/1912965/mutual-funds/546#1912965.17492 |
| Re: Fixed Deposit Vs Mutual Funds: Which Pays Returns With ₦100k Investment? by lordm(m): 11:42am On Sep 27 |
I get 2 sure odds for you o |
Fixed Deposit VS Farm Deposit (farm Crowdy, Payfarmer, Farm Funded) Which Way? • Which Is Better; Fixed Deposit Or Bonds? • Index Funds Vs Mutual Funds • 2 • 3 • 4
Nigerian Stock Exchange Beginner's Guide • Better Days Ahead • Beware!!! Mmm Is A Scam.
