₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,443 members, 8,523,214 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 11:50 PM

Toggle theme

Free Will And Loyalty: What If Adam Had Not Sinned? - Christianity Etc - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Free Will And Loyalty: What If Adam Had Not Sinned? (64 Views)

1 Reply (Go Down)

Free Will And Loyalty: What If Adam Had Not Sinned? by wumiwumi100(op): 9:57am On Sep 28
When we talk about free will, we often make it sound as though it means we are completely free to do whatever we want. But is that really what free will means?

I don't think so.

What we usually call free will is better understood as the ability to make choices within certain boundaries. Our choices are influenced by rules, circumstances, desires, and consequences. In other words, our freedom is conditioned.

Take Adam, for example. According to Genesis, Adam was free to eat from the trees in the garden except one. God specifically told him not to eat from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil and told him what the consequence would be if he did. Adam therefore had a choice, but he did not have absolute freedom. There was a rule, and there was a consequence for breaking it.

This distinction matters.

If I am told, "You are free to do whatever you want, but if you do something I have forbidden, you will be punished," I still have the ability to choose. But I am not absolutely free. My choices are being made within a system of rules and consequences.

We see the same thing in everyday life. Someone may want to commit a crime, but the possibility of being arrested and punished can influence that decision. The person can still choose to commit the crime, but nobody would describe that situation as complete freedom.

Religion works in much the same way. Many Christians avoid certain behaviours because they believe those actions violate God's laws and could result in divine punishment, destruction, hellfire, or loss of salvation. Some may genuinely want to do things the Bible condemns but choose not to because they fear the consequences.

If those consequences did not exist, some people would probably make different choices.

That does not mean they have no ability to choose. It means their choices are conditioned by the consequences attached to them.

So when we say humans have free will, I think what we really mean is conditioned free will, not absolute free will.

But What About Perfect Beings?

This becomes even more interesting when we consider Adam and Eve.

They were supposedly perfect, yet they still disobeyed God.

If perfection guaranteed permanent obedience, Adam and Eve should never have sinned. But they did.

That tells us something important: perfection does not eliminate the possibility of making a wrong choice.

And Adam and Eve were not the only examples.

Satan is presented in the Bible as a heavenly being who rebelled against God. Whatever one's interpretation of the passages traditionally associated with his origin, the biblical narrative clearly presents Satan as someone who chose to oppose God.

Then there are the angels mentioned in Genesis 6, Jude 6, and 2 Peter 2:4. These passages describe angels who sinned and abandoned their proper position. Christian interpretation has traditionally connected these accounts with angels who rebelled against God by taking human women.

Think about what that means.

These were not ordinary imperfect humans struggling with inherited sin. They were heavenly beings. Yet they still chose to go against God's will.

So we have a recurring pattern:

Adam and Eve were perfect, yet they disobeyed.

Satan was a heavenly being, yet he rebelled.

Other angels are described as having sinned and abandoned their proper position.

Perfection clearly does not guarantee permanent obedience.

What If Adam Had Remained Faithful?

If Adam had never sinned, would humanity really have continued living forever from the beginning of creation without ever facing another test of loyalty?

I don't think we can confidently say that.

The Bible tells us what happened after Adam sinned. However, it does not give us a detailed account of what would have happened if Adam had remained obedient forever, except that the earth would have been filled with perfect humans.

But we cannot really be sure that humanity would definitely have lived forever without ever facing another test of loyalty. Many Christians make assumptions about this hypothetical situation, even though the Bible does not actually describe it in detail.

And there is a logical problem with that assumption.

If perfect beings can make choices that go against God’s will, then perfection itself cannot guarantee that there will never be another act of disobedience. Jehovah’s Witnesses teach that a time is coming when all humans will be perfect and remain loyal to God. But if perfect angels were able to go against God, why should we assume that perfect humans could never do the same? Loyalty to God might not necessarily last forever simply because someone is perfect.

Who knows whether another rebellion could have happened in heaven over and over again since the completion of the Bible? Since history can repeat itself, we cannot completely rule out that possibility.

My point is that we cannot confidently say that such a thing could never have happened.

The examples we already have show that the possibility existed.

Does Free Will Require the Possibility of Disobedience?

This is where the issue gets even deeper.

If God gives a creature genuine freedom to choose whether to obey, then choosing differently must remain possible. Otherwise, obedience is guaranteed rather than genuinely chosen.

If a perfect creature is incapable of choosing against God’s will, then its obedience is no longer the result of meaningful choice in the same sense. But if that creature can genuinely choose against God’s will, then disobedience remains possible.

That is the tension.

Free will gives us the ability to choose. Rules give us something to obey or disobey. And consequences give those choices significance.

So if our choices have real consequences, then our freedom is not absolute. We are free to choose, but we are not free from the consequences of what we choose.

Therefore, as long as there are rules, meaningful choices, and consequences attached to those choices, the possibility of disobedience remains. In that sense, what we call “free will” is not complete freedom, because every choice is made within limits and carries consequences.

This Is Why I Question the Idea of Absolute Free Will

I am not arguing that humans cannot make choices. Obviously, we can.

My argument is that the freedom we experience is not absolute.

We cannot choose the circumstances into which we are born. We cannot choose the laws of nature. We cannot simply remove the laws of the society we live in. And when it comes to religion, we cannot claim that we are completely free while simultaneously accepting that certain choices can result in divine punishment.

Our choices are always made within boundaries.

That is why I think conditioned free will is a more accurate way to describe what we actually have.

We have the freedom to choose, but not the freedom to choose without limits or consequences.

And if that is true for humans, why would it necessarily be different for perfect beings?

Adam was perfect, yet he chose to disobey.

Satan was a heavenly being, yet he rebelled.

Other angels are described as having abandoned their proper position.

So perfection does not appear to remove the possibility of choosing differently.

The Question That Remains

If Adam had remained faithful, perhaps humanity would have continued forever without another major test of loyalty. Perhaps God would have arranged things differently. We simply do not know.

But what we cannot establish from the biblical account is that another test of loyalty would have been impossible.

If free will remained, and if perfect beings could still choose differently, then the possibility of another test or another act of rebellion would remain.

That is the point I find most interesting.

The question is not simply whether Adam had free will.

The deeper question is:

If free will means having the genuine ability to choose differently, and perfection does not remove that ability, why should we assume that humanity would never again have faced a test of loyalty?

The biblical examples of Adam and Eve, Satan, and the other rebellious angels suggest that perfection does not guarantee permanent obedience.

And if perfection does not guarantee obedience, then a perfect world does not necessarily mean a world where disobedience is impossible.

Maybe the real issue is not whether Adam had free will, but whether any created being can ever have absolute free will while still being subject to rules, authority, and consequences.

Re: Free Will And Loyalty: What If Adam Had Not Sinned? by Truthseeker10: 4:28pm On Sep 28
wumiwumi100:
When we talk about free will, we often make it sound as though it means we are completely free to do whatever we want. But is that really what free will means?

I don't think so.

What we usually call free will is better understood as the ability to make choices within certain boundaries. Our choices are influenced by rules, circumstances, desires, and consequences. In other words, our freedom is conditioned.

Take Adam, for example. According to Genesis, Adam was free to eat from the trees in the garden except one. God specifically told him not to eat from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil and told him what the consequence would be if he did. Adam therefore had a choice, but he did not have absolute freedom. There was a rule, and there was a consequence for breaking it.

This distinction matters.

If I am told, "You are free to do whatever you want, but if you do something I have forbidden, you will be punished," I still have the ability to choose. But I am not absolutely free. My choices are being made within a system of rules and consequences.

We see the same thing in everyday life. Someone may want to commit a crime, but the possibility of being arrested and punished can influence that decision. The person can still choose to commit the crime, but nobody would describe that situation as complete freedom.

Religion works in much the same way. Many Christians avoid certain behaviours because they believe those actions violate God's laws and could result in divine punishment, destruction, hellfire, or loss of salvation. Some may genuinely want to do things the Bible condemns but choose not to because they fear the consequences.

If those consequences did not exist, some people would probably make different choices.

That does not mean they have no ability to choose. It means their choices are conditioned by the consequences attached to them.

So when we say humans have free will, I think what we really mean is conditioned free will, not absolute free will.

But What About Perfect Beings?

This becomes even more interesting when we consider Adam and Eve.

They were supposedly perfect, yet they still disobeyed God.

If perfection guaranteed permanent obedience, Adam and Eve should never have sinned. But they did.

That tells us something important: perfection does not eliminate the possibility of making a wrong choice.

And Adam and Eve were not the only examples.

Satan is presented in the Bible as a heavenly being who rebelled against God. Whatever one's interpretation of the passages traditionally associated with his origin, the biblical narrative clearly presents Satan as someone who chose to oppose God.

Then there are the angels mentioned in Genesis 6, Jude 6, and 2 Peter 2:4. These passages describe angels who sinned and abandoned their proper position. Christian interpretation has traditionally connected these accounts with angels who rebelled against God by taking human women.

Think about what that means.

These were not ordinary imperfect humans struggling with inherited sin. They were heavenly beings. Yet they still chose to go against God's will.

So we have a recurring pattern:

Adam and Eve were perfect, yet they disobeyed.

Satan was a heavenly being, yet he rebelled.

Other angels are described as having sinned and abandoned their proper position.

Perfection clearly does not guarantee permanent obedience.

What If Adam Had Remained Faithful?

If Adam had never sinned, would humanity really have continued living forever from the beginning of creation without ever facing another test of loyalty?

I don't think we can confidently say that.

The Bible tells us what happened after Adam sinned. However, it does not give us a detailed account of what would have happened if Adam had remained obedient forever, except that the earth would have been filled with perfect humans.

But we cannot really be sure that humanity would definitely have lived forever without ever facing another test of loyalty. Many Christians make assumptions about this hypothetical situation, even though the Bible does not actually describe it in detail.

And there is a logical problem with that assumption.

If perfect beings can make choices that go against God’s will, then perfection itself cannot guarantee that there will never be another act of disobedience. Jehovah’s Witnesses teach that a time is coming when all humans will be perfect and remain loyal to God. But if perfect angels were able to go against God, why should we assume that perfect humans could never do the same? Loyalty to God might not necessarily last forever simply because someone is perfect.

Who knows whether another rebellion could have happened in heaven over and over again since the completion of the Bible? Since history can repeat itself, we cannot completely rule out that possibility.

My point is that we cannot confidently say that such a thing could never have happened.

The examples we already have show that the possibility existed.

Does Free Will Require the Possibility of Disobedience?

This is where the issue gets even deeper.

If God gives a creature genuine freedom to choose whether to obey, then choosing differently must remain possible. Otherwise, obedience is guaranteed rather than genuinely chosen.

If a perfect creature is incapable of choosing against God’s will, then its obedience is no longer the result of meaningful choice in the same sense. But if that creature can genuinely choose against God’s will, then disobedience remains possible.

That is the tension.

Free will gives us the ability to choose. Rules give us something to obey or disobey. And consequences give those choices significance.

So if our choices have real consequences, then our freedom is not absolute. We are free to choose, but we are not free from the consequences of what we choose.

Therefore, as long as there are rules, meaningful choices, and consequences attached to those choices, the possibility of disobedience remains. In that sense, what we call “free will” is not complete freedom, because every choice is made within limits and carries consequences.

This Is Why I Question the Idea of Absolute Free Will

I am not arguing that humans cannot make choices. Obviously, we can.

My argument is that the freedom we experience is not absolute.

We cannot choose the circumstances into which we are born. We cannot choose the laws of nature. We cannot simply remove the laws of the society we live in. And when it comes to religion, we cannot claim that we are completely free while simultaneously accepting that certain choices can result in divine punishment.

Our choices are always made within boundaries.

That is why I think conditioned free will is a more accurate way to describe what we actually have.

We have the freedom to choose, but not the freedom to choose without limits or consequences.

And if that is true for humans, why would it necessarily be different for perfect beings?

Adam was perfect, yet he chose to disobey.

Satan was a heavenly being, yet he rebelled.

Other angels are described as having abandoned their proper position.

So perfection does not appear to remove the possibility of choosing differently.

The Question That Remains

If Adam had remained faithful, perhaps humanity would have continued forever without another major test of loyalty. Perhaps God would have arranged things differently. We simply do not know.

But what we cannot establish from the biblical account is that another test of loyalty would have been impossible.

If free will remained, and if perfect beings could still choose differently, then the possibility of another test or another act of rebellion would remain.

That is the point I find most interesting.

The question is not simply whether Adam had free will.

The deeper question is:

If free will means having the genuine ability to choose differently, and perfection does not remove that ability, why should we assume that humanity would never again have faced a test of loyalty?

The biblical examples of Adam and Eve, Satan, and the other rebellious angels suggest that perfection does not guarantee permanent obedience.

And if perfection does not guarantee obedience, then a perfect world does not necessarily mean a world where disobedience is impossible.

Maybe the real issue is not whether Adam had free will, but whether any created being can ever have absolute free will while still being subject to rules, authority, and consequences.
So from your write-up, are you saying that free-will makes it impossible for humans to live forever in a peaceful world?
Re: Free Will And Loyalty: What If Adam Had Not Sinned? by Dtruthspeaker: 7:02pm On Sep 28
You are making a mistake. Free will is simply the exercise of your freedom of will. It is immaterial if nature or retaliatory/responsive consequences truncates the exercise of your freedom of willing.

So, thus, a person can exercise his will freely, to walk through eleko beach to Ikoyi, even if he will drown if he tries to accomplish that will.

So, the mere fact that you have freewill does not mean that it must always be accomplished. Those are the mistakes your post makes
Re: Free Will And Loyalty: What If Adam Had Not Sinned? by wumiwumi100(op): 8:12pm On Sep 28
Truthseeker10:
So from your write-up, are you saying that free-will makes it impossible for humans to live forever in a peaceful world?
My point is that there is no such thing as absolute free will, and being perfect does not guarantee permanent obedience, even in a perfect and peaceful environment.

Adam and Eve were perfect, yet they disobeyed. Satan was a heavenly being, yet he rebelled, and other angels are also described as having sinned.

So, if free will means having the genuine ability to choose differently, then the possibility of disobedience will always remain.

A peaceful world could certainly exist, but I don't see how we can logically conclude that free will and perfection would make another test of loyalty or another act of rebellion impossible.
Re: Free Will And Loyalty: What If Adam Had Not Sinned? by wumiwumi100(op): 8:19pm On Sep 28
Dtruthspeaker:
You are making a mistake. Free will is simply the exercise of your freedom of will. It is immaterial if nature or retaliatory/responsive consequences truncates the exercise of your freedom of willing.

So, thus, a person can exercise his will freely, to walk through eleko beach to Ikoyi, even if he will drown if he tries to accomplish that will.

So, the mere fact that you have freewill does not mean that it must always be accomplished. Those are the mistakes your post makes
I understand your distinction, but I think we are using "free will" differently. I am not arguing that having consequences means a person cannot exercise their will freely. My point is that this shows why what we call free will is not absolute.

What is the meaning of having the absolute freedom to do whatever you want if there are conditions attached to your choices, including punishment for choosing something God has forbidden? You can still make the choice, but the choice exists within a system of rules and consequences. That is conditioned freedom, not absolute freedom.

Your Eleko Beach example actually illustrates my point. Yes, a person can freely decide to walk from Eleko Beach to Ikoyi, but the physical limitations of the environment determine what can actually happen. The person has the ability to choose, but not unlimited freedom to accomplish whatever they choose.

The same principle applies to Adam. He could freely choose to eat the fruit, but he could not choose to remove God's prohibition or the consequence attached to breaking it.

And there is another important point. As long as a being has the genuine ability to choose differently, there is always a possibility that it will choose something God does not want. Adam and Eve were perfect, yet they disobeyed. Satan was a good heavenly creature, yet he chose to rebel against God, and other angels are also described as having sinned.

So my argument is not that consequences eliminate the ability to choose. My argument is that free will is conditioned by rules, circumstances and consequences, and therefore it is not absolute. And if even perfect beings can choose against God's will, then perfection itself cannot guarantee permanent obedience.
Re: Free Will And Loyalty: What If Adam Had Not Sinned? by Truthseeker10: 8:47pm On Sep 28
wumiwumi100:
My point is that there is no such thing as absolute free will, and being perfect does not guarantee permanent obedience, even in a perfect and peaceful environment.

Adam and Eve were perfect, yet they disobeyed. Satan was a heavenly being, yet he rebelled, and other angels are also described as having sinned.

So, if free will means having the genuine ability to choose differently, then the possibility of disobedience will always remain.

A peaceful world could certainly exist, but I don't see how we can logically conclude that free will and perfection would make another test of loyalty or another act of rebellion impossible.
So in what condition do you logically think that a Peaceful world could certainly exist?
Re: Free Will And Loyalty: What If Adam Had Not Sinned? by Dtruthspeaker: 9:25pm On Sep 28
wumiwumi100:
I understand your distinction, but I think we are using "free will" differently. I am not arguing that having consequences means a person cannot exercise their will freely. My point is that this shows why what we call free will is not absolute.

What is the meaning of having the absolute freedom to do whatever you want if there are conditions attached to your choices, including punishment for choosing something God has forbidden? You can still make the choice, but the choice exists within a system of rules and consequences. That is conditioned freedom, not absolute freedom.

Your Eleko Beach example actually illustrates my point. Yes, a person can freely decide to walk from Eleko Beach to Ikoyi, but the physical limitations of the environment determine what can actually happen. The person has the ability to choose, but not unlimited freedom to accomplish whatever they choose.

The same principle applies to Adam. He could freely choose to eat the fruit, but he could not choose to remove God's prohibition or the consequence attached to breaking it.

And there is another important point. As long as a being has the genuine ability to choose differently, there is always a possibility that it will choose something God does not want. Adam and Eve were perfect, yet they disobeyed. Satan was a good heavenly creature, yet he chose to rebel against God, and other angels are also described as having sinned.

So my argument is not that consequences eliminate the ability to choose. My argument is that free will is conditioned by rules, circumstances and consequences, and therefore it is not absolute. And if even perfect beings can choose against God's will, then perfection itself cannot guarantee permanent obedience.
Ok. Your point is free will is not the same as absolute free will
1 Reply

CHRISTIANITY EXPOSED: If Adam & Eve Were Created, Explain This • If Adam And Eve Were First Humans How Did Other Races Come About • What Do You Think The World Would Have Been Like Had Man Not Sinned? • 2 • 3 • 4

Apostle Arome Osayi Needs To Be Censored. • Open Heavens 21 November 2026 • Evu Cobwebs How Pls!!!!