Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade - Foreign Affairs (3) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › Foreign Affairs › Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade (3117 Views)
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by kafeii123: 5:55am On Nov 16 |
IAM4BAT4plus4:Oh..Boko Haram is a traditional or Chrisian movement? |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by kafeii123: 5:55am On Nov 16 |
Kobojunkie:really? |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by Easyluv2live(m): 9:05am On Nov 16 |
nairalanda1:Then what will the apology do, will it bring everything back the way they where or Will automatically make all of us unite and love each other, that's not what we should be pursuing or looking for...we need to build our continent and African leaders are the worst of it |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by triplechoice(m): 9:18am On Nov 16 |
seunayantokun:Your claim that some Arab countries still have laws backing slavery is false. Slavery is illegal everywhere in the world. The trans Saharan trade was an atrocity committed against the black race. It should be discussed, taught and acknowledged. But you do not advance that cause by inventing laws that do not exist and smearing a religion. It allows anyone to dismiss everything else you said |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by joseff14(m): 9:27am On Nov 16 |
And they haven't changed a bit experts: |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by seunayantokun(m): 9:49am On Nov 16 |
triplechoice:No, I'm not excusing any at the expense of the other. My aim is to say it's hypocrisy and unacceptable when you bury your crime and seek to get another punished. Let me add that African kingdoms and states which participated in slavery were equally to blame. Remember, the British forced many of them in West Africa to stop it. There were Individuals, including the forebears of those claiming to be victims all over the world today, who were equally culpable. Some of them became slaves and were sold off after they had previously captured and/or sold off their fellow Africans. What we should realise is that the blame should be shared and we should forgive and move on. |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by seunayantokun(m): 10:11am On Nov 16 |
triplechoice:Your response tells me you need to do more to help humanity get better. I'm talking about Arab countries, but you are making it an islamic matter. Is pointing out what an Arab country has done wrong the same as smearing Islam? Where is the false equivalence coming from? Well, Arab countries may have abolished slavery but make sure none of the people close to you travel to some of the countries on Kafala. You know what Kafala is and how it's actually practised? Research it please. You can also do some internet searches on slavery in Lybia. Thank you. |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by triplechoice(m): 10:55am On Nov 16*. Modified: 11:24am On Nov 16 |
seunayantokun:Your own words reproduce for you below. seunayantokun:Focus on the substance and don't bring in your personal feelings into it. Yes, de facto slavery persists in some places, Mauritania being the clearest example. But de facto slavery is not the same as a law that permits it. Mauritania criminalised slavery in 2007 and made it a crime against humanity in 2012 . The problem they have is enforcement, not legality. Kafala is a labour sponsorship system, not a slavery statute. Conflating the two does not prove your claim. It proves you could not support it. |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by UrVillageChief: 11:16am On Nov 16 |
experts:Yes o. It doesn’t matter now that the topic is about the Arabs; your slave masters and not the Westerners. I find it extremely funny, ironic and troubling how you black Africans tend to blame White people and Christianity for slavery while deliberately exonerating Islam and the Arabs despite the fact that they later were equally guilty of the shameful practice. Ironically, the people you blame for it were actually the ones who eventually ended it globally.🤣🤣 |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by triplechoice(m): 12:05pm On Nov 16 |
seunayantokun:I agree we should forgive and find a way to move on. But before I respond to the others , please let me know the hypocrites who want to "bury" their crime and " seek to get another punished"? |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by seunayantokun(m): 1:55pm On Nov 16 |
triplechoice:My friend, 'Arab' is not the same as Islam. Two, Islam is not only a religion, it is also a political ideology. When I said 'because of islam', I was only pointing to a restricting factor which poses two faces. It's a fact that Islam is a big factor in the international diplomatic arena. Then, while we are sensitive to the religion as a matter of respect for our fellow human beings, we shouldn't be scared away from saying it as it is when we need address a political ideology which seeks to satisfy certain interests. Those who should speak up should do so without fear or favour to Islam, that's what I meant. But the problem now is, even in the West, governments, and the UN, are afraid of being tagged islamophobic. Nevertheless, shouldn't you be able to tell me the contributions of Islam as a political ideology to ending slavery and slave trade in Africa? For me, Kafala is slavery. If you love it, you can go for it. Many of those black Africans who have fallen into it don't have good stories to tell. If Kafala operated in Europe or the US, would they be attractive to people from different religious backgrounds streaming there? |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by seunayantokun(m): 2:04pm On Nov 16*. Modified: 6:28pm On Nov 16 |
triplechoice:It's hypocrisy to ask someone to tender an apology and pay reparations for an offence you're equally guilty of. All countries from any part of the world involved at the UN pushing for reparations. And those voting in support. Many of them are African/Carribbean and Arab countries. But I'm particularly pointing at the Arab countries there. |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by Kobojunkie: 2:51pm On Nov 16 |
kafeii123:I repeat, no evidence!😒😒 |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by treasureboy09(m): 3:31pm On Nov 16 |
kafeii123:That's their cup of tea, his religious viewpoint can't erase the fact/evils of the Trans-Sahara, and even in today's world even as a Muslim, he has a better shot at life with a Westerner compared to the Arabs ......... |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by Kobojunkie: 4:10pm On Nov 16*. Modified: 11:32pm On Nov 16 |
seunayantokun:Islam has never repealed its slave laws... and yes, Islam is a political system. It pretends to be a religion while imposing its legal framework as the one to rule over all, including those who want no part in it. This means that any country that runs on Sharia definitely has Slavery still embedded in its constitution. 😒😒 So, when someone says that slavery is illegal in Islamic nations, the person is literally lying. Also, included in that list of states where slavery remains legal is Nigeria-- Sharia is embedded in the Nigerian constitution to date-- which, to this day, has some of the highest rates of human trafficking cases that go uninvestigated year after year. It is intentional, again, because slavery is not necessarily illegal.😒😒 |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by favour32(m): 6:04pm On Nov 16 |
Zorn:They hid in their dungeons this time round. |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by seunayantokun(m): 11:30pm On Nov 16 |
Kobojunkie:Political correctness is political corruption. You just don't want to be politically correct. You definitely have spoken. |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by triplechoice(m): 4:01pm On Nov 17*. Modified: 7:24pm On Nov 17 |
seunayantokun:Your hypocrisy accusation rests on a premise you have never proven: that every African society participated in the trans-Saharan and transatlantic trades, or even in internal slavery. That premise is faise. It is on record that several African societies never participated in internal or the external slave trade. They banned it ,resisted it, and even formed local vigilantes to protect weaker tribes from being captured as slaves. The Jola of Casamance refused to sell captives to outsiders.The Baga of Guinea fought off slave traders. The people of Gwollu built a double-walled fortification to keep out raiders. The Maasa shielded the Kenya interior for centuries Walter Rodney argued that slavery on the upper Guinea Coast was "non existent" or marginal before the external trades began . So where are you getting it from that every tribe in Africa was guilty of slavery, and therefore deserves neither apology nor reparations? And your logic does not even add up. If the entire African population had been busy kidnapping and buying and selling one another there would have been no pool of victims left to supply the external trade for the two centuries it lasted. The market would have collapsed on the first day. But it did not collapse, because the sold vastly outnumbered the very few, who collaborated with outsiders. If the descendants of the sold, who were the majority, are now demanding an apology and the payment of reparations from those who benefitted more , even if not to every part of Africa, then at least to the communities that suffered most from this ignoble trade. where is the hypocrisy in that? It is grossly insensitive, and intellectually dishonest, to equate the millions of victim with the few guilty collaborators in order to dissolve accountability.. All countries from any part of the world involved at the UN pushing for reparations. And those voting in support. Many of them are African/Carribbean and Arab countries. But I'm particularly pointing at the Arab countries there.You are "particularly pointing at those Arab countries " because you do not have your facts right. Gulf Arab states did not co-sponsor that resolution. Those who did were Tunisia, Algeria, Comoros , Djibouti, Sudan, Somalia, Egypt, Morocco, and Mauritania. Everyone one of them is an African Union member. They signed because they are part of the African group, and their own people were affected by the trade. And that is continental solidarity, not hypocrisy. The major European beneficiaries of the trade did not sign either; Britain, France, Germany, and the rest of the EU abstained. So the Arab sates you are accusing of hypocrisy are the African ones, the victims, while the architects and major beneficiary of the trades, the Gulf states and the European stayed out. Here is a list of reference materials for some of the things I explained. The first five are peer-reviewed journal articles in established academic journals. 1. Linares, Differing to trade in slaves: The Jola of Casamance, History in Africa, vol. 14 2.Crutcher; "For kings and Empire. Kru Mariners in Atlantic Africa. The journal of African history, vol .64 3.Walter Rodney, African Slavery and Other Forms of Social Oppression on the Upper Guinea Coast. The journal of African History, vol.7 4. Decolonising Maasai History: A Path to Indigenous African Futures ( Bloomsbury Academic ,2025) Open access. Documents that Maasai warriors prevented Arab caravans from raiding for slaves in their territory. 5. Swanepoel , Natalie. 'The walls of Gwollu; conflict and cooperation in a nineteenth-century contained community, Upper West Region, Ghana. Journal of conflict Archaeology, 2025. 6. There Tarikh al- Sudan ( Abd al-Sadi, c. 1655) records a statute protecting free persons from enslavement among the Mossi. This is a primary source, stronger than a secondary article. 7 Sudan Rights Watch Network, "No more Formal slavery and oppression Against Humanity" ( 2 April 2026) Confirms the list of Arab co-sponsors as Tunisia, Algeria, Comoros, Djibouti, Sudan, Somalia, Egypt, Morocco and Mauritania.. The resolution was submitted by Ghana. When you reply to this, ensure you provide references materials for any counter argument you would present. I'm no longer interested in replying to your personal opinion or feelings and invented facts, including your strawman. Thank you. |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by triplechoice(m): 7:16pm On Nov 17 |
Kobojunkie:The claim that slavery is legal in Nigeria is false. The Nigerian constitution Article 34(1)(b), states that no person shall be held in slavery or servitude. . The criminal code Act criminalises slave dealing under the Section 369. The 2015 Trafficking in persons Act criminalises trafficking and dealing in slaves under Articles 23 and 24. Yes, it is true sharia courts exist within the legal system, but they operate under the constitution, which is the supreme law and explicitly forbids slavery So when you claim slavery is legal in Nigeria because of sharia, you are not only revealing your prejudice, you are revealing that your argument is disconnected from the law. |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by Kobojunkie: 7:50pm On Nov 17 |
seunayantokun:Until Sharia is completely stripped from the Constitution of Nigeria, Nigerians will never be able to enjoy their government, and worse, Islam, by way of the two-tier policing system that is the current system, will continue to ravage and eventually engulf the State and the region. 😒😒 So, again, anyone insisting that slavery, which is fully sanctioned under Sharia that is enshrined in the Nigerian Constitution, is illegal in Nigeria, is lying to you and me. 😒😒 |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by seunayantokun(m): 9:44pm On Nov 17 |
Kobojunkie:Correct! |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by seunayantokun(m): 9:54pm On Nov 17 |
triplechoice:You created the argument you're attacking here. I don't think I've got even 1 minute to spend with you further on this matter. Thank you. |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by triplechoice(m): 10:47pm On Nov 17 |
seunayantokun:Vague talk as usual to. dodge. Point out the "created argument" if you're sure of what you just said. |
| Re: Peacepro Urges Arab Nations To Apologise To Africa Over Trans-Sahara Slave Trade by experts(op): 6:46am On Nov 18 |
Participating as part of the value chain is not the same as creating the system, building the infrastructure, logistics, insurance etc. Those who built the infrastructure and institutions of slavery are the owners and beneficiaries and they're the one's who get compensated when it was abolished. All others were victims of circumstances |
BBC To Apologise For Doctored Trump Speech • Trump Imposes Sanctions On South Africa Over Genocide Case Against Israel. • Trump Threatens To End Aid To South Africa Over Land Policy, Ramaphosa Responds • 2 • 3 • 4
Russia Vs Usa (no Nukes) • Breaking! Joe Biden Signs Executive Order Paving Way To An End Of The USD • Obama Depicted As Murderous Devil In Moscow