Understanding Religious Delusions. - Christianity Etc - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Understanding Religious Delusions. (6804 Views)
| Understanding Religious Delusions. by NoContract(op): 11:52am On Dec 08, 2013*. Modified: 1:27pm On Nov 20, 2014 |
Let's imagine that I tell you the following story: |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by NoContract(op): 11:52am On Dec 08, 2013*. Modified: 1:27pm On Nov 20, 2014 |
One final examplehttp://godisimaginary.com/i7.htm |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Aafulenu(f): 12:08pm On Dec 08, 2013 |
Wow! |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by mymz(f): 2:14pm On Dec 08, 2013 |
^^ yea. wow. @Op, while there may be little or no evidence of the above mentioned "imaginary stories", It doesn't stop the millions who believe in them because for some reason, it comforts man to be, as u've so clearly shown, "deluded". my two cents however is this; I know for sure that there exists or existed a master plan somewhere, when this entire dimension -life-was being thought out. (I guess it suffices to cast myself among the "deluded" lot seeing as there's no proof of this either) who the master planner is ? why he/she chose this plan? what objective is this plan supposed to accomplish ? when will this plan come to fruition and what happens after this plan runs its course? all these questions and more, we obviously do not have answers to. albeit, yet. the way I see it, everyone has made a choice; those who believe in some doctrine or the other, those who don't believe in any, those who want (or need) proof before they believe and those who don't want or need to believe in anything at all, proof or no proof. now, the variants of religions out there, all preach punishment and reward for disobedience and obedience, respectively. they all also tell of a God somewhere, an afterlife, and all claim they are the sure way towards getting into the good place in the afterlife. is there an afterlife? - I guess someone has to 'die' and 'resurrect' with that info. why were we made with a mind of our own and the ability to choose if we're just meant to tow a particular line? - o yea, I forgot, rewards and punishments. but why would I be punished or rewarded when there's no clear path to the right choice? my summary is this: so far, the only set of people who are trying to get answers to the millions of questions that mankind is afflicted with, are scientists. if I was God, and I created the world and indeed commanded Abraham to "go forth into the world and multiply", I'd welcome back into my arms the more productive sets of 'Abrahams'. #my2-probably-more-cents |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by unmask: 6:58pm On Dec 09, 2013 |
Quite insightful |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by unmask: 8:31am On Dec 11, 2013 |
this post should be on front page its especially for those with religion tolerance issues |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Nobody: 9:20pm On Dec 13, 2013 |
Sir, I void your first example. Santa clus indeed existed But the story surrounding him has been beautified to make him look extra ordinary. I live around the northpole today and would testify its wasn't a fairy tale. It happened real and people witnessed it. Just like every other rich wealthy people you see today who offer money to charity. Beside he didnt do it like all his life, the king of those small city at so e point invited him, offered him some money to continue doing that to encourage young kids. " santa is coming to town" yes of cus he has been paid to do so. Same applies to online business today. Most online startup first started by offering freebies, then when they became famous, they had people pay them to continue to offer freebies. Offering gift was a charitable function. He built and offered affordable gift to families whose kids behaved well during that year to encourage them. Let me remind you that this gift were mostly handmade wooden and fur gift? wood is common here. He rode on reindeer becUse that was the only means of transport over there in north pole where there are huge snow logged. The reindeer didnt fly. Lol only if it was a superman. Dont know about other stories, but as for this one, i confirm it to be true but beautified truth. |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Ranchhoddas: 11:42pm On Dec 13, 2013 |
@op Very insightful but factor in supernatural occurences in places of worship(churches,mosques,etc)and ur whole claim that religion is a total delusion is invalidated.PS:i expect you to come and start trying to rationalize those 'alleged' occurences. |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by NoContract(op): 11:34am On Dec 15, 2013 |
Ranchhoddas: @op Very insightful but factor in supernatural occurences in places of worship(churches,mosques,etc)and ur whole claim that religion is a total delusion is invalidated.PS:i expect you to come and start trying to rationalize those 'alleged' occurences.This is not a story book. Re read and use your common sense. I am not a professor! |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by samsard(m): 11:56am On Dec 15, 2013 |
Well well well, well said, but like xtians will tell you: "have faith". *laughs* |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by ChristyG(f): 10:33pm On Oct 13, 2014 |
WOW THIS IS ONE OF THE BEST ARTICLES HAVE EVER READ ![]() |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by simplex2: 4:33pm On Nov 09, 2014 |
![]() ![]() |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Nobody: 10:49pm On Nov 09, 2014 |
@OP, you are taking stories in isolation and trying to pass them as fables. Now if YOU told me today that you rode on a mythical horse to heaven, it is a fable... I would not believe you. However, if thousands of people of known integrity and position vouched for your honesty, and in addition, you produced equally fabulous signs attested to by friend and foe alike. You presented a Book of unsurpassed prose, teaching moral codes and ethics which could reasonably be proved to be years ahead of your time, and providing a practical way of life unmatched by any -ism or -acy available to mankind. If also, you gained neither wealth nor worldly advantage through the dissemination of your claims, and died in a mud hut on a straw mat, principled to your teachings, despite the fact that millions followed you and would have built mighty palaces for you if you had just commanded it. Would I then believe you if you said that you rode to heaven on a mythical horse? Definitely... such a great person could not be a liar. It is not comforting to be "deluded" to believe in accountability to our Creator. I would imagine that it would be more comforting to believe that I can indulge in all kinds of vices, fornicate with other men's wives, steal, rob, pillage and at the end of all that; if I am smart and don't get caught, and I take my vitamins regularly; live to ripe old age, die and escape all accountability for my misdeeds. It is atheists who derive comfort from their delusions. |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by UyiIredia(m): 11:12pm On Nov 09, 2014 |
Abuamam:Well said. It isn't comforting to stand risking hell or deprive yourself of lusts. |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by simplex2: 6:14am On Nov 10, 2014 |
UyiIredia:Lol...91% of christians are so because of the fear of hell; only 9% because of the true love of god. **the fear factor** |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by simplex2: 6:21am On Nov 10, 2014 |
Abuamam:All the 3 cases the Op quoted had thousands of people vouching for their stories and still produced great books considered divine by their millions of followers. Shall we then conclude that they all are true? Even someone here on this thread is vouching that santa claus is real..lol @last paragraph, true muslims don't steal, fornicate or even drink alcohol. Moral people without religious background don't do those things either. So I don't get your point. |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by UyiIredia(m): 7:03am On Nov 10, 2014 |
simplex2:What of for the love of heaven ? |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Nobody: 8:49am On Nov 10, 2014 |
@simplx2 True, moral people without religion don't do many of those things. However they believe that even if they do, nothing happens, and they are not going to account to anyone anyway. So you would agree with me that there is less barrier to doing things if the situation arises. As for the stories above, you are wrong. I refer to substantiated evidence with an established, well researched chain of narrators. I do not know how other religions authenticate their chain of narrations, but in Islam, the science of authenticating chains of narrators is an academic field in itself, with Phd holders. Each and every statement attributed to our prophet (saw), as well as others who heard from him, is carefully analysed and ranked based on degree of authenticity. |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Nobody: 5:00am On Nov 11, 2014*. Modified: 7:14am On Nov 11, 2014 |
This mildly reminded me of a piece of non-fiction I'd picked up, but haven't had the proper chance to get into. It's about a psychiatric case study on three institutionalized schizophrenics who all thought they were Jesus Christ. |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Nobody: 5:23am On Nov 11, 2014 |
EnlightenedSoul:http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Three_Christs_of_Ypsilanti http://www.weirdexperiments.com/06ypsilanti.htm |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Nobody: 5:41am On Nov 11, 2014*. Modified: 7:14am On Nov 11, 2014 |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Sagamite(m): 11:48am On Nov 13, 2014 |
Abuamam:From your username and reference to a story synonymous with the Buraq, I am assuming you are a Muslim. Now, please kindly explain to us which "people known for integrity" vouched for the stories told by Muhammed. Explain to them how you came to the conclusion that the judgement of their integrity and honesty is reasonable. Then progress by educating us on what "fabulous signs" you refer to. We will start from there. There are still other parts of your post I will want to jointly review later. |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Sagamite(m): 11:51am On Nov 13, 2014 |
Abuamam:We will review statements from this as well later. |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Nobody: 6:31pm On Nov 13, 2014 |
Sagamite:Yes I am a muslim now, though have previously denied that God exists. The science of hadith thoroughly vouches each and every person involved in a chain of narrators. His life history is studied for evidence of truthfulness, possibility of forgetfulness, whether he historically lived in the time period and location as the person he claimed to have recieved the information from, and the probability of his having studied or actually heard from the person. And the process continues up the chain of narrators directly to the person(s) who saw the event directly from the prophet (saw). The process does not stop there. Evidence is sought from independent sources for collaborating narrative of the same event. These independent sources would likely have their own chain of narrators who also undergo thorough vouching. This goes on until all the chains for a specific hadith have been vouched. We are looking at a single statement from the prophet (saw) here, or a single action. The hadith can then be ranked as authentic, acceptable, weak or fabricated... to mention the simplest form of ranking. This system of historical narrative is the most reliable possible, and no other historical events undergo such authentication; historians of other events often base their hypotheses on a single faded papyrus and it gets accepted worldwide. The muslim system requires exhaustive examination before acceptance. "Fabulous signs" are a reference to signs that are inexplicable from a scientific perspective. These events or 'miracles' if you like, occurred hundreds of times during the life of the prophet (saw). While muslims believe that such miracles are not exclusive to prophets or 'Godly' men, and we do not boast of them as signs of prophethood, we know that many such scientifically inexplicable signs did occur by his agency. I mention it here not as evidence of the truth of Islam, but to inform you that the story of the Buraq is just one out of hundreds of transmitted narrations of different miracles. |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Nobody: 6:41pm On Nov 13, 2014 |
simplex2:No one vouches for Santa Claus' existence except 3 year olds. Hardly considered to be historians. As for biblical accounts, there are thousands of extant different copies, with different narratives. The authors of most of the narratives are considered to be unknown by Christian scholars and there are no authentifiable chains of narrators back to the time frame that Jesus is believed to have been on earth. For this reason, from an Islamic perspective, biblical narratives cannot be ranked in any manner so as to verify their truth or lack of it. They are just stories that define a faith. We believe that a few could be accurate, but we can not identify which, if any, are true. So we remain silent on that issue. Islamic narratives are a different ball game entirely. |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Sagamite(m): 6:44pm On Nov 13, 2014 |
Abuamam:I doubt this answers my questions. I asked you to name the people of integrity you refer to. And why you see them as people with integrity. All you gave us here was that you believe the writings because the same writings by the illiterates argue that the writings are true and was validated by following generations of illiterates. Secondly, you propagate that their evidence of things happening is by researching if the dates are aligned to the time Muhammed was there. That begs the question, in the case of the Buraq, how did they very if Muhammed flew to heaven on an Imaginary horse or spoke to an Angel while in a cave on his own. You now progressed by referring to "independent sources" which you did not name. What "independent sources"? Abuamam:Again you waffle and everything else expect answer the question. What fabolous signs? What miracles or events were "attested for by friends and foes"? |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Nobody: 7:36pm On Nov 13, 2014 |
Sagamite:In this case, google is your friend. I am not going to list thousands of narrators for miraculous events and the personal history and scholarship of each one of them for you. As for their illiteracy, all I can say is you are threading the same path that fanatic deists thread. Denigrating to win points. Does that make you a fanatic atheist? Logical atheists should always retain their acclaimed objectivity. I assume it was a typing error. The narrators include reknowned scholars and historians of their time, to cut a long story short. In any case, a Phd in nuclear physics is not essential to narrating a witnessed or learnt event, so their academic qualifications should not be topics of discussion. Miracles of the prophet (saw) are in the hundreds. Again google is your friend. My premise is not that you must believe the story of the Buraq. My premise is that your method of disproving an event is erroneous. That you 'think' that religion is a delusional because you 'think' that certain events narrated are impossible, is not following logical procedure; unless of course you consider yourself to be omniscient, and your thoughts to be absolute. |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Sagamite(m): 8:05pm On Nov 13, 2014 |
Abuamam:Oh, now it is "google is your friend"? ![]() So you cannot name any of the people you so confidently proclaimed as men with integrity? Nor can you name your miracles? Why? You pulled those arguments from your arsse? |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Nobody: 8:12pm On Nov 13, 2014 |
Sagamite:Thank you for your time. Obviously we are not on the same level here to have a meaningful discussion. |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Sagamite(m): 8:17pm On Nov 13, 2014 |
Abuamam:Yep, we are not on the same level. I have a brain at a higher level that sees through BS argument, BS stories and can never bring myself to follow such BS because some medieval illiterates fell for the BS and passed it down. I have a highly functional brain that means I can tell it is BS about a man flying on a Horse to heaven to speak to God and then say "it is verified because some illiterate medieval people believed it". |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Nobody: 10:01pm On Nov 13, 2014 |
Sagamite:Ok. Congratulations. |
| Re: Understanding Religious Delusions. by Sagamite(m): 7:46am On Nov 14, 2014*. Modified: 8:05am On Nov 14, 2014 |
Abuamam:If I was to take pleasure in shredding more of your arguments by picking up another thinking below my level, I would say it was more delusional to believe a man that: Cuts off people's heads, orders torture to obtain treasure, spreads his unverified and unverifiable proclamations by the sword of killing, orders killings of unarmed poets for verbal/written challenges of his proclamations, orders killings for refusal to accept his proclamations and follow him, orders the killing of followers that change their minds and want to leave the religion, orders and participates in armed robberies, treats those that are not his followers as inferior beings, takes slaves, raapes his female slaves etc would not qualify to be accountable to "your Creator" for any misdeeds. Rather you believe "your Creator" would see him as a hero is what I would regard as deriving comfort from low-level thinking delusions. At my level, you don't need to be omniscient to know those are wrong and unacceptable in any transcendental realm, even if you believe in unverified and unverifiable junk folklores. At least, you can see now that Google has all this while been my cousin and you don't need to introduce it to me as a friend. |
The Delusions Of Forgiveness And The Christian Morality. • PROOF: Understanding Religious Delusion • Understanding Religious Delusion • 2 • 3 • 4
Beware: Spacetacular Is Felixomor • See The Oldest Catholic Church In Eastern Nigeria, Started In 1886: Pics • Archbishop Resigns Over S-e-x Scandal
THIS IS ONE OF THE BEST ARTICLES HAVE EVER READ 
