₦airaland Forum

The fact of the matter is that Nigeria operates two broadly classified foreign exchange markets. There is the official market, where the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) funds banks, who in turn fund their customers’ offshore transactions. Banks basically bid for foreign currencies at the CBN on behalf of their clients. Banks also trade their own foreign exchange liquidity amongst themselves, at a small premium over the CBN rate, but still under the ambience of the official market.

The other foreign exchange market is the parallel market. It is big credit to the reform of this market since its dark, chaotic past, decades ago that it is hardly again called “black market” that it once was. Today, the parallel market is officially recognised and funded by the CBN.

Whereas the official market is mainly for wholesale transactions, the parallel market serves retail purposes. Industrial imports are funded through the official market, as well as officially recognised trade and foreign consumption bills. On the other hand, the retail market accommodates all sorts of transactions, many of which are off the official radar and sometimes counter-productive to trade.

However, the official and parallel markets to a lesser extent serve the financial stability policy purpose of the Central Bank. The CBN also uses its exchange rate policy to manage inflation. For a country that meets substantial local demands for intermediate and finished products through importation, the domestic inflation is largely pressurised by the prices of imports.

In the past few months, the CBN has for good reasons prioritised stability of exchange rate in the official market. It has drawn an exclusion list of avoidable imports from being funded in the official market. With the forex demand for the items transferred to the parallel market, rates in that market have soared. But in truth, the effect of this has had almost no negative impact on the standard of living of the average citizen. The prices of locally produced items, especially food, have remained relatively stable and benign for the inflationary outlook, according to recent data by Nigerian Bureau of Statistics.

What is apparent, therefore, is that the parallel market is subordinate to the official market. The official market is also much bigger than the parallel market. With this alone, the anomaly of profiling the foreign exchange market by parallel market rates is obvious. Yet, the abnormality of a smaller part defining the bigger part has held sway in sensational reporting of the foreign exchange rates since the country started dealing with the practical implications of fallen oil prices with low reserve buffers since November 2014.

So, we hear and read the screaming headlines of the naira crashing to “all time low” and the currency exchanging at 280.00 to one U.S. dollar. The sharp rises in the dollar exchange rate have been in the parallel market. But this volatility has not been allowed to extend to the official market where the most economically important transactions are funded. Although the dollar exchanged for N280.00 at the Bureau de change (BDC) in the week before Christmas -- and even retreated immediately, by the way – at the official market, the dollar has continued to exchange at N199.00 since March.

While parallel market rates should not be denied the deck, it is pandering to sensationalism for them to be headline grabber. Unwittingly, the existing reportage is serving the interests of speculators. Sensational reporting of an increase in the exchange rate can drive further increases by building a surge of speculative demand pressure.

What is anticipated has a huge influence on the reality in financial markets. As much as speculation can drive up equity prices, even so can it drive down the value of the currency. While the two asset classes are driven in two opposite direction by the same stimulus, the consequences are the same: financial instability.

It is important to understand the reason for the disparity of up to N80.00 (as at December 18th) between the official and the parallel markets. Contrary to the reportage in the media, the official exchange rate is the reporting exchange rate for the economy. Allowing this rate to adjust rapidly, can cause irreparable damage to the economy years after the country achieves a better foreign reserve position. This risk is especially true because of the speculative demand for dollars in the system.

Given this factor, the CBN has taken a position -- which, reasonably, is backed by the Administration of President Buhari -- to protect the official market from speculation and damaging devaluation. It is of course far less damaging both in the present and the future if the uncontrolled exchange rate adjustment takes place in the parallel market. At the return of more auspicious times, the CBN can easily deploy policy measures that would correlate the parallel market to the official market. This can be as simply as supplying more liquidity to the parallel market or relaxing the extant restrictions in the official market.

Nigerians, widely travelled as we are, are not unfamiliar with the variations between official and parallel market rates abroad. Within the precinct of Heathrow Airport and other international aviation hubs, wide disparities are noticed in the rates offered by the BDCs operating there and rates outside, say, in the banks. The unofficial higher rates don’t for this reason supplant the official rate in reporting the economy.

Media reportage of the domestic market has deviated from this norm. In a sense, this deviation may be a reflection of the struggle of Nigerians in accepting the necessary adjustment we have to make in support of the efforts of the government and the CBN in promoting import substitution and economic diversification. Although we all want to see a much more diversified Nigerian economy, we may have limited the requirements for achieving the diversification to government. But the reality is that, as a people, we have to make adjustment in our tastes. Not only should we be ready to replace foreign products with local substitutes; we must be prepared to let go of some exotic products, even where there is no direct alternative. It is part of the demand of building a virile country and a sustainable economy.

The Nigerian Export-Import Bank has in the last six years renewed focus on the industrial sectors – manufacturing, agro-processing, solid minerals and services. The Bank has been facilitating non-oil exports, to help the country earn more foreign exchange and thereby support the objective of a stable exchange rate. This focus is in line with the institutional mandate of NEXIM Bank as the official Trade Policy Bank of the Federal Government. But as the current oil price slump lays bare, this is a national imperative.

Perhaps the CBN should have more consideration for increasing the public awareness of the objectives of its foreign exchange policy and their practical implications right to the local market. However, the media would have to exercise a lot of discretion in reporting data from the foreign exchange markets. If the unofficial, “black market” prices of petrol around the country do not subsume the official price of N87 per litre, it is completely wrong to designate the foreign exchange markets by parallel market rates. Doing so actually distorts market reality.

Culled From FinancialNigeria.com

Nice write up, explain a lot but I will like to ask why is the parallel market rate affecting the banks that they have to restrict usage of card abroad and why does the bank don't transact with the CBN official rates?

zinosleek:
Nice write up, explain a lot but I will like to ask why is the parallel market rate affecting the banks that they have to restrict usage of card abroad and why does the bank don't transact with the CBN official rates?

You asked astute questions.
Here are a few facts:
Buhari was elected to fight corruption and improve the plight of the poor.
The parallel (emphasis on 'BLACK') market is illegal- a criminal act, according to the law.
Therefore since May 29, there should have been multiple arrests of all those trading in foreign currency outside official channels.
The arrests will never happen because the black market is run by a northern cabal.
Thanks to BVN, there is now a means to monitor every dollar that's issued by the CBN: Even if you enter the country with dollars, at the very least a scan of your passport can be made to ID any sellers of foreign currency that didn't originate from the CBN.
This monitoring by the regulator will not happen because of said cabal; in fact, I've read newspaper articles that have asked these same questions.
Also a particular columnist has been begging the CBN to issue dollar certificates- which are not transferable- to all importers thereby ensuring that round-tripping is curtailed, even if not eliminated.
------------------------------
Regarding it's regulatory role, the CBN under Emifiele could have simply raised taxes on those 41 items, instead of driving an artificial scarcity.
OR: If a ban was the way it insisted on going, a deadline for the ban on dollar access for those items would have both ended their importation and given importers time to sell off their goods and transfer their funds to other import areas- without passing on the effects of higher fund costs to their Nigerian customers- thereby weakening the naira's value.

The joke is that the importers actually GOT the funds from unofficial channels, thereby denying the economy the benefits of the dollar purchase tariffs they would have paid! Some even went to neighbouring countries to send dollars when they were banned from paying into their accounts!!
This means that the entire payment for their imports completely by-passed our economy and benefited our neighbours!!!

This all means that the CBN has been trying to manage the damage that IT ACTUALLY CAUSED!

Factor in the utter lack of any economic policy in GMB's first 6 months and you have the inability of the economy- had it been under proper management- to cushion the effects of the ban.

So there's little value in talking about how wonderful a job the CBN is doing when it's the source of the problem. By the way, restricting access to any currency simply makes it more expensive. This is simple, common sense. So restrictions on dollar access have actually worsened the situation, making the naira weaker against ALL CURRENCIES.

As an aside, the 'sensationalism' arises because now, the black market is about the ONLY source of 'short term' access- the various official methods favour large, industrial players and institutional buyers of dollars, not the SMEs who need it for their day-to-day; the irony being that the same CBN will claim that these SMEs are the drivers of the economy.

Meanwhile, two questions:
Why has the FEC not given a deadline for all financial industry players to put a stop to the black market, as the much touted 'best practice' in developed nations?
What happened to the news report we all got that banks have over $5billion in their vaults?

God help us all.

Oh, I actually forgot to comment on your post title:
Things ARE worse than they appear to be.
The single stone of Emefiele's ban on 41 items has caused a ripple effect.
The effects are what he's been trying to counter and cover up with all the further restrictions he's placed no dollar access.