Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church - Christianity Etc (11) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church (27425 Views)
1 2 3 ... 8 9 10 11 12 Reply (Go Down)
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by gemale(m): 7:42pm On Feb 22, 2016 |
Sacluxpaint:Check scripture well "hail Mary" were d 1st words angel Gabriel spoke 2 Mary. Those words weren't angel Gabriel's own. Dey were of God. So if God hailed Mary, y shldnt we hail her too? R u bigger Dan God? If u r, I'm nt. So I say "hail Mary, mother of God & my mother also". |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by gemale(m): 7:45pm On Feb 22, 2016 |
Sacluxpaint:Those was no Bible then. Those were Jewish books dt was being quoted then. Portions were later incorporated in2 d bible as d old testament. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by gemale(m): 8:16pm On Feb 22, 2016 |
Sacluxpaint:I read it. D fact is dt D author was practicing Catholicism just 2 pls his father. I was 1ce lyk dt until I left & later came back. All those allegations r something a priest in d church wld poke full of holes. Where he started missing it was @ d beginning when he said d church doesn't encourage discussions abt their beliefs. Very wrong. D same church dt gruels her priests in training wt philosophy, critical thinking, theology so dt dey r well grounded & truly blv in it. I wld always remember fondly when I took an adult confirmation class in my parish. It was an open discussion group where we cld ask questions concerning our doubts abt d Catholic faith. It was so lively & most tyms we might even spend d duration of dt class discussing our questions & digressing 4rm our lesson 4 dt day. It was dere dt I knew d Catholic teachings were indeed divinely inspired. If I had ample time & was less busy, I wld have researched d dude's allegations & constructed a befitting, enlightening response. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by Nobody: 10:10pm On Feb 22, 2016 |
gemale:I believe thats Luke 1:28, it was hail, check YOUR own bible, nothing like Mary followed after the 'Hail' and the angel was just greeting Mary, more like Peace be with you, do not be afraid, the angel said that to calm her down. You Catholics are fond of twisting scripture to suit your doctrines. If this is the way you want OP to remain in the catholic faith, brother you have to try harder. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by eaglejay13(m): 6:16am On Feb 23, 2016 |
Sacluxpaint:What about following Jesus and hailing Mary at the same time? I'm happy you said "hail" not "worship" |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by Mariner007: 6:46pm On Mar 02, 2016 |
eaglejay13:How does that translate to him baptized based on trinitarian doctrine? |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by Mariner007: 6:47pm On Mar 02, 2016 |
Ubenedictus:Answer my own questions. If you can't answer say so. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by Mariner007: 6:49pm On Mar 02, 2016 |
Ubenedictus:Hahaha! Okay, since you deny all I have said as being your own doctrines and all, tell me your creed, let me still prove it wrong based on the bible. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by eaglejay13(m): 7:55pm On Mar 02, 2016 |
Mariner007:If you don't understand this simple explanation, then you're not yet ready for the truth, neither are you ready to be a good Christian |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by Mariner007: 12:20am On Mar 03, 2016 |
eaglejay13:Please leave that talk. Show me any person that was baptized based on trinitarian doctrine in the bible, I will believe you! Stop trying to connect different things to make it mean what you want. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by Ubenedictus(m): 9:42am On Mar 03, 2016 |
Mariner007:ill give u an example of a creed. d word creed come form the latin credo, ie i belive, it contain a summary of beliefs below is a catholic creed I believe in God the father almighty maker of heaven and earth, i believe in Jesus christ his only son our lord who was concieved by d power of d holyspirit born of d virgin mary suffered under pontius pilate was crucified died and was buried, decended into hades the 3rd day he rose again from the dead he ascended into heaven sitted at d right hand of God d fada almighty from whence he shall come to judge d living and d dead, i believe in the holy spirit, the holy catholic church, the communion of saints, the forgiveness of sins the ressurrection of the bodyy and lifee everlasting Dat is a catholic creed, if u dont know what a creed is go and learn. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by Mariner007: 11:09am On Mar 03, 2016 |
Ubenedictus:Haba! Don't you believe these as well: 1. THE VIRGIN MARY AS CO-REDEMPTRIX, MEDIATRIX AND ADVOCATE 2. THREE gods 3. Baptism in titles and not a Name. ANSWER my questions too. Show me a single person baptized based on the trintarian doctrine in the bible!! I am still waiting! Weeks have passed! |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by eaglejay13(m): 12:25pm On Mar 03, 2016 |
Mariner007:What makes it different things? You're not just ready for the truth, it's right in front of you, but you just don't want it. I won't reply you again because people like you ain't worth my time. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by gemale(m): 5:18pm On Mar 03, 2016 |
Sacluxpaint:maka y guy? dis is an issue of simple english language. who was d angel speaking 2 when he said "hail"? was it nt mary? So in essence, what u r saying is dt God wasnt speaking thru d angel gabriel? because u r insinuating dt gabriel added his own words 2 God's message. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by gemale(m): 5:24pm On Mar 03, 2016 |
Mariner007:Go & read d great commision by Jesus according 2 d gospel of saint matthew "go ye in2 d world & make disciples of all nations;baptizing dem IN D NAME OF D FATHER AND OF D SON AND OF THE HOLY SPIRIT (D Holy Trinity)". |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by Mariner007: 9:55pm On Mar 04, 2016 |
gemale:Those are titles and not names. Okay O! Show me ONE person baptized in that in the bible. I'll stop and believe you! If you can't. well, I'll still be waiting. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by gemale(m): 12:02am On Mar 05, 2016 |
Mariner007:Guy ur reasoning ehn! what is a title if nt a name? Dey can b used interchangeably. If u r waiting 4 d name trinity in d bible, it doesnt appear bt its meaning is contained dere. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by Mariner007: 9:25am On Mar 05, 2016 |
gemale:What I am telling you is that there are no 3 gods, but 1 God operating in 3 offices. Should I explain more? |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by Peritus(m): 11:47am On Mar 05, 2016 |
Mariner007:This you said is true, but the three offices or manifestations of one God are employed in baptism. That portion of the Bible did not say, "baptize in the name of the father or the son or the spirit" |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by Peritus(m): 12:02pm On Mar 05, 2016*. Modified: 12:26pm On Mar 05, 2016 |
Anybody arguing the intercessory role of Mary has completely misplaced her place in redemption. Her last statement in the Bible is "anything He tells you, do it". Same with the voice of God during transfiguration, "this is my beloved son with whom I'm well pleased, LISTEN TO HIM". The same Jesus whom we we're commanded to listen to, told us that He is the way, the truth and the life, and that we who are heavily ladened should come to Him that He will give us rest. That He is the true vine and we are the branches, which means we are attached to him. He is our source of life. He is in us and we in Him. We look on to Him, the author and finisher of our faith. Why then do we defy His instructions by treating Him as though he is very far from us by going through the saints and His mother. He is ready to listen to us, instead, we go back to His mother who has directed us to Him. Mary has done her job and has been well rewarded. I respect/love her, but she just did her job well and nothing more. Again, the role assigned to Mary by Catholics is almost same as Christ's. Check this prayer to "OUR LADY OF PERPETUAL HELP". ((O Mother of Perpetual Help, grant that I may ever invoke thy most powerful name, which is the safeguard of the living and the salvation of the dying. O Purest Mary, O Sweetest Mary, let thy name henceforth be ever on my lips. Delay not, O Blessed Lady, to help me whenever I call on thee, for, in all my needs, in all my temptations I shall never cease to call on thee, ever repeating thy sacred name, Mary, Mary. O what consolation, what sweetness, what confidence, what emotion fill my soul when I pronounce thy sacred name, or even only think of thee. I thank God for having given thee, for my good, so sweet, so powerful, so lovely a name. But I will not be content with merely pronouncing thy name: let my love for thee prompt me ever to hail thee, Mother of Perpetual Help.)) Now tell me if this prayer is seeking her intercession aside exulting her "most powerful name" which is the "salvation of the dying". How would God feel when His people exult the name of Mary instead. How would Mary feel? Do you know also that several saints are seen to possess certain powers, exercisable from heaven. Either St Anthony or Jude is known to be the saint for lost items. you pray to him when in search of lost item. Another saint is for love, another for healing, etc. Then you pray to them when in need of those. This is complete distortion of the Scripture. What is the position of Holy spirit (our comforter/helper) in Catholic church? Do you have any prayer to Him, but you have several to Mary and saints, why? Who is your comforter, who is your advocate? The same God, so pray to Him alone. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by Mariner007: 12:32pm On Mar 05, 2016 |
Peritus:What I am meaning to do is to let my friends know that there is only 1 God and not 3 as they believe. Nothing like trinity. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by Nobody: 6:38pm On Mar 05, 2016 |
gemale:The problem with you is that you tried to seek answers with a carnal mind(1 Corinthians 1:20-31). Did you genuinely give your life to Christ? Did you personally accept him as your personal lord and saviour? Instead you went to a priest who is a human being like you and he gave you books of human wisdom.(James 1:5) . Let God be true and every man a liar( Romans 3:4).Even if Jesus appears before you today, you would still run to virgin mary and the saints. If you want to seek God, worship him in truth and in spirit(John 4:24). God bless you and help your soul to seek divine understanding. Amen. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by dukum: 6:39pm On Mar 05, 2016 |
Mariner007:Truly u are ignorant,been observing your post and trying to avoid this but what the hell,no catholic believes in tree gods.drop ur know it all attitude and get your facts right, if u truly want to have a meaningful discussion (obviously it seems like u want to say u know better and your words are absolute). |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by Nobody: 6:41pm On Mar 05, 2016 |
eaglejay13:Trying to be clever by half, you know what I am talking about... |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by dukum: 6:46pm On Mar 05, 2016 |
Sacluxpaint:Did you think before writing this,or are all this just assumptions from a mindset with a feeling of grandiose? Go find out the problem with you before you see that in others. Again to mariner and sacluxpaint and any other protestant(funny beyond words),for as long as you are a christain you are still doing something Catholic. Stick to your beliefs and drop your know it all attitude. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by Mariner007: 7:22pm On Mar 05, 2016 |
dukum:I don't know it all. I am basing everything on the bible they say they wrote. And to emphasize, baptizing with titles is just as if you are not baptized. Let me shock you more. Marriages done based with the titles are not even marriages. Let me break it down my friend. Let's use someone popular, say Buhari. Buhari has a wife, and she calls him her HUSBAND Buhari has a daughter, and she call him FATHER Buhari is the presiding over a country, and we call him PRESIDENT. Now tell me, do you or I have the right to Buhari as our HUSBAND or FATHER? NO! But he is the PRESIDENT to us. Does ZAHRA have the right to him as a HUSBAND? no! But he is her FATHER. But watch he is the very same person. But manifesting in 3 offices and not 3 different people. Just as I said. To summarize, all I am saying is that the titles you cling onto, is nothing without the NAME. So the name (and not names) of the Father, Son , Holy Ghost is Our Lord Jesus Christ. Well, if you don't believe, I wouldn't force you. I am just pointing out the holes. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by eaglejay13(m): 9:15pm On Mar 05, 2016 |
Sacluxpaint:I don't. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by gemale(m): 11:49pm On Mar 05, 2016*. Modified: 12:42am On Mar 06, 2016 |
Sacluxpaint:see below 4 reply. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by gemale(m): 12:40am On Mar 06, 2016 |
Sacluxpaint:Dude! it seems u didn't read wt i typed well. All those things u asked, i had done all dt & even started vilifying d catholic church (lyk u). I felt i had reached where God wanted me 2 b & dt all i needed 2 nw was ask d Holy spirit (who i received) 2 help me interpret scripture when i read it. I was initially reluctant 2 c d priest because i saw dem as blind leaders of d blind bt in line wt d 10 commandments dt tells us 2 honor our parents (d only commandment wt a blessing attached),i had 2 obey. So i left wt d purpose of defending my new found 'faith' (kinda lyk saul). I prayed b4 leaving asking God earnestly 2 let His spirit take control so dt dere wld b no manifestation of d flesh. I expected d priest 2 try defending d catholic faith bt he didn't. Those books he gave me werent books dt derided Protestantism & Pentecostalism. Dey were an in depth delving in2 d reasons behind d various articles of d catholic faith wt scriptural & theological backing. B4 reading every book i was given, i asked d Holy spirit 4 illumination & discernment (nw i understand d meaning of d 1st words spoken when saying d Rosary "come Holy spirit & fill d heart of d faithful" 2 which d response is "& en-kindle in us d fire of Ur love" )& disabused myself of d mindset dt "catholic is evil & Pentecostal is good" & adopted d mindset of "is Catholicism really of God?, does it teach divinely inspired doctrines?, is it possible dt i could b wrong abt d catholic church?, y does it teach wt it teaches?". Wt every book i read, d same feeling dt made me decide 2 c d priest (divinely ordained obedience) made me realize i was wrong abt d catholic church. 2 reject d discoveries & knowledge i garnered 4rm reading those books wld have been me rejecting d truth i claimed 2 seek. Reading those books made me realize dt d bible is a basic instruction manual. 2 rely on it solely wld b lyk a student of chemistry saying new school chemistry (popularly called ababio) is d only true chemistry textbook & any oda chemistry textbook dt doesnt replicate wt it says exactly is false. Imagine if dis student still sticks 2 d same mindset when he is running a masters or doctorate program. Ur snide comment abt me seeing d priest shows pride (a vice) & ignorance of d fact dt God speaks & acts thru humans sometimes even in their imperfections. Nobody is perfect or infallible bt everybody is created in d image of God therefore dere is still d tendency (no matter hw small) 2 reflect His nature. After all St. Augustine said "O God who created our hearts; truly our hearts r restless until dey rest in You". In seeking Jesus, i found out dt He isn't alone. He is in d company of God d Father,d Holy spirit, His mother Mary, the angels & saints. My relationship with Him means dt i am His & He & His is mine. His mother is my mother. His followers whether on earth or in heaven r my brother & sisters & dey can offer prayers of intercession on my behalf (what Pentecostals call "standing in d gap" . We r all in d family of God. I cant claim 2 b a member of dis family & shun oda members. Dts y d church is a community & isnt isolated ie members interact wt 1 anoda. Yes Christianity is abt a personal relationship wt God bt it is reflected by our relationship wt odas. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by eaglejay13(m): 4:12am On Mar 06, 2016 |
gemale:Bros, well done, but if you think these people will listen to you and have a change of heart, you're wasting your time, I know their type, they know the truth but don't want to accept it, they just want to find non existent faults. Imagine somebody saying Catholic believes there are three God's even when the Catholic Creed begins with "I believe in One God". |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by mjblinks(f): 10:47am On Mar 06, 2016 |
gemale:You didn't tell me the names of the books as you promised. |
| Re: Why I May Have To Leave The Catholic Church by misreal(m): 11:41am On Mar 06, 2016 |
Speechless3:firstly,you need to hand over your life to christ.....blv me sir,catholic dont teach the bible,and if you continue reading the bible,you will soon find out y everybody is not a sinner as you were thought in catholic.the word of God will so purify u dat u will hate sin with perfect hatred and you will begin to see yourrself live far above sin.i recommend you find a good bible believinng church or fellowship. |
Names Of Victims Of Ozubulu Catholic Church Massacre Released • Nigerian Congregation In London Rejects Pastor Asks Him To Leave The Church • Man Who Donated His Hotel Building To Catholic Church, Turns Keke Napep Driver • 2 • 3 • 4
Lord's Chosen Members In The Mud (Video) • Nasarawa Church Cancels A Wedding Because The Lady Is Three Months Pregnant • No PVC, No Mass: Catholic Priest Denies Members Without PVCs Entry To Church
. We r all in d family of God. I cant claim 2 b a member of dis family & shun oda members. Dts y d church is a community & isnt isolated ie members interact wt 1 anoda. Yes Christianity is abt a personal relationship wt God bt it is reflected by our relationship wt odas.