Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law - Christianity Etc (7) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law (15008 Views)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Reply (Go Down)
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by raphieMontella: 11:45pm On Sep 06, 2016 |
shadeyinka:we both believe time didnt start with out universe...a common ground tho.. if the particle had been in an unstable equillibrium, it suggest a spontaneous creation of the particles still by an external force.IOW u mean the virtual particles arise by an external force?#aided ![]() Either way, external forces to the singularity initiated the Big bang.i hold the view that the virtual pairs which arose and created this universe were from the black hole of another universe.. Bt as for the bang(expansion)..inflation theoryy has taken care of that... Since the external force is not part of the singularity, it may not obey the known laws of Physics and so, we Theists will say that it is in the rhelm of God.what if the energy killed of this god? Such immense energy? To me..this universe doesnt seem planned! Maybe an accident from experiments of Gods...or just normal natural means or the multiverse... But if i were to believe in an external hand..i'd place my bet on Gods..not God.. |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by raphieMontella: 6:28am On Sep 07, 2016 |
lordnicklaus:the word only which u used is strong o... I believe our universe started from the black hole of another universe.. And quantum fluctuations gave rise to the virtual particles which expanded...i dnt think time started with our universe |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by raphieMontella: 6:29am On Sep 07, 2016 |
shadeyinka:u mean the sumerians? |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by raphieMontella: 6:31am On Sep 07, 2016 |
lordnicklaus:he must not exist in a universe without cause... I may be in a locked room... Bt it doesnt 100 imply that outside that room there is no air.... |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by ValentineMary(m): 8:49am On Sep 07, 2016 |
shadeyinka:Gravity can actually interfer with spacd that's why we have space time curvature. So space is not exactly nothing in general relativity. In mathematics, anything is possible. We can actually dimension/divide a space into as many parts as we want. ..a form of compartmentalization but as per BREAKING space, I don't know.I believe the laws of mathemtics are absolute as said by Sir Isaac Newton. For example, mathematics proved that there are particles that exist in multi dimensional space decades before string theory was discovred. Also mathematics proved that anti matter exist a year before it was discovered. So let us be patient with physics because it seems math is faster. Theoretically yes but how about practically? Pick a dying star, by how much percent in volume can it in reality condense?We have to wait billions of years to find out but we can find out now if we apply mathematics to it. I will submit that the current physical laws came into existence at the point of the Big bang. before that time however, another different laws of physics (if you like) was in operation. Since time is relative, it makes sense only in the physical rhelm to start from the big bang but it doesnt mean that time doesn't exist before the bang.It depends on what u call time. As for me, I believe in a kind of cteator force but I usually ask "What is this force" not who is it. Because I doubt the possibility of it being an animate force. |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by ValentineMary(m): 8:53am On Sep 07, 2016 |
shadeyinka:This is one mistake I feel we often make. From what I know space did not exist outside the singularity before the big bang. |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by ValentineMary(m): 8:59am On Sep 07, 2016 |
shadeyinka:Well I know nature did a good job but for us to know if it could have done a better job, we need 2 universes to compare. But unfortunately we have only one which we havd adapted to so we can't know if nature would have done a better job. As for the computer codes I can compare between 2 jobs who the better is. |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by Nobody: 11:32am On Sep 07, 2016 |
raphieMontella:Time should have ended with the crunching of a pre-existent universe which would become static. |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by Nobody: 11:41am On Sep 07, 2016 |
shadeyinka:The infinitesimal is a dimension beyond measured quantities. Since time is calculated, it is not within infinitesimal. |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by Nobody: 11:44am On Sep 07, 2016 |
OgundeleT:Yes I agree with you but every culture has a perception of a single creator and there are some which feel that forces which He created should be revered alongside Him. |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by Nobody: 11:51am On Sep 07, 2016 |
raphieMontella:Would it be possible for a new universe to arise from an area of gravitational singularity? |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by malvisguy212: 2:37pm On Sep 07, 2016 |
shadeyinka:weldon bro, I love the way you handle this atheists here. What this atheists are saying is " if we disobeyed God, is God fault". This is foolishness, is like your father set RULE for you to obey and be a Good son, but when you break this rule, you blame your dad ? Good lord!!! |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by raphieMontella: 4:54pm On Sep 07, 2016 |
lordnicklaus:its possible... Einstein's gravitational singularity is based on general relativity..and general relativity doesnt necessarily govern quantum particles.. I believe its possible#new universe arising at the other side.. |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by Nobody: 4:57pm On Sep 07, 2016 |
raphieMontella:Then what are the odds of this current multiverse becoming an area of gravitational singularity? |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by raphieMontella: 4:58pm On Sep 07, 2016 |
lordnicklaus:the big crunch? Thats also possible...but the big crunch makes the universe infinite and definitely needing not a creator... |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by Nobody: 5:04pm On Sep 07, 2016 |
raphieMontella:Putting a creator out of the picture doesn't entirely show rationaity or outright certainty of the universe's infiniteness. Also when taking an event such as "the big crunch" into consideration, one would also have to consider factors such as "dark matter" and "the god particle" which are quite abundant and also prove supplementary to our sphere and making it quite impossible for a crunch to occur. |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by raphieMontella: 5:06pm On Sep 07, 2016 |
lordnicklaus:black holes form in space in this universe... Singularities are in black holes... In the multiverse view of the cosmos.. Universes spring up sporadically. Dont really know how it works in the multiverse view...but the number of universes are ''infinite'' |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by raphieMontella: 5:12pm On Sep 07, 2016 |
lordnicklaus:its quite possible... If ''dark energy'' eventually uses up all the available usable energy it can use and loses to gravity...its quite possible |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by Nobody: 5:18pm On Sep 07, 2016 |
raphieMontella:Would that account for parallel universes? If that is so, then there are dimensions beyond this present multiversal dimension. There is a higher sphere which is beyond "time and space" and God would exist in such an unreachable sphere and thus He would not be subject to the principle of "cause and effect" and it is this dimension that I deem "infinitesimal". Time and motion are the major dimensions of space. All other quantities such as Heat, Entropy, Enthalpy, Kinetics, Light and its rectilinear propagation, Elasticity and quantum fluctuations are dependent of these two fundamental quantities. So, all sub-physical mechanisms which work according to the listed quantities can only be verified in a universe possessing the two fundamental quantities. |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by raphieMontella: 5:30pm On Sep 07, 2016 |
lordnicklaus:i do not know much on parallel universes If that is so, then there are dimensions beyond this present multiversal dimension. There is a higher sphere which is beyond "time and space" and God would exist in such an unreachable sphere and thus He would not be subject to the principle of "cause and effect" and it is this dimension that I deem "infinitesimal". Time and motion are the major dimensions of space. All other quantities such as Heat, Entropy, Enthalpy, Kinetics, Light and its rectilinear propagation, Elasticity and quantum fluctuations are dependent of these two fundamental quantities. So, all sub-physical mechanisms which work according to the listed quantities can only be verified in a universe possessing the two fundamental quantitieshmm...@bolded...specifiaclly quantum fluctuations.. Then why do u now believe a universe cannot arise unaided if the newtons' first law has only been tested in ''SPACE-TIME''.. Catch the drift? |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by Nobody: 5:35pm On Sep 07, 2016 |
raphieMontella:Sure! Same here though I only know such in Sci-Fi hmm...@bolded...specifiaclly quantum fluctuations..For other quantities to become reality, the universe would first have to be set in motion. |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by raphieMontella: 5:48pm On Sep 07, 2016 |
lordnicklaus:and the law of being set in motion with a cause has been tested only in this universe... And it need not be a conscious creator who set the stufff in motion..it could be just ''nature'' as per ''cosmic inflation theory'' E.g Two bodies at rest will start to move towards each other due to gravity. They can be each other's first mover. Therefore, the prior conscious mover requirement is unnecessary. |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by shadeyinka(op): 5:46am On Sep 08, 2016 |
malvisguy212:Thanks bri |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by shadeyinka(op): 5:47am On Sep 08, 2016 |
lordnicklaus:I agree with you |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by shadeyinka(op): 5:53am On Sep 08, 2016 |
ValentineMary:You are correct. But since there is no reference for comparison, we have to compare with the best of mans best. What will it take to write an artificial intelligence code with emotion, will , intellect and consciousness starting from the elementary parilces neutrino, positrons, etc The code complexity of the universe and life is to say the least dounting |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by shadeyinka(op): 5:59am On Sep 08, 2016 |
ValentineMary:This is just a re-echo of a statement not a fact! Define space even in terms of mathematics set theory and you know that it is impossible for space not to have existed. Many Atheists will wish that your statement is true anyway, because it is the point of breakdown of the physical laws which is supposed to be immutable. As a Theist, if the Physical laws have a beginning, it suggests the presence of an Initiator/ Creator/ God! |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by shadeyinka(op): 6:41am On Sep 08, 2016 |
ValentineMary:I guess that as scientists, we must clearly define what SPACE is. Should space be defined in terms of the measurable or the immeasurable? Should space be real or abstract? Should space be defined strictly by mathematical descriptions? ...Hm! ValentineMary:LOL. Do you know that this is a classic example of Great Faith! And you know, this Faith isn't bad and neither is it unreasonable. Your Faith is in the Object of Mathematics: You TRUST the INTEGRITY of Mathematics even though the Answer is in FUTURE. Its the same with we Theists: Our Faith is in the Object of God: We TRUST in the INTEGRITY of God the Creator even though the Answer is in the FUTURE. We are both men of Great Faith my Friend. ValentineMary:You believe in a kind of Creator Force! I am a little happy with this information even though I understand your definition of this force as Inanimate. Let me Pray for you pls say AMEN Father, I ask that You reveal Yourself to this Your son who answers to the name ValentineMary on Nairaland in Jesus Name. I know you laugh at me right now, I don't mind. God still loves you my Friend. |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by shadeyinka(op): 6:59am On Sep 08, 2016 |
raphieMontella:Yes the Sumerians, the Greeks. Babylonian Calenders, Roman Calendar, Mayan Calendar its baffling. Even though they do not have the scientific instruments, they obtained answers so impossible to guess |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by shadeyinka(op): 7:38am On Sep 08, 2016 |
raphieMontella:..which is good! raphieMontella:As a Theist, I believe that both Real and Virtual particle were created simultaneously and from the same source raphieMontella:If our universe was created from the black hole of another universe, it still doesn't change the question of the laws of physics being violated. Its a question of extending time back to the formation of the universe who gave birth to our own dear universe. If another universe can exist, then, one should NOT doubt the existence of other Consciousness. As Theists, we say God is THE Consciousness the origino-uno of everything. raphieMontella:..which is still an unverified THEORY (intelligent postulates) raphieMontella:I laughed continuously for 15 minutes on reading this. The God we talk about is not subject to time because He is not made from ATOMS and MOLECULES. He is not subject to Gravity because He does not have a mass. He is not subject to the Laws of nature because He WROTE them. Example: We created computers and the Rule(CODES) that controls them: The question is as Creators of the Computer, are we subject to Binary Arithmetic. Are we subject to need for Electrical Supplies; are we subject to Memory upgrade, Software upgrade, ..... We are not bound to the rules of the computer because we made them! raphieMontella:Does the ATOM look unplanned to you? How about Chemical Reactions? How come the laws of Physics are "unchanging" DNA unplanned? Cells unplanned? You know what I see, the smaller you go, the more detailed is the Meticulous rules imposed to govern it behaviour. Do you disagree with these above? How do you know etcivingiving enclosure is not nature made? Building Blocks, Cement, Functionality etc You may put your bet on gods however the harmony of the building blocks of the universe suggests ONE designer. Of course, God is a Spirit who has a kingdom of Spirit beings created for His kingdom. Some of the dissidents among them are what some humans call their own god! |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by shadeyinka(op): 7:55am On Sep 08, 2016 |
AnonyNymous:Do you think space can make sense outside the classical 3D definition? Since space is defined by an un-occupied volume. Should space not be a real rather than a concept(abstract)? Its just my thoughts |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by Nobody: 8:19am On Sep 08, 2016 |
shadeyinka:Read up on the M-theory. Its pure math. |
| Re: Atheism Contradicts Newtons First Law by 0ubenji(m): 8:29am On Sep 08, 2016 |
shadeyinka:touché |
If The Qur'an Affirms The Gospels, Then It Contradicts Itself • Conclusion : Atheism Is So Illogical , The Atheist Delusion • From Atheism To Jesus: My Testimony • 2 • 3 • 4
What Does It Mean To Carry Bunch Of Plantain In The Dream • Logicboy Meets Anony Again! Philosophy Vs Naturalism • What Are The Words In The Bible That Scare You Most As A Christian?
