₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: RegisterLoginWith GoogleTrendingRecentNew

Stats: 3,330,537 members, 8,445,944 topics. Date: Wednesday, 15 July 2026 at 07:27 PM

Toggle theme

If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born - Christianity Etc (3) - Nairaland

Nairaland ForumNairaland GeneralChristianity EtcIf I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born (7836 Views)

1 2 3 4 5 Reply (Go Down)

Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by Nobody: 3:38pm On Jan 06, 2017
shadeyinka:
You actually exist as nothing. If you know where you were before now, tell us?
So you don't even know the answer yet you lead me on with confidence like you are sure of your steps? You just wanted to type for the sake of it, not that you actually had any useful input to make. Lol.
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by shadeyinka(m): 4:09pm On Jan 06, 2017
Nobleking2000:
Then is man a physical or a spiritual being.
[size=38pt]BOTH[/size]
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by MizJanet(f): 4:14pm On Jan 06, 2017
shadeyinka:
What is so difficult in understanding that you are a trinity of a Body, Soul and Spirit!

What is so difficult in understanding what happens to your Body If your Soul and Spirit leave your body?

When Jesus resurrected, was it with a physical body or spiritual body?

If we don't yet have a spirit body as you seem to imply, why did Paul say ....my spirit prays but my mind is unfruitful. Or why would Elisha tell his servant Gahaz...did not my spirit follow you...

Do you honestly think Paul was saying that resurrection is purely spiritual: How come there is RESURRECTION?




I believe your bias is making you read what doesn't exist.
Where did I say the spirit is the real you?
Thank God we are just on the second page, so it is easy to check and quote exactly what I said.

Your conclusion was based on a false premise dear!
In your response to Oluwaseyi000 , you said


"
A spirit being (which you are ) never ever dies"


If Oluwaseyi000 is a Spirit being that can never ever die as you implied above , it then mean Oluwaseyi000 can never ever die

Apply that logic to Jesus too, it means he is a spirit being and can never ever dies

So if your position is true, then Jesus didnt die for anyone, comprehende ?

.
Even though you quoted the definition of death I posted, you still refuse to understand



To be dead isn't to be Non living:
Are Abraham, Elijah, Lazarus and the rich Man dead?
How come in death, they are still alive.

Jesus even quoted: God is not the God of the Dead but of the living.
Even your bible make a fool of you when it said the dead will not live . to be living is to live


Isaiah 26:14 says they are dead , They will not live

If the dead wont live. It means they are non living grin
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by shadeyinka(m): 4:16pm On Jan 06, 2017
Nobleking2000:
Then in what image is man created
In a spiritual image clothed in flesh and blood.
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by shadeyinka(m): 4:19pm On Jan 06, 2017
NinjaX:
So you don't even know the answer yet you lead me on with confidence like you are sure of your steps? You just wanted to type for the sake of it, not that you actually had any useful input to make. Lol.
I just affirmativly told you the answer. You existed as Nothing.

The second sentence was a question for you as you seem to think otherwise. Its a free world isn't it?

What is your answer? Plane and Simple
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by Nobody: 4:32pm On Jan 06, 2017
shadeyinka:
I just affirmativly told you the answer. You existed as Nothing.

The second sentence was a question for you as you seem to think otherwise. Its a free world isn't it?

What is your answer? Plane and Simple
I asked you to give reason(s) for your assertion, but instead you twisted my statement to mean the opposite and are now demanding I provide reasons for something I did not agree to. You don't see the fallacy in that, do you?
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by shadeyinka(m): 5:13pm On Jan 06, 2017
MizJanet:
In your response to Oluwaseyi000 , you said


"
A spirit being (which you are ) never ever dies"


If Oluwaseyi000 is a Spirit being that can never ever die as you implied above , it then mean Oluwaseyi000 can never ever die

Apply that logic to Jesus too, it means he is a spirit being and can never ever dies

So if your position is true, then Jesus didnt die for anyone, comprehende ?



Even your bible make a fool of you when it said the dead will not live . to be living is to live


Isaiah 26:14 says they are dead , They will not live

If the dead wont live. It means they are non living grin
Rev 6:11
And white robes were given unto every one of them; and it was said unto them, that they should rest yet for a little season, until their fellowservants also and their brethren, that should be killed as they were, should be fulfilled.


If these people were killed, how come they are alive?
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by Heavenly102: 7:03pm On Jan 06, 2017
shadeyinka:
I just affirmativly told you the answer. You existed as Nothing.

The second sentence was a question for you as you seem to think otherwise. Its a free world isn't it?

What is your answer? Plane and Simple
I've got a question if a spirit is eternal then it shouldn't have a beginning nor an end because the word eternal means ever existing
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by shadeyinka(m): 7:10pm On Jan 06, 2017
Heavenly102:
I've got a question if a spirit is eternal then it shouldn't have a beginning nor an end because the word eternal means ever existing
No!
Eternal means NEVER ENDING.

Eg. Eternal life
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by MizJanet(f): 8:57pm On Jan 06, 2017
Address the issue of spirit being pls , if Oluwaseyi000 is a Spirit being that can never ever die , it means Jesus is a spirit being that can never ever die too, and doesnt die for anybody since he cant die, comprehende ?


shadeyinka:
Rev 6:11
And white robes were given unto every one of them; and it was said unto them, that they should rest yet for a little season, until their fellowservants also and their brethren, that should be killed as they were, should be fulfilled.


If these people were killed, how come they are alive?
You mean your holybook contradicts itself ?


Isaiah 26:14 they are dead, they will not live grin grin grin grin
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by MizJanet(f): 8:58pm On Jan 06, 2017
Nobleking2000:
Where was this unconscious spiritual image before it was brought to life .
Good question
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by shadeyinka(m): 9:12pm On Jan 06, 2017
NinjaX:
I asked you to give reason(s) for your assertion, but instead you twisted my statement to mean the opposite and are now demanding I provide reasons for something I did not agree to. You don't see the fallacy in that, do you?
Its simple.
It's obvious our answers are different even though you haven't stated yours. Maybe your explanations will make me go deeper. The foundations of arithmetic must be laid before calculus isn't it?
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by shadeyinka(m): 9:15pm On Jan 06, 2017
MizJanet:
Address the issue of spirit being pls , if Oluwaseyi000 is a Spirit being that can never ever die , it means Jesus is a spirit being that can never ever die too, and doesnt die for anybody since he cant die, comprehende ?




You mean your holybook contradicts itself ?


Isaiah 26:14 they are dead, they will not live grin grin grin grin
Your definition of death isn't my definition of death therefore, you can't impose your definition and expect a response.

I have defined what death is, yours is to refute or concur that definition.
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by Nobody: 9:40pm On Jan 06, 2017
shadeyinka:
Its simple.
It's obvious our answers are different even though you haven't stated yours. Maybe your explanations will make me go deeper. The foundations of arithmetic must be laid before calculus isn't it?
Nope. That I'm yet to accept your opinion doesn't imply our stance are different because I never made mine known. You made a big claim, that's what it is, and it remains a claim as long as it has no backbone or foundation. It's just floating aimlessly in the air.

Explain giving reasons why you think we never existed before we were born, then let's see how it goes.
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by shadeyinka(m): 10:01pm On Jan 06, 2017
NinjaX:
Nope. That I'm yet to accept your opinion doesn't imply our stance are different because I never made mine known. You made a big claim, that's what it is, and it remains a claim as long as it has no backbone or foundation. It's just floating aimlessly in the air.

Explain giving reasons why you think we never existed before we were born, then let's see how it goes.
I will give you only a scientific reason for this: as it is the easiest to prove:

Biologically, your DNA is unique.
1. Only your Father and Mother could have produced you.
If your Father had not impregnated your mum, you could never ever exist.

2. Statistically, It is impossible for your parent to duplicate you no matter how many times they tried.

Except you can show otherwise how you can exist as YOU in the whole Universe with either non or just one of your parent.
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by Anas09: 10:12pm On Jan 06, 2017
Wilgrea7:
ok....so the language of the spirit is different... ok




how does being a spirit give immortality?? the bible already said only God has immortality... being a spirit isn't an automatic ticket for immortality..... besides... the verse you quoted stated that God created them male and female... meaning he created spirits male and female? spirits have gender? he told them to be fruitful and multiply... looking at the story you will know its not even the story of adam and eve neither is it talking about spirits.. cuz spirits don't reproduce




image means to look like... all throughout the bible... the image of something means to look like it




nowhere in the first chapter did it hint that man was invisible... chapter one and two are different creation stories.. chapter one said he created THEM(plural tense... hinting more than 2 people) male and female, gave them dominion and told them to multiply(not something spirits do)... in verse 2 God created only Adam from dust..breathed into him.. thats how he came alive.. he wasn't living before then...not as a spirit.. nothing.. if he were a spirit, then God would've created a body and sent his(Adam's) spirit into the body.. but that wasn't the case... then he used a rib from adam to create eve(was still not existing before)




the spirit is the consciousness... yes... the spirit being in the body makes it a soul... spirit+body=soul




halleluyah




i believe that there are certain things in life being revealed by the holy spirit.. i won't deny that.. but the double creation story seems to be a problem.. its ok to try to unify it... but it still remains 2 different stories to me... my mind can't unify it. i really respect you and appreciate your effort in trying to explain it to me... the lord is your strength.. but I've already kinda researched this and seem to be sure to an extent... i may be wrong.. i don't have the monopoly of being right.. i will learn more in due time.. maybe in favour of your teaching .. maybe against it.. i dunno.. I'm not saying you're wrong.. nor am i saying otherwise.. but one day... we'll all find out for sure.. continue the good work ma'am.. God bless
Womderful. So, Spirits are something other than immortals? Do you care to tell?

Sir, every Spirit is immortal, except you don't know what a spirit is.

Hahahahaaha, What are you doing with the Holy Spirit you are given or you don't have Him? Is that why your understanding is superficial? When he created them, they Spirits, but their Purpose was to Dominate the earth, so He later formed them to comform with the material earth.

Spirits have no gender, but He purposed for them to procreate. He knew they would have gender, hence, the proclamation, Go into...

The Spirit is not the conciousness, the soul is.
Very funny you. Spirit+body=Soul? Care to.elaborate?

Oh, wait!!!, you are a Jehovah's Witness. Watch Tower blinders won't let you harness the Holy Spirit.

Enjoy your Watch Tower.
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by HardMirror(m): 10:34pm On Jan 06, 2017
Ranchhoddas:
How do you know his mind has been made up?
Even if it were, do you not think that your answers(if you have any that is) might be useful to some other person; perhaps a guest viewer?
Can we all stop being diplomatic for a while. Fact is they have no answers and they know it. The fact remains that the foolishness and absurdity is glaring, but fear of the "unknown" wld not make them agree. They fear, "what if god is real?" That alone has kept the obvious lie alive.
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by HardMirror(m): 10:36pm On Jan 06, 2017
dorox:
The bible teaches that all life comes from God, without Him none can be alife. After the sin of Adam and Eve, God told them that from dust the were and to dust they shall return. In other words, they were nothing before He gave them life and at death they shall return to their initial lifeless state.
Immortality on the other hand is a gift from God to His faithful servants.
The bible what?...

Since when did the bible become a fact book?
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by HardMirror(m): 10:44pm On Jan 06, 2017
TheOtherRoom:
Anas09 for your info am well versed in
Israelite History and Religion. Your analysis is filled with wild and open arguments not properly guarded... If man is the king over the earth, how do you explain the demons or the Lucifer and its constant war with god??

Try to study 1 samuel 28:7 would and Jeremiah 1:5
Might give you some insight since the Bible is your yard stick
Smiles, it is funny that the acclaimed christians always address issues as if they are talking to dolts or kids under 2yrs old.

Honestly it is so unfortunate we barely have intelligent christians here
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by DoctorAlien(m): 10:47pm On Jan 06, 2017
I smell a liar on this thread who said he was a Christian.

Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by Nobody: 11:13pm On Jan 06, 2017
Nobleking2000:
Where was this unconscious spiritual image before it was brought to life .
[quote author=Nobleking2000 post=52590534]this is the simple summary of this (my) thread
I will appreciate factiful facts for or against
no need digressing or making thread unnecessarily long

thanks
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by Anas09: 11:56pm On Jan 06, 2017
NinjaX:
"Where was I before I was born?" This is the question I've been wanting to ask. I will follow this thread and watch out for peoples opinions.
Do you know the Holy Spirit? Have you tried asking Him?
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by Anas09: 11:59pm On Jan 06, 2017
HCpaul:
Good one.....

And God been a spirit being also doesn't have a beginning??

I think this thread is seriously exposing theists illogical way of thinking.
Lol. Little mind.
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by Anas09: 12:00am On Jan 07, 2017
Wilgrea7:
many Christians won't agree with this view..

concerning the creation story, i know there's a hell lot more to it than what is in the bible... I'm sure of it... check the oldest religions in history... they were mostly monotheistic before many moved to polytheism... but check the monotheistic religions of old... they have a creation story too similar to ignore... so you may be right... a literal interpretation might not be the best idea... but again... many Christians won't agree with the view
Have i been talking to a pagan all along?
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by Anas09: 12:03am On Jan 07, 2017
Nobleking2000:
Going by your logic anything that has a start must have an end
God, didn't start, so can't and won't end
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by MizJanet(f): 2:22am On Jan 07, 2017
Address the issue of Spirit being please , if oluwaseyi000 is a spirit being who can never ever die, do u agree Jesus too is a Spirit being who can never ever die and therefore did not die for anybody's sin ?

shadeyinka:
Your definition of death isn't my definition of death therefore, you can't impose your definition and expect a response.

I have defined what death is, yours is to refute or concur that definition.
grin grin Isaiah refute your definition of death, scatter it to pieces . shred it with hammer


The dead will not live . meaning they are Non living


Even angels in the bible support this definition of death as Non living when they asked the women who came to Jesus tomb

" Why are you looking for the living Among the dead?" Luke 24:5 Which means the dead are not alive . grin grin


They are dead, they will not live . use your common sense nah
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by Wilgrea7(m): 6:16am On Jan 07, 2017
Anas09:
Womderful. So, Spirits are something other than immortals? Do you care to tell?

Sir, every Spirit is immortal, except you don't know what a spirit is.

Hahahahaaha, What are you doing with the Holy Spirit you are given or you don't have Him? Is that why your understanding is superficial? When he created them, they Spirits, but their Purpose was to Dominate the earth, so He later formed them to comform with the material earth.

Spirits have no gender, but He purposed for them to procreate. He knew they would have gender, hence, the proclamation, Go into...

The Spirit is not the conciousness, the soul is.
Very funny you. Spirit+body=Soul? Care to.elaborate?

Oh, wait!!!, you are a Jehovah's Witness. Watch Tower blinders won't let you harness the Holy Spirit.

Enjoy your Watch Tower.
I'm no jw neither am i a pagan.. i stated something

Romans 2:7 To them who by patient continuance in well doing seek for glory and honour and immortality, eternal life:

2 Timothy 1:10 But is now made manifest by the appearing of our Saviour Jesus Christ, who hath abolished death, and hath brought life and immortality to light through the gospel

1 Timothy 6:16 Who only hath immortality, dwelling in the light which no man can approach unto; whom no man hath seen, nor can see: to whom be honour and power everlasting. Amen.

the last verse seems to show that only God has immortality.... true immortality.. the verses above are clearly stating that innortality/eternal life is a gift from God to the righteous.... except you have another way of explaining those verses... then I'm all ears... i don't take our souls to be truly immortal.. i don't even take angels to be truly immortal.. i take only God to be truly immortal.. the rest have conditional immortality.. meaning they can still be destroyed if the creator deems it fit

as to the soul spirit connection... I'm beginning to see your point... i made a research on it... it seems there were some people who didn't want us to know the difference between soul and spirit.. after my research (cuz I've been silent on the soul issue)... i take the spirit as the source of life allowing the soul to be able to dwell in the body... the spirit goes to God at death while the soul goes on to the afterlife.. the soul is the real you.... again... I'm no jw or pagan... i like to research things and find out for myself.. you seem to be very skilled when it comes to jumping to conclusions concerning people's identity
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by Wilgrea7(m): 6:19am On Jan 07, 2017
Anas09:
Have i been talking to a pagan all along?
nope... I'm a Christian... i just analyse facts... i didn't draw any conclusion... i only said there's more to the story than what is written in the bible... how does that qualify me as a pagan huh
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by Wilgrea7(m): 6:38am On Jan 07, 2017
Anas09:
The Spirit is not the conciousness, the soul is.
Very funny you. Spirit+body=Soul? Care to.elaborate?

Oh, wait!!!, you are a Jehovah's Witness. Watch Tower blinders won't let you harness the Holy Spirit.
Wilgrea7:
the spirit is the consciousness... yes... the spirit being in the body makes it a soul... spirit+body=soul
i clearly mistook the soul for the spirit... how is that a jw doctrinehuh
Re: If I Will Live Forever Either In Hell Or Heaven, Where Am I Before I Was Born by shadeyinka(m): 6:40am On Jan 07, 2017
MizJanet:
Address the issue of Spirit being please , if oluwaseyi000 is a spirit being who can never ever die, do u agree Jesus too is a Spirit being who can never ever die and therefore did not die for anybody's sin ?




grin grin Isaiah refute your definition of death, scatter it to pieces . shred it with hammer


The dead will not live . meaning they are Non living


Even angels in the bible support this definition of death as Non living when they asked the women who came to Jesus tomb

" Why are you looking for the living Among the dead?" Luke 24:5 Which means the dead are not alive . grin grin


They are dead, they will not live . use your common sense nah
1 2 3 4 5 Reply

Prophet Kumchacha: Women Who Scream God's Name During Sex Will End Up In HellBelieve Right And You Will Live Right - Olamide Obire10 Reasons Why Many People may End Up In Hell.234

Open Heavens Devotional.1st Bible Translated In Yoruba By Ajayi Crowther Inside 1st Storey Building (picPictures Of Jesus Suffering On The Cross

Viewing this topic: 1 guest(s)