Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) - Christianity Etc - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) (9490 Views)
| Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by butterflylion(op): 1:41pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
What is your position on the existence of the supernatural and is there any difference in terminology in between the atheists who believe in the supernatural and those who don't? Atheism is, in my estimation, the lack of belief in God or gods but is that where it stops? Are there atheists who venture outside this caged definition here on nairaland? If there are, I wonder if there is a term for such people and a different term for those people who don't believe in any supernatural existence, not just the disbelief in deities. I have heard a number of atheists say they do believe in something mystic, albeit not any deity. For purposes of this discussion, when I say "supernatural" I mean outside of the nature. When I say "nature" I mean Dark matter, dark energy, any other known and unknown components of nature, any possible parrallel universes and everything else that exists in the natural order. So if as an atheist you believe in ghosts, spirits, or anything you term as supernatural but not a diety let's all have a chat. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by tintingz(m): 1:59pm On Aug 17, 2017*. Modified: 2:38pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
Atheist that claim to believe in supernatural is contradicting the meaning of atheism or am I wrong? ![]() |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by obinna58(m): 2:07pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
Op Atheists also lack belief in those beings u mentioned They exist only in the mind |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by butterflylion(op): 2:09pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
tintingz:There is apparently little correlation between a belief in the supernatural and a belief in deities. Each one stems from a different set of experiences or lack of. For example It is fairly common for both religious and non religious people to describe having seen a ghost and what would constitute as personal evidence for the person having the experience Therefore, a belief in deities is learned while a belief in ghosts may come from direct experience. But whether concrete or psychological, that it is a common phenomenon to people in all walks of life regardless of their religious inclination or lack thereof. So it's not really a contradiction. Sure, atheists can believe in anything they want to, with the single exception that if they believe in a God or gods, they're not atheists. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by butterflylion(op): 2:25pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
obinna58:Not all atheists do. Atheism is simply a lack of belief in the existence of God or gods and not everything supernatural or which their experiences prove are beyond natural occurrences. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by Nobody: 2:32pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
good luck finding an atheist who believes in the supernatural to discuss with. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by tintingz(m): 2:36pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
butterflylion:God is a spirit being so also ghost, ghost are said to come from God. This made them both supernatural. So if an athiest said he doesn't believe in God or gods but believe in spirits or anything supernatural, that atheist will have to proof spirit exist, and the thing is at the end he/she will end up shooting himself in the foot. Belief or believing in ghost is also learn, people also claim they experience seeing a deity. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by butterflylion(op): 2:41pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
tintingz:God is not a ghost. For sake of clarity to ourselves we coined the word "ghost" in reality a ghost isn't known as a ghost to a ghost (that is if they do exist) It's like saying a dog is a dog while to a dog it does not see itself as a dog in name but something different which is at its level of reasoning. To an atheist God does not exist so he cannot claim ghosts come from God. He simply experiences them and as long as he believes there is no attachment they have to a non existent God he is Okay with that belief in ghosts. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by Nobody: 2:42pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by tintingz(m): 2:55pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
butterflylion:# What I meant is, God is a spirit being and Ghosts are spirit beings. # God is supernatural entity, ghost is supernatural entity, ghost are said to come from higher source which religious people call God, an atheist that claim to believe in supernatural beings excluding god(s) will have to proof ghost exist. # Your argument is like saying I believe in electricity but I don't believe in generator. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by butterflylion(op): 3:25pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
tintingz:My discussion is not from a religious point of view so you got it wrong. If Ghosts are said to be supernatural and both religious and the irreligious have by personal experience laid claim to seeing a few then those experiences are personal to them. As long as an atheist has settled the most important aspect of atheism which is it's core that God or gods do not exist and there is no proof available that would sufficiently prove their existence than an atheist can conclude that yes Ghosts exist but could just be another form of energy yet unexplained. Or the supernatural exists as another form of energy unexplained but both have absolutely no link to a non existent God or gods which is the core of atheism. Do you understand it now? Atheists can believe in fairies, unicorns, elves, aliens, UFOs, ghosts or anything outside natural occurrences but only kick against a God or gods existence. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by tintingz(m): 3:33pm On Aug 17, 2017*. Modified: 4:59pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
butterflylion:Atheism does not end in lack in belief in god/gods but also supernatural, myths, legends, superstitions. So, the question is, those acclaimed atheist that believes in supernatural proof supernatural entities exist? |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by dalaman: 3:45pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
Proudgorgeousga:I tire. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by butterflylion(op): 3:52pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
tintingz:You are looking at the supernatural as always being something abstract and as something that somehow never interacts with the natural. I just gave you an example of both religious and irreligious people who claim to have personally experienced Ghosts. Note that these are their personal experiences and they have no reason to disbelieve it when they knew they were not hallucinating when having this experience. Another example are atheists who believe in astrology. They believe in stargazing and zodiac signs which by their personal experiences have happened as specifically predicted by these supernatural elements but to them it still would not prove God since at their foundation God or gods do not exist and there isn't sufficient proof for their existence. I never said that an atheist who believes in the supernatural means supernatural entities exist. You said it not me. Remember I said these experiences are personal to that atheist which is why I wish to discuss based on a personal experiential basis. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by ifenes(m): 4:05pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
butterflylion:"Supernatural" based on individual level of knowledge. We tend to term things beyond our knowledge and expectations " Supernatural" but everything is natural. Ignorance is the only problem. Athiesm itself is born out of rebellion against organised religion/ programmed, mis-education on the term " God". Because our human societies have been severely misinformed on topics about Gods, demons, ghosts etc , it is normal to find some people react differently to such beliefs and dissociat themselves from such and rather look for evidence. This is a typical human feature that we share with other life forms. However, it doesn't mean people who term themselves Athiest have the right information,but at least they ain't buying an obvious rediculous interpretation from religious leaders. This is how far Athiesm has gone,but it is still a very primitive idea.......otherwise our human history and academical lessons also need to be questioned. Perhaps such people would have to come by another name/ title. Personally I feel Athiesm will evolve from just destroying organised lying religious empires to actually rectifying,repairing and solving them. Knowledge will be gained and terms like Ghosts, God, parallel universes, energy bubbles, extradimensional beings will be fully understood. With the way people's minds have been wrongfully misinformed, any other ideas is wrong. But we must not see anything as " supernatural " because we do not understand them but natural because nature is vast. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by PastorAIO: 4:13pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
tintingz:I believe you are conflating Naturalism with Atheism. @OP, I think that your definition of natural might be circular. In fact I haven't heard of a rigorous definition of naturalism in all the long decades of my life. Even those things you term as 'ghosts' etc are not necessarily supernatural or unnatural however you define it. Why? Because the brain, a 'natural' organ, 'naturally' works to create hallucinations all the time. If you define natural as anything that can be explained with the knowledge we have then the fact that something seems supernatural may yet turn out to be quite natural once you've found a way to explain it. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by butterflylion(op): 4:15pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
ifenes:You have said yours also based on your personal experiences thus you believe your position. Likewise an atheist with their own personal experiences in the areas you mentioned would believe themselves because probably in that moment they first tried to rationalise these events but found no explanation for them. We ourselves as humans live within a bubble and that bubble is called nature but can our natural observations be enough to rule out things that may be outside this bubble? Isn't it possible that the supernatural is out there and to them the natural also does not exist. This is a comment by Sally Ulianich an atheist based on her own experiences. My belief is that we who are alive are all here now and life is now, angels and devils are people, heaven and hell is now, not after we die. When we die, that's it. We won't be swept away to the gates of heaven or hades. But also, we all have energy that we can feel in each other and I think it's possible for that energy to continue on after we die. I don't know that we can physically see it, and maybe some can, but I think there is enough evidence of it for me to personally believe in it. She isn't mad surely not. She is simply trying to rationalise her personal experiences regarding the supernatural as an atheist. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by Nobody: 4:18pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
PastorAIO:[quote a butterflylion:uthor=butterflylion post=59562884]What is your position on the existence of the supernatural and is there any difference in terminology in between the atheists who believe in the supernatural and those who don't? Atheism is, in my estimation, the lack of belief in God or gods but is that where it stops? Are there atheists who venture outside this caged definition here on nairaland? If there are, I wonder if there is a term for such people and a different term for those people who don't believe in any supernatural existence, not just the disbelief in deities. I have heard a number of atheists say they do believe in something mystic, albeit not any deity. For purposes of this discussion, when I say "supernatural" I mean outside of the nature. When I say "nature" I mean Dark matter, dark energy, any other known and unknown components of nature, any possible parrallel universes and everything else that exists in the natural order. So if as an atheist you believe in ghosts, spirits, or anything you term as supernatural but not a diety let's all have a chat.[/quote]https://www.nairaland.com/3992671/tithing-truth-history-origin-catholic |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by butterflylion(op): 4:25pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
PastorAIO:Super in supernatural creates a gulf of separation from what natural is. Super is a higher form of natural which could be in non tangible spirit form to us but a perfectly tangible natural form to those in the supernatural. Explaining anything does not erase what personal experiences explain themselves because the build up to these experiences are never the same and the experiences themselves are also never the same. Atheists have declared houses haunted by ghosts because of their personal experiences and what others have truthfully witnessed about the same houses. Atheists have submitted themselves to mediums who say they can communicate with spirits and these mediums have revealed deep dark secrets to them only known by them and also passed on messages from dead relatives which turned out to be true, etc. Like I said, these are personal experiences but as long as God is not in the mix, an atheist is free to believe in anything. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by obisco4u: 4:34pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
Believe me, before the airplane was invented, the sight of metal flying in mid-air was considered supernatural. But now it is understood as a reality made possible by the application of scientific principles. Therefore anything supernatural is nothing but an aspect of nature yet to be scienifically understood. And when that happens it seizes to be supernatural. Trust me, science will get there! #Men made the idea of a God! |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by butterflylion(op): 4:43pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
obisco4u: Please my thread is about atheists who believe in ghosts or the supernatural and not God being an idea made by men. The supernatural does not have to be God does it? Let me help focus your thought. In Nigeria and other white nations there have been multiple accounts of people who died and their deaths were unknown to certain people but the same dead person would pay a visit to this close person and spend some time with them before they found out about their death. A lot of these accounts have been witnessed by multiple people who could testify of seeing what the main person also saw. Are you focused now please? |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by tintingz(m): 4:50pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
butterflylion:Supernatural can interacts with natural which can be magic, hallucinations etc. I just gave you an example of both religious and irreligious people who claim to have personally experienced Ghosts. Note that these are their personal experiences and they have no reason to disbelieve it when they knew they were not hallucinating when having this experience.How do these people know they were not hallucinating when they see ghost? Another example are atheists who believe in astrology. They believe in stargazing and zodiac signs which by their personal experiences have happened as specifically predicted by these supernatural elements but to them it still would not prove God since at their foundation God or gods do not exist and there isn't sufficient proof for their existence.So where are these atheists? I never said that an atheist who believes in the supernatural means supernatural entities exist. You said it not me. Remember I said these experiences are personal to that atheist which is why I wish to discuss based on a personal experiential basis.I'm very sure, your goal here is to proof god/gods exist. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by tintingz(m): 4:56pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
PastorAIO:Was just giving the OP example. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by butterflylion(op): 5:09pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
tintingz:You still do not get it. Your opinion says the supernatural interacting with the natural is simply hallucinations but the atheists who experienced same say otherwise and I already gave a quote from one of such atheists and said her name is Sally Ulianich. Let me post one of her full experiences here. I've had multiple experiences in which a ghost or energy seemed to be the most rational explanation, including a series of events that happened all in one night:. She knows this house and she as well as others have a history of experiences in this house which defy explanation plus even new residents run away after a couple of years. You desperately wish to move this discussion to proof or no proof of God don't you? Surely you can have a rational discussion without always ending up in God or no God argument can you not? |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by PastorAIO: 5:25pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
I can say in this world there are Dingdongs and then there are superdingdongs. I bet you'll be none the wiser though because I haven't defined a dingdong. If I say a superdingdong is something over and beyond a dingdong that will not help you because I haven't defined a dingdong as yet. Ultimately we are discussions the mechanism of the universe. How things work? Many people believe that there is only one single principle underpinning the way all the universe works. We haven't discovered it yet but the search is on for the ToE, the Theory of Everything. At the moment there are two known principles by which phenomena can be explained. Einsteins relativity theories and secondly quantum mechanics. These are both classified as 'natural' principles. Even your example of atheists going to mediums doesn't suggest any other principles at work other than what we are commonly used to. Have you heard of cold reading? There are many techniques that seem like magic to those who are not in the know but they are all very common phenomena. butterflylion: |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by PastorAIO: 5:32pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
This sounds like poltergeists phenomena and it's more likely that the cause is the young lady rather than any entity in the house. From what little I know about such phenomena they are strongest around kids that are going through puberty. butterflylion: |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by butterflylion(op): 5:45pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
PastorAIO:Yes I know about cold reading and hot reading and warm reading but they are also limited. I doubt if there can ever be a Theory of everything and even Eisteins relativity or quantum mechanics which though applicable to this natural world may be obsolete if there was a world which does not subscribe to its laws. That was why I said we are in a bubble named nature and that is all we know until something breaks through what we know and forces us to begin to think that perhaps there is something beyond nature. Here is another personal experience by an atheist. Maybe you can try and explain away her personal experience after studying her experience. Her name is Daisy. So, here's my story. It's not all that scary, but it's not something I talk about a lot. Because honestly, it's hard to say outloud without questioning myself. It just sounds so ridiculous. I accepted a while ago, that, no, I'm not exaggerating or making things up. I know my truth, even if my truth seems impossible or no one else believes me.. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by tintingz(m): 5:55pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
butterflylion:Where did she said she's an atheist? Anybody can cook up fictional stories. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by NPComplete: 5:59pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
ifenes:I agree with this |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by butterflylion(op): 6:18pm On Aug 17, 2017*. Modified: 7:55pm On Aug 18, 2017 |
tintingz:. |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by tintingz(m): 6:32pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
butterflylion:Where is the link to her story? |
| Re: Atheists Who Believe In The Supernatural Please Come In(discussion) by butterflylion(op): 6:51pm On Aug 17, 2017 |
tintingz:Are you serious? I am sure you think I made it all up. |
Need Proof of the Supernatural? Meet Joshua Selman Nimmak • There Are Atheists Who Acknowledge the Existence of the Creator of the Universe • Atheists, Who Generates The Force That Rotates Planet • 2 • 3 • 4
The Prayer Of The Righteous Is A Delight To God But The Wicked's An Abomination! • How Do We Identify A Righteous Person? • 5 Signs Your Star Is Under Attack
