Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,152,126 members, 7,814,942 topics. Date: Thursday, 02 May 2024 at 12:41 AM

Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? - Islam for Muslims - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Islam for Muslims / Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? (9536 Views)

Reasons For The Emergence Of Muslim Sects / Before The Media Set The Nation On The Path Of Religious War: MSSN / The Ten Nullifiers Of The Islam Of Tmc Members (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (Reply) (Go Down)

Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by AlBaqir(m): 6:37pm On Oct 19, 2017
This article is written by Brother Sulayman Olayinka.

In His Name The Most High.

RESPONSE TO QUESTION ON FORMING SECT/GROUP IN ISLAM.

I won't waste much time on the issue of group as it is a crystal clear issue from Quranic perspective unfortunately it is being misunderstood.

* SECT OR FACTION

What is Sect? An English Dictionary defines "Sect" as a group following a specific ideal or leader.

In the holy Quran, sect (shia) is used on numerous occasion with different interpretation in relation to the content it appears. Allow me to highlights but few.

In Q.6:65, it is used here as "party", Q.6:159, it is used as "Sect ", Q.28:15 it is used as "party"

So with the above interpretation we can conclude that the word sect (shia) will become a phrase if taken out of context.

So, Did Quran warned us of forming sect? In Quran 6:159, Allah says:


"Surely they who divided their religion into parts and became shiya (pl. of shia), you have no concern with them; their affair is only with Allah, then He will inform them of what they did."

This verse is often used by some to condemn sect. However, the verse says "those who DIVIDED the Religion into parts and form sects..." This type of sect is very clear i.e those sects that lead to dividing religion. Ithna Ashariyah (majority Shia), Ash'ariyyah (majority Sunni), Athariyyah (mostly Salafi, Wahabi), Matrudiyyah, etc are all "SECT/PARTY" that fall into this Qur'anic category based on their differences in Aqeedah (beliefs) and fiqh (jurisprudence).


To make the point more clearer, let us look into this popular authentic hadith of the Prophet (s).

Imam Ibn Majah documents:

Narrated ‘Awf b. Malik:

Allāh’s Apostle, peace be upon him, said:
“The Jews divided into 71 sects. Only one of them will be in Paradise while the remaining 70 will be in Hellfire. The Christians divided into 72 sects. 71 of them will be in Hellfire while one will be in Paradise. I swear by One Who has the soul of Muhammad in His Hand, my Ummah will divide into 73 sects. Only one of them will be in Paradise, while the remaining 72 will be in Hellfire.”

It was said: “Who are they (i.e the saved sect)?” He replied: “The Jama’ah
.”

Al-Albani comments: Sahih (authentic)

Source: Muhammad Nasir al-Din al-Albani, Sahih Sunan Ibn Majah (Riyadh: Maktab al-Tarbiyyah al-‘Arabi li Dawl al-Khalil; 1408), vol. 2, p. 364.


# Shaykh al-Albani comments on the submission by Imam al-Tirmidhi on the meaning of "The Jama'ah" thus:

"This meaning was taken from the statement of Ibn Mas’ud: “The Jama'ah is whatever agrees with the Haqq (Truth) even if it is only you (that follow it).” Ibn Asakir recorded it in Tarikh Dimashq (13/322/2) with a Sahih chain from him"

Source: Muhammad b. ‘Abd Allah al-Khatib al-Tabrizi,Mishkat al-Masabih (Beirut: al-Maktab al-Islami; 1405)[annotator: Muhammad Nasir al-Din al-Albani], vol. 1, p. 61

From the above hadith, the Prophet (s) explains that his Ummah will divide into sects and only ONE SECT will be with him. Then we are made to understand that the Jama'ah doesn't necessarily mean "following the majority."


* GROUP/PARTY

Are groups like MSSN, TMC, TABLIGH, NASFAT, ANSARUDEEN etc also "SECT" in the definition of Aqeedah and Fiqh?

Quran 3:104 reads:

"And from among you there should be a PARTY who invite to good and enjoin what is right and forbid the wrong, and these it is that shall be successful."

The above Ayah talks about emergence of various "sects/groups" with a DEFINED RESPONSIBILITY of calling to "Good, and enjoin what is right and forbid the wrong". This is where the above-mentioned groups fall and at the end each one of them is surely belong to either Sunni, Salafi, Shia etc based on their Aqeedah (+fiqh).

2 Likes

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by AlBaqir(m): 7:31pm On Oct 19, 2017
AlBaqir:

* GROUP/PARTY

Are groups like MSSN, TMC, TABLIGH, NASFAT, ANSARUDEEN etc also "SECT" in the definition of Aqeedah and Fiqh?

Quran 3:104 reads:

"And from among you there should be a PARTY who invite to good and enjoin what is right and forbid the wrong, and these it is that shall be successful."

The above Ayah talks about emergence of various "sects/groups" with a DEFINED RESPONSIBILITY of calling to "Good, and enjoin what is right and forbid the wrong". This is where the above-mentioned groups fall and at the end each one of them is surely belong to either Sunni, Salafi, Shia etc based on their Aqeedah (+fiqh).

# In a Nutshell, Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen etc are NOT (new) Sect because their activities do not preach or introduce NEW Aqeedah (beliefs) or Fiqh (Jurisprudence) rather their activities is calling towards goodness, enjoining what is right and forbidding evil.

This is the reason they can be classified as "group/party" (equivalent to the one ordered in Q.3:104).


NB: This thread is NOT interested in examine the correctness or wrongness of their activities as some might want to submit, rather it only wish to state clear the definition of SECT/FACTION as different from a mere GROUP/PARTY.

10 Likes

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by Empiree: 2:06am On Oct 20, 2017
Agreed

1 Like

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by iamgenius(m): 6:49am On Oct 20, 2017
Some sects are Sunni, Shia, Qadariyyah, Jabariyyah, Kalaamiyah and others. May Allah help us die as the follower of Prophet Muhammad's (peace be upon him) teachings (Kitaab and Sunnah) Aamin.

10 Likes

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by shahydbinaliyu(m): 8:25am On Oct 20, 2017
Laughing . . .wahala wa o . . awe keferi yi just go dey sp0il ign0rant and pe0ple that d0n't understand the deen wella aqeedah . . . this is exactly why SALAFS SAID NEVER TO READ OR LISTEN TO ONI BIDIA, KAFIR FATWAS

3 Likes

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by shahydbinaliyu(m): 8:30am On Oct 20, 2017
This is exactly the same thing that ASRAU BILAL, ISA AKINDELE QUOTE TO DEFEND THEIR KUFRU (HIZBIYUN, FIROQ, SECT, ISLAMIC GROUP, EGBE) . . . . .wAlai if you die bel0nging to an islamic affiliated sect, walai you wil stay forever in hell

2 Likes

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by shahydbinaliyu(m): 8:37am On Oct 20, 2017
BETTER GO READ THE HADITH OF HUDAIFAH IBN YAMAN . . BUKHARI 7084, MUSLIM 1847 . . . EGBE IS KUFRU. . PLAIN KUFRU . . . IF Y0U ARE A MUSLIM, NEVER BELIEVE ANYTHING THIS SHITE ALBAQIR SAYS O. . WALAI HE IS WORSE THAN JEWS. . EVEN THAN AWON BABA ALAWO . . WORSE THAN SUFI XEF. . pers0n wey hate abubakr and aeesha, umar, uthman, abu hurayrah and many sahabahs . . every friday dem dey curse our sahabahs . . them say aeesha did adultery . . them even have absolute different quran and hadith . . . taqiyah is what he is using. . 7

8 Likes

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by aleeyus(m): 10:14am On Oct 20, 2017
Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by blackbelt(m): 10:15am On Oct 20, 2017
No they are not sects
Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by hamzeiy: 10:25am On Oct 20, 2017
The might not be strictly drscribed as sect but groups or associations which might or might not be under a sect. That been said all forms of group or association is discouraged within the muslim ummah. Either its mssn oh or nasfat and the rest, this is what I know and understand from the explanation of a noble sheikh of sunna I trust. Mal abdulrahman abdulrauf abu naseer (may Allah guide him further) . Allah knows best
Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by DaBillionnaire: 10:27am On Oct 20, 2017
[quote author=AlBaqir post=61581319]

# In a Nutshell, Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen etc are NOT (new) Sect because their activities do not preach or introduce NEW Aqeedah (beliefs) or Fiqh (Jurisprudence) rather their activities is calling towards goodness, enjoining what is right and forbidding evil.




please, i will like you to define the activities of this groups and compare them to the correct ways of practicing the deen and let's see if they go against or not.

3 Likes

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by Nobody: 10:30am On Oct 20, 2017
shahydbinaliyu:
This is exactly the same thing that ASRAU BILAL, ISA AKINDELE QUOTE TO DEFEND THEIR KUFRU (HIZBIYUN, FIROQ, SECT, ISLAMIC GROUP, EGBE) . . . . .wAlai if you die bel0nging to an islamic affiliated sect, walai you wil stay forever in hell
brother, calm down
this is not a recommended way of dawah by d profet
u don't say pple will stay in hell, are u d 1 in charge?
Fear Allah, his fataawas might be wrong which I know but some things are still true der.
At least, he mention followung quran wa sunnah.
We know dat sects is not d best fin in Islam mostly d way dey re nowadays but den even if ure sect, wat is expected of any muslim is to follow d quran and sunnah as understood by d faithful predecessors, ur name, ur grp is nt d problem
but ur aqeedah and mnahaj

and Brother, pls don't do takfeer for pple just like dat for Allah sake
Allah might change him later even if he ia shia, and u knw dat hadith dat if u call sm1 member of hell and he was later pardoned by Allah, ull b d member of hell
Allahu Mustaan

12 Likes

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by Hassan080196(m): 10:53am On Oct 20, 2017
shahydbinaliyu:
This is exactly the same thing that ASRAU BILAL, ISA AKINDELE QUOTE TO DEFEND THEIR KUFRU (HIZBIYUN, FIROQ, SECT, ISLAMIC GROUP, EGBE) . . . . .wAlai if you die bel0nging to an islamic affiliated sect, walai you wil stay forever in hell

See jabata people. Always calling people Kaafir while what you people do is more grief. I laugh in swahili. Go listen to Sheikh ibn baz, uthymeen and sulaymeen ar ruhayli fataawas on groups/sects. Lest I forgot, you've termed all these scholars Kaafir as well undecided. I pray Allah open your eyes from that state of ignorance you're wallowing in.

Any group following following the madhab of kutabu (Qur'an) wa Sunnah (Hadith) and manhaj salafu Salih is welcome in Islam.
Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by Hassan080196(m): 10:56am On Oct 20, 2017
Abdullah2892:

brother, calm down
this is not a recommended way of dawah by d profet
u don't say pple will stay in hell, are u d 1 in charge?
Fear Allah, his fataawas might be wrong which I know but some things are still true der.
At least, he mention followung quran wa sunnah.
We know dat sects is not d best fin in Islam mostly d way dey re nowadays but den even if ure sect, wat is expected of any muslim is to follow d quran and sunnah as understood by d faithful predecessors, ur name, ur grp is nt d problem
but ur aqeedah and mnahaj

and Brother, pls don't do takfeer for pple just like dat for Allah sake
Allah might change him later even if he ia shia, and u knw dat hadith dat if u call sm1 member of hell and he was later pardoned by Allah, ull b d member of hell
Allahu Mustaan

Jazak my brother.

Don't you know them ni, it's in their blood to always call people kaafir while we all know that they are not in the position to do so.
Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by budosky(m): 10:56am On Oct 20, 2017
لا فرق عندى بين المشركين الأصلي والشيعة أو الروافض العصر. وإذا نظرنا الا عقيدتهم ومناهجهم الفاسدة، سنرى أن الشيعة أو الروافض أشد كفرا من اليهود و النصارى

2 Likes 1 Share

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by Nobody: 10:57am On Oct 20, 2017
Allah Knows Best.

1 Like 2 Shares

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by AlBaqir(m): 11:01am On Oct 20, 2017
DaBillionnaire:


please, i will like you to define the activities of this groups
and compare them to the correct ways of practicing the
deen and let's see if they go against or not.

NB: This thread is NOT interested in examine the
correctness or wrongness of their activities as some might
want to submit, rather it only wish to state clearly the
definition of SECT/FACTION as different from a mere
GROUP/PARTY.

# SECT OR FACTIONS like AhluSunnah, Shia, Salafi etc preached Aqeedah (beliefs) and Fiqh (jurisprudence) different from each other. All of them are definitely among the 73 sects that the Prophet says his Ummah will be divided into.

# GROUP/PARTY like Nasfat, Ansarudeen, MSSN etc primarily belong in their Aqeedah and Fiqh, to one of the abovementioned SECTS/FACTIONS (i.e Sunni, Shia, Salafi etc) therefore are NOT "SECT" but "GROUP, PARTY OR ASSOCIATION" with a defined activities. We have established this fact with Quran 3: 104.

AGAIN, whether they are right or wrong, is not the scope of this thread.
Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by budosky(m): 11:05am On Oct 20, 2017
Temilayhor:
Allah Knows Best.

نعم، الله أعلى واعلم لكن، النبي عليه صلاة والسلام قد بين الإسلام كله لأمته. ولهذا، يجب لكل مسلم أن يتعلم دينه جيدا!

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by RapportNaija(m): 11:05am On Oct 20, 2017
NB: This thread is NOT interested in examine the correctness or wrongness of their activities as some might want to submit, rather it only wish to state clear the definition of SECT/FACTION as different from a mere GROUP/PARTY...


This has done it for me, so ama just shut up.
Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by budosky(m): 11:12am On Oct 20, 2017
AlBaqir:


NB: This thread is NOT interested in examine the
correctness or wrongness of their activities as some might
want to submit, rather it only wish to state clearly the
definition of SECT/FACTION as different from a mere
GROUP/PARTY.

# SECT OR FACTIONS like AhluSunnah, Shia, Salafi etc preached Aqeedah (beliefs) and Fiqh (jurisprudence) different from each other. All of them are definitely among the 73 sects that the Prophet says his Ummah will be divided into.

# GROUP/PARTY like Nasfat, Ansarudeen, MSSN etc primarily belong in their Aqeedah and Fiqh, to one of the abovementioned SECTS/FACTIONS (i.e Sunni, Shia, Salafi etc) therefore are NOT "SECT" but "GROUP, PARTY OR ASSOCIATION" with a defined activities. We have established this fact with Quran 3: 104.

AGAIN, whether they are right or wrong, is not the scope of this thread.

قولك هذا هو قولٌ مبني على الكذب، والظلم، وقلة العلم الصحيحة، وافتراء على الله سبحانه

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by proudlyYoruba(m): 11:14am On Oct 20, 2017
May Allah continue to increase ur knowledge
Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by AlBaqir(m): 11:16am On Oct 20, 2017
budosky:


قولك هذا هو قولٌ مبني على الكذب، والظلم، وقلة العلم الصحيحة، وافتراء على الله سبحانه

# If you think the definition is based on lies, and lack of proper understanding, then, you are free to present yours. Simple as that.
Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by budosky(m): 11:30am On Oct 20, 2017
AlBaqir:


# If you think the definition is based on lies, and lack of proper understanding, then, you are free to present yours. Simple as that.

أن لن أحاور الشيعي ام الرافضي مثلك أبداً… حتى تؤمن بالّله وحده وأن محمد عبده ورسوله... فإذا فعلت ذالك، سوف يصح الجلسة والحوار معك
!…

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by AlBaqir(m): 11:40am On Oct 20, 2017
budosky:


أن لن أحاور الشيعي ام الرافضي مثلك أبداً… حتى تؤمن بالّله وحده وأن محمد عبده ورسوله... فإذا فعلت ذالك، سوف يصح الجلسة والحوار معك
!…


* Shi'a and Rawafidha are obviously your eternal problem. Unfortunately, we are not discussing Shiism here so its of no use replying you on that.

It's funny though grin grin It's like you are just learning Arabic. This is an English thread/forum faah. Let people see your thoughts on the subject matter.

4 Likes

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by budosky(m): 11:41am On Oct 20, 2017
Abdullah2892:

brother, calm down
this is not a recommended way of dawah by d profet
u don't say pple will stay in hell, are u d 1 in charge?
Fear Allah, his fataawas might be wrong which I know but some things are still true der.
At least, he mention followung quran wa sunnah.
We know dat sects is not d best fin in Islam mostly d way dey re nowadays but den even if ure sect, wat is expected of any muslim is to follow d quran and sunnah as understood by d faithful predecessors, ur name, ur grp is nt d problem
but ur aqeedah and mnahaj

and Brother, pls don't do takfeer for pple just like dat for Allah sake
Allah might change him later even if he ia shia, and u knw dat hadith dat if u call sm1 member of hell and he was later pardoned by Allah, ull b d member of hell
Allahu Mustaan

يا هذا، هل عرفت انّ التكفير من وقع فى الكفر، وتبديع من وقع فى البدع، والتفسيق من وقع فى الفسقِ بعد شروطهم واردة فى فى الإسلام؟

1 Like 1 Share

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by budosky(m): 11:42am On Oct 20, 2017
AlBaqir:


* Shi'a and Rawafidha are obviously your eternal problem. Unfortunately, we are not discussing Shiism here so its of no use replying you on that.

It's funny though grin grin It's like you are just learning Arabic. This is an English thread/forum faah. Let people see your thoughts on the subject matter.

ههههههههههه
Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by Empiree: 12:03pm On Oct 20, 2017
budosky:


يا هذا، هل عرفت انّ التكفير من وقع فى الكفر، وتبديع من وقع فى البدع، والتفسيق من وقع فى الفسقِ بعد شروطهم واردة فى فى الإسلام؟

You just looking to derail this thread by any means necessary?

1 Like

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by Empiree: 12:04pm On Oct 20, 2017
shahydbinaliyu:
This is exactly the same thing that ASRAU BILAL, ISA AKINDELE QUOTE TO DEFEND THEIR KUFRU (HIZBIYUN, FIROQ, SECT, ISLAMIC GROUP, EGBE) . . . . .wAlai if you die bel0nging to an islamic affiliated sect, walai you wil stay forever in hell
I hope you realized that Sheikh Bin Baz(ra) also made the same submission as op did?.
Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by Raintaker(m): 12:19pm On Oct 20, 2017
budosky:

ههههههههههه
Ogbeni, the way you type shows you are immature. This is a strictly English Forum.

2 Likes

Re: Nasfat, MSSN, TMC, Ansarudeen Etc. Are These Groups "SECTS"? by budosky(m): 12:28pm On Oct 20, 2017
Raintaker:
Ogbeni, the way you type shows you are immature.
This is a strictly English Forum.

I'm immature coz of the way I type?

What a stereotypical conclusion. Well, that's my preferred language and I type with it when dealing with Islamic matters.


"This is a strictly English Forum" Says who? .

I don't think you know the meaning of strictness or you don't know what you're saying. Maybe you should recheck the forum rules!

(1) (2) (Reply)

Are Infants' Vomits Pure Or Impure? / Words Of Advice For Those That Share "Ultimatum Messages'' / Islam hates Women?

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 66
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.