₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,397 members, 8,522,813 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 06:04 AM

Toggle theme

FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules - Politics (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules (10637 Views)

1 2 Reply (Go Down)

Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by Lightening: 9:09am On Apr 14, 2018
chloride6:
Nigerian states have no powers to reject requests filed under the Freedom of Information Act (FoI), the Court of Appeal has ruled.

In a March 27 decision at the Akure Division, the Court of Appeal ruled that the requests for information, especially around public expenditure, under the FoI, are made in public interest and should be honoured by all states.

The decision came in an appeal filed by Martins Alo, a journalist, against the Speaker of Ondo State House of Assembly and Auditor-General of Ondo State.

Mr Alo had demanded the audited report of Ondo State Government between 2012 and 2014 to properly access how public funds are utilised in the state. But the request was rejected, prompting him to seek judicial redress.

The Akure Division of Ondo State High Court had previously ruled in 2016 that Mr Alo had no right to demand how the state was spending money, saying the FoI was not applicable to states and the request was not in public interest to begin with.

The judge, Williams Akintoroye, also said Mr Alo should pay a damage of N10,000 for wasting time and resources of the state.

But Mr Alo’s lawyer, Femi Emodamori, appealed the ruling on behalf of his client, arguing that Mr Akintoroye erred in his judgment and that his client was acting in public interest.

A three-member panel at the Court of Appeal rejected Mr Akintoroye’s ruling and agreed with the appellant that the FoI was applicable to states and it was in public interest for the state government to release its audited report.

The Court of Appeal judges who sat on the matter included Uzo Ndukwe-Anyanwu, Obande Ogbuinya and Ridwan Abdullahi.

Mr Ndukwe-Anyanwu wrote the lead opinion, saying Mr Alo has a right to act on behalf of the public to obtain the information from state authorities. He also quashed the N10,000“In a democratic dispensation, such as the Nigeria’s, the citizens have been proclaimed the owners of sovereignty and mandates that place leaders in the saddle,” Mr Ogbuinya said in his concurring opinion.

The citizens have a right to know details of “expenditure of public funds generated from their taxes,” Mr Ogbuinya added.

Several states, including Lagos, Adamawa, Akwa-Ibom and Ondo, have been rejecting FoI requests relating to their activities since the law was signed in 2011 by former President Goodluck Jonathan.

The states argued that the FoI is a federal law and its provisions are simply not binding on their respective jurisdictions, frustrating accountability efforts by media outlets and transparency advocates.

“The decision of the Court of Appeal is consistent with well-established principles of legislation,” said rights activist Inibehe Effiong.

Mr Effiong, who has repeatedly filed judicial proceedings for public disclosure of expenditure by states, told PREMIUM TIMES the states are willfully wasting public funds in pursuing the cases because the Nigerian Constitution is clear on laws like FoI..

“By virtue of paragraph four and five in part two of the second schedule of the Constitution, the states should know that the National Assembly can make laws with respect to the archives and pubic records,” he said. “The FoI Act is a law that stipulates how the public should have access to public record.”

“Even if a State House of Assembly makes a law about how the public should have access to public record, such law would only be subservient to a similar one passed by the National Assembly.

‘I am not surprised by the judgement. The states too know this but they’re just wasting public funds in challenging the matter, he added. fine imposed by the lower court.

“Only international treaties and instruments could be domesticated, you don’t need to domesticate a federal law,” the lawyer added. “Anyone who is aggrieved should proceed to the Supreme Court, but I am confident that the Supreme Court will uphold the ruling of the Court of Appeal.”

It was not immediately clear whether Ondo State lawyers, led by Taiwo Olubodun, plan to appeal the ruling to the Supreme Court.

The Ikeja Division of Lagos State High Court had reached a similar conclusion in late last year, telling Lagos State government to immediately comply with all FoI requests because the state was bound to obey federal laws.

But the state rejected the ruling, filing an appeal to have it overturned. Based on the principle of precedent, the Lagos State appeal would be struck out following the latest ruling in Akure.



It's another great day for democracy.

https://www.premiumtimesng.com/news/headlines/264863-freedom-of-information-act-applicable-to-all-states-in-nigeria-appeal-court-rules.html
Shame on the sophisticated judges of Akure division of the state high court. A judge that thinks that tax payers don't have the right to know and question government expenditures, that one na judge?
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by 0monnak0da: 9:16am On Apr 14, 2018
Lightening:
Shame on the sophisticated judges of Akure division of the state high court. A judge that thinks that tax payers don't have the right to know and question government expenditures, that one na judge?
A judge is not there to give opinions but to interpret the law.

I Agree we should know but I don't agree that the end justifies the means.

I think the judgment is wrong and undermines federalism. Perhaps it could have been hinged on the constitution rather than the Act.

There are many potential far reaching unintended consequences of this judgment. I hope it goes to the Supreme Court. In fact I am certain it will because other states too would be interested.

If we are to have genuine federalism then such laws should not be made for the states by the National Assembly.

We may say it is okay because we agree with the outcome. There are many more consequential outcomes thhat will be very unpalatable in the futuure if this stands
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by biggy26: 12:59pm On Apr 14, 2018
lailo:
for those shouting Tinubu and Lagos state. Has it even been obeyed by both FG and other states.
Does that justify Tinubu and Lagos state?
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by efrebor177: 1:01pm On Apr 14, 2018
doctokwus:
There is still slight hope with these kinds of judges.
With this ruling people should demand the expenditure accounts of Lagos state government since the era of Tinubu to Fashola(that publicly proclaimed that FOI cannot be domesticated in Lagos!),down to Ambode that is constructing without a single cost being publicly made known.
The revelations will be earth shaking.
And DELTA STATE from Ibori to Ugduagan and the present stooge called Okowa. With nothing to show for the 13% derivation collected monthly. No mention of the undisclosed IGR.
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by phase1: 5:24pm On Apr 14, 2018
The ondo Judge should be Debarred.
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by phase1: 6:00pm On Apr 14, 2018
0monnak0da:
A judge is not there to give opinions but to interpret the law.

I Agree we should know but I don't agree that the end justifies the means.

I think the judgment is wrong and undermines federalism. Perhaps it could have been hinged on the constitution rather than the Act.

There are many potential far reaching unintended consequences of this judgment. I hope it goes to the Supreme Court. In fact I am certain it will because other states too would be interested.

If we are to have genuine federalism then such laws should not be made for the states by the National Assembly.

We may say it is okay because we agree with the outcome. There are many more consequential outcomes thhat will be very unpalatable in the futuure if this stands
Give us examples of the 'unintended consequences' and 'unpalatable outcomes'
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by adisaigbo1(m): 7:42pm On Apr 14, 2018
seguno2:
Are you no longer Igbo from your name? Or are you confused about your identity nihuh
National ID card officer... well done Sir!!
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by omohayek: 9:09pm On Apr 14, 2018
This is one legal ruling I support wholeheartedly, and yes, the first state I think of for its application is Lagos, followed by Ogun and the rest of the SW states in declining order of IGR. Even if certain people are rubbing their hands in glee at this ruling merely out of their hatred of Tinubu, Fashola and Ambode, that stil doesn't mean their calls for greater transparency in LASG expenditures are wrong. More transparent taxing and spending by state governments can only mean more reasonably priced and higher-quality projects, which in turn means Lagos state taxpayers getting better value for their money. If we want to wean our states completely off their dependence on federal allocations, it is essential that people come to trust that their taxes are being properly spent, instead of being pocketed by a few bigwigs through shady contracts.
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by NdiaraIGBO: 10:25pm On Apr 14, 2018
doctokwus:
There is still slight hope with these kinds of judges.
With this ruling people should demand the expenditure accounts of Lagos state government since the era of Tinubu to Fashola(that publicly proclaimed that FOI cannot be domesticated in Lagos!),down to Ambode that is constructing without a single cost being publicly made known.
The revelations will be earth shaking.
Face your 5 village states, Lagos state has nothing to do with igbos, you are just a tenant!

The best place to start are the 13 derivation states with the colossal amount of allocation money they receive.
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by chloride6(op): 11:24pm On Apr 14, 2018
0monnak0da:
A judge is not there to give opinions but to interpret the law.

I Agree we should know but I don't agree that the end justifies the means.

I think the judgment is wrong and undermines federalism. Perhaps it could have been hinged on the constitution rather than the Act.

There are many potential far reaching unintended consequences of this judgment. I hope it goes to the Supreme Court. In fact I am certain it will because other states too would be interested.

If we are to have genuine federalism then such laws should not be made for the states by the National Assembly.

We may say it is okay because we agree with the outcome. There are many more consequential outcomes thhat will be very unpalatable in the futuure if this stands
i disagree with you sir. This does not undermine federalism in any way.

It is a widely accepted fact that federal law trumps state law when ever there is a clash.

Furthermore, there are a good number of laws that control the affairs of the state and are made at the federal level. The law use act is one of them.

Another act pertinent to the issue at hand is the Personal Income Tax Act of 2011.

If the state relies on federal law to empower it to collect tax , then federal law is sufficient to compel to divulge its finances especially regarding the same tax.
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by 0monnak0da:
chloride6:
i disagree with you sir. This does not undermine federalism in any way.

It is a widely accepted fact that federal law trumps state law when ever there is a clash.

Furthermore, there are a good number of laws that control the affairs of the state and are made at the federal level. The law use act is one of them.

Another act pertinent to the issue at hand is the Personal Income Tax Act of 2011.

If the state relies on federal law to empower it to collect tax , then federal law is sufficient to compel to divulge its finances especially regarding the same tax.
Federal law trumps state law? ? Widely accepted by whom?

Can you back that claim up.
We operate a federal system just like the US . They have Federal FOI laws and state ones too. There is no question of one FOI trumping the other there.
I will refer you to Lagos Statee v The Federal Government at the Supreme Court in the matter of Hotel Licensing.

The FG cannot make laws about how state governments should run its affairs

I do not see the relevance of the personal income tax act. The collection of Personal Income Tax is a constitutional matter. The states do not RELY on the Federal law to EMPOWER them to collect that . I am sorry that is nonsense


The so call ed Land Use Act is actually a Military decree from 1978 and is a constitutional matter. It cannot be repealed by the Federal Government without changing the constitution.

Recently another court ruled that the EFCC has no power investigate the state government finances .Why did the Federal not "TRUMP" the state.
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by chloride6(op): 7:38am On Apr 15, 2018
0monnak0da:
Federal law trumps state law? ? Widely accepted by whom?

Can you back that claim up.
We operate a federal system just like the US . They have Federal FOI laws and state ones too. There is no question of one FOI trumping the other there.
I will refer you to Lagos Statee v The Federal Government at the Supreme Court in the matter of Hotel Licensing.

The FG cannot make laws about how state governments should run its affairs

I do not see the relevance of the personal income tax act. The collection of Personal Income Tax is a constitutional matter. The states do not RELY on the Federal law to EMPOWER them to collect that . I am sorry that is nonsense


The so call ed Land Use Act is actually a Military decree from 1978 and is a constitutional matter. It cannot be repealed by the Federal Government without changing the constitution.

Recently another court ruled that the EFCC has no power investigate the state government finances .Why did the Federal not "TRUMP" the state.
Personal Income Tax is not constitutional. There is no common law jurisdiction where person income tax is.

In the US, the bulk of PIT is collectedness at the Federal level. That is set to change soon in Nigerian once our states become economically viable.
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by 0monnak0da: 11:10am On Apr 15, 2018
chloride6:
Personal Income Tax is not constitutional. There is no common law jurisdiction where person income tax is.

In the US, the bulk of PIT is collectedness at the Federal level. That is set to change soon in Nigerian once our states become economically viable.
Personal Income Tax is unconstitutional??

Let us not digress otherwise we will find ourselves talking about the FIFA world Cup soon.

Like I said I do not see its relevance to this matter so let us stick to the topic.

I do not know what common law jurisdiction has got to do with Nigeria or this matter.
You are just introduciing random irrelevances. What is the meaning of "common law jurisdiction" what does that meanhuh

You are well withn your rights to disagree with me as you did but whilst doing that let us not end up talking about how Knorr cubes are superior to Maggi cubes and stick firmly to the issue at han which is the ruling that FOI act applies to the States. As it is now there is another case at the Appeal Court involving Lagos > If that Case finds differently to this we shall have to see what the Supreme Court says. The claim in the Final paragrraph about principle of Precedent is wrong. Court are not bound to precedents by courts of similar standing.

I stand by by claim that there is a contradiction between this judgment and the EFCC judgment with regards to the Force of Federal laws over state governments
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by chloride6(op): 2:05pm On Apr 15, 2018
0monnak0da:
Personal Income Tax is unconstitutional??

Let us not digress otherwise we will find ourselves talking about the FIFA world Cup soon.

Like I said I do not see its relevance to this matter so let us stick to the topic.

I do not know what common law jurisdiction has got to do with Nigeria or this matter.
You are just introduciing random irrelevances. What is the meaning of "common law jurisdiction" what does that meanhuh

You are well withn your rights to disagree with me as you did but whilst doing that let us not end up talking about how Knorr cubes are superior to Maggi cubes and stick firmly to the issue at han which is the ruling that FOI act applies to the States. As it is now there is another case at the Appeal Court involving Lagos > If that Case finds differently to this we shall have to see what the Supreme Court says. The claim in the Final paragrraph about principle of Precedent is wrong. Court are not bound to precedents by courts of similar standing.

I stand by by claim that there is a contradiction between this judgment and the EFCC judgment with regards to the Force of Federal laws over state governments
grin grin grin grin

First of all, i apologize if i said personal income taxes are not unconstitutional. I did not mean that PIT was unconstitutional, i simply meant that it is not made reference to in the document we refer to as the "constitution".

The Personal Income Tax law empowers state to collect taxes..

THE PIT is a federal law


PART I

Imposition of tax and income chargeable

1. Imposition of tax

There is hereby imposed a tax on the income-

(a) of individuals, communities and families; and

(b) arising or due to a trustee or estate,

which shall be determined under and be subject to the provisions of this Act. [1996 No. 30.]

2. Persons on whom tax is to be imposed

(1) Tax of an amount to be determined horn the Table set out in the Sixth Schedule (in this Act referred to as "income tax"wink shall be payable for each year of assessment on the total income of-

(a) every individual other than persons covered under paragraph (b) of this sub- section or corporation sole or body of individuals deemed to be resident for that year in the relevant State under the provisions of this Act; and

(b) the following other persons, that is-

(i) persons employed in the Nigerian Army, the Nigerian Navy, the Nigerian Air Force, the Nigerian Police Force other than in a civilian capacity;

(ii) officers of the Nigerian Foreign Service;

(iii) every resident of the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja; and

(iv) a person resident outside Nigeria who derives income or profit from Nigeria.

Collection of Tax from Itinerant Workers [Inserted by s.2(b) of No. 20 of 2011]

(1A) Notwithstanding anything in the Principal Act, the relevant tax authority in a State shall have powers to collect tax under this Act from itinerant workers.

Furthermore, the constitution states that,

7. In the exercise of its powers to impose any tax or duty on -

(a) capital gains, incomes or profits or persons other than companies; and

(b) documents or transactions by way of stamp duties.

the National Assembly may, subject to such conditions as it may prescribe, provide that the collection of any such tax or duty or the administration of the law imposing it shall be carried out by the Government of a State or other authority of a State.


In summary, it is the federal government that gives the state power to collect PIT. Infact taxation is in the exclusive list.

Your argument of the conflict between EFCC judgement in Ekiti and the FOI does not hold water. The EFCC case is an issue of financial investigation, the FOI simply reveals information. There is a mammoth difference.

My argument is that if federal law is sufficient to empower states to collect taxes, it is sufficient to compel them to reveal their use of it.

By common law jurisdiction i meant other countries where common law is applicable.

The truth is that in a federal structure such as is obtainable in the US and other countries where common law is applicable, PIT is jointly collected by the state and federal government with the larger chunk going to the Federal.

In the future, the PIT will be amended to reflect this.
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by mabea: 2:33pm On Apr 15, 2018
Good! No more secrecy in government. Lagos for example, has been operating a one man show govt.
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by 0monnak0da: 2:43pm On Apr 15, 2018
chloride6:
grin grin grin grin

First of all, i apologize if i said personal income taxes are not unconstitutional. I did not mean that PIT was unconstitutional, i simply meant that it is not made reference to in the document we refer to as the "constitution".

The Personal Income Tax law empowers state to collect taxes..

THE PIT is a federal law


PART I

Imposition of tax and income chargeable

1. Imposition of tax

There is hereby imposed a tax on the income-

(a) of individuals, communities and families; and

(b) arising or due to a trustee or estate,

which shall be determined under and be subject to the provisions of this Act. [1996 No. 30.]

2. Persons on whom tax is to be imposed

(1) Tax of an amount to be determined horn the Table set out in the Sixth Schedule (in this Act referred to as "income tax"wink shall be payable for each year of assessment on the total income of-

(a) every individual other than persons covered under paragraph (b) of this sub- section or corporation sole or body of individuals deemed to be resident for that year in the relevant State under the provisions of this Act; and

(b) the following other persons, that is-

(i) persons employed in the Nigerian Army, the Nigerian Navy, the Nigerian Air Force, the Nigerian Police Force other than in a civilian capacity;

(ii) officers of the Nigerian Foreign Service;

(iii) every resident of the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja; and

(iv) a person resident outside Nigeria who derives income or profit from Nigeria.

Collection of Tax from Itinerant Workers [Inserted by s.2(b) of No. 20 of 2011]

(1A) Notwithstanding anything in the Principal Act, the relevant tax authority in a State shall have powers to collect tax under this Act from itinerant workers.

Furthermore, the constitution states that,

7. In the exercise of its powers to impose any tax or duty on -

(a) capital gains, incomes or profits or persons other than companies; and

(b) documents or transactions by way of stamp duties.

the National Assembly may, subject to such conditions as it may prescribe, provide that the collection of any such tax or duty or the administration of the law imposing it shall be carried out by the Government of a State or other authority of a State.


In summary, it is the federal government that gives the state power to collect PIT. Infact taxation is in the exclusive list.

Your argument of the conflict between EFCC judgement in Ekiti and the FOI does not hold water. The EFCC case is an issue of financial investigation, the FOI simply reveals information. There is a mammoth difference.

My argument is that if federal law is sufficient to empower states to collect taxes, it is sufficient to compel them to reveal their use of it.

By common law jurisdiction i meant other countries where common law is applicable.

The truth is that in a federal structure such as is obtainable in the US and other countries where common law is applicable, PIT is jointly collected by the state and federal government with the larger chunk going to the Federal.

In the future, the PIT will be amended to reflect this.
What is the relevance of common law here?
What is the relevance of Common law jurisdiction here?
Common Law does not have anything to do with Taxation in the US that is complete rubbish. Perhaps you should go and learn what common law means because I am sorry you are completely "off point"

The FG does not give the states power to collect tax that is total nonsense.

States have ALWAYS collected PAYE tax in Nigeria . It did not start in 2011 .
It did not start in 1999.
In order to understand the Nigerian connstitution there is a fundamental principle that eludes you apparently.
The Nigeria Constitution is essentially DECREE 24 of 1999 . It bears repeating. The 1999 constitution is Decree 24 of 1999

.What this means is that any extant decrees that were not repealed continued to operate with constitutional force. e.g the Land Use Decree of 1978 now called Land Use Act

The introduction of EFCC is about the princple of subordination of states to federal legislation. The details of the specific legislation are not in issue .
Ultimately it is not a mathematical problem of the kind to which there is only one correct answer it is down to the interpretation of our courts. As I said there is a court case involving Lagos state so let us wait for that and also wait to see if the case goes to the Supreme Court.


I mentoned the earlier Supreme Court involving LAgos State on Hotels

Your argument that

My argument is that if federal law is sufficient to empower states to collect taxes, it is sufficient to compel them to reveal their use of it.


but
The EFCC case is an issue of financial investigation, the FOI simply reveals information. There is a mammoth difference. is sel contradictory and silly.

So according to you the FG gives states the power to collect tax and so can compel them to reveal their use of it but not for the purposes of financial investigation. What is the purpose of seeking information ? For use in television shows like "Want to be a millionaire"??

Is there now a concept of "financial investigation" in law that is distinct from the revelation of information? Can the EFCC make a FOI request?
It would be interesting to hear how you define "financial investigation"

Anyway each to his own let us wait for the Lagos State case and subsequent developments
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by chloride6(op): 3:28pm On Apr 15, 2018
0monnak0da:
What is the relevance of common law here?
What is the relevance of Common law jurisdiction here?
Common Law does not have anything to do with Taxation in the US that is complete rubbish. Perhaps you should go and learn what common law means because I am sorry you are completely "off point"

The FG does not give the states power to collect tax that is total nonsense.

States have ALWAYS collected PAYE tax in Nigeria . It did not start in 2011 .
It did not start in 1999.
In order to understand the Nigerian connstitution there is a fundamental principle that eludes you apparently.
The Nigeria Constitution is essentially DECREE 24 of 1999 . It bears repeating. The 1999 constitution is Decree 24 of 1999

.What this means is that any extant decrees that were not repealed continued to operate with constitutional force. e.g the Land Use Decree of 1978 now called Land Use Act

The introduction of EFCC is about the princple of subordination of states to federal legislation. The details of the specific legislation are not in issue .
Ultimately it is not a mathematical problem of the kind to which there is only one correct answer it is down to the interpretation of our courts. As I said there is a court case involving Lagos state so let us wait for that and also wait to see if the case goes to the Supreme Court.


I mentoned the earlier Supreme Court involving LAgos State on Hotels

Your argument that

My argument is that if federal law is sufficient to empower states to collect taxes, it is sufficient to compel them to reveal their use of it.


but
The EFCC case is an issue of financial investigation, the FOI simply reveals information. There is a mammoth difference. is sel contradictory and silly.

So according to you the FG gives states the power to collect tax and so can compel them to reveal their use of it but not for the purposes of financial investigation. What is the purpose of seeking information ? For use in television shows like "Want to be a millionaire"??

Is there now a concept of "financial investigation" in law that is distinct from the revelation of information? Can the EFCC make a FOI request?
It would be interesting to hear how you define "financial investigation"

Anyway each to his own let us wait for the Lagos State case and subsequent developments
FoI requests made be used for any purposes the requester wants it for and is not restricted to financial investigation.

How about just for knowledge purposes?

I can not find any reference to Decree 24 on the internet. Perhaps you could point me the right direction.

Are you saying that a judgement in the USA cannot set precedent in Nigeria and vice versa.
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by chloride6(op): 3:45pm On Apr 15, 2018
0monnak0da:
What is the relevance of common law here?
What is the relevance of Common law jurisdiction here?
Common Law does not have anything to do with Taxation in the US that is complete rubbish. Perhaps you should go and learn what common law means because I am sorry you are completely "off point"

The FG does not give the states power to collect tax that is total nonsense.

States have ALWAYS collected PAYE tax in Nigeria . It did not start in 2011 .
It did not start in 1999.
In order to understand the Nigerian connstitution there is a fundamental principle that eludes you apparently.
The Nigeria Constitution is essentially DECREE 24 of 1999 . It bears repeating. The 1999 constitution is Decree 24 of 1999

.What this means is that any extant decrees that were not repealed continued to operate with constitutional force. e.g the Land Use Decree of 1978 now called Land Use Act

The introduction of EFCC is about the princple of subordination of states to federal legislation. The details of the specific legislation are not in issue .
Ultimately it is not a mathematical problem of the kind to which there is only one correct answer it is down to the interpretation of our courts. As I said there is a court case involving Lagos state so let us wait for that and also wait to see if the case goes to the Supreme Court.


I mentoned the earlier Supreme Court involving LAgos State on Hotels

Your argument that

My argument is that if federal law is sufficient to empower states to collect taxes, it is sufficient to compel them to reveal their use of it.


but
The EFCC case is an issue of financial investigation, the FOI simply reveals information. There is a mammoth difference. is sel contradictory and silly.

So according to you the FG gives states the power to collect tax and so can compel them to reveal their use of it but not for the purposes of financial investigation. What is the purpose of seeking information ? For use in television shows like "Want to be a millionaire"??

Is there now a concept of "financial investigation" in law that is distinct from the revelation of information? Can the EFCC make a FOI request?
It would be interesting to hear how you define "financial investigation"

Anyway each to his own let us wait for the Lagos State case and subsequent developments
Besides, who has always collected what is irrelevant. What is important is who allows who collect what.

The constitution places tax legislation under federal legislative and further discusses PIT in the PIT act of 2011.

The argument of common law is to show you that in similarly structured countries, PIT is collected by the Feds, not the state. And when the ensuing case of who should really collect PIT begins, the federal govt may make an arguement based on that.

In advanced countries, PIT dwarf corporation taxes by far and in the nearest future the Federal govt will make a go for it.

The state is a tempoary benefactor of the PIT.
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by 0monnak0da: 3:47pm On Apr 15, 2018
chloride6:
FoI requests made be used for any purposes the requester wants it for and is not restricted to financial investigation.

How about just for knowledge purposes?

I can not find any reference to Decree 24 on the internet. Perhaps you could point me the right direction.

Are you saying that a judgement in the USA cannot set precedent in Nigeria and vice versa.
Guy you are wasting my time. I am not sure where we are going with any of this.
The Nigerian constitution is decree 24 of 1999 . I don't have anything else to add to that.
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by chloride6(op): 3:58pm On Apr 15, 2018
0monnak0da:
Guy you are wasting my time. I am not sure where we are going with any of this.
The Nigerian constitution is decree 24 of 1999 . I don't have anything else to add to that.
Seen.

You didn't have to be brash

Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by 0monnak0da: 4:30pm On Apr 15, 2018
chloride6:
Seen.

You didn't have to be brash
Are you gayhuh
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by 0monnak0da: 4:38pm On Apr 15, 2018
chloride6:
Besides, who has always collected what is irrelevant. What is important is who allows who collect what.

The constitution places tax legislation under federal legislative and further discusses PIT in the PIT act of 2011.

The argument of common law is to show you that in similarly structured countries, PIT is collected by the Feds, not the state. And when the ensuing case of who should really collect PIT begins, the federal govt may make an arguement based on that.

In advanced countries, PIT dwarf corporation taxes by far and in the nearest future the Federal govt will make a go for it.

The state is a tempoary benefactor of the PIT.
Who has alway collected is very important because we must question the authority on which they collect.

The point is ththat the FG as we know it today is not what "ALLOWS" states to collect PAYE rather it is the Taxes and Levies Decree 21 of 1998. So it is important to understand that very crucial point. i.e constitutional status of these unrepealed decrees and the fact that the constitution itself is a decree.

So the National Assembly cannot wake up tomorrow and repeal the decree 21 of 1998 and decide that PAYE should accrue to the FG. That is a constitutional matter
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by chloride6(op): 4:40pm On Apr 15, 2018
0monnak0da:
Are you gayhuh
grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin grin
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by chloride6(op): 4:41pm On Apr 15, 2018
0monnak0da:
Who has alway collected is very important because we must question the authority on which they collect.

The point is ththat the FG as we know it today is not what "ALLOWS" states to collect PAYE rather it is the Taxes and Levies Decree 21 of 1998. So it is important to understand that very crucial point. i.e constitutional status of these unrepealed decrees and the fact that the constitution itself is a decree.

So the National Assembly cannot wake up tomorrow and repeal the decree 21 of 1998 and decide that PAYE should accrue to the FG. That is a constitutional matter
Just asking, how was the NYSC decree repealed?
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by 0monnak0da: 4:48pm On Apr 15, 2018
chloride6:
Just asking, how was the NYSC decree repealed?
I have absolutely no idea if Buhari uses toilet roll , you would know better
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by chloride6(op): 4:50pm On Apr 15, 2018
0monnak0da:
I have absolutely no idea if Buhari uses toilet roll , you would know better
grin grin grin grin grin grin grin

okay sir. it was nice talking with you.

Thank you for the exposition into decree 24.
Re: FOI Act Applicable To All States In Nigeria - Appeal Court Rules by 0monnak0da: 5:04pm On Apr 15, 2018
chloride6:
grin grin grin grin grin grin grin

okay sir. it was nice talking with you.

Thank you for the exposition into decree 24.
No worries, regards to Buhari grin
1 2 Reply

FOI: SERAP Seeks Details Of Spending On Failed $460m CCTV, Other Chinese Loans • FOI: Buhari’s State House Among Most Non-Transparent Govt Institutions – Survey • NNPC Rejects Falana’s FOI Request On Fuel Importation, Not A Public Institution • 2 • 3 • 4

Enugu LG Polls: Ugwuanyi, Ekweremadu, Others Campaign For PDP • PDP NWC Dissolves Kano Party Executives, Appoints Seven-Man Committee • Abia PDP Holds Governorship Primary Election Today Amidst Tight Security