What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? - Politics (4) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Politics › What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? (27527 Views)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... 12 Reply (Go Down)
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by MXrep: 1:07pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
Iamgrey5:All obas originate from benin. All emirs are fulani. Deal with it |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Westtimeline: 1:09pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
MXrep:Lol, and where is the proof? I do not take distorted history as fact. Cos if two children fight and they will surely talk I need favor of themselves. So nothing a Benin or Yoruba man will say that I will accept. I prefer outsider which is neutral. |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by MXrep: 1:09pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
Iamgrey5:Benin controlled the coast. |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Westtimeline: 1:10pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
MXrep:You are just a Paine igbo. Well, una no get history. |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Iamgrey5(m): 1:10pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
MXrep:Lol. How come there's only one Oba in Benin because of the link with the Yorubas And it's common in Yorubaland ![]() |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by MXrep: 1:12pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
Westtimeline:I love this. Since you also discredited yoruba version. However, as a neutral person from the east I go with benin version. Even the name oduduwa sound so Benin. Unlike ezechime and akalaka which are purely igbo names adventurers from igbo to benin |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Iamgrey5(m): 1:12pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
MXrep:Which coast did they control The bight cut across different countries The bini did not even have any influence in Dahomey history ![]() |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by MXrep: 1:14pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
Iamgrey5:They controlled from lagos to benin. Ijaw controlled the eastern axis until the rise of Aro |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by MXrep: 1:16pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
Iamgrey5:Because yoruba had many city states. Just like fulani spread emirs in the north |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by MXrep: 1:17pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
Westtimeline:The nosense fabrications at ibadan is not history. See how hollow it is even on this thread. Nigeria had to ban history in our schools because of yoruba mischievous revisionism |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Iamgrey5(m): 1:20pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
MXrep:They didn't control lagos. They were given the opportunity to provide security in sections of Lagos island, while the Yorubas kept the ownership of their lands. The ilaje controlled their own territory in Ondo, while Ijaw and some Edo influence controlled the rest to the East. Yorubas, Fons and Guns controlled the sea side of the present day Benin Republic. ![]() |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by MyVILLAGEpeople(op): 1:21pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
Binikingdowm:Same evidence you Benin have. According to the Yorubas. Oramiyan the son of oduduwa came to rule Benin( he called it ile ubinu before it was corrupted to Benin) and he gave birth to eweka. The story is kinda long though. This is also in their history. |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Iamgrey5(m): 1:21pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
MXrep:Emirs is not a Fulani but a Muslim title. Oba is quite different ![]() |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by MXrep: 1:22pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
Iamgrey5:You are very funny. We are talking about ancient people when it was all about Conquest. Lol. They can't be guarding the land if they had not conquered it |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by MXrep: 1:24pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
Iamgrey5:Fulani brought islam. They were first emirs and emir is hereditary. Do the maths |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Iamgrey5(m): 1:26pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
MXrep:How come they don't own any land in a conquered territory The idumota the oba built his palace was even given to him by Aromire chiefs Abi we should have large villages with bini population in lagos now |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Iamgrey5(m): 1:31pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
MXrep:Emir is Islamic The holy war that brought Fulani conquest lead by Utman Daffadio is well documented. It is reason why we have a caliphate(Islamic state) in Sokoto But oba is well established in Yoruba land even before the Advent of Oduduwa, we had Obatala in Ife. ![]() |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by MxreR: 1:39pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
Basil welcome back. Your oga is here ![]() MXrep: |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Nobody: 1:39pm On Mar 31, 2019*. Modified: 2:05pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
Iamgrey5:Actually, the word Oba is the title of the emperor of Benin empire. The Yorubas copied it in the colonial era by using it to replace the word "sir" in front of the names of their nobles. Benin empire was the super power of the region which is why it gave its name to the the bight of Benin and Dahomey later copied the name Benin as well. |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Iamgrey5(m): 1:43pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
prolog31:Not true. Benin Empire were the first to come in contact with Europeans not the most powerful by any stretch. Secondly, the word oba have long existed among the Yorubas even before the advent of Oduduwa. it is Binis that started using oba after they came in contact with Oranmiyan. Obatala's household were the ones providing the kings in ife before the Advent of Oduduwa's dynasty. |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Binikingdowm: 1:49pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
MyVILLAGEpeople:that's true. What we Benin's are saying is that, oduduwa is a Benin man, so technically oramiyan is Benin. |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Nobody: 1:58pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
Iamgrey5:The Europeans who visited the region said that Benin Empire was the superpower of the region, also the reason the British wanted to overthrow the Oba is because they couldn't trade in the region without asking for his permission. Oduduwa is a fable, you lose all credibility when you start talking about fictional characters such as oduduwa and oranmiyan. The Europeans who visited the region wrote down the titles of the nobles of the region especially in the precolonial period close to the colonial period. You can see the photos of your early colonial or late precolonial Yoruba nobles and notice that none of them is referred to as "Oba" while the Oba of Benin is. |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Nobody: 2:00pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
Binikingdowm:What I am saying is that those characters were made up like the story of Santa. It is disgraceful that in Nigeria, adults believe in children stories. |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Nobody: 2:09pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
Most Yoruba are very sensitive about Benin empire and will never admit the truth no matter how obvious it is. Instead the Yoruba would use fictional characters such as oduduwa and oranmiyan to "prove" their points while rejecting logically and factually obtained statements. |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by PVision2020(m): 2:17pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
MXrep:Unman Dan fodio came into northern Nigeria through through Jihad conquest with highly trained Islamists guerrilla warlords. Unlike your claim that a pseudo Benin Prince came all by himself to govern/conquer a city and people that are light years ahead of his father's Kingdom. How come binis bear Yoruba names and also practice the ancient yoruba elders cult (OGBONI). tell me one bini influence on the Yoruba. |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Nobody: 2:24pm On Mar 31, 2019*. Modified: 2:41pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
PVision2020:Yoruba, it seems you guys don't care about being objective at all. Who told you Yoruba were "light years ahead of Benin" ? Your claim contradicts all eyewitness accounts ! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nh2Tac1gNPU I agree with you on only one thing, ogbonni is Yoruba. And it was indeed introduced into the heart of Benin Kingdom during the colonial era when the midst was part of the western region which was political dominated by the so called Yoruba. |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Nobody: 2:28pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
MXrep:Emir is not a fulani title |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Nobody: 2:29pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
yemaldo:In nigeria, it is |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Nobody: 2:32pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
MXrep:U know little or nothing about history, Malians brought Islam to west,that's why they call it "esin imale" (mali's religion) |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Nobody: 2:33pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
prolog31:That's why we need to bring back history |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Nobody: 2:37pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
yemaldo:I agree, we need to bring back history but judging by the bad work of some Nigerian historians (revisionism), I would argue that the fundamental concept of history needs to be reintroduced in Nigeria. And actually the faculty of reasoning needs to be greatly enhanced in Nigeria. Most Nigerians are dumber than European kids. |
| Re: What Is The Relationship Between Benin, The Country And Benin City In Nigeria? by Nobody: 2:51pm On Mar 31, 2019 |
Those who keep saying ife is older than Benin city are liars. Indeed think about this: Benin city was burnt down and destroyed by cannon fire and explosives in 1897. Ife was not. Yet there is no indigenous architecture in ife. It is all colonial or post colonial constructs. Have you seen a picture of Oba palace before it was destroyed by the British ? It was as big as an entire town. Benin city was built up and served as the capital of an empire (Benin empire). The relics of Benin city are in every western European country's national museum and in north america. The queen of England has her own collection of objects coming from Oba palace, so did Rockefeller...You guys should stop being so sentimental about the passed of Benin. Just accept facts and move on with your lives. Benin empire was the superpower of the region, deal with it! |
Remi Tinubu Is Actually The President Of This Country And Not Bola Ahmed (PHOTO) • Oshiomhole Accident In Benin: The Damaged SUV Conveying Ex Governor • In Benin, The Governor Kneels To Greet The King, But Not So In Other Kingdoms.. • 2 • 3 • 4
Gov Emmanuel Applauds FG On Speedy Actualization Of Ibom Deep Seaport • Gunmen Attack Army Checkpoint In Enugu, Kill 2 Officers • Ambode Fires CEO Of Lastma, Arabamen

