LtChisom:

The OP is asking for an intelligent security dog not an abnormal volatile unbalanced temperance beast.

u seem to be against pits

But according to wat i watched and browsed on i was able to conclude that a standard American pitbull shpuld not be human aggresive...dey were bred to combat against dogs and to hunt animals.

A Rotteweiler is territorial aggresive but can not cause a damage dat a pit can cause...so in a nutshell i will go for rott buh if i cant go for rotts i will go gor american bully

Herdeyholuwa:

u seem to be against pits

Nope, am answering with respect to the question which is which is a better security dog but if you've asked which can win in a fight, you'll be surprised I may be siding the pit. Hope you understand ?

LtChisom:

Nope, am answering with respect to the question which is which is a better security dog but if you've asked which can win in a fight, you'll be surprised I may be siding the pit. Hope you understand ?

Yup I grab

I'm even confused now,alot of anwers different views and points,i gues I will av to tink over it b4 taking my final decision

Kaykay999:


Wow ur pit bull nah confirm full breed
But to find the full breed here in Nigeria nh war

Am here to help u import full breed of any dogs into Nigeria from South Africa..
Give me a trial today n surely won't regret it..
+27737839889

Get a Rott and thank me later, that's the only thing I'll tell u

A rottweiler is more territorial
A rottweiler is more aggressive
A rottweiler is more fierce looking and intimidating which is needed to scare of intruders at first site
Rottweilers are big beasts who'll deal great damage as their bite force is far greater than pits
A rottweiler is an overly balance dog great in all aspect and can be used for several purposes u name... I can't shout o

Orhevus:
Get a Rott and thank me later, that's the only thing I'll tell u

A rottweiler is more territorial
A rottweiler is more aggressive
A rottweiler is more fierce looking and intimidating which is needed to scare of intruders at first site
Rottweilers are big beasts who'll deal great damage as their bite force is far greater than pits
A rottweiler is an overly balance dog great in all aspect and can be used for several purposes u name... I can't shout o

bro u lie in that aspect of bite between both breeds go and confirm from google

Herdeyholuwa:
I'm even confused now,alot of anwers different views and points,i gues I will av to tink over it b4 taking my final decision

Just check online bro. Pitbull is not for learners.

ChristoBam:


Just check online bro. Pitbull is not for learners.

I’ll say it again, anybody who says a Rottweiler can Guard a home better than a pitbull has never owned a real APBT before. There’s something that happened in Owerri sometime last 2 years, a man requested for a pitbull pup from a Breeder in Jos, there were lots of delays in bringing the pup so the man got angry and impatient, when the pup finally came the man saw the pup and concluded he wasn’t pure. I guess he mistook the APBT for an American bully, a friend of mine decided to board the dog for a while, weeks turned into months and this dog grew steadily into a beast. At 6 months the man saw the picture of the pitbull and decided to get the dog back probably because he was now looking more like a good dog, he paid boarding fees of up to 4 months and the dog was released to him. He kept the 6 months old pitbull with his adult alpha male Rottweiler ! Big mistake, cos the very next day the 6 months old pitbull pup destroyed the Rottweiler to become the alpha male in that compound. Note, I didn’t use killed I used destroyed cos the Rottweiler’s carcass was looking like it was hit by a high velocity train. The man sold all the other male dogs excluding the pit

As for this boy Lion en story too much. The only time this boy is calm is when he comes out to mate and the female has to be receptive else na fight.

Namdeenero:
All these people praising Rottweiler here I’m sure y’all have never owned a real pitbull before. Op don’t joke with a real APBT. Where a Rottweiler will waste time barking, a pitbull will attack


Inpic is Lion my neighbors APBT that made him sell off his two Rottweilers

I was just laughing reading other people's comments saying rott over pitbull
I swear down, most of these people don't know what they call pitbull.. .. ..

olamirewaju6190:
Lol you guys must be kidding me! Rott over pitbull??! FYI pitbull are band in some countries and not advisable for first time dog owner to start with. Pit bull would take down rott easily, pitbull so dangerous and temperamental that it could attack the owner! Not advisable for you to have a pitbull bros since you just a first time dog owner Rott is still okay to have around and with children! But pitbull!! Hell no! Pitbull is the kinda American police shoot first ask questions later..

Gid bless you!!! Most of these people have never seen a pure breed pitbull before

Orhevus:
Get a Rott and thank me later, that's the only thing I'll tell u

A rottweiler is more territorial
A rottweiler is more aggressive
A rottweiler is more fierce looking and intimidating which is needed to scare of intruders at first site
Rottweilers are big beasts who'll deal great damage as their bite force is far greater than pits
A rottweiler is an overly balance dog great in all aspect and can be used for several purposes u name... I can't shout o

Bro, I'm afraid all the points you laid down are false!!! Looking at both alone, which would you run from first

It pains me when people with no outright knowledge about dogs still brag in their ignorance......
A Rott and a Pitt are two great breeds of dog bred for various reasons and those reason are precise.
The Pitt was bred for fighting that does mean it will win a fully grown Rott, a Pitt aggression against an animal is different from towards a human being....
A Rott aggression to a human being is higher than towards an animal.
Now to prove a point outside their environment a rott with still bite you if you go toward it owner but a Pitt may not... A Pitt will rush to kill a goat but the Rott with just sleep.... And in a fight between them by the types of rotts I have seen whose head is the size of three Pitbull.... One sure bite and you have a dead Pitt talking from experience.

Timantech:
It pains me when people with no outright knowledge about dogs still brag in their ignorance......
A Rott and a Pitt are two great breeds of dog bred for various reasons and those reason are precise.
The Pitt was bred for fighting that does mean it will win a fully grown Rott, a Pitt aggression against an animal is different from towards a human being....
A Rott aggression to a human being is higher than towards an animal.
Now to prove a point outside their environment a rott with still bite you if you go toward it owner but a Pitt may not... A Pitt will rush to kill a goat but the Rott with just sleep.... And in a fight between them by the types of rotts I have seen whose head is the size of three Pitbull.... One sure bite and you have a dead Pitt talking from experience.

You’re a joker, if I haven’t seen a pitbull take down a full grown Rottweiler I’d have probably believed all this you said.. Bro don’t be fooled, the size of a pitbull is not a disadvantage my guy. All confident dogs will attack a goat or a sheep they see on the road, my little Maltese attacked a goat on the road, my Caucasian attacks too so don’t make it look like only only pitts do that, I don’t know if you’ve watched that video of a man walking two Rottweiler dogs when a goat came too close and the dogs almost killed it.. Forget all these mongrel dogs around that people call pits, a Rottweiler is no match for a real APBT I can say it anywhere!

Caleb91:

bro u lie in that aspect of bite between both breeds go and confirm from google

Rottweiler has stronger bite force than pitbulls
Even gsd has stronger bite force than pitbulls

ChristoBam:


Just check online bro. Pitbull is not for learners.

This is a study to show which dog is unstable with random human attacks in america, it's not a chart to show which dog is a better security dog.
Dangerous doesn't mean best guard dog, it means more random human attacks

Namdeenero:
I’ll say it again, anybody who says a Rottweiler can Guard a home better than a pitbull has never owned a real APBT before. There’s something that happened in Owerri sometime last 2 years, a man requested for a pitbull pup from a Breeder in Jos, there were lots of delays in bringing the pup so the man got angry and impatient, when the pup finally came the man saw the pup and concluded he wasn’t pure. I guess he mistook the APBT for an American bully, a friend of mine decided to board the dog for a while, weeks turned into months and this dog grew steadily into a beast. At 6 months the man saw the picture of the pitbull and decided to get the dog back probably because he was now looking more like a good dog, he paid boarding fees of up to 4 months and the dog was released to him. He kept the 6 months old pitbull with his adult alpha male Rottweiler ! Big mistake, cos the very next day the 6 months old pitbull pup destroyed the Rottweiler to become the alpha male in that compound. Note, I didn’t use killed I used destroyed cos the Rottweiler’s carcass was looking like it was hit by a high velocity train. The man sold all the other male dogs excluding the pit

The OP is asking which is more security conscious but all the stories you've said are about animal aggression.
That is a completely different thing from being a guard dog.
Rottweilers are better security dogs than pitbulls, they are more human aggressive and they are more territorial.
Pitbulls are not guard dogs and they weren't even bred for that.

LordOfTheWeed:

Bro, I'm afraid all the points you laid down are false!!! Looking at both alone, which would you run from first

Funny how you picked a happy female rotts pic

IamAnderson:

Rottweiler has stronger bite force than pitbulls
Even gsd has stronger bite force than pitbulls

so gsd has more bite force than pitbulls
.
.
.
i laugh at your blind ignorance i dnt argue blindly go and confirm for yourself on google then thank me later

Namdeenero:
Drop yours chief

zero 7 zero 6558 5225

Caleb91:

so gsd has more bite force than pitbulls
.
.
.
i laugh at your blind ignorance i dnt argue blindly go and confirm for yourself on google then thank me later

if you're gonna use google as your reference point maybe you should consider using it sometime instead of hearing gist and assuming you are being backed with scientific facts

IamAnderson:

The OP is asking which is more security conscious but all the stories you've said are about animal aggression.
That is a completely different thing from being a guard dog.
Rottweilers are better security dogs than pitbulls, they are more human aggressive and they are more territorial.
Pitbulls are not guard dogs and they weren't even bred for that.

Bro forget all those things about how they were bred, only few people stick to breed standards these days... A pitbull can guard a house as good as a Rottweiler can maybe even better (From personal experience) Pitbulls have a more fearsome reputation than Rottweiler, just knowing you have a pitbull in your home is enough to deter any intruder

Rots are real guard dogs..very very aggressive and protective..the PBT is also a wonderful fella but loves cuddling and rubbing..mine here is lovely but the irony about her is that she is a good fighting dog..very powerful at that..just go for a Rotweiller pinscher .

stevematics:
Rots are real guard dogs..very very aggressive and protective..the PBT is also a wonderful fella but loves cuddling and rubbing..mine here is lovely but the irony about her is that she is a good fighting dog..very powerful at that..just go for a Rotweiller pinscher .

i love this your pit

Thanks ...

Well I have been reading all the comments, I wouldn't support a rot over a pit cuz I own a pit n she would kill u man or animal if u der to cross boundaries. But if u need a good guard dog I would disqualify both n pick either a dolberman pincher or a GSD, easy to train and understand commands even when its coded n dey are damn deadly. But if u want proof of pitbull guard instinct download Once upon a time in Hollywood, watch d end and see what Bradpits pitbull did in that movie.

Namdeenero:
Bro forget all those things about how they were bred, only few people stick to breed standards these days... A pitbull can guard a house as good as a Rottweiler can maybe even better (From personal experience) Pitbulls have a more fearsome reputation than Rottweiler, just knowing you have a pitbull in your home is enough to deter any intruder

Rottweilers are more human aggressive and more territorial than pitbulls, that's what makes a guard dog a guard dog.
even all the stories you told us now are about animal aggression, what does that have to do with guard capabilities?
pitbulls can be used as guard dogs yes but Rottweilers are better more natural guard dogs than pitbulls.
pitbulls are more aggressive towards animals than humans, it's the other way around for Rottweilers

IamAnderson:

Rottweilers are more human aggressive and more territorial than pitbulls, that's what makes a guard dog a guard dog.
even all the stories you told us now are about animal aggression, what does that have to do with guard capabilities?
pitbulls can be used as guard dogs yes but Rottweilers are better more natural guard dogs than pitbulls.
pitbulls are more aggressive towards animals than humans, it's the other way around for Rottweilers

Alright chief

Davecut:
Well I have been reading all the comments, I wouldn't support a rot over a pit cuz I own a pit n she would kill u man or animal if u der to cross boundaries. But if u need a good guard dog I would disqualify both n pick either a dolberman pincher or a GSD, easy to train and understand commands even when its coded n dey are damn deadly. But if u want proof of pitbull guard instinct download Once upon a time in Hollywood, watch d end and see what Bradpits pitbull did in that movie.

this is why you should not use movies to judge reality.
the attack scene at the end of that movie was staged and done with a puppet not a real dog
and let's assume it was a real scene, the dog in that movie is a 3yr old pitbull trained and owned by a stuntman and to do that scene they actually used 3 different dogs, they were thought how to attack on command, a lot of dogs can be thought that, it doesn't mean it's a good guard dog.
the dogs were on a movie set with 100s of people and equipment and they lunged at a stuntman on command, what does that have to do with a dog guarding a house? do the two scenarios correlate?

Davecut:
But if u want proof of pitbull guard instinct download Once upon a time in Hollywood, watch d end and see what Bradpits pitbull did in that movie.

you can read behind the scenes by yourself bro