₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,444 members, 8,523,221 topics. Date: Monday, 23 November 2026 at 12:05 AM

Toggle theme

Truthseeker10's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Truthseeker10's Profile › Truthseeker10's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 (of 145 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 10:49am On Jun 09
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
Let's look at those two statements directly. There is no trick here; it comes down to how the word "firstborn" is used in scripture.

In biblical context, **"firstborn" (*prototokos*)** doesn't mean "first created." It is a title of status meaning **"supreme heir"** or **"preeminent ruler."**

When Paul calls Jesus the "firstborn over all creation" in Colossians 1:15, he explains exactly why Jesus holds that title in the very next verse (v. 16):

> *"**For by him all things were created:** things in heaven and on earth... all things have been created through him and for him."*

The logic is simple: Jesus holds the status of "firstborn" (supreme ruler) over creation *because* He is the Creator of it. A creature cannot create all things; only the Creator can.
Oga it is too late to explain yourself. You are only deceiving yourself. Below in bold was your statement.

"Paul says Christ is firstborn because He is the Creator".

Below in the screenshot is the analysis of your statement. You are a deceiver.

Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 10:12am On Jun 09
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
No, that criticism only works if the same standard was not being applied.

The standard was:

1. What does the text explicitly say?
2. What conclusions do people draw from it?

Applying that standard consistently:

• Revelation 3:14 does not explicitly call Jesus a "creature."
• Revelation 3:14 does not explicitly call Jesus a "creator."
• Colossians 1:16 does not explicitly call Jesus "Creator."

Therefore, neither "creature" nor "Creator" should be presented as though they are the direct wording of those verses.

However, interpreters often draw conclusions from what the verses do say.

Some conclude from Revelation 3:14 that Jesus is a created being.

Others conclude from Colossians 1:16 that Jesus is Creator.

Whether those conclusions are correct is a separate debate.

The important point is that a conclusion drawn from a text is not the same thing as the text explicitly stating that conclusion.

If the same distinction is maintained in both passages, then the standard is being applied consistently.
Lol....you are trying to play smart. Below are two statements made by you in this discussion.
Statement 1: "Since all things were created through Christ, therefore Christ is Creator."
Statement 2:"Paul says Christ is firstborn because He is the Creator"

The screenshot below proves that you are not straightforward and that you are out there to deceive the gullible.

Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 12:41pm On Jun 08
plesion:
In the Scripture you find the very general statements about many things, and it is the doctrine, which is genuinely derived from the Scripture, that explain those, for the Word in its letter is accomodated to a simple man, so that they in the letter may understood even simply, but if one is to understand those truths wisely, he would need the true doctrine, which explain the various aspects of the Divine and Human, and how the Lord made His Human Divine. In fact, the Old Testament in its inmost sense is speaking about that, namely, how the Lord made His Human Divine, but this is all inwardly, within the letter, while the letter is speaking about the various historicals.
Oga I see that you are not yet serious since you can't point one verse.
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10:
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
The point is precision.

If someone says:

"Colossians 1:16 calls Jesus 'Creator.'"

I would say:

"Not exactly. The verse says all things were created through him. 'Creator' is a conclusion drawn from that statement."

The reason for making that distinction is consistency.

For example:

• Colossians 1:15 explicitly says "firstborn of all creation."
• Revelation 3:14 explicitly says "beginning of the creation of GOD."

If a person insists that every conclusion must be based only on explicit wording, then they should apply that standard everywhere.

On the other hand, if a person is willing to draw conclusions from implications, then they can argue:

"Since all things were created through Christ, therefore Christ is Creator."

The debate is not really about the word "Creator." The debate is about what conclusions should be drawn from the verses.

That is why I distinguished between:

1. What the text directly says.
2. What interpreters conclude from it.

Without that distinction, people often treat their interpretation as though it were the exact wording of the scripture itself.
🤣🤣🤣 look at this guy. You went against your own rules. You told us not to force "creator" or "creature" into Revelation 3:14 because the greek does not force it. You said that Revelation 3:14 neither teaches that Jesus is a "creator" nor a "creature". So why are you now inconsistently forcing "creator" as what Paul said into Colossians 1:16 even when the Greek words of Paul do not force it? Can you now see that you are an inconsistent teacher?
Christianity Etc › Re: Does Hellfire Really Exist? Answering The Skeptics With Scripture by Truthseeker10: 8:50am On Jun 08
LordTosinJ:
There's no double standard here. I don't know how you can read all the scriptures I quoted above and still come to the conclusion that Hell is symbolic. it's mind blowing.

Ironically, even if i'm to agree with Janosky guy above that the word used for hell in that passage is Gehenna. Is Gehenna not still a symbol of the literal hell were sinners and evil doers will burn like garbage?

One thing is clear. Jesus used physical hyperbole 'pluck out your eye' to warn against a permanent spiritual reality HELL. take it or leave it.
So you Mean that Death and Hades will also be burned like garbage according to Revelation 20:14?
Christianity Etc › Re: Does Hellfire Really Exist? Answering The Skeptics With Scripture by Truthseeker10: 8:47am On Jun 08
LordTosinJ:
There is a growing trend to dismiss the reality of hell, Many people today say that hell is not real. They claim that the Bible does not even speak about it. But hell is a real place. The exact words in the Bible show this clearly. Let us look at what the Bible says.
The Testimony of Jesus in the Gospels

Some try to dismiss the book of Revelation as purely symbolic, but Jesus Himself spoke repeatedly and warningly about a literal fire.

• Matthew 5:22 (ESV):
"But I say to you that everyone who is angry with his brother will be liable to judgment; whoever insults his brother will be liable to the council; and whoever says, ‘You fool!’ will be liable to the hell of fire."

• Matthew 10:28 (ESV):
"And do not fear those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul. Rather fear him who can destroy both soul and body in hell."

• Luke 12:5 (ESV):
"But I will warn you whom to fear: fear him who, after he has killed, has authority to cast into hell. Yes, I tell you, fear him!"

Why would Christ command us to fear the One who can send us to hell if it isn't a real place? What is there to fear if it is just a metaphor? Jesus wasn't playing semantic games; He was issuing a severe warning.

Furthermore, He explicitly describes the nature of this punishment as eternal and physical:

• Matthew 25:41 (ESV):
"Then he will say to those on his left, ‘Depart from me, you cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels.’"

• Mark 9:43, 47-48 (ESV):
"And if your hand causes you to sin, cut it off. It is better for you to enter life crippled than with two hands to go to hell, to the unquenchable fire... It is better for you to enter the kingdom of God with one eye than with two eyes to be thrown into hell, ‘where their worm does not die and the fire is not quenched.’"

"Unquenchable fire" and a "worm that does not die" point directly to an unending, forever punishment.



The Final Judgment in Revelation

When we couple the words of Jesus with the vision given to John in Revelation, the picture becomes undeniable. The final destination for the wicked is explicitly named the "Lake of Fire."

• Revelation 20:10 (ESV):
"...and the devil who had deceived them was thrown into the lake of fire and sulfur where the beast and the false prophet were, and they will be tormented day and night forever and ever."

• Revelation 20:14 (ESV):
"Then Death and Hades were thrown into the lake of fire. This is the second death, the lake of fire."

• Revelation 20:15 (ESV):
"And if anyone's name was not found written in the book of life, he was thrown into the lake of fire."



Conclusion: Let's Stop the Shenanigans

The Bible uses words like "hell of fire" and "eternal fire." It also says "unquenchable fire" and "the lake of fire." So, how can anyone say that hell is not real?

If a person says there is no hell, they do not believe Jesus Christ. They also do not believe the words of the New Testament prophets.
So body and soul goes to hell fire according to Matthew 10:28?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 11:04pm On Jun 07
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
You keep asking the same question again and again. I have answered you several times, is it that you just loved it and have refused to learn and obey? Or you you are built in asking the same question every timehuh
Do you agree with the information in the screenshot below? Yes or no?

Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 9:22pm On Jun 07
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
Yes, I said that Christ is Creator, Owner, Heir, and Sustainer of creation. The question, however, is whether Paul's words in Colossians 1:16 support that conclusion.

Paul says that all things were created in Him, through Him, and for Him. If all things were created through Him and for Him, then He is not merely part of the created order being discussed. He stands in a unique relationship to it.

Now, if you disagree that such language supports the title "Creator," explain why "all things were created through Him" should not be understood as a creative role. Merely demanding the noun "Creator" does not resolve the issue. Scripture often describes a person's identity and function without using a specific title.

So the real question is not whether Paul used the English word "Creator," but whether Paul's description of Christ's relationship to creation warrants that conclusion.
I did not ask you to interpret and you are claiming what i did not claim neither did i ask you if the the noun "Creator" is in the verse. I asked you a clear question:

So when Paul says "for by Him all things were created" in colossians 1:16, do the Greek words that Paul used compel the "creator" title to Jesus, Yes or no?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 4:51pm On Jun 07
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
Answer this question first... and then we can continue,



But you have to answer this question first.....Why does Paul explain Christ's "firstborn of creation" status by immediately describing Him as the one through whom all things were created, for whom all things were created, and in whom all things hold together?
PSTKYLIFELIGHT I don't know the answer to your question. I have never made any interpretation of Bible verses that we've quoted in our discussion here. It is clear that you are the teacher here. So please answer:

Ok let's take the title "creator" that you claimed made Paul to call Jesus "firstborn of creation".

So when Paul says "for by Him all things were created" in colossians 1:16, do the Greek words that Paul used compel the "creator" title to Jesus?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 12:42pm On Jun 07
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
Answer this question first... and then we can continue,



But you have to answer this question first.....Why does Paul explain Christ's "firstborn of creation" status by immediately describing Him as the one through whom all things were created, for whom all things were created, and in whom all things hold together?
I don't know the answer to question. I have never made any interpretation of Bible verses that we've quoted in our discussion here. It is clear that you are the teacher here. So please answer:

Ok let's take the title "creator" that you claimed made Paul to call Jesus "firstborn of creation".

So when Paul says "for by Him all things were created" in colossians 1:16, do the Greek words that Paul used compel the "creator" title to Jesus?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 12:34pm On Jun 07
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
Answer my question first
PSTKYLIFELIGHT I never made any claim on Paul's words on colossians 1:15 or verse 16 so I'm not obligated to answer your question. Now answer the question below:


Ok let's take the title "creator" that you claimed made Paul to call Jesus "firstborn of creation".

So when Paul says "for by Him all things were created" in colossians 1:16, do the Greek words that Paul used compel the "creator" title to Jesus?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 7:33am On Jun 07
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
Answer my question first
I never made any claim on Paul's words on colossians 1:15 or verse 16 so I'm not obligated to answer your question. Now answer the question below.


Ok let's take the title "creator" that you claimed made Paul to call Jesus "firstborn of creation".

So when Paul says "for by Him all things were created" in colossians 1:16, do the Greek words that Paul used compel the "creator" title to Jesus?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 10:50pm On Jun 06
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
That is a fair question.

Strictly speaking, Paul does not use the exact words "Creator," "Owner," "Heir," and "Sustainer" in Colossians 1:16–17.

Those are theological descriptions derived from what Paul says.

"For by Him all things were created" → Creator role.

"All things were created through Him and for Him" → the phrase "for Him" points to His supremacy, purpose, and inheritance over creation, which is why many theologians speak of Him as its heir and rightful Lord.

"He is before all things" → preeminence over creation.

"In Him all things hold together" → Sustainer role.

So let us be precise: I did not claim Paul used those exact titles in the text. I claimed those titles summarize the functions Paul attributes to Christ in the text.

However, notice that this clarification does not actually advance your argument.

The question remains the same:

Why does Paul explain Christ's "firstborn of creation" status by immediately describing Him as the one through whom all things were created, for whom all things were created, and in whom all things hold together?

Whatever "firstborn" means in verse 15, verses 16 and 17 clearly connect it to Christ's unique relationship to creation, not merely to His being part of creation..




But you have to answer this question first.....Why does Paul explain Christ's "firstborn of creation" status by immediately describing Him as the one through whom all things were created, for whom all things were created, and in whom all things hold together?
Ok let's take the title "creator" that you claimed made Paul to call Jesus "firstborn of creation".

So when Paul says "for by Him all things were created" in colossians 1:16, do the Greek words that Paul used compel the "creator" title to Jesus?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 2:18pm On Jun 06
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
That objection misunderstands both the argument and the text.

No, the reason is not “inheritance alone,” and that is not what was claimed.

The point is this: Paul never uses “firstborn” as a generic label for “creator, owner, or sustainer.” He uses it as a Messianic and relational title applied to the Son in relation to creation and redemption, and he immediately defines it in the context of the Son being the agent and goal of creation (Colossians 1:16–17).

Now to your question directly:

The Father is not called “firstborn of creation” not because He lacks inheritance, but because Scripture never assigns Him that role or relational position in relation to creation. The Father is consistently described as the source “from whom” all things are, while the Son is the one “through whom” all things are.

“Firstborn” in Colossians 1:15 is not a reusable title you can freely apply to any divine person who creates. It is tied to Paul’s Christology: the Son is the image of God, the agent of creation, and the preeminent heir over creation.

So the issue is not “one missing attribute.”

The issue is different biblical roles that are not interchangeable in the text.
So where does Paul says that Christ is called "firstborn of creation" in colossians 1:16, 17 because he is the CREATOR, OWNER, HEIR AND SUSTAINER OF CREATION. please point out where those titles are used for Jesus in the those verses.
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 1:28pm On Jun 06
plesion:
That arises out of the detailed explanation of the sense of the letter of the Word as to its interiors, and out of the explanation what is implied by the various ideas.

For instance, the idea that the Lord has assumed a Human, that is, He was born as a Man, implies that which is involved in the idea of man, and then man involves the rational (broadly speaking), or the intellectual part, and the natural (or the part, which relates to the daily activities, outward desires, which has their inward and outward as well), and also involves the lowest of the natural mind, which is sensuos, and corporeal.
And when the Lord was glorified, it is not simply the word without meaning, or some kind of glorification that is given to this kind of this world, but that means that He became Divine, that is, that His Human became Divine, that is, whatever was in that human became Divine, thus related to those things that were spoken about in the previous message. With regard to the very general ideas, it is clear that His Human became Divien, because after the Ressurection He was seen passing through the walls, which no material human body can do, thus it was Divine. But not only the Body but everything within Him. Thus, as we are told, in the Lord "dwells all the Divinity of the God/Godhead bodily"
I simply asked you for a verse and you are giving me further stories. Is it that you did not find the stories in scripture?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 1:25pm On Jun 06
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
Because "firstborn" is not a title Paul gives to everyone who creates.

It is a title Paul specifically gives to the Son.

The Father is the source of creation. The Son is the heir, image, and mediator of creation.

So the question is not, "Could the Father theoretically be called firstborn?"

The question is, "Why did Paul choose to call the Son firstborn?"

Paul's own explanation is found in verses 16 and 17, where he connects the title to the Son's supremacy over creation, not to the Father.

In other words, the Father is not called "firstborn" simply because Scripture never assigns that title to Him.
Please don't be dubious and deceptive.
Below is your statement for the reason why Paul called Jesus "firstborn of creation":

"Paul says Christ is firstborn because He is the Creator, Owner, Heir, and Sustainer of creation.".

So out of all the reasons that you claimed paul stated in colossians 1:16, 17, the only reason that we cannot call the Father "firstborn of creation" is because he is not a "heir"?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 9:04pm On Jun 05
plesion:
I do not think that you can understand the whole idea if you only rely on the general terms, without understanding them, and their context. So, it is better to look at the whole context, and see the usage terms in their context. Generally, in the Lord was the Internal Man, or interiors, from Jehovah, and the external man, or the exteriors, from Mary. And this exteriors included the bodily part, but also, as far as I understand, also those things which were adjoined to the internal man from Mary, thus the things related to memory, even some outward intellectual, into which there was the inflowing from the interior man. And so whatever was in the exterior man had to be glorified, or made Divine, and so the Lord made His Rational and Natural Divine, down to the Sensuos and Corporeal, having put away the things from Mary, and having put the things from the Father, from within, in place on them, so in doing this He was God and then complete Divine Man, or the Divine both to the interiors and Exteriors, but now in the Divine Human, not merely the Divine Itself without the Human, but now in the Human of His Own, assumed and glorified.

Thus, Lord and God, God-and-Man.
Please kindly quote the verse where you got the information above.
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 7:40pm On Jun 05
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
The simple answer is this:

“Firstborn” is never used in Scripture as a title for the Father because it is a covenant and relational title assigned to the Son in relation to creation and redemption, not a general synonym for “creator” or “source.”

Your comparison does not work because you are flattening different roles into one category.

The Father is consistently described as “from whom are all things.”

The Son is described as the One “through whom are all things.”

Those are not interchangeable roles in the biblical text.

Even if “firstborn” includes ideas like rank, supremacy, or heirship, it is still applied specifically to the Son in relation to creation and resurrection.

So the real issue is not whether the Father is “greater” or “source,” which Scripture already affirms.

The issue is whether the Son is included inside the category of created things.

And that question is not answered by simply swapping titles between persons where Scripture never does so.
Please do not deviate from the topic. We are discussing why Jesus is called "firstborn of creation" and not "firstborn of resurrection".

Below is your answer to why Jesus is called "firstborn of creation" in Colossians 1:15:

"Paul says Christ is firstborn because He is the Creator, Owner, Heir, and Sustainer of creation.".

Kindly tell us the reason why we cannot call the Father the "firstborn of creation" for the very same reason you claimed Paul called Christ " firstborn of creation" above?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 7:11pm On Jun 05
plesion:
Somewhat more correctly: it was the internal (man) of the Lord, thus it was also within both his body and the exteriors of his mind (at least, how I understand it)

"The Lord was indeed born as are other men, but it is known that he who is born a man derives what is his from both the father and the mother, and that he has his inmost from the father, but his exteriors (that is, the things which clothe this inmost) from the mother. Both that which he derives from the father, and that which he derives from the mother, are defiled with hereditary evil. But it was different with the Lord: that which He derived from the mother in like manner had in it an heredity such as is that of any other man; but that which He derived from the Father, who was Jehovah, was Divine. For this reason the Lord's internal man was not like the internal of another man; for His inmost was Jehovah. This is therefore the intermediate which is called the celestial of the spiritual from the rational. But concerning this, of the Lord's Divine mercy more will be said in the following pages." (from Arcana Coelestia #4963)
Please I don't want to get confused and I am not even sure you understand your write up above. So Jehovah clothed himself with a flesh called Jesus?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 4:07pm On Jun 05
plesion:
There are ways to think of God according to the letter alone, without the spirit, and htere is a way to think of it not from the letter alone, but also from the spirit.

If from a letter alone, then there is one God who sends another God, and then two of those send the third One. So, in thinking, though not in the expression, there is then the idea of the three Gods.

Though as we know there is only one God.

So, then we have not only to read the letter, but also attempt to understand it so that our understanding may agree with both the Word and the sound reason.

In that sense, God Himself, as He is in Himself, or the Infinite, technically cannot come on earth, for then He would either destroy it completely, for then there is no accomodation. And yet we are told in the Old Testament constantly that Jehovah would come to deliver his people.

And thus He comes, but comes in the way that allows to carry out his mission. Thus, He assumes the Human, which is concevied and born of Him.

For those who are interested here is a more detailed explanation:

" 84. God could not have redeemed people, that is, rescued them from damnation and hell, without first taking on a human manifestation. There are many reasons for this; they will be disclosed step by step in what follows. Redemption was a matter of gaining control of the hells, restructuring the heavens, and then establishing a church. Despite his omnipotence, God could not accomplish these things except through his human manifestation, as one cannot do work without arms. In fact, in the Word his human manifestation is called the arm of Jehovah (Isaiah 40:10; 53:1). By analogy, one cannot attack a fortified city and destroy the temples of idols there without powerful means.
The Word as well makes it clear that having a human manifestation gave God the omnipotence to do this divine work. God is in the inmost and purest realms. There was no other way he could cross over to the lowest levels where the hells exist and where people were at that time, just as a soul cannot do anything without a body. By analogy, there is no way to overpower enemies who are not in sight and whom we cannot get close to with weapons such as spears, shields, or guns.
To redeem people without a human manifestation would have been as impossible for God as it would be for someone [outside India] to take control of people in India without sending in troops on ships. It would be as impossible as growing trees on heat and light alone if air had not been created as a medium through which they travel and earth had not been created in which the trees could grow. In fact, it would be as impossible as catching fish by throwing a net in the air and not in the water.
Given Jehovah's inherent nature, despite his omnipotence he could not touch any individual devils in hell or any individual devils on earth and control them or their rage or tame their violence unless he could be as present in the farthest realms as he is in those closest to him. In his human manifestation he is in fact present in the farthest realms. This is why the Word refers to him as the First and the Last, the Alpha and the Omega, the Beginning and the End [Revelation 1:8, 11; 21:6; 22:13]." (True Christian Religion).

" 125. That Jehovah God could have entered upon and have accomplished such a work only by means of His Human may be illustrated by various comparisons; as, that one who is invisible cannot shake hands or converse with another until he becomes visible; thus an angel or spirit could have no interaction with a man, even if standing close to his body and before his face. Neither can anyone's soul converse with another or act with another except by means of his body. The sun with its light and heat can enter into man, beast, or tree only by first entering the air and operating through it; or can enter into a fish only by means of the water, since it must act through that element in which the subject resides. No one can scale a fish without a knife, or pluck a crow without fingers; or descend to the bottom of a lake without a diving-bell; in a word, anyone thing must be adapted to another before it can communicate with it or operate with it or against it."

When that mission was accomplished, and the Human was made Divine, the Lord God Jesus Christ is not a God, which is separate from Jehovah God, and the more so it is not those two separate Gods send the third One.

But as it is said: "I and the Father are One". "The one who sees me sees the Father". So, when the Human became Divine, Jehohav God is then seen in the Glorified Human of His Own, and so when we approach the Lord, we approach at the same time the Jehovah in Him, as the Soul int the Body of its own, with that specification, that in the Lord Jesus Christ there is both Divine and Human, and they make one, the Divine Human.
So it was Jehovah who is the father that was inside the body of the person that was Jesus on earth?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10:
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
You keep asking and asking, yet you deliberately have refused to answer any of my questions......


If "firstborn of creation" means "first creature," how can Paul immediately say that all things were created through Him?

That is the tension your interpretation must resolve.
If you can show me where I claimed in our discussion that "firstborn of creation" means "first creature", I will answer you.

Now answer me without you trying to be cunning. I have the evidence that You claimed that the reason why Paul called Jesus "firstborn" in colossians 1:15 is embedded in the next verse which is verse 16. And you went to say that: "Paul says Christ is firstborn because He is the Creator, Owner, Heir, and Sustainer of creation.".

Now in a short sentence, why can we not say the father is "firstborn" for the same reason that you gave that Paul called the son "firstborn" according to colossians 1:15, 16?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 10:57am On Jun 05
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
No, I am not denying it.

My point remains the same: Paul explains Christ's "firstborn" status in verses 16 and 17 by describing His relationship to creation.

I did not say "creator" is the definition of "firstborn."

I said Paul grounds Christ's firstborn status in the fact that all things were created through Him, for Him, and are sustained by Him.

The question you still have not answered is simple:

If "firstborn of creation" means "first creature," how can Paul immediately say that all things were created through Him?

That is the tension your interpretation must resolve.
Are you trying to be cunning? I have the evidence that You claimed that the reason why Paul called Jesus "firstborn" in colossians 1:15 is embedded in the next verse which is verse 16. And you went to say that: "Paul says Christ is firstborn because He is the Creator, Owner, Heir, and Sustainer of creation.".

Now in a short sentence, why can we not say the father is "firstborn" for the same reason that you gave that Paul called the son "firstborn" according to colossians 1:15, 16?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 10:27am On Jun 05
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
Fair point. Let me answer directly and precisely.

No, the Father is not called "firstborn."

Why?

Because "firstborn" is not simply a title for a creator. If it were, the Father would indeed be called firstborn.

Rather, it is a Messianic title given to the Son in His relationship to creation, redemption, and inheritance.

My point was not that "creator" automatically means "firstborn."

My point was that Paul explains Christ's firstborn status by describing His supremacy over creation:

"for by Him all things were created."

In other words, Christ is called firstborn because He stands above creation, not because He is the first creature within it.

Now let me ask a simple question in return:

If "firstborn of creation" means "first creature," why does Paul immediately say:

"for by Him all things were created"?

How can Christ be part of the created class if all created things came into existence through Him?

That is the issue you still need to answer.

The debate is not whether the Father is called firstborn.

The debate is whether Paul intended "firstborn" to mean "first creature."

The next two verses strongly suggest he did not.
PSTKYLIFELIGHT you avoided my question again. Please answer

Below in your statement in bold, you claimed the following:

"Paul says Christ is firstborn because He is the Creator, Owner, Heir, and Sustainer of creation.
"

Are you now denying what you claimed that Paul said above in colossians 1:15, 16?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 10:33pm On Jun 04
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
Fair point. Let me answer directly and precisely.

No, the Father is not called "firstborn."

Why?

Because "firstborn" is not simply a title for a creator. If it were, the Father would indeed be called firstborn.

Rather, it is a Messianic title given to the Son in His relationship to creation, redemption, and inheritance.

My point was not that "creator" automatically means "firstborn."

My point was that Paul explains Christ's firstborn status by describing His supremacy over creation:

"for by Him all things were created."

In other words, Christ is called firstborn because He stands above creation, not because He is the first creature within it.

Now let me ask a simple question in return:

If "firstborn of creation" means "first creature," why does Paul immediately say:

"for by Him all things were created"?

How can Christ be part of the created class if all created things came into existence through Him?

That is the issue you still need to answer.

The debate is not whether the Father is called firstborn.

The debate is whether Paul intended "firstborn" to mean "first creature."

The next two verses strongly suggest he did not.
Below in your statement in bold, you claimed the following:

Paul says Christ is firstborn because He is the Creator, Owner, Heir, and Sustainer of creation.

Are you now denying what you claimed that Paul said above in colossians 1:15, 16?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 8:38pm On Jun 04
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
No, and that question actually exposes a category error in your argument.

The issue is not whether "firstborn" means supreme, heir, or preeminent. The issue is to whom the title is being applied and why.

The Father is never called "firstborn" because the title itself is relational. A firstborn is firstborn in relation to others. The Father is never presented as the heir of creation, the firstborn among many brothers, or the firstborn from the dead. Those roles belong specifically to the Son.

In Scripture, Christ is called:

"Firstborn of all creation" (Colossians 1:15)

"Firstborn from the dead" (Colossians 1:18)

"Firstborn among many brethren" (Romans 8:29)

Notice the pattern. The title is consistently connected to Christ's position relative to others.

The Father is not "firstborn from the dead" because He did not become incarnate and rise from the dead.

The Father is not "firstborn among many brethren" because believers are never described as the Father's brethren.

The Father is not "firstborn of creation" because creation is not presented as His inheritance in the same covenantal and Messianic sense that it is presented as the Son's inheritance.

Therefore, asking whether the Father can be called "firstborn" misses Paul's point entirely.

More importantly, your question does not advance the claim that Christ is a creature.

Even if I granted for the sake of argument that the Father is never called firstborn, that would not prove that "firstborn" means "first creature."

You still have to explain why Paul immediately follows the title with:

"For by Him all things were created."

You still have to explain why Paul says:

"All things were created through Him and for Him."

You still have to explain why Paul says:

"He is before all things."

And you still have to explain why Paul says:

"In Him all things hold together."

The real problem is that your interpretation focuses on one title while ignoring Paul's explanation of that title.

Paul does not say:

"He is the firstborn of creation because He was the first thing God made."

Paul says:

"He is the firstborn of creation because all things were created through Him, for Him, and are sustained by Him."

That is Paul's argument, not mine.

The burden is therefore not on me to explain why the Father is not called firstborn.

The burden is on you to explain how someone who created all things, existed before all things, and sustains all things can simultaneously be part of the class of created things.

That is the question your position still has not answered.
The bolded below are not my words they are actually your words in your earlier submission so don't push them to me. Your words are the ones in bold below.

Paul says Christ is firstborn because He is the Creator, Owner, Heir, and Sustainer of creation.


Therefore, "firstborn" can mean preeminent one, heir, supreme one, or one holding the highest rank.


In the above words you claim that Paul called Christ "firstborn of creation" because he is the creator. Following your logic, is the father not the creator and why is he not "firstborn"?....answer in simple sentences I'm not a fan of long epistles.
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 4:03pm On Jun 04
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
Gladly.

Colossians 1:15 says:

"He is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of all creation."

The question is: What does "firstborn" mean?

You assume it means "first creature created."

But Paul does not stop at verse 15. He explains his meaning in verses 16 and 17.

"For by Him all things were created... all things were created through Him and for Him. He is before all things, and in Him all things hold together."

Notice Paul's argument:

1. Christ is the firstborn of all creation.
2. Because by Him all things were created.
3. Because all things were created through Him and for Him.
4. Because He is before all things.

The word "for" (because) is important. Verse 16 explains verse 15.

Paul does not say Christ is firstborn because He was the first thing created.

Paul says Christ is firstborn because He is the Creator, Owner, Heir, and Sustainer of creation.

In Scripture, "firstborn" often refers to rank and inheritance, not birth order.

For example, GOD says of David:

"I will make him My firstborn, higher than the kings of the earth." (Psalm 89:27)

David was not the first king.

David was not even the first son in his family.

Yet GOD called him "firstborn" because of supremacy and royal status.

Likewise, Israel is called GOD'S "firstborn" nation (Exodus 4:22), even though many nations existed before Israel.

Therefore, "firstborn" can mean preeminent one, heir, supreme one, or one holding the highest rank.

Now consider the alternative interpretation.

If "firstborn of all creation" means Jesus is the first creature, then Paul immediately creates a problem in the next verse:

"For by Him all things were created."

Did Jesus create Himself?

If He is a creature, He belongs to the category of created things.

But Paul says all created things came into existence through Him.

That would mean Christ somehow existed before He existed in order to create Himself.

The logic collapses.

Furthermore, Paul deliberately includes every category:

"Whether thrones or dominions or principalities or powers."

He is sweeping the entire created order into one category and placing Christ outside that category as the One through whom it came into existence.

Therefore, Colossians 1:15 does not teach that Jesus is the first creature.

It teaches that Jesus is the supreme heir, Lord, and preeminent One over all creation.

Paul's own explanation in verses 16 and 17 tells us exactly why Christ is called "firstborn": because all things were created through Him, for Him, and are sustained by Him.

That is not the description of a creature.

That is the description of the One who stands above creation as its source, sustainer, and rightful heir.
Below is your logic in bold.

Paul says Christ is firstborn because He is the Creator, Owner, Heir, and Sustainer of creation.


Therefore, "firstborn" can mean preeminent one, heir, supreme one, or one holding the highest rank.



Can the Father be referred to as "Firstborn" using your logic above?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 2:15pm On Jun 04
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
Yes, I will answer directly.

No, Revelation 3:14 does not teach that Jesus is a creature.

And no, Revelation 3:14 by itself is not a standalone statement saying, "Jesus is the Creator" in the sense that the entire doctrine rests on that one verse alone.

What it does teach is that Jesus is "the arche of the creation of God." The dispute is over what "arche" means in that context.

You have assumed that "arche" must mean "the first thing created." But that is the very point that must be proven, not assumed.

If John intended "first creature," there were clearer Greek expressions available to communicate that idea. Instead, he chose "arche," a word that can mean beginning, origin, source, first cause, or ruler depending on context.

Now here is the critical issue:

Whatever meaning you assign to Revelation 3:14 must harmonize with the rest of John's writings.

John 1:3 says:

"All things were made through Him, and without Him was not anything made that was made."

That leaves only two possibilities:

Either Christ belongs to the category of things that were made, or He does not.

If He belongs to that category, then John 1:3 creates a contradiction because Christ would have had to make Himself.

If He does not belong to that category, then Revelation 3:14 cannot mean He is the first creature.

Therefore, the interpretation of Revelation 3:14 that best fits John's own theology is that Christ is the origin, source, or sovereign beginning of God's creation, not the first item within creation.

Notice also that Revelation was written by the same apostle who recorded:

"In the beginning was the Word."

Not "came into existence."

Not "was created."

But "was."

John deliberately distinguishes between the eternal existence of the Word and the coming into existence of created things.

So the real question is not whether Revelation 3:14 contains the word "arche." Everyone agrees that it does.

The real question is whether your interpretation of "arche" can coexist with John 1:1, John 1:3, Colossians 1:16 to 17, Hebrews 1:2, and the rest of the New Testament witness.

That is where the "first creature" interpretation encounters its greatest difficulty.

A doctrine is not established by isolating one possible meaning of one word. It is established by reading that word in harmony with the entire testimony of Scripture.
Ok....explain colossians 1:15.
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 12:16pm On Jun 04
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
The question forces a false binary: either Revelation 3:14 makes Christ a creature or it makes Him the source of creation. The text itself does not demand either conclusion.

Revelation 3:14 says:

“the Amen, the faithful and true witness, the *arche* of God’s creation”

The Greek word *arche* has a broad range of meaning: beginning, ruler, origin, or first principle. The meaning must be determined by context, not assumed in advance.

If *arche* is taken to mean “first created being,” then Christ would be placed inside creation as part of it. However, this reading immediately clashes with the broader New Testament witness:

John 1:3 says all things were made through Him.
Colossians 1:16 says all things were created through Him and for Him.
Hebrews 1:2 says God made the worlds through the Son.

If all created things came into existence through Him, then He cannot simultaneously be included as part of the created set without collapsing the meaning of “all things.”

On the other hand, if *arche* is understood as origin, ruler, or source of authority over creation, then Revelation 3:14 is describing Christ’s relationship to creation rather than placing Him inside it.

This aligns with the broader pattern in Scripture:

The Father is described as the One “from whom are all things” (ultimate source).
The Son is described as the One “through whom are all things” (divine agent of creation).

So the real issue is not choosing between “creature” or “source” as rigid categories. The issue is how *arche* functions in context.

The text does not force Christ into the category of a created being, nor does it redefine Him as the ultimate source in the same sense as the Father. It points to His primacy, authority, and foundational role in relation to creation.

Therefore, the binary itself is not the correct framework for reading Revelation 3:14. The meaning must be drawn from the full consistency of Scripture, not an isolated lexical assumption.
PSTKYLIFELIGHT you have been avoiding my question. Please answer.

So according to you, Revelation 3:14 does not teach that Jesus is a creature neither does It teach that Jesus is the creator even though the verse claims that Jesus is "the Beginning of God's creation", Yes or no?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 10:40pm On Jun 03
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
The question forces a false binary: either Revelation 3:14 makes Christ a creature or it makes Him the source of creation. The text itself does not demand either conclusion.

Revelation 3:14 says:

“the Amen, the faithful and true witness, the *arche* of God’s creation”

The Greek word *arche* has a broad range of meaning: beginning, ruler, origin, or first principle. The meaning must be determined by context, not assumed in advance.

If *arche* is taken to mean “first created being,” then Christ would be placed inside creation as part of it. However, this reading immediately clashes with the broader New Testament witness:

John 1:3 says all things were made through Him.
Colossians 1:16 says all things were created through Him and for Him.
Hebrews 1:2 says God made the worlds through the Son.

If all created things came into existence through Him, then He cannot simultaneously be included as part of the created set without collapsing the meaning of “all things.”

On the other hand, if *arche* is understood as origin, ruler, or source of authority over creation, then Revelation 3:14 is describing Christ’s relationship to creation rather than placing Him inside it.

This aligns with the broader pattern in Scripture:

The Father is described as the One “from whom are all things” (ultimate source).
The Son is described as the One “through whom are all things” (divine agent of creation).

So the real issue is not choosing between “creature” or “source” as rigid categories. The issue is how *arche* functions in context.

The text does not force Christ into the category of a created being, nor does it redefine Him as the ultimate source in the same sense as the Father. It points to His primacy, authority, and foundational role in relation to creation.

Therefore, the binary itself is not the correct framework for reading Revelation 3:14. The meaning must be drawn from the full consistency of Scripture, not an isolated lexical assumption.
So according to you, Revelation 3:14 does not teach that Jesus is a creature neither does It teach that Jesus is the creator even though the verse claims that Jesus is "the Beginning of God's creation", Yes or no?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10:
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
The question forces a false binary: either Revelation 3:14 makes Christ a creature or it makes Him the source of creation. The text itself does not demand either conclusion.

Revelation 3:14 says:

“the Amen, the faithful and true witness, the *arche* of God’s creation”

The Greek word *arche* has a broad range of meaning: beginning, ruler, origin, or first principle. The meaning must be determined by context, not assumed in advance.

If *arche* is taken to mean “first created being,” then Christ would be placed inside creation as part of it. However, this reading immediately clashes with the broader New Testament witness:

John 1:3 says all things were made through Him.
Colossians 1:16 says all things were created through Him and for Him.
Hebrews 1:2 says God made the worlds through the Son.

If all created things came into existence through Him, then He cannot simultaneously be included as part of the created set without collapsing the meaning of “all things.”

On the other hand, if *arche* is understood as origin, ruler, or source of authority over creation, then Revelation 3:14 is describing Christ’s relationship to creation rather than placing Him inside it.

This aligns with the broader pattern in Scripture:

The Father is described as the One “from whom are all things” (ultimate source).
The Son is described as the One “through whom are all things” (divine agent of creation).

So the real issue is not choosing between “creature” or “source” as rigid categories. The issue is how *arche* functions in context.

The text does not force Christ into the category of a created being, nor does it redefine Him as the ultimate source in the same sense as the Father. It points to His primacy, authority, and foundational role in relation to creation.

Therefore, the binary itself is not the correct framework for reading Revelation 3:14. The meaning must be drawn from the full consistency of Scripture, not an isolated lexical assumption.
So according to you, Revelation 3:14 does not teach that Jesus is a creature neither does It teach that Jesus is the creator even though the verse claims that Jesus is "the Beginning of God's creation", Yes or no?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is God Almighty Apart From His Word? by Truthseeker10: 3:55pm On Jun 03
PSTKYLIFELIGHT:
Your argument only works if you assume that the word "source" must carry exactly the same meaning in every passage. That assumption has not been demonstrated.

1 Corinthians 8:6 says:

"One God, the Father, from whom are all things."

Here Paul identifies the Father as the One from whom all things ultimately proceed.

Revelation 3:14, however, uses the Greek word *arche*. The word *arche* has a broad semantic range that includes beginning, ruler, origin, first cause, and chief authority.

Therefore, moving from "the Father is the source of creation" to "the Father is the ultimate source of creation" is not a retreat. It is an attempt to distinguish categories that Scripture itself distinguishes.

You are also assuming that John 1:3 excludes the Son from any role that could be described as originating creation. But John does not say that.

John says:

"All things were made through him."

The text emphasizes the Son's indispensable role in creation. Without Him, nothing that was made came into existence.

The fact that creation came through Him does not diminish His status. It magnifies it.

The real issue is that you are treating "from whom" and "through whom" as mutually exclusive categories when Scripture presents them as complementary categories.

Paul writes:

"One God, the Father, from whom are all things... and one Lord Jesus Christ, through whom are all things."
1 Corinthians 8:6

Paul is not diminishing CHRIST. He is describing the relationship between the Father and the Son in the work of creation.

So the question is not whether the Father is the source and the Son is the agent. The question is whether Revelation 3:14 can describe CHRIST as the *arche* of creation without contradicting John 1:3 and 1 Corinthians 8:6.

Simply claiming that it cannot is not an argument.

You must first prove that *arche* in Revelation 3:14 is being used in exactly the same sense as "from whom" in 1 Corinthians 8:6. Until that is established, the charge of inconsistency remains an assertion rather than a demonstrated conclusion.
So where do you stand, does "arche"(beginning) in Revelation 3:14 refer to Jesus as a creature or as a creator(source)?

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 (of 145 pages)