THE PURPORTED FG-ASUU AGREEMENT!!!

The reader is warned that this piece contains the implied opinion of the writer. The reader is also free to draw conclusions.

Thanks to Qawiy Temitope for this excellent piece, I am much indebted.

ASUU Part Quatre: We Have An Agreement
Before you complain that Peter Jackson’s Lord of The Rings only had 3 parts, I have 2 words for you – The Hobbit.

First of all, shout out to the good man who dug up this agreement, scanned it and emailed it to me. As we say here in Blighty; you Sir, are the dog’sbollocks. Thank you.

I think the first thing that struck me about this agreement is how strong ASUU are as a union. I wonder how other unions will feel if they see the kind of stuff ASUU managed to extract from government. Part of the reason
for this, in my opinion, is immediately obvious when you look at the list of the people who negotiated for both sides. While the ASUU delegation was led by its President and senior members, the government side was led by Gamaliel Onosode and some other Professors and ex Pro-Chancellors. The highest ranking members of the negotiating team from the government side appear to be some civil servants who acted as ‘observers’.

This is not to invalidate the agreement of course – the government clearly signed it so they should honour it. But when you look at the composition of people purportedly negotiating on behalf of the government, ASUU were already 1 nil up even before anything was signed. Does anyone know why things were done this way? Was it that relations between government and
ASUU had broken down to the point where they couldn’t sit round a table and trash out the issues? Not even a minister?
To the agreement proper – there were 4 main issues to be negotiated namely 1) Conditions of service [salaries] 2) Funding 3) University autonomy
and freedom 4) ‘Other matters’.


Here are the highlights of the agreement as I saw them
1. ASUU asked for and got a special salary structure for themselves called Consolidated University Academic Salary Structure II (CONUASS). This CONUASS was further made up of 3 components – 1) CONUASS I [the previous one from 2007] 2) Consolidated Peculiar University Academic Allowances [CONPUAA] 3) Rent.
The CONPUAA was apparently to capture all the other allowances that they wanted but not captured in the CONUASS. Stay with me. The reason why
they were allowed this was because the committee agreed that ‘Nigerian academics represent the critical mass of scholars in the society’ and as a result of this they ‘deserved unique conditions that will motivate them [...]
to attain greater efficiency’.

2. In exchange for this new pay, ASUU agreed to be of good behaviour and not do anything that disrupts the academic calendar to get whatever it wants i.e. no striking.

3. Next thing they did was to look at the countries where Nigerian academics frequently migrated to e.g Botswana, Ghana and other developed countries. Based on this they came up with a salary structure that would prevent this kind of brain drain. They called this Table 1. The highest salary anyone could earn based on this table was N7.5m per annum.
But ASUU then seemingly looked at the government’s condition and took pity on them because the government didn’t have a lot of money and then gave them some sort of ‘discount’. This gave birth to Table 2 in which the
highest possible salary was N6m. The cynic in me thinks this was simply a clever negotiating tactic but I wasn’t there.

4. As far as I am aware from all of ASUU’s statements since the strike began, the government has complied with this CONUASS salary structure. Indeed it will be difficult for the government to not pay them the salary they agreed to. It is the next bit that seems to have caused all the problems and it’s easy to see why.
Something called Earned Academic Allowances was also agreed to by both parties. In essence, this was supposed to be a kind of piece-rate payment where ASUU members as academic staff were paid a fixed amount for each unit of work they did. So for supervising postgraduate students, a Professor was to be paid N25,000 per student while a Lecturer 1 and Senior Lecturer were to be paid N15,000 and N20,000 per student respectively.
For Teaching Practice/Industrial Supervision/Field Trips, a Professor was entitled to N100,000 per annum. Further, if a Professor did more than one
field trip in a year, he would be paid separately for each one. Even though this money was for field trips, such an academic staff would be entitled to mileage and overnight allowance in line with government regulations. It’s unclear why, after being paid N100,000 for a field trip, the same person will then be entitled to mileage and overnight allowance. What is the definition
of ‘field trip’ I wonder?
There was also Honoraria for helping to conduct exams internally or externally ranging from N45,000 for Master’s to N105,000 for Doctorate. For
moderating external undergraduate or postgraduate exams, there was a separate honoraria ranging from N60,000 for 50 undergraduate students to
N80,000 for more than 10 postgraduate students.
To encourage young academics to ‘further’, postgraduate study grants were to be given – N350,000 per session (up to a maximum of 2 sessions) for a
science based masters and N500,000 per session (up to a maximum of 4 sessions) for a science based doctorate. The figures were N250,000 and
N350,000 respectively for non science studies.
I am not too familiar with the intricacies of academia but another N200,000 was to be paid to external assessors for the position of Reader and Professor. Call duty and clinical hazard allowances were to be paid to those
who qualified to them per existing government regulations.
It is unclear what a Responsibility Allowance is (at least to me) but a Vice Chancellor and Librarian were entitled to N750,000 per annum for this allowance while ‘all other officers’ were entitled to N150,000.
Excess Workload Allowance was to be paid per hour to teaching staff ranging from N2,000 per hour for a Graduate Assistant to N3,500 per hour for a
Professor.

You can see the problem with these allowances – there is no way for the government to know how much they will cost in advance. They could cost N10bn or they could cost N100bn. Lecturers would simply submit the bills
and the government would have to cough up the money. You can also see that ASUU played a clever hand by giving the government a ‘discount’ on the base salaries while loading up with all sorts of allowances elsewhere.
For a lecturer earning say N3m per annum, it wont take much for he/she to earn an extra say 50% of that salary through all these allowances. The government isn’t there on the campus so it will simply get the bill to pay.
And I have not even mentioned corruption.

5. There were other non-salary benefits in the agreement as well. Each academic staff was entitled to a car loan equivalent to his/her annual salary charged at 2% for administrative cost (stop laughing). They were also
entitled to a car refurbishment loan for those who wanted to refurbish their old cars, again charged at 2%. At least with a car loan you get to see the new car if you want to, but refurbishment? That’s just money in the bush.
For housing loans, each academic was entitled to 8 times his/her annual salary to buy a house. After 6 years service, an academic would be entitled to a sabbatical leave. If this sabbatical was abroad, the university would pay the ‘transport’ costs for the academic, a spouse and up to 4 children. If hospitalised, an academic would be entitled to 6 months paid sick leave which could be extended for another 6 months.

Retirement age was increased from 65 to 70 and any one who retired as a Professor would be entitled to a pension equivalent to his/her final salary.
Indeed even if the Professor retired before the retirement age of 70, he would still be entitled to the final salary pension provided he had served as a Professor for 15 years in a university.
University staff and their spouses as well as up to 4 children under the age of 18 were entitled to health insurance. There are various other benefits in
the agreement but these are mainly standard stuff like maternity and 26 days leave.


What I find interesting is that while the section on pay was quite specific in what university staff were entitled to, as soon as you get to the other
sections, everything turns to a ‘recommendation’. So for example it was
recommended that the government spend N472bn on the universities in 2009, N498bn in 2010 and N549bn in 2011. Somehow, the Federal Government was also supposed to fund the State Universities (at least
recommended to) on a per student basis i.e. N3.7m per student in total from 2009 to 2011.
Another recommendation was for the state and federal governments to spend a minimum of 26% of their budgets on education. Of this amount, at least 50% was to be allocated to universities. Bear in mind that this was a negotiation between ASUU and the FG – the primary and secondary school interests were not represented there but ASUU was effectively making a recommendation on how much they should get from the budget. In all this,
there are 1.2m students in our universities while we need to find a way to get 10.5m children into school.
It was also recommended that the Education Tax Fund be changed to a Higher Education Fund i.e. solely for the universities, polytechnics and colleges of education. This would be hilarious if it wasn’t so scandalous –
after taking 50% of the budget, the universities were to take 100% of the ETF as well. You couldn’t make it up but then, when you start negotiations from the premise that there is a critical mass of nation transforming
scholars in our universities, this is not a surprise. I wonder if the mumu NUT who are threatening to go on strike in solidarity with ASUU know that ASUU don’t really give a toss about them.

Universities were also to access the Petroleum Technology Development Fund (PTDF) for the training and development of their staff i.e. more money for
ASUU and government was to grant universities duty-free importation rights for educational materials. Given that even our churches have been known to terribly abuse such waivers in the past, this is amusing to say the least.
Where the agreement descends into outright farce is when it reaches the section on autonomy. Having demanded and obtained all the above things from the government, ASUU then proceeded to add insult to injury by asking that university autonomy and academic freedom should be ‘enhanced and protected’. Note that this agreement wasn’t exactly reached with smiles and
good-natured banter – it came after a strike that eventually forced the government to the negotiating table. So ASUU were not only asking the government to give them as much money as they could demand with a
straight face, they were asking to be left alone to spend it and run their affairs as they wish ranging from changing the laws impeding university independence to allowing them admit students as they saw fit. You want
the government to look after you and your family by paying everything you want and you want the same government to grant you freedom and
autonomy. Eh?

As I’ve said several times before – this dispute is all about pay and nothing else. The thing with recommendations is that they are just that;
recommendations. You cant take someone to court for not following a recommendation. So it was up to the government to follow those parts of the agreement or not. But ASUU weren’t messing about with the parts that concerned them. The numbers were clearly specified which is why today they can say the government is owing them N92bn in earned allowances or
whatever the figure is. It is also the same reason why the government feels it can throw N30bn at them and ask them to ‘manage’ it. Afterall its ASUU’s
word against the government’s.

You hardly come across the word ‘student’ in the agreement at all. And there is nothing specific about infrastructure in there other than the large sums of money the government was supposed to give the universities. There are many people today making ignorant noises about government ‘honouring
the agreement’ and even coming up with things that are not in said agreement as ‘ASUU’s demands’. There really isnt anything for anyone in here other than ASUU so personally I’d say, leave them to fight it out with
government.
Who in Nigeria wont like free medical insurance for their family? This is why I get confused when the whole debate about education comes down to pay.
Even if we had the best universities in the world, there will still be a case for paying our lecturers more. 99.9% of humans beings, when asked if they wanted more pay, will respond ‘Yes’. So why exactly is this the pillar on
which the arguement always rests?
You can also see the sinister side of ASUU in the draft amendment bill with the way they were eager to tightly regulate the private universities via the NUC to protect themselves… going as far as recommending up to 5 year jail terms with no option of fine for anyone who so much as uses his property for the operation of an unapproved university.
Be that as it may, I think the government should honour this agreement. It should pay every last penny. That is the only way it might learn a lesson for the future. How you can send a team of ex-academics to negotiate with a
team of academics on your behalf is beyond me. But hey, I don’t know what went down in those days. Once this strike is over, prepare for the next one because as sure as night follows day, it will come.

Ultimately this document shows the impossibility of reaching an ‘agreement’ after one party has forced a negotiation via hostage taking. There is absolutely no way in this life or the next we are going to have anything approaching education reform until we break out of this death spiral of strikes and pay deals. The conversation we need to have has not even begun at all. My suggestion will be that the government should just pay ASUU whatever it is it wants right now and then begin talks on university reform i.e. the lecturers need to be in class when negotiations start. That way, we can know what everyone really wants.

Written by Morakinyo Ayobami and copied from UI students' union fb page.

Please take time to read. It's quite enlightening.

CONFIRM!!!
FinestBoy, pls....this must enta d frontpage

Mods front page o

frontpage please

ASUU ar bunch of old bastards......old foolish greedy men.....my house rent has expire and my landlord is now demandin for anoda rent ...why i only lived in one semester in the room.....my God punish this bastards call ASUU...thm and dia family

Front page mods

The obvious question here is, what was yar'adua thinking when he signed this agreement?

Front page things mods...na only God go fit save us for dis country. Gross ineptitude from d FG, wanton selfishness on the part of ASUU, hapless students caught in d ensuing crossfire...
It is high time we collectively fight for our rights in this country...but perhaps a individual foundational values makeover can serve as a catalyst for that to happen.

Lmao! And to think that the infrastructures they claim to be fighting for was just 'a recommendation'

mikeoh: ASUU ar bunch of old bastards......old foolish greedy men.....my house rent has expire and my landlord is now demandin for anoda rent ...why i only lived in one semester in the room.....my God punish this bastards call ASUU...thm and dia family

. Same here bro,my house rent expired july ending and the care taker have been calling me to pay or pack out.I am confused at the moment because I was hoping to pay for only 6months since am suppose to gradaute next year Feb,but now that's not possible again.God knows best.#EKSU#

@OP,

Do you know what it takes to be a Professor? You think its as easy as doing a political campaign for some weeks and winning elections. There is nothing wrong if the allowances you mentioned are truly for them(I still don't believe you wholly). And do you know how much the minister of Finance(Ngozi Iweala) is collecting as salary? Remember her pay caused trouble during OBJ's time because of the fact that its in dollars which runs in millions of naira per month when converted. How much is an oil worker earning per month? Some of them earn two million naira per month and some earn four to five miilion per month. Most of them are just first degree holders who got to the senior position they are through the years of service. Those who earn 600 thousand per month in the oil companies are not the very senior officers. Yet this is what a prof is collecting and you are saying it as if its so magnificient. How much are the central bank workers, NNPC etc earning. I have a lot of profs as friends and I ve not seen them earning all the allowances you mentioned and the so called car loan you mentioned etc. Some still ride on rickety cars. These are what is written on paper but in reality they don't see the money. You said they recommended the one of infrastructure. But at least they have made the govt to cough out 100 billion naira for infrastruture for the first time. With their insistence, if govt adds any more money on the infrastructure money is it not good? You want to present ASUU as selfish yet they have achieved the release of 100 billion for infrastructure. Every organization has allowances they pay their various staff according to their level. Some of the allowances runs iin millions. There is absolutely wrong for someone who has reached the zenith of his academic career(professor) to collect the allowances you mentioned. So a prof should be poor or what? Or you mean lecturers should not talk about their pay in a country where government never thinks of giving pay rise to its workers except they protest by way of strike? Its only the unexposed students that ll be carried away by your write up. Be balanced.

The NUT you are blaming are only being reasonable. With their support to ASUU they have established a relationship with them. There is no way ASUU will not give them same support whenever the need arises. They are wise to have established this relationship now. Stop blaming them.

Front page pls

Let me jst comment... End Time Agreement...

FG should pls implement d agreement they had with ASUU since 2009, the 4 years grace given to them b4 dey embark on dis Strike is a handshake beyond d elbow.

@dr.kay, are you sure you read the article at all? Does that look like something that can be implemented?

By the way, check out an article on the strike by Tolu Ogunlesi www.punchng.com/opinion/asuus-strategy-and-the-nigerian-university/

Nice write up, if there are any contentious issues in the agreement then government should feel free to talk about it.