Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,152,510 members, 7,816,231 topics. Date: Friday, 03 May 2024 at 08:04 AM

Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? - Politics (2) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? (12105 Views)

Buhari: Nigeria Now Self-Sufficient In Cement Production / Atiku: If We Truly Deregulated, Shouldn’t Fuel Price Drop? / Border Closure: Benin, Niger Economies Under Pressure (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by SamuelAnyawu(m): 7:56am On Oct 18, 2019
God Bless you Muhammadu Buhari
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by ctleurocollege: 8:00am On Oct 18, 2019
Let the borders continue to be closed grin

1 Like

Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by Hero2k9: 8:01am On Oct 18, 2019
OK we av heard.
Buhari Pls stop importing GENERATOR into OUR country n also focused on generating POWER from within.

3 Likes 1 Share

Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by Techsunny: 8:01am On Oct 18, 2019
adioolayi:
keep complaining ....The closure is here to stay.
Idoit! this type of people should nt share things in common with Biafrans, intellect2% vision, 1%.Northern Fools can't even produce self sufficient ..... for one state in Nigeria here ranting closure is here to stay, mumu can't eve see 2square meals to eat.Suffering ndsmiling.
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by Vulcanheph(m): 8:04am On Oct 18, 2019
ednut1:
Are we queuing for food Are the markets empty Answer is no. Am with Buhari on this
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by EzekaUdenee: 8:06am On Oct 18, 2019
[s]
solmusdesigns:
we can borrow to buy rice
[/s]
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by Cmeo(m): 8:09am On Oct 18, 2019
The govt may be right after all becos rice is not the only food in Nigeria.

1 Like

Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by Vulcanheph(m): 8:14am On Oct 18, 2019
ednut1:
Are we queuing for food Are the markets empty Answer is no. Am with Buhari on this
So is it untill we start living like Refugees in our own country will You start believing that things are hard?
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by maasoap(m): 8:15am On Oct 18, 2019
gaetano:
Buhari did this "close the border" thing in 1984 and 1985. You guys didn't learn.

Now it appears that his second term will even be more protectionist than his first term.

The Pic below is from the Adeshina days (Adeshina was simply the most remarkable agriculture minister Nigeria ever add). He wasn't simply a "close the border and magic will happen" kind of minister.

How many of these problems will "closing the borders" solve? Please ask Buharideens.

Did we stop stop food importation when he was the minister? What is your point exactly? I knew for a fact that rice production has increased more than what we had under Adesina. What was even the budget of ministry of agriculture when Adesina was there? In case you didn't know, let me tell you. The year Okonjo called our budget "the budget of agricultural transformation", a paltry sum of 6 billion naira was the ministry of agric entire earmarked budget. What did we have in excess, produced in excess under Adesina that has gone down now?

1 Like

Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by adioolayi(m): 8:20am On Oct 18, 2019
Techsunny:
Idoit! this type of people should nt share things in common with Biafrans, intellect2% vision, 1%.Northern Fools can't even produce self sufficient ..... for one state in Nigeria here ranting closure is here to stay, mumu can't eve see 2square meals to eat.Suffering ndsmiling.

Are you part of the smugglers? Nigeria's boarder have been closed for good.....start a new life legitimately. If you can't and you are not happy with the closure, relocate to the nearest country that can accommodate your illicit trade.

3 Likes

Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by Mexyz(m): 8:25am On Oct 18, 2019
adioolayi:
keep complaining ....The closure is here to stay.

For majority of Nigeria's population born in 70's and early 80's......Rice was gold...eaten mostly around festive period and in parties. Maybe we should go back to that era and start eating our porridge corn and Beans. (Egbo ati ewa)
Oga I support the border closure because I have been eating Nigerian rice for long now without knowing, but your useless opinion that rice should only be eating during festive period just because that was the practice in the 70s is laughable.
Always think before typing, I don't need to remind you that we are in 2019, I guess you still use black and white TV in your house.

2 Likes

Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by jamesversion: 8:26am On Oct 18, 2019
Beremx:
Nigeria is not self sufficient In all ramifications. Buhari should stop deceiving himself that he is working. Instead, he is adding more sufferings to Nigerians

Madam, I noticed this border closure seems to have a perpetual irritation on you. Are you an importer or do you run an eatery... or what is you particular problem?
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by Realdeals(m): 8:27am On Oct 18, 2019
I think if we don't, we will. Nigeria have all the resources to be self sufficient (good soil, good climate and water), the problem is that we the citizens are too lethargic, everyone expect others to be doing all the work while they stay in one corner advising and complaining.

2 Likes

Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by adioolayi(m): 8:33am On Oct 18, 2019
Mexyz:
Oga I support the border closure because I have been eating Nigerian rice for long now without knowing, but your useless opinion that rice should only be eating during festive period just because that was the practice in the 70s is laughable.
Always think before typing, I don't need to remind you that we are in 2019, I guess you still use black and white TV in your house.
Why the abuse I provided an alternative to anyone who cannot afford rice... na crime

1 Like

Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by bixton(m): 8:33am On Oct 18, 2019
From being forced to settle for low quality staple food, to increase in the general price level, the average Nigerian pays the price for the federal government’s border closure policy.

This is the most absurd statement in the entire post.
Please mention the low quality staple food(s) you know as a Nigerian that exist in the country?


And anyone saying Nigeria is not self sufficiet in terms of food should think well and very well again?
Are we actually over 180 million persons even with the illegal migrants in this country?

Can anyone put a claim that its the poverty in the land and recent closure of border that has reduced the consumption rate and use of petroleum products by end users; can that be said for staple foods too?

Our ingenuity in lies is the reason this country has refused to move for the better.

3 Likes

Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by pharmagba: 8:39am On Oct 18, 2019
TheSaxophonist:
When the federal government announced the closure of Nigeria’s land borders on the 20th of August, it sighted the need to establish a relationship of mutual coexistence between Nigeria and her neighbors. The Nigerian customs boss maintained that Nigeria’s land borders would remain shut until neighbouring countries comply with protocols on movement of goods and persons as established by the Economic Community of West African States.

While some experts have questioned the legality of the move, others have praised it for the economic advantages it supposedly offers Nigerian farmers.

Short cut to success
When the federal government launched the economic recovery and growth plan (ERGP) in 2017, one of its cardinal stanchions was to create over 15 million jobs by 2020, as well as drive food security by achieving self sufficiency in tomato (2017), rice (2018) and wheat (2020).

By 2018, Nigeria’s demand for rice had risen to 6.7 million tons, with domestic production falling well below 4 million tons in the same period. Despite a 70% hike in tariffs and levies since 2015, but with local production still far below demand, rice has found its way across Nigeria’s borders by hook or crook.

Since the recent land border closure intended to enforce an outright ban on rice importation, the price of rice has risen abruptly. Since June 2019, one kilogramme of rice (imported high quality sold loose) has gone from N352.82 per kilogramme to N540 per kilogramme. With local production hardly rising above previous levels and consumers moving away from the expensive foreign alternative, some experts predict that the price of a kilogramme of rice might stabilize at N800 by the years’ end (that’s N40,000 for a 50 kilogrammes bag).

Self sufficiency should translate to our local demand been met by local production and if this be the case, we are still half way there.

However, with time the federal government’s cosmetic approach if sustained might force a drop in general consumption, as Nigerian consumers bare the largest share of the policies burden.

If prices continue to rise as predicted and consumption falls with respect to the elasticity of rice, then that point comes when the general demand will match local production. At this point we can say we are “self sufficient”, but definitely not at the current disequilibrium.

Good or bad policy?
The Nigerian customs recently revealed that it has raked an average of N4.7 billion to N5.8 billion daily since the border closure. An estimate it claimed was above its initial revenue prior to the closure.

The federal government also claims that since the border was closed on the 20th of August, the diversion of petroleum products from Nigeria to neighbouring countries had ceased, saving us 10.2 million litres of premium motor spirit (PMS).

What’s the catch?
In its latest inflation report, the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) revealed that consumer price index had risen to 11.24% by September 2019. Previous data from the NBS showed that inflation began to rise following Nigeria’s closure of its land borders.

With an outright ban on trade through the nation’s land borders, aggregate demand seems to outpace aggregate supply. This unavailability of adequate supply leads producers/suppliers to increase prices, thus leading to a demand-pull inflation.

From being forced to settle for low quality staple food, to increase in the general price level, the average Nigerian pays the price for the federal government’s border closure policy.

By Cephas Kadiri and Uwemedimoh Sampson

Source:
http://www.gpggnigeria.org/border-closure-are-we-truly-self-sufficient-in-food-production/
With this beautiful piece one would had thought , Nigeria interest would have be the hallmark but you didn't even look at Nigeria interest.
They say necessity is the mother of invention, and where there is a need there is an opportunity.
Nigeria does not have to achieve sufficiency before closure of border, to be candid self sufficiency will never be achieved when border are open to all to all and sundry.
The border closure will encourage more Nigerian get involved with food production because it is now profitable and with more engagement food production will increase cause price to dip then sufficiency will be achieved.
Please let our economics be grounded
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by Mexyz(m): 8:41am On Oct 18, 2019
adioolayi:

Why the abuse I provided an alternative to anyone who cannot afford rice... na crime
. No Sir, I did not abuse you, I only pointed out that your opinion was useless and you should endeavor to always give out critically thought ideas...
I apologize if it sounds like an insult to you.. E mabinu
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by GuestLog: 8:45am On Oct 18, 2019
adioolayi:
keep complaining ....The closure is here to stay.

For majority of Nigeria's population born in 70's and early 80's......Rice was gold...eaten mostly around festive period and in parties. Maybe we should go back to that era and start eating our porridge corn and Beans. (Egbo ati ewa)
See the way you are shamelessly romancing poverty because you want the whole country to live impoverished lives like you did in the 70's.

God no go let us see bad thing.
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by stanliwise(m): 8:52am On Oct 18, 2019
adioolayi:
keep complaining ....The closure is here to stay.

For majority of Nigeria's population born in 70's and early 80's......Rice was gold...eaten mostly around festive period and in parties. Maybe we should go back to that era and start eating our porridge corn and Beans. (Egbo ati ewa)
if you understand the conspiracy theory, maybe you will later come back to delete this post.
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by PropertyBase: 8:55am On Oct 18, 2019
Untill Abiola rice came and Arosor.�

The real problem is that Nigerians prefer to export the little production we do here.

The government should empower farmers to produce more to go round.


adioolayi:
keep complaining ....The closure is here to stay.

For majority of Nigeria's population born in 70's and early 80's......Rice was gold...eaten mostly around festive period and in parties. Maybe we should go back to that era and start eating our porridge corn and Beans. (Egbo ati ewa)

1 Like

Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by Twoclans(f): 8:56am On Oct 18, 2019
Truth be told we are not self sufficient yet,however we need to feel the pain of some decisions to enable us become a great nation .

3 Likes

Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by WonderManly(m): 9:00am On Oct 18, 2019
NewsMuncher:

Lol. It's not off head though, its offhand
That's my teacher. thanks!
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by Pusyiter(m): 9:02am On Oct 18, 2019
.....unfortunately, that has not been the case as we always feels the pain yet we are not on the path of greatness
Twoclans:
Truth be told we are not self sufficient yet,however we need to feel the pain of some decisions to enable us become a great nation .
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by adioolayi(m): 9:17am On Oct 18, 2019
Mexyz:
. No Sir, I did not abuse you, I only pointed out that your opinion was useless and you should endeavor to always give out critically thought ideas...
I apologize if it sounds like an insult to you.. E mabinu
Criticism is welcome, constructive criticism devoid of any element of abuse is most welcome. Calling people's opinion "Useless" and saying ideas are not "Critically thought of" shows the path you belong...desist from acts of this nature and toe the right path...especially on public forum like this.

1 Like

Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by obidark: 9:33am On Oct 18, 2019
does it matter....??

what our neighbors are doing is not good....
they dont mind to destroy their neighbors because of petty taxes....

this is how mediocre they are....
how can benin be importing so much foreighn rice and be dumping it in nigeria....??

this morafvckers have no shame,i tell you....

1 Like

Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by obidark: 9:36am On Oct 18, 2019
its sad that this drastic measure is hittin genuine farmers but they have too much criminals....

people that dont even grow food are importing rice from abroad to sell....

you see how lazy and wicked they are....??
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by MNDY(m): 9:37am On Oct 18, 2019
Are we talking about only rice? What of the price of other things we cannot produce that has been banned from coming in and has become scarce and more expensive because of the border closure?
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by obidark: 9:39am On Oct 18, 2019
adioolayi:

Criticism is welcome, constructive criticism devoid of any element of abuse is most welcome. Calling people's opinion "Useless" and saying ideas are not "Critically thought of" shows the path you belong...desist from acts of this nature and toe the right path...especially on public forum like this.

wetin be your problem....??

he already apologized....

wetin dey worry you....
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by obidark: 9:40am On Oct 18, 2019
MNDY:
Are we talking about only rice? What of the price of other things we cannot produce that has been banned from coming in and has become scarce and more expensive because of the border closure?

chai....nigerians sef....una only sabi how to complain....

get to work already....!!

1 Like

Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by johnad3(m): 9:45am On Oct 18, 2019
Is it true all the border in north are open?
Re: Border Closure: Are We Truly Self Sufficient In Food Production? by Elamin21(m): 9:48am On Oct 18, 2019
The population of Nigeria is much and as such local food produced here can't sustain us all..... So if them get sense make them open the border back.

(1) (2) (3) (Reply)

APC Thugs Accused Of Destroying Kwankwaso's Billboards In Kano / Photos: See How Nigeria Ladies Celebrate's National “ no bra day” / Man Arrested For Impersonating Adamu Sule, Buhari’s Adviser

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 57
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.