Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,152,376 members, 7,815,799 topics. Date: Thursday, 02 May 2024 at 06:35 PM

Why China's Response To US Warships In Taiwan Strait Surprised Analysts - Foreign Affairs - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / Foreign Affairs / Why China's Response To US Warships In Taiwan Strait Surprised Analysts (1242 Views)

China Complains As US Destroyer, Ralph Johnson Warship Navigates Taiwan Strait / Chinese Carrier Sails Through Taiwan Strait Hours Before Biden - Xi Call / US Warships Shadowed In South China Sea By Military Vessels ( Pics) (2) (3) (4)

(1) (Reply) (Go Down)

Why China's Response To US Warships In Taiwan Strait Surprised Analysts by Mikeiron78(m): 2:26pm On Aug 29, 2022
CNN- Brad Lendon

After United States House Speaker Nancy Pelosi visited Taiwan in early August, the Chinese military staged some of its biggest ever military exercises around the island.

Chinese warplanes swarmed across the Taiwan Strait and the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) even fired missiles over Taiwan, the democratically ruled island that the Chinese Communist Party claims as its sovereign territory despite having never controlled it.

Those Chinese military exercises set what some analysts and officials feared might be a “new normal” across the strait: A more permanent PLA presence ever closer to Taiwan.

US officials, meanwhile, vowed Washington would stay the course and Chinese intimidation tactics would be challenged.

On Sunday, the US Navy sent two guided-missile cruisers through the strait, which China now claims as its “internal waters.” The US and others maintain the strait is international waters under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea.

It was the first time in at least four years the US Navy had sent two cruisers through the strait, said Collin Koh, research fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies in Singapore, who has been keeping a database on the transits.

“Having two instead of the usual one vessel to do this mission is certainly a ‘bigger’ signal of protest against not only Beijing’s recent military exercises around Taiwan following the Pelosi visit, but also in response to Beijing’s attempt to subvert the legal status of the waterway and the longstanding freedom of navigation rights through the area,” Koh said.

That the US warships made the transit Sunday was no surprise. They have made dozens of such voyages in recent years, and US officials had said transits would continue.

What was surprising to analysts was the muted response from Beijing.

The Chinese military’s Eastern Theater Command said it monitored the two ships, maintained a high alert and was “ready to thwart any provocation.”

Even the state-run Global Times tabloid, known for its often jingoistic and staunchly nationalist editorials, said the presence of the two cruisers brought “no actual threat to China’s security.”

Related video: United States shows unwavering support for Taiwan; navy chief raises concerns over China

developments, not just in Taiwan but also the China India border.

Past transits have elicited a stronger response. After the destroyer USS Benfold went through the strait in July, Col. Shi Yi, spokesman for the PLA’s Eastern Theater Command, described the US as the “destroyer of peace and stability in the Taiwan Strait.”

While earlier this month, the Chinese ambassador to Washington, Qin Gang, called on the US to halt naval transits, saying they intensify tensions and embolden “Taiwan independence separatist forces.”

“If there’s any move damaging China’s territorial integrity and sovereignty, China will respond,” Qin told reporters in Washington in response to a question on possible upcoming transits.

Koh, the analyst, noted Beijing’s comparatively tame statements Sunday.

“Why didn’t the Chinese go beyond that given their earlier strong opposition to Washington’s professed intent to continue such transits?” he said, offering three possible factors.

Firstly, Beijing may be wary of “international blowback,” as any attempt to curtail US Navy navigation through the strait could be seen as threatening the rights of vessels from other nations to go through the waterway.

Secondly, after the Pelosi visit to Taiwan, Beijing suspended key military communications channels with Washington, raising the risk of misunderstandings during any PLA Navy-US Navy interaction.

Thirdly, there are other areas where Washington and Beijing do cooperate, and China may not want to strain those, Koh said.

“It doesn’t make sense to provoke further heightened tensions that can potentially escalate into a clash,” he said.

Carl Schuster, a former director of operations at the US Pacific Command’s Joint Intelligence Center in Hawaii, suggests a fourth possibility.

“I think (Chinese leader Xi Jinping) is going to avoid any action that might strengthen the Republicans’ and other China hawks’ chances in the upcoming elections. He doesn’t want a House and Senate that may enact legislation that more strongly supports Taiwan, or limits Chinese investment and influence in the US,” Schuster said.

Meanwhile, he said, the use of two cruisers in the latest strait transit might not be seen so much as a statement, but as reasonable military planning.

“Given China’s threats and recent missile firings into international waters … it does seem prudent to have two warships transit those waters together,” Schuster said.

And expect the US Navy to go about business as usual with regular transits of the strait, he said.

“Under international law it is international waters and so there is no official dispute on its status,” he said. “The US Navy transit makes that statement quietly and effectively.”
Re: Why China's Response To US Warships In Taiwan Strait Surprised Analysts by Kingozymandias(m): 2:32pm On Aug 29, 2022
It doesn't surprise those of us who are saavy in. International politics.

China is an empty barrel that just makes noise...

Off course Beijing would be silent .. Don't belive all the hype and call of duty video games ...

China does not want to go to war with America. Making noise online and in the internet is easy , backing it up is what is tough.

See ordianry Ukraine Russia has been unable to defeat and begging for support from allies like Belarus.

Thinking you can defeat America in all out war will be any nations undoing . No smart nation will want to go to war with America. Forget all these fan boys who shout Slava Russia or whatever NONSENSE.

They haven't seen what real war is beyimg their playstation video game simulation

4 Likes 1 Share

Re: Why China's Response To US Warships In Taiwan Strait Surprised Analysts by MadeInTokyo: 3:00pm On Aug 29, 2022
On Sunday, the US Navy sent two guided-missile cruisers through the strait, which China now claims as its “internal waters.” The US and others maintain the strait is international waters under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea.

It was the first time in at least four years the US Navy had sent two cruisers through the strait, said Collin Koh, research fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies in Singapore, who has been keeping a database on the transits
.

“Having two instead of the usual one vessel to do this mission is certainly a ‘bigger’ signal of protest against not only Beijing’s recent military exercises around Taiwan following the Pelosi visit, but also in response to Beijing’s attempt to subvert the legal status of the waterway and the longstanding freedom of navigation rights through the area,” Koh said.
That the US warships made the transit Sunday was no surprise. They have made dozens of such voyages in recent years, and US officials had said transits would continue.

What was surprising to analysts was the muted response from Beijing.
China always barking , they should have fired missiles to those US naval missiles guided cruisers that passed through the strait yesterday, which China has always been claiming the strait is their territory
Re: Why China's Response To US Warships In Taiwan Strait Surprised Analysts by Brainmytool: 3:08pm On Aug 29, 2022
Nigerians wake up.

This is misinformation. They are lieing to us. All of dem are preparing us for their one world government. Nigeria is part of them, none is a saint, Russia, US, China, UK, Japan, India to mention but a few. There all want us to fight against The Aliens above with the Ones Within. It has always been their agreement to prepare and unify us (voluntarily or otherwise) against the reigning Aliens who resides in space in war with the Aliens with their tunnels in every opening of the earth.

Reference: the bible said; and the beast will come out of the seas of the earth. Which beast? You should have asked urself. Its important to note that you must worship the beast.


Before you qoute me answer the below handful questions:

Can you bank without BVN?

Can you make communications without NIN?

Can you travel without being vaccinated against Covid?

Can you eat without money, live and shelter urself?

None of this countries is a saint. And remember to get urself ready for the Upcoming Chip Implantation which they will give an excuse to force it on You.
Re: Why China's Response To US Warships In Taiwan Strait Surprised Analysts by Mikeiron78(m): 3:25am On Aug 30, 2022
Brainmytool:
Nigerians wake up.

This is misinformation. They are lieing to us. All of dem are preparing us for their one world government. Nigeria is part of them, none is a saint, Russia, US, China, UK, Japan, India to mention but a few. There all want us to fight against The Aliens above with the Ones Within. It has always been their agreement to prepare and unify us (voluntarily or otherwise) against the reigning Aliens who resides in space in war with the Aliens with their tunnels in every opening of the earth.

Reference: the bible said; and the beast will come out of the seas of the earth. Which beast? You should have asked urself. Its important to note that you must worship the beast.


Before you qoute me answer the below handful questions:

Can you bank without BVN?

Can you make communications without NIN?

Can you travel without being vaccinated against Covid?

Can you eat without money, live and shelter urself?

None of this countries is a saint. And remember to get urself ready for the Upcoming Chip Implantation which they will give an excuse to force it on You.


People like you so exist in this world. I'm sure you'll claim to have some kind of education, but conspiracy theories is messing you up. Wake up bro lol
Re: Why China's Response To US Warships In Taiwan Strait Surprised Analysts by RepoMan007: 9:59am On Aug 30, 2022
Even colonial masters don't allow the colonized territory to have president not subjective to them. Taiwan has been independent for 70 years and I wonder what China was thinking all these while.
Re: Why China's Response To US Warships In Taiwan Strait Surprised Analysts by Brainmytool: 6:38pm On Aug 30, 2022
Mikeiron78:



People like you so exist in this world. I'm sure you'll claim to have some kind of education, but conspiracy theories is messing you up. Wake up bro lol

ur so called education is built on falsehood. I don't need to be awake cos i am already. But u should be awake cos u have always been a target for misinformation. Relax, dey have produced malaria cure for u since u refused to take covid cure, lol. Baba wake up to the reality.
Re: Why China's Response To US Warships In Taiwan Strait Surprised Analysts by Emma15678: 1:46pm On Aug 31, 2022
Kingozymandias:
It doesn't surprise those of us who are saavy in. International politics.

China is an empty barrel that just makes noise...

Off course Beijing would be silent .. Don't belive all the hype and call of duty video games ...

China does not want to go to war with America. Making noise online and in the internet is easy , backing it up is what is tough.

See ordianry Ukraine Russia has been unable to defeat and begging for support from allies like Belarus.

Thinking you can defeat America in all out war will be any nations undoing . No smart nation will want to go to war with America. Forget all these fan boys who shout Slava Russia or whatever NONSENSE.

They haven't seen what real war is beyimg their playstation video game simulation
China has never been serious about a war with US. But if Russia was in Chinese Shoes we would have a full blown war on our hands. Correction:
Russia is neither struggling or seeking aid from Belarus rather Belarus is seeking aid from Russia

1 Like

Re: Why China's Response To US Warships In Taiwan Strait Surprised Analysts by Owen247: 12:55pm On Sep 01, 2022
Emma15678:

China has never been serious about a war with US. But if Russia was in Chinese Shoes we would have a full blown war on our hands. Correction:
Russia is neither struggling or seeking aid from Belarus rather Belarus is seeking aid from Russia

i dnt understand how dat guy said dat Russia is begging for help from Belarus.

if russia has the financial power dat china has, it will be a serious war btw usa and russia.

other thing here,if china enters taiwan at the same time that russia is in ukraine it might lead to a big all out,round war. And i think thats what they are trying to avoid.

2 Likes

(1) (Reply)

Russia Suspends Participation In Grain Deal After Ukrainian Attack / Sleepy Don: Americans Mock Donald Trump For Sleeping In Court Two Days In A Row / Why Did The Arab Kings Survive The Arab Spring?

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 37
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.