Aletheia's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Aletheia's Profile › Aletheia's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 77 78 79 80 81 82 (of 82 pages)
Kay 17:1. A lot of words there, but still no definition, and in order to show that I make the error of equating belief and facts you will need to define a. fact, b. belief as I earlier requested, not give me examples of what you think a fact is and a belief is. 2. And please stop making fallacious statements. "a Christian believes that it is the demon of malaria that causes malaria" |
Atheists:1. Your god helped free his chosen people. So you acknowledge for a fact He exists? BTW His chosen ones also includes Rwandans. 2. Why so much angst and anger towards Someone whose existence you deny. Could it be, there is a still small voice within you that acknowledges His existence? |
mazaje:1. Is that a true statement? 2. Do you believe it? |
Kay 17:Before I respond to your initial question I would like to understand what you mean when you say "facts are known not believed because doubt is inherent in every belief." What do you define as: 1. fact 2. belief. This discussion would be unproductive if we are not sure about the meaning of the words the other is using. Granted in all religions most are conditioned [/i]to accept their particular religion but that does not rule out the existence of God(s). As for your assertion about man's vast base of scientific knowledge; the question I would like to ask you is this: Is there a limit, a boundary to what that science can reveal? Moreover, has it occurred to you that that same science is [i]based upon some philosophical propositions (I will try to address that on the thread you asked me to open). I am acquainted with the basic premises of other religions. |
Deep Sight:I didn't imply that the box is the universe. The box represents the boundaries of what we can know with the tools at our disposal. Kay 17:Outside the box, there is the possibility that unicorns of whatever hue exist. Perhaps there really are PINK unicorns in NGC 4414. I do not possess the tools to rule out that fact. toneyb:I concede the point that belief can shape one's perception of reality. The same way that your belief in atheism will cause you to reject any evidence for the existence of God(s). But beliefs don't necessarily have to be false. My belief is in the existence of the God who revealed Himself in the bible, not any of those you enumerated above. The reasons for that are beyond the scope of this discourse as that will lead us to a comparative study of religions and their competing claims. This discussion is about the existence of the God of the bible as implied by the question on the genocide. What my argument has basically been is that employing only reason and logic can never lead any atheist or theist for that matter (if they will be honest) to offer conclusive proof for the non-existence or existence of God(s). At best, we will be agnostic. At the end, given what we can know by empirical reasoning, we can only make a choice on the balance of the available evidence to believe or disbelieve. Which is why christians talk about faith: "By faith we understand that the universe was created by the word of God, so that what is seen was not made out of things that are visible." |
The limits of the atheist's knowledge.
|
@Deep Sight Deep Sight:I believe you have hit the nail on the head with regards to the views of the atheists on this forum. I wish they would examine the assumptions that underpin their beliefs and compare it with the empiric evidence rather than base it on a rejection of a book which they claim is all fables. |
toneyb:Proof? Why avoid addressing my suggestion that human knowledge has limits beyond which we cannot know with certainty? |
Kay 17:Precisely. You rely on reason, a tool that has its limits. Are you saying there are no limits to what you can know. How does reason explain the paranormal? |
Deep Sight:Quite right ![]() |
[quote author=Tudór link=topic=356567.msg5033932#msg5033932 date=1259748249]Well After all the ranting back and forth NOBODY is yet to tell us where God was during the genocide and why he/she/it didn't stop it. What I gotta do to get an answer. . .sacrifice my testicles? [/quote]You don't have to castrate yourself. But I'd already given an answer in one of my earlier posts: "He was present." What did he do about it? I also replied that "He had acted in time about 2000 yrs ago to address the problem of the Rwandan Genocide". Of course you wouldn't agree with my answer because of your belief that God does not exist. You would also probably ask why didn't he act at the point of the tragedy? But that question presupposes that death is the worst thing that could happen to a human. But the Christian Worldview makes it clear that death and all those horrific events of the Genocide is only a consequence of something even worse: sin. And so He acted in time to solve the sin problem once and for all. He didn't need to repeatedly intervene every time an atrocity is committed. Granted a lot of terrible things have been done in the name of religion but this only goes to show that sin is very much present in man. Kay 17:I would like to respond to some of what you say above. 1. You said within man's knowledge, thereby admitting that there are limits to human knowledge. The thrust of my arguments has been that given the limits of what we can know, human reason using the empiric method can not prove the non-existence of God. God is a transcendental being. Zeus, Poseidon & PINK unicorns are not transcendental beings. You persist in trying to use the wrong tools to determine the existence of what your tools can not measure in the first place. To a man who only has a hammer, the whole world is a nail. A creature placed within a box cannot determine what exists outside of the box.2. I do not have to be omniscient to say that God exists. All I need is credible evidence that he exists. Hence my analogy involving Dark Matter. "Science" discovered Dark Matter not by direct observation but by inference from its interaction with visible matter. In the same way, I can infer the existence of God by his interaction with us. Philip Pullman in his fictional trilogy: "His Dark Materials" indicates that Dark Matter is the host of Angels. I make no such or any similar claim, only presented an analogy involving Dark Matter. 3. I do not dismiss all scientific knowledge as false. Neither do I agree with your statement that "belief is ignorance of the facts". I believe that if I jump off the top of the Empire State Building, I will plummet to the ground. Is that ignorance of the facts? Again you do not present a logical argument. 4. God is perfect. God is love. Love greater than that which I have for my baby. [b]Love so great as to include even men like Hitler and Stalin. [/b]Most of you atheists objections in this thread is hinged on that attribute of God. But you forget that God is also Holy, requiring perfect justice. How do you reconcile perfect love which requires Hitler and Stalin and the perpetrators of the Genocide to be forgiven and perfect justice which demands their punishment? If you atheists can give me a better answer than this: For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son, that whoever believes in Him should not perish but have everlasting life. For God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world through Him might be saved, I will become an atheist. |
@sauer This is what you said in an earlier post: "While the above is no doubt true, it is also very true to add that: though non-believers cannot prove that God doesn't exist, they can in fact posit (from details available in history, science and in recent events) that the chances that they exists no God is well above 90%." As I recall certainty = 100%. Thank you for conceding the point I made earlier: An atheist, to be consistently assured that his belief is accurate, must also claim to be omniscient, for there always exists the possibility of the existence of God outside his knowledge. You are not certain that God does not exist. |
Do I count as one? |
toneyb:bla, bla and more bla from you. Half-truths couched in tendentious sentences. Like I said earlier if you are going to base your answers on the bible, at least get it right? How can you critique a book that you repeatedly demonstrate abysmal knowledge of? God did not address all the people living in Israel (which would be the geographic location) through a public speech. He addressed the people assembled at Mount Sinai, which is outside the borders of Israel. If you cannot truthfully present facts you disagree with, how can we be such that you are being honest in all your replies? I said individuals make claims in newspapers of God speaking to them. My point was not the veracity of such claims but the fact that they are[b] recorded[/b] just as such encounters are recorded in the bible as you will realize from my post if you weren't reading it through the rose-tinted lenses of atheism. Your premise was flawed. The modern man is more intelligent, Really? For an empiricist you disappoint. Show me the IQ tests you carried out that supports such a statement. You said, all the evidence and case made for the existence for such a god is found in the bible in forms of various stories. Christians have also offered proof for the existence of God from outside of the bible. Your sentence reveals that you are not acquainted with all of the Christian's arguments for the existence of God, only basing your suppositions on a rant against the bible. Even as you disagree with my views, try to be honest. Okay. ![]() |
Kay 17:RED HERRING. We are not debating the existence of PINK unicorns? |
toneyb:You so quick off the mark to prove your point that you do not care to consider the flaws in what you write. Your contention is that God spoke in the past to people. He doesn't at present address people through public speech? How do you know? All that you can be certain of is that he has not addressed you toneyb through public speech. A cursory reading of newspapers will reveal several individuals that make such claims. So the bible, which you discount anyway, and newspapers which you read everyday record similar stories. toneyb:Hmmm. Are you rejecting the God of the bible or the existence of God(s)? Some emotionally charged words there: 1. morally reprehensible - what morals? The one that atheism revealed to you? Or ones applicable in all human societies based on the belief in God(s). 2. killing of innocent children - Innocence? This word last time I checked meant not being guilty of a crime or freedom from sin and evil. See you cannot even argue about the existence of God without using words that imply his existence. Where did you get your idea of innocence from? Was it from atheism? BTW, the bible doesn't refer to the Canaanites as innocent. If you are going to argue from the bible, at least acquaint yourself with it. toneyb:Yes, I believe them. They were reliable eyewitness accounts. toneyb:Another sweeping statement by one whose grasp of history is tenuous. There are many things that modern man has achieved. But there are also things that the Ancient societies accomplished that modern man finds astounding and difficult to replicate. Examples abound. toneyb:Advice to you: 1. Go buy a dictionary 2. Look up the meanings of transcendent and immanent 3. Then read your bible again. You will find your answers there. toneyb:Classic. Accusing one who defends his views of playing the victim card. Why would I do that? To invoke your sympathy? And you are dishonest. I say some atheist are "angry" at God. But as usual your revisionist tendencies cannot but manifest. You replace angry with "hate" in quotes to make it seem as if I said atheists hate God. If you are going to be an atheist at least learn to present a logical defense of your creed, not playing to the emotional gallery. BTW you have not responded to this: An atheist, to be consistently assured that his belief is accurate, must also claim to be omniscient, for there always exists the possibility of the existence of God outside his knowledge |
Kay 17:I begin to understand that while you atheists arrogate to yourselves authority to ask questions and query the assumptions that underpin the theist worldview, you are uncomfortable when a theist returns the favor. Has any of you even bothered to examine the assumptions that lie beneath your beliefs instead to parroting worn-out arguments.What is the main issue here if not a discussion on the existence of God? [/b]You an atheist asks Where Was God During The Rwandan Genocide? I have already since provided an answer: "He was present." You ask this question with a view to proving the non-existence of God, so why not cut through all the song and dance and get to the heart of the matter. Perhaps, you will do well to read all my posts on this thread, so that you will follow the flow of my arguments. I [b]"keeps hittin (sic) that man's empirical knowledge is limited and therefore, impossible to prove that God does not exists." because not one of you has addressed that point. How certain are you Kay17 of what you say you know? At least sauer conceded he was 90% sure there is no God - leaving the small matter of 10%. ![]() BTW your analogies above do not cut it, because as a doctor I know the limits of the knowledge with which I diagnose malaria &c. You place God in the same category as vampires, PINK unicorns &c because you consign them all to the realm of the fantastic. But God is not in the same category as these others. We believe that God is an eternal uncreated being who created all that exists including PINK unicorns if they exist somewhere. Last time I checked, nobody has made such claims not even for the Greek god Zeus. This is again another example of the tactics you atheists employ on this forum, introduce red herrings and try to muddy the waters of this discourse. Perhaps, there are those who believe in such but this discussion centres on the existence or non-existence of God. |
[quote author=Tudór link=topic=356567.msg5027549#msg5027549 date=1259654034]Its funny the way aletheia and co are all here whining about how their God is trancedent and cannot be proven using physical means at our disposal. . . Is it not the SAME god who was having conversations with moses? God who also fought battles side by side with isrealites and sent down fire for elijah to prove that he himself is most powerful, God who spoke for all to hear during the baptism of jesus then ALL OF A SUDDEN when mankind became smarter and abandoned primitivity and myths then God disappeared and became shy. Now to prove their God has become a problem we now hear them ranting god is "transcedent" and cannot be perceived with our 5 senses. I laugh in tongues![/quote]Again you are being disingenuous. Can't you respond without dragging out red herrings all the time. 1. God had conversations with Moses. That he hasn't had a conversation with you, does not prove his non-existence 2. God fought battles with the Israelites. Yes, so what if he did? 3. He spoke for all to hear during the baptism of Jesus. Those were there heard Him. You weren't there. 4. "then ALL OF A SUDDEN when mankind became smarter and abandoned primitivity and myths then God disappeared and became shy." So what you are saying is essentially God demonstrated his presence in the past. Since he does not do so in similar ways in the present, he cannot exist. Poor logic. Modern man is still grappling to understand the sophistication of Ancient civilizations like the Maya, Egypt, Babylon, China. The Greeks were quite intelligent philosophers. All these societies believed in god. You are a poor student of history. 5. Again, the non-existence of God cannot be proven by the means at your disposal, considering the limits of what you can know. 6. That Christians claim that God is transcendent is a valid point which atheists cannot disprove. 7. How can we know the existence of a transcendent being. Only if He chooses to interact with us, hence my analogy involving Dark Matter, which some of you obviously do not get since you try to twist my words to mean that I proffer the existence of Dark Matter as a proof for God. 8. All that comes out in your posts here is anger and rejection of God, not a well reasoned or articulated defence of your hypothesis. |
sauer:Here in is proof that atheists are a confused bunch, who cannot even begin to logically explain what they profess without entangling themselves in conundrums. 1. Atheists make a definite, categorical statement. God does not exist. They state this with absolute certainty. They are 100% certain that He does not exist. 2. Here we have a self-avowed atheist claiming he is 90% certain that God does not exist. What about the small matter of 10%? So we can state that sauer is about 10% certain that God exists. Are sure you are an atheist? 3. This is obviously a case of not understanding the implications of what you believe - just as someone 9jaganja said atheists believe in god. 4. It is quite obvious that the atheists in this forum despite their pretensions, cannot engage in a philosophical discourse using logical arguments to buttress their hypothesis. What comes across is their sneering attitudes and rage at a God who they claim to believe does not exist. Witness as an example, Tudor's diatribes and refusal to address the assumptions that underpin their worldview. A worldview that is based upon faith rather than reason. For if based upon reason why not proffer those reasons rather than using the failings of Christianity as a justification. 5. Not one atheist on this forum has addressed the problems of epistemology which I pointed out. What can we know? What are the limits of that knowledge? How can we be certain of what lies beyond those limits? Devoid of independent thought, they continuously recycle tired old half-truths, and evasions. BTW sauer, your statement above proves my contention: An atheist, to be consistently assured that his belief is accurate, must also claim to be omniscient, for there always exists the possibility of the existence of God outside his knowledge |
your responses are weak. sauer:You are only restating your hypothesis. Where is your proof that he only dwells in the heads of the people who promote him? The existence of god must not be inferred by other means. [/quote]Why not? If your knowledge is limited and the tools at your disposal are limited. If you can infer the existence of Dark Matter from its interaction upon visible matter, I can infer the existence of God from his interaction as well with visible matterExistence is a consequence of what? Your existence is a consequence of what? In addition, no other thing on this earth has been ruled to exist only by other means, why then god?Because God as his attributes show is not of this earth. If one must prove his existence by other means and not by regular means, then we can safely rule him out of our scope and not bother about him.Non sequitur By the same token, he evidently has no input whatsoever in the daily affairs of humans, since this will ultimately become impossible.Another non sequitur Get real with your arguments! and stop quoting from this bookBut I am real. The book is real. And I will quote from the book. ![]() For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal power and Godhead, so that they are without excuse, because, although they knew God, they did not glorify Him as God, nor were thankful, but became futile in their thoughts, and their foolish hearts were darkened. Professing to be wise, they became fools, |
you atheists are a sorry bunch, always producing red herrings and non-sequiturs. you asked for evidence of a global flood. i gave that to you and y'all start ranting about the earth being 6000 yrs old. you are an intellectually lazy bunch. you all claim to be intellectuals but not one of you has rebutted the following points which i will continue to repeat ad nauseam until one of you tackles them. You atheists still don't get it, do you? Even a child can understand the thread of my argument. 1. What you can know or infer about the universe is limited and circumscribed by the physical laws that govern the universe? 2. Beyond, those limits, you cannot be certain of what you claim either positively or negatively 3. God as defined, by both atheists and believers is transcendent hence you cannot prove or disprove the non-existence of God using the means at your disposal. 4. The existence of God must be inferred by other means can't one of you atheists respond to that. anyone? or is it because y'all are clueless and have no idea about the rational basis for your religion. |
sauer:You atheists still don't get it, do you? Even a child can understand the thread of my argument. 1. What you can know or infer about the universe is limited and circumscribed by the physical laws that govern the universe? 2. Beyond, those limits, you cannot be certain of what you claim either positively or negatively 3. God as defined, by both atheists and believers is transcendent hence you cannot prove or disprove the non-existence of God using the means at your disposal. 4. The existence of God must be inferred by other means For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal power and Godhead, so that they are without excuse, because, although they knew God, they did not glorify Him as God, nor were thankful, but became futile in their thoughts, and their foolish hearts were darkened. Professing to be wise, they became fools, |
[quote author=Tudór link=topic=356567.msg5025521#msg5025521 date=1259614336]@athelia You are a LIAR. There is NO archeological or "anthropological" evidence for a global flood. These lies have been constantly exposed on this forum. I suggest you search for those threads and view them.[/quote]Whose athelia? Your girlfriend I think you meant aletheia:You will find evidence for a global flood here: http://www.answersingenesis.org/get-answers/features/worldwide-flood-evidence Try to read it objectively. |
[quote author=Tudór link=topic=356567.msg5025521#msg5025521 date=1259614336]@athelia You are a LIAR. There is NO archeological or "anthropological" evidence for a global flood. These lies have been constantly exposed on this forum. I suggest you search for those threads and view them.[/quote]Maybe. But what about points 1,2,3,5,6, and 7. I take it you agree with those then. |
[quote author=Tudór link=topic=356567.msg5025297#msg5025297 date=1259612290]Excuse me? Since you claim to be such an expert in logic then you need no magician to tell you the ONUS LIES ON WHO IS MAKING THE POSITIVE CLAIM TO PROVE IT. Statements like " (Atheists) provide positive evidence for their theisis God does not exist" are really dumb. What theisis? The idea of a God comes from the theist, an atheist is one who simply rejects God theisis based on the LACK of evidence. You can't just wake up one morning and rant about a magician in the clouds and expect your listeners to run around looking for evidence to disprove your shit. Its left for you to PROVE IT, if you can't, then the dust bin is where your deluded claims belong.[/quote]Hello, wake up and smell the coffee. 1. I made no claims to being an expert in logic. 2. Enough evidence as to the existence of God has been presented elsewhere as you no doubt are aware of. Atheists reject out of hand any evidence that cannot be pigeon-holed into their naturalistic and deterministic worldview. 3. I only seek to demonstrate that atheists make a categorical statement that requires positive proof but which they are either unwilling or incapable of proving. 4. if atheists would start from a position of honesty, then they would concede that by definition, proof of the existence or non-existence of god cannot be deduced from the tools at their disposal. At best they can only be agnostics. But it is obvious that my arguments are too difficult you "atheists" to follow. BTW, you are not an atheist by a rational explication of phenomena at your disposal, but became one due to your rejection of the hypocrisy you see in religion. Also you are yet to give a satisfactory answer to my statement. "If I choose not to answer your phone calls, does it prove my non-existence?" |
Kay 17:You are being disingenuous; peddling half-truths and seeming to imply that the bible makes all of the above claims. You show an ignorance of history and literary devices and ancient languages. A point by point rebuttal follows. 1. There is no where in the bible where it is stated that the earth is flat. In fact it is implied to be a sphere: See Isa 40:22 It is He who sits above the circle of the earth, And its inhabitants are like grasshoppers, Who stretches out the heavens like a curtain, And spreads them out like a tent to dwell in. The flat earth theory was a product of the belief of medieval men championed by the catholic church. 2. The belief that the sun revolves round the earth was based upon Ancient Greek astronomy specifically the Ptolemiac model devised in Alexandria circa AD 140. His challenge was to explain the complex motions of the planets, including the fact that they sometimes appear to move westward or backward in their orbits. In order to explain the observation, he assumed that each planet revolved in a small orbit called an epicycle. The center of the epicycle then revolved about the Earth on a much larger circle. In plain English; he devised a geometric model which sought to explain the movements of the heavenly bodies as seen from earth based on the assumption that they revolved around the earth. 3. The bible does make the claim that the universe was created in 7 days. 4. Anthropological and archaeological evidence proves the occurrence of a global flood. 5. The Tower of Babel. Gen 11:4 -And they said, "Come, let us build ourselves a city, and a tower whose top is in the heavens; let us make a name for ourselves, lest we be scattered abroad over the face of the whole earth." The Hebrew word "Shamayim" may be variously translated "Sky", "Air" as well "Heavens" referring to Space beyond the visible sky. So you see that verse does not in any way mean that they intended to build a tower that reached into orbit. The bible verse does not mean what you try to imply it means. 6. You said "you christians" thus implying that your major grouse is with the God of the Christians, but an atheist if he will be logical and consistent to his creed cannot simply point at the "contradictions" of the bible as proof for the non-existence of God. At best he can only try to prove the non-existence of Yahweh. To prove the non-existence of god, you need to prove the non-existence of all gods by providing positive, empirical and logical proof of the non-existence of all gods. You have a hypothesis. According to the scientific method, provide evidence for your hypothesis not reasons where your opponent's hypothesis is flawed. 7. BTW, in statistical theory (which underpins much of the empirical method) you seek to prove the null hypothesis not disprove the alternative hypothesis. You atheists are stating the null hypothesis without any proof. Over to you. |
@9jaganja I thought you were an atheist. But you make it clear to me that you believe in the existence of god but whether your apprehension of god is the correct one remains a topic for another discussion. However some points, you said: Atheism is not the belief that their is no God. I think they gave that word a wrong definition. Atheism is actually a conclusion of choosing not to think God is an all powerful and all good god. It has many premises to arrive at such conclusion but you will choose to define atheism by folks with weaker arguments here but those arguments still put your suppose to be strong argument on fire. Atheism is not a belief that there is no God? I'm sorry I don't think any atheists here will agree with you. Please consult any dictionary. Here is what encarta dictionary says a·the·ism [áythee ìzzəm] noun unbelief in God or deities: disbelief in the existence of God or deities Microsoft® Encarta® 2009. © 1993-2008 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved. |
Kay 17:So sorry if you are in over your head and cannot follow the thread of my argument. Let me break it down for you in words of one syllable so you can understand. 1. There are limits to what we can know because the tools for observing the physical universe are in themselves limited being dependent on the physical laws of the universe. 2. We cannot be certain that we can directly observe phenomena that lies outside the limits of our means of observing the universe 3. By definition, the nature of God is such that He cannot be directly observed since he is transcendent. 4. Proof of the existence of God can only be provided by other means hence my illustration using Dark Matter. 5. Ergo, if you will be honest, you will realize that you cannot prove or disprove the existence of God using the means at your disposal. You are not a rational atheist, just someone who is angry with God. Which is why you can only provide emotional arguments of the type: "Your beliefs about God are not consistent, therefore He cannot exist." |
Kay 17:I asked you to be coherent but your reply is as muddled as ever. You provide no positive or logical proof for your thesis. Are you saying there cannot be ever the possibility of God existing outside your knowledge? You are omniscient! Your grasp of logic leaves one flabbergasted. You said "As long as its a belief, its a characteristic you share with pagans and muslims. they are simply[b] imaginations[/b] which just come out of your head." I believe that if I jump off the top of the empire state building, I will plummet down to the ground. Is gravity simply an imagination of one's mind? So you are saying if I believe a fact, it becomes an imagination. That there are a multiplicity of religions does not logically negate the existence of God. After all, you "atheists" are always quick to claim that religions are man-made constructs. God is not a man-made construct. Provide empiric, logical and coherent proof of his non-existence. No more emotional arguments or pointing out what are the beliefs of those who say He exists. |
Ever since I was little (and till today) she keeps feeding me this mumbo jumbo about how God abi na jesus revealed to her the afternoon i was born, I'll be a great servant of God and other shit like that. . .several times I told her it was the anti-pain morphine that caused the hallucinations. To her it will be a fulfilment of the that divine vision. Perhaps that's why Tudor is an atheist. |
Where was God During the Rwandan Genocide? The short answer: He was present. The long answer The question is obviously a straw man set up by atheists to knock down with their arguments. But wait what arguments? The reason atheists ask this sort of questions is because they reason along these lines: 1. God is good and all-powerful. 2. Tragic things happen. 3. A good and all-powerful God will not permit tragic things to happen. 4. Therefore since tragic things occur God cannot exist. An examination of this line of reasoning reveals their flawed logic. The correct conclusion from this line of reasoning would be God is either not good or all-powerful since tragic things occur. The atheists on this forum proceed from an a priori hypothesis of God's non-existence but fail to put up any coherent or logical reason for their belief. All they do is point out that God failed to prevent this or that tragedy as proof of their thesis. In doing this, they betray a flawed logic. Just as I posited earlier; "If I choose not to answer your phone call, does it prove my non-existence?" The atheists on this forum cannot refute that simple statement without tying themselves up in contradictory knots. For example consider 9jaganja's response: "That is a far fetched analogy you can't use such analogy to explain god's existence. Nature of God is suppose to be different from the nature of humans. I can say maybe you are dead or in jail, that's why you refused to answer my call. That analogy is flawed" He says the nature of God is suppose (sic) to be different from the nature of humans thereby conceding the point with Christians have always made that God is of a different nature from humans; "God is a Spirit." Is it not a contradiction for 9jaganja to tell me about the nature of a being who he claims is non-existent. He then goes on to prove my point that my non-existence cannot be proven if I refuse to answer his phone calls: "I can say maybe you are dead or in jail" For me to be dead implies I must have existed, I must exist to be in jail. Tudor tries to side-step the question by asking: "Does that in anyway prove your existence too?" But the point is that a non response does not in any way prove my non-existence. Nobody has claimed that non-response is proof of existence. Most of the atheists on this forum are not as rational as they would have us believe, otherwise they would provide positive evidence of their thesis that God does not exist. A fundamental dictum of the scientific method which atheists claim to utilize in arriving at their worldview is "that absence of evidence does not constitute evidence of absence." Yet not one atheist on this forum has addressed the point I raised earlier: "An atheist, to be consistently assured that his belief is accurate, must also claim to be omniscient, for there always exists the possibility of the existence of God outside his knowledge." Only Tudor tries to address this point by taking refuge in sarcasm; "The same way we have to be omniscient to rule out the possibility of floating testicles two galaxies away right?" The logical answer to which is yes. How do you know there aren't two testicles floating two galaxies away if you are not there. The atheists on this forum are intellectually dishonest as not one of them has satisfactorily addressed the possibility of the existence of God outside their knowledge. Dark Matter Since none of the atheists can address this point, I will proceed to do so for them. What can we know? And what are the limits of what we know? The atheist exclaims that since he can not see, hear, smell or touch God, he cannot exist. But we know that assertion is fundamentally flawed. The atheist cannot see into the infra-red or ultra-violet; does it therefore mean that what is not perceived by the visible light spectrum does not exist? Of course the atheist will be quick to say there are instruments for measuring infra-red and ultraviolet light. Good, but no matter how sophisticated these instruments are, they depend on the inherent properties of light and are circumscribed. Modern astronomy indicates the existence of Dark Matter which does not give off or reflect detectable electromagnetic radiation. Dark matter is practically invisible, but its existence has been determined detecting its gravitational interaction with matter that does give off detectable electromagnetic radiation. Thus we see a tangible demonstration of the limits of direct observation. By its nature the existence of Dark Matter must of necessity be inferred by its effects on that which can be directly observed. I am not here saying that the existence of Dark Matter implies or is proof of the existence of God (as no doubt some atheists here will be quick to allege) but rather as an example that some objects by their nature cannot be perceived by the empiric method. In other to be able to make a positive, categorical statement such as "There is no God", the atheist must assure us that he has investigated every possibility. But we know that that is not possible, given the limits of what we can know. We simply do not have the equipment. Moreover, the atheist's assertion is based on an assumption that the nature of what he seeks to disprove is as rooted in the natural world as we. But how can he be certain of that. A honest and rational atheist will very soon relinquish his atheism and become an agnostic, for we can neither prove nor disprove the existence of God using the means at our disposal. |
Kay 17:Be coherent. Present your response to this: "An atheist, to be consistently assured that his belief is accurate, must also claim to be omniscient, for there always exists the possibility of the existence of God outside his knowledge" I await your response. |
alright, i admit i'm not omniscient, i rely on reason,
A creature placed within a box cannot determine what exists outside of the box.