Godx: He was not even the best England player on the pitch talkless of man of the match lol. Rico Lewis is 5 times more talented, experienced and better than this Maino.
Android17: 16 goals and 13 assists does not justify being placed over Ronaldinho and Etoo the latter who scored more than Messi in less games.
It was Pep who knew that Messi could score and assist a lot more if used rightly. He built the team around him and made sure he got the ball at moments he could do the most damage and then Messi became a 50-goal a season player.
Foden has 28 G+A this season already. Same number as Jude Bellingham by the way but one of them has played as a striker for most of the season.
But Phil Foden played 42 games for his 28 G+A in a team that just won the trebble. You can’t compare that to what Messi did in 2008.
raumdeuter: 12months later Messi was dropping almost 60 G +A
Messi and Foden no get the same talent nor ability. Actually no one in football for the past 20yrs have close to 60% of Messi
I don’t know what Android is trying to prove.
Messi under a finished Rijkaard had those numbers. And his talent was there to see. Foden doesn’t score goals by himself or create chances consistently for others around him. He pales in comparison but you want a national team to be built around him.
Android17: Messi did not show any consistency when Pep had announced that the team will be built around him.
Zidane has never been consistent in his life.
A manager just has to believe in a player and deploy how to maximize him by signing players that complement him and using the formation that helps said player express himself.
Zlatan vs Pep issue comes to mind here.
Pep took over Barca in 2008. Messi was part of the team that won the UCL in 2006. Go figure. Pep never coached a younger Messi.
Apart from that, not all teams are built around one particular player.
Android17: If you are referring to me I said Rooney isn't and has never been a FAR FAR superior talent to Foden. I have always put them on equal footing. Nobody will ignore KDB or Haaland to build around Rooney based on a seriatim.
No manager that wins as much as Pep will do that. SAF built around CR7 vs Rooney. Even though Rooney showed more promise at a younger age. A wise manager builds around who can more than likely guarantee winning. Benzema vs CR7 etc.
What did Dortmund win with Haaland out and the team built around Jude? Not directed at you. I'm just laughing for future sake.
A wise manager builds around consistent, top performers. SAF didn’t build around CR7 when he was inconsistent. Pep never did the same for a younger Messi. It was when those guys started showing promise on a consistent basis that their managers decided to build around them.
Android17: You know Foden had an appendix issue last season?
He did? I didn’t know that. But clearly, it didn’t stop him from playing 32 league games. Martial never had appendicitis but he missed even more games.
What a load of bollocks. The guy comes across as too eager. Almost everybody is special at 4 years FGS. It’s all part of the newfound senseless hype for Kobbie.
Unnecessary and overboard. It’s too much in my opinion. The dude hasn’t even settled at club level yet.
afrodoc2: 4) Some of them are just overhyped and not as good as advertised. The English Press is senseless in the way they raise players up to be gods and demigods, and pile ridiculous amount of pressure on them. I just watched them interview the man who coached Mainoo as a 4yr old.
Yes. But Amass is at least a year away from being a proper regular starter in the first team. Guy is still young but he's got so much talent and potential. He's one of the best players in the U18s right now. Doesn't have bad games even if the whole team is playing badly.
Buying a new young LB might derail his route to the first team. We should be getting an experienced player in bis prime instead and not splurge on a young unproven LB.
The young lads (if we get the second one) can play second fiddle to the experienced guy and take over in one or two years.
mostob: Didier Deschamps on Arsenal's William Saliba: "He is having a good season, but he also does things that I don't like so much. For France, he has limited game time, but when he plays, that hasn't necessarily gone well."
Jodera: The kind of striker Kane is, I doubt Foden will even shine in that left wing for England. Yeah Rashford hasn't had a great season but I'll prefer Gordons to Foden there. Let Foden just drag it out with Bellingham. This one no be Man city were he'll be playing wing with structural play
LooL.
Foden couldn’t dislodge Riyad Mahrez, Rahim Sterling and even Bernardo Silva who isn’t a proper winger. He just looks lost in that English squad.
I’m waiting to see what Southgate will cook up this summer tho.
afrodoc2: Nobody is doubting his talent. The debate is about his best position for the team. They are all developing and getting better, but the skillset is the skillset. He is a CAM not a LW. He is even a worse LW than he is a RW. Anthony Gordon, Grealish, Rashford will be a more effective weapon as LW for England than Foden. Kane likes to drop in and link up play and he is not quick, so the wingers have to be pacy.
It’s difficult, right?
Best to leave him on the bench. Maybe a midfield of Foden, Jude and Rice would work.
But all these structures depend on Southgate and his merry band of robbers.
afrodoc2: He played it in the last world cup and struggled. Foden has to play 10 with Bellingham at 8 OR play 10 with Bellingham on the bench OR be on the bench himself. Playing him on the wing shortchanges him and shortchanges the team that needs pace up front.
Foden has improved immensely over the last couple of years. He’s not the finished product yet, but he seems to be on the right path.