N5, N10, N20 are fast going into extinction if at all they are not already phased out. For N50 I see it every once in a while but definitely it is way more scare now than a year ago. Meaning that it’s already approaching extinction too.
Chucks13: I will still says it only a complete mad man like idiagbon( his blessed memery) can rule Nigeria and everybody will sit up or run to exile because no matter how you try to fix this country some demons won't let it work.
Only a iron fist tactics can stop the mess in NNPC whatever because there are 5 or 7 cabals who have be existing since IBB era till date who has vowed to make sure it s either them as per NNPC or nothing, surprisingly two among these demons are among those who want to rule Nigeria by all means and these two demons were among the top arrow-heads that betrayed Gej and joined others to kicked him out.
Seriously first thing iss to dismantle those Petrol Marketers(These two demons also in that group) but coming out to pretend to Nigerians they are saints and kept attacking Tinubu to hide their secret wicked deeds and those confused gullible ones out there supporting them and hailing them not known these 2 demons are one of the real enemy of this country.
And for those "lack of independent reasoning capacity Emergency Nigeria Citizen" quote me and say whatever sorry I don't care.
You mention decisiveness in Nigeria’s leadership to address these recurring issues but the only thing you missed out is who is responsible to carry out the work. Or is it Chuks13 that will address the cabals? The buck stops at someone’s table and if that person is unwilling or incapable to address the malaise, does he deserve to be in office?
maasoap: It is not your or my job to identify poor and vulnerable people but you must know that there would be a way to do that. That is the job of the local government employees, they were in charge. And how do you identify poor and vulnerable than to send people to go to their midst (CDAs)? I'm not defending Tinubu or Buhari or APC but my point is that don't rubbish what you don't understand based on the kind of mindset you already have towards the system.
If we should ignore the shortcomings of the register for the poor and vulnerable, the least we expect the government to do is to distribute the judiciously and diligently to the 15m but guess what? Only 5.6m (37% of 15m) was used for this purpose. The rest was used for other purposes which you can tell us since you know better. Mind you, the figure will be much less than 37% if we calculate in real terms.
In other words, they collected loan to make direct transfer of three tranches of N75,000 to 15m very poor. At the end of the day, the people that received at least one N75,000 payment was not up to 40% meaning that if you calculate the families that got all three transfers, maybe you’d be looking at a far less percentage.
Why do we Nigerians have to make excuses for this kind of evil?
nairalanda1: Poverty cannot be conquered on an economy based on oil.
Simple
No economy only has one source of revenue - it’s always a mix of different things including ours. Whether you are borrowing, receiving tax, getting oil money, etc. If there is no real effort in closing the leakages, forget about conquering poverty.
Before you blame the artisans for not contributing to the tax revenues of government, ask yourself:
1. Do they get billed on a daily basis? Yes. 2. Where does all that money go to? You know the answer. (This is a multi-billion naira industry mind you) 3. Does government have what it takes to channel those funds to productive fiscal use? Of course 4. Why won’t they do it? Maybe you know the answer
Therefore any attempt to place to responsibility of dwindling revenues on the informal sector has no other name than gaslighting. Before you ask to milk the people more, you must tell the officials to make the best of what is on ground. If you do a one-liner on government’s failure in channeling funds in the informal sector but you emphasize the idea that artisans must pay more, you are gaslighting them.
nairalanda1: Don't bother me. We are poor. Let the borrowing continue. If I complain, people llike you will tell me to keep quiet that tinubu is doing a good job...so borrow borrow.
What is wrong with wanting your country to become a developed nation? You people seem to think it is wrong.
We all want the country to be better for ourselves and our children but we cannot sidestep the major cankerworm and expect that that will happen no matter the lofty ideas being touted.
nairalanda1: Okay. We are poor. Let the borrowing continue.
Don't complain
Me I complain . And I wish government sometimes took the right decisions
Your decision is to support tinubu borrowing then comrade. I don't
Even the borrowing will not amount to anything if the fundamental issue is not addressed. And by the way borrowing is not actually bad.
Saying that the reason why government is underperforming is because it doesn’t tax the people enough is gaslighting. As things stand artisans get levied in various ways but the monies end up in pockets of private individuals that have solid backing from their political godfathers.
Should the solution be to tax them more? Should they be blamed for government’s inability channel these funds which sum up to billions of naira monthly appropriately? What exactly would you have them do?
It’s called gaslighting! You guys are gaslighting Nigerians for a role that government is supposed to do but is clearly unwilling to do.
Even the guys that do POS cash business on the roadsides are levied daily in a ridiculous manner. These monies end up in private pockets of “larger than life” boys of the political big-wigs.
So I am wondering if players in the informal sector are supposed to help the government set up a system of effectively collecting and deploying these levies for state use?
Some people want to bury their head in the sand and claim that government is borrowing and in need because Nigerians don’t pay taxes when the tout industry that operates daily in broad day light is a multi-billion dollar one.
How do you even know that you don’t have enough when the so-called little is being embezzled unrestrained?
It is even better than 2016 when PwC stated that the value was 16%.
World bank was even more optimistic in 2019, they stated that the value was 30%
I have known about how bad it is since that 2019. It is very bad . Most of us are in the informal sector, so we don't pay income tax.
Apologies if I missed that significant detail but point me to where it says “income tax” rather than “tax.” The reality of Nigerians is that they are taxed in sone form or the other. These are monies they have to do away with which would have made them have more disposable income otherwise.
Is it the fault of Nigerians that most of them do not belong to the formal sector? Is it the fault of Nigerians that the government is unable to effective deploy a tax regime that will effectively receive taxes and use same for provision of social amenities properly?
Is it the fault of informal players that they get taxed all manner of frivolous levies by hoodlums and touts loyal to government officials? Don’t the government officials know that the tout industry is a billion naira one? Can’t they deploy the system in such a way that the money doesn’t end up in private pockets of government loyalists that collect millions everyday and patronize call girls daily but it is deployed in an organized manner to meet social demands?
It is wrong to assert that only 19% of Nigerians pay tax as suggested in the write up just like it’s wrong to imply that only income tax is relevant in the tax discourse.
nairalanda1: Can a country work when less than 20% of the people pay taxes?
Answer that, and we can talk.
Oga PDP man wey wan call me agbado, because I dey laugh at am!
I can't lie to you.
You have accepted his words as absolute fact that only 19% of Nigerians pay tax. What’s his proof of that though? It is incumbent on whoever that makes a claim to also prove.
Furthermore, if only 20% of people in a country pay tax, what is being done to ensure that this gets to the required percentage? Why is he telling us all this story if he lacks power to rectify it? If there is any merit in what he is saying, he is inducting himself because it means that the tax collection process is porous. If tax collection in the west was similarly porous, many people wouldn’t pay tax. People pay tax there because they know they are in trouble if they don’t.
Now Obi is doing the same thing as opposition. If he won the Presidency and changed mouth, we will remind him of what he said before he got there.
His party knew that what PDP was doing was on the right path but for politics, they were ready to go against the government because it would have affected their chances of winning an election
Now to answer your question directly. Nigeria has refineries but it refused to use them and they keep doing TAM, all the Ministers of Petroleum under Buhari promised to get the refinery working, they gave us different dates, it never worked. Ibe Kachikwu first promised to resign if local refineries don't work
And then they kept promising when it was going to work. NNPC promised us that the local refineries will work before 2023 and then we discovered that Dangote, a private company will be rescuing Nigeria. So Buhari made sure he commissioned it before he left because Dangote did not want a repeat of what happened under Yar DUA in 2007.
The government did not hold anyone responsible for its failure, no one was punished and corruption kept running. The state refineries aren't working.
Now let's go back to subsidy. Let's agree that Nigeria cannot meet its local demand due to corruption. Then the government granted some marketers license to import the product then it found out that these people were inflating prices, they were not importing what they said they would do, they cut corners and some of the importers are just on the list to collect government money, what do you do as a government? Say we will close this program because we cannot punish those who are taking advantage of the system?
Sir, the government can tackle both if they want to. The corruption they allow makes it look like the problem is bigger than it is. Some analysts said Obi would not have the balls to deal with the cabal like Asiwaju has, please tell me, is he afraid to call their bluff? Are the refineries still working? Is he scared of them? Isn't he the same person who can remove a democratically elected governor but all of a sudden, will be scared of a so called cabal? They should tell that to the marines. Government is complicit in the issue. People can now see that subsidy itself was not entirely bad because it was a social contract. What was wrong was to cancel subsidy without appropriate replacement. We don't have local refineries producing and we still prefer to import. The corruption showed its hand when Dangote started refining. We didn't punish those who take our oil outside Nigeria to sell, we didn't punish those selling our unrefined crude and security personnel that could be complicit, it's ordinary Nigerians we said must be punished for the sin of a few. Nigeria we hail thee.
ubimagos: Same people that said the refinery is not working will be the first to blame the management of refinery!
I don’t think you will gone many people blame the new management per se. What people are saying is that you cannot successfully run a country on lies and propaganda. This is two years and counting and all we have is lies the Warri and PH refineries are working.
When Sahara reporters debunked their claim and people that have refused to be sold lies asked critical questions, they said it’s all political hate. I hope we can see the people that really hate this country.
How do you love a country when the people have the tools to change the country are only interested in telling lies and you are a willing window to perpetuating those lies?
MrIcredible: If you knew anything about good governance, you won't be here castigating any political party. Also, the past is very important. It's many of the past actions that puts us in the present situation. Mind you, I'm not in support of this current government.
Read my post very well. I have not said the past isn’t important. I am saying that current governments are employed to clean the mess of previous admins. They campaigned, lobbied, cajoled and many times even killed and maimed to get the opportunity. Hold them responsible today. Simple!
aylipple: Not everything has to be viewed from a political or tribal prism, Chief.
I was wrong to have attributed the development to a slow business day or time without addressing the issue of the empty shelves.
I later read another submission on this thread that gave me another perspective to why this may be the case among other factors and I did say so here 👇
Point is, we may agree to disagree without attaching our cause of disagreement or agreement to tribal or political reasons.
This is not just a a ShopRite thing. If we judge dispassionately, general standard of living now is a far cry from the years past. And I think you may not agree because of your obvious political affiliation which is evident in the post I replied to. And so my point is clear that we should judge things objectively. I’m happy you reiterated that advice in your last post. The only thing I want you to do is abide by it.
MrIcredible: You people need to stop all these OP0NU mentality. The problem of this country is not about any political party. There's absolutely no difference between APC, PDP, labour etc. It's the same people going back and forth in those different names. The same thing Maina, Dezani etc did under Jonathan is what Emefiele did under Buhari... Our problem is bad people which is the product of bad leaders that we have.
If you are making excuses and defenses for this present administration (I’m not saying you are doing that, I said “if”) then you are one of the people working against the good of the nation. There are many people on this forum that are defending bad governance for various reasons like tribalism, religious and political affiliation, stipends they get, etc.
Jonathan is past tense. The reason why he is not at the helm now is because Nigerians deemed him unworthy to continue. There is someone on that seat now. We need to judge him objectively and dispassionately - for the future of the country.
The political class are uniting more than ever before because there is more money to share and the man on ground is not shy of spending whenever he needs to. But the people whose livelihood are being taken away are fighting for these men instead of fighting for themeslves.
aylipple: Foot falls at shopping malls in some parts of the country are now being used as a benchmark to measure the success or otherwise of the Tinubu admin. While those who use this indices to measure the admin may not be entirely wrong, it’s also not an accurate reflection of the economic situation in the country; before my position is mistaken as denying the existence of economic hardship realities across the country, what I’m saying is there are other ways to measure than using foot fall in malls For instance, the video could’ve been made on a slow business day or time also, the fact remains that if any such business owners in the mall aren’t making sales in volumes that cover their running costs and then some little profit, they would’ve closed shop without delay to cut further incurring losses. Finally, they try to paint the economy as very terrible & unfavorable to businesses yet, their hero who came 3rd in the last presidential elections, has rebuilt his mall (Next Cash & Carry) that was burnt down in a fire accident some few years back; he will restock the business, employ new hands, etc knowing how business owners operate and project, if the economy isn’t viable and doesn’t support businesses to grow and make profit, would he have bothered to reinvest tens of billions to rebuilding? Who rebuilds in a dying or stiffling economy?
You said the video could have been taken on a slow business day? I think you are wrong. The shelves are practically empty. This was not the case in this and many other ShopRite stores nationwide some years back. Tribalism and political affiliation need not cloud our judgement about what is very obvious before our eyes.
It’s impossible to produce a good society with mostly good people when the system of justice, recompense, law and order as guided by the leadership, is faulty.
nedekid: Oga it is possible, the medical center will be an MD customer, ie those that have private transformers, we struggle with average monthly bills of 5m for a small boutique hotel and an event center. Note that it is not daily you have events in which you turn on ACs. The hotel closeby I hear average 20m, the Chinese making nylon next door have bills of averagely 30m. All this is aside diesel cost which is the real killer. Infact most business these days see diesel as the major expense. Most cannot afford to restart production process when nepa takes light and bring it at will so they just keep the gen running. Now if the federal medical center is a big place such as Lasuth, or LUTH, I assume they will have heavy equipments such as CT scanners, MRI and other power hungry equipments you cannot just shut down, they are not like computers or TV you off and on, it takes a long process. Based on that assuming they run a 1000kva generator which ast 80% load consumes eg 180 liters of diesel per hour for 15 hours daily ie 2700 liters per day or 81k liters monthly. Yes corruption as you rightly said will be there. I give you an example, few days ago we bought 500 liters, the next day by 5am estate security stopped a vehicle leaving with 7 kegs of diesel, last last it was traced to my premises. By 5am my security man had drained 220 liters into 7 kegs and a buyer came that early morning with a vehicle to carry, paying him 24k per keg. And this has gone on for a long time, luckily we caught them.
Just imagine somebody who has never managed a hospital before (even in his dream) claiming that the MD is lying. All to defend an inept government. It is shameful.
Anyone that is expecting a people to be properly behaved when the system that should regulate good and bad behavior in the society punishes the good person and rewards the criminal - that person must be a 🤡 🤡 🤡
When the head of a system is faulty, the body follows accordingly most definitely but if the body is faulty while the head is good, in no time there will be a transformation of the body. In case you are in doubt, the head is not the skull but the brain (the co-ordinator of the body system).
“ If the President is sinking N10b into solar in lamentation of the high cost of electricity in the Villa; the Deputy Governor of Lagos State wringing his hands on the millions he pays on electricity tariff monthly while many agencies of government are crying out, are they thinking of how the worker or the average citizen is going through under such high tariff? At least that should tell government what it has subjected us to.”
APCNig: We have the highest number of children aming black nations, our children’s population is more than the total population of several nations combined. So it is not expected that we have more poor children than others. If those that announced this have any sense at all, then they will talk about the percentage against other percentages.
However m, those that brought Nigeria to this bad state will all die miserably
Even if you are unable to read the entire post, just read the headline alone first.
Whatever dressing you decide to adopt is up to you really but if your house-help wears the exact thing in front of your spouse, will you approve of that particular clothing?
If yes, then maybe it’s decent If No, maybe it is not.
casualobserver: You are like Obi, you like writing epistle about the problems but no solution. I don’t need to be told over and over the problems, we all know! I have told you the road to good governor and that it is in the hands of the citizens. You refuse to accept and are waiting for a messiah to save you.
How can a messiah emerge when you collect rice and money when elections come? Do you not stop to engage your brains that someone who is willing to give rice 5k for votes is not going to work for me when he gets into office? Did they force you to collect rice? Again I ask you, are APC, PDP or LP the only parties in town? Why do you always vote for them? In 2023 I voted for Tinubu and I own it but in 2015 the choice was Buhari or GEJ, I voted for KOWA party. In 2019 the choice was Buhari or Atiku, I knew both would be a disaster so I voted for someone else even though I knew he wouldn’t win because I felt even if he doesn’t win he will be encouraged!
Nobody forced you to vote for the candidates of APC, PDP or LP all of whom are different grades of crooks.
Take responsibility for your own errors as a citizen. If you voted I am sure you voted for APC, PDP or LP so really you have no right to pontificate. You got what you voted for!!
Why did they collect rice? The foundation of it like you noted is still leadership democratizing corruption in the past and current leadership taking it to higher levels. In such a community how would you expect that people will not collect rice. That’s the problem but what is the solution? Is it to continue to support people who are perpetuating this system? No but you think it is. By the way I’ve never collected 5k or rice or anything. There are many people like me too but how has it changed the narrative when your current messiahs would rather die there? Where did you see it written that KOWA party is the solution. Stop sup printing corruption by legitimizing it. At least play your part.
casualobserver: Oga stop wasting my time. Go and find your good leaders. It me I know so long as citizens think like you we are going nowhere. You want a great country but you don’t want to play your part. You are waiting for a messiah to save you.
New flash! Nobody is coming to save you! You have to prove to the quiet good people you are worth saving or else they won’t enter the ring! They are not there to steal so why should they enter the ring when you the citizens continue to behave like entitled clowns?
In our long or not-so-long conversation I’ve never said that I’m unwilling to play my part. I’m saying that there is no way 200m individuals can just change their orientation without a co-ordinated approach. Even if the 200m are all blood siblings, it’s not possible. This is not Cartoon Network. Why do you imagine that a system will be orderly when the keepers of the order are disorderly? It will never work.
I am saying that even if some play their part, if the system is rigged against them, they may not get the reward for their good deeds. The guys doing the bad things will get the rewards. Is that what you want?
Haven’t you seen in civil service, a diligent lady who is climbing the ranks like a snail but the lady servicing oga is getting promoted. If the state doesn’t correct those anomalies, good deeds will be wasted and there won’t be the encouragement to continue to do good.
A lot depends on leadership no matter how you want to skip it. It’s the critical factor.
casualobserver: Tell them where I absolved them? As an educated man I expect you to be able to read and understand what you read. I said we have bad leaders so how have I absolved them? I have simply maintained that the reason why we have bad leaders is because good ones stay away. The reason good ones stay away is because the citizens.
KOWA party presented a good candidate did you vote for her? SDP presented a good candidate, did you vote for him? Are APC, PDP and LP the only parties in town?
Your position is wrong. Bad leaders don’t stay away because of the citizens. They don’t win because they hardly stand a chance due to nefarious acts by the powers that be (as you call them).
And sensible people don’t just vote because someone is said to be a good person. They try to see what you have done when given the opportunity at a lower level. The attitude of making sure a potential president has some level of trustworthiness having served at a lower level is not a bad thing. It’s just trying to be sure. If such a contender can’t garner plenty votes at that level, they can start from somewhere and grow.
casualobserver: This time I didn’t read your post beyond the 1st sentence because it seems you still want to absolve the citizens for the problems of the country.
Nigerias problems are the citizens, you don’t agree…no problem! No need for further engagement or both of us writing epistles back and forth.
The same way you are absolving the actual perpetrators. We already agree that since Babagida era there has been a drastic change in orientation of Nigerians. Nigerians of 1980s and the ones today aren’t the same. It’s tells you something - once the head is bad the body will follow suit.
You are wicked to expect good citizens when the leaders that administer law and order and justices are lawless and disorderly. The result would be lawlessness and the longer it persists the more it will eat into the society fabric.
But you prefer to support people who will kill to remain in power. Continue…..
casualobserver: It’s either you don’t live in Nigeria or you are living in denial!
If you want to fix Nigeria, fix the citizens. They are the ones with the power. I already gave you the example of ENDSARS…what happened? ENDSARS was simply a copycat movement (remmember black lives had just happened in America) just as the occupy movement was a copy to the occupy movement in North Africa. The same youth sold each other out and then collapsed into a movement led by a man who not only is part of the same system but ironically was the one who more or less created SARS! You can’t make this stuff up!
Fix your citizens and you will have a good country. Keep blaming leaders or waiting for a leader to emerge and things will only get worse!
1. Fix the citizens you say? Fix 200 million people with different social status, financial status, education, exposure, culture, life aspiration, religious persuasion, belief system, etc. Who is unrealistic here? If there was no need for leaders why not we advocate for scrapping of political positions, will that work too? In any system once the head is bad the body will follow but if the body is bad and you correct the head, soon enough the body aligns.
2. They tried to hijack ENDSARS unsuccessfully ti they brought the military to start shooting at wave-carrying peaceful protesters. That was the genesis of the chaos. It was three years later that they told us that they found 3000 dead bodies lying on the ground unaccounted for. ENDARS was another example of how hard it is to win against power grabbers and desperadoes. These guys have the money, power, police, security, judiciary, senate, etc in their pockets. The military first denied that they were not at the Lekki toll gate scene then when it was busted they said they fired n the air. When they were shown video evidences to the contrary they said they fired blank bullets. Again that was busted when live bullets were seen at the location. Yet there was zero accountability.
3. If you claim that the problem is the people and that people will not want an ideal leader if they had a choice, then tell the powers that be (as you call them) to play fair. It’s only then we can truly know that the people were given the opportunity but they didn’t want ideal leadership or how else can you determine that they wouldn’t want ideal leadership when the power brokers don’t even give them the opportunity to have their say?