Naptu2's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Naptu2's Profile › Naptu2's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 2314 2315 2316 2317 2318 2319 2320 2321 2322 (of 2585 pages)
My final post before I leave home. The thread title is "Dangote Is Nigeria's Biggest Problem He Has Bought Aso Rock" and I insist that the problem is not an individual, but our structures and attitudes. Will the problem go away if Dangote dies today? 25 years ago some people said that Abiola is our problem, where is Abiola today and has the problem been solved? Major Orkah staged his coup in 1990 and my neighbours came out to celebrate Babangida's exit. I asked them some questions - why are you celebrating? Do you know who the coup leaders are? Did they ask your permission before taking over? What if we replace "Maradona" with "Pele"? Some have called for a revolution, a call I support, but the question is, who will lead the revolution and what will be its outcome? Will it simply replace one set of dictators with another? The point is that our problems continue because we focus on individuals, rather than the systems that allow these individuals to emerge. Would Dangote have been able to donate $2 million to PDP if we had campaign finance laws and an independent Inec to enforce it? Would he have been able to dominate the cement market if there was a competitions commission? Saying that importation is the answer is simply diversionary. The same system that enabled him to dominate production will enable him to dominate imports (witness Umaru Dikko with respect to rice in the early 1980s). The solution is to have strong and transparent regulation and for Nigerians to ensure that government enforces those regulations. That's my take and nobody has been able to disprove it. |
Got to go now. It's been fun. |
Why impose restrictions? Why not allow the market/consumer decide between american and japanese cars? |
Basically, it's about protectionism. Protecting domestic industries via tariffs or restrictions. |
1981 Automobile VERhttp://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voluntary_export_restraints |
0lumide: No no no no... We are talking about price here. That consumers find one more fuel efficient is left to consumer's choice. We are talking about PRICING and price fixing which led to efficiency. Did American government tell American automakers to sell their cars for cheap or it's as a result of cost? If Americans weren't manufacturing efficiently, how come Toyota, Nissan etc all have their plants in US and Canada? naptu2, say what you know oo.. nuh dey wash to get points.Guy that's why I said you should read the article I posted. Japanese cars were outselling american cars by far. The american government (George HW Bush, etc) put pressure on the Japanese. In order to avoid a trade war, the Japanese agreed to voluntary restrictions (restricting the number of japanese cars that can be imported into the US). In order to get around this, Japanese car makers set up shop in the US (Lexus, Acura, etc) so that they can still make profit from the american market and avoid the restrictions. |
pazienza: From the above, i understand now that without an outright revolution by the deprived and have nots, there is no stopping of Dangote and his gang, cos they will always have our government on the pocket. Oh dear! naija problems are complex.Now you are beginning to understand what I've been saying. |
Ishilove: Ignore himGood morning ![]() Don't worry, I know how it is. I was once 25. |
0lumide: LMAO!!!! NAPTU2 u don goof ooo. AMERICAN AUTO INDUSTRY IS WHAT YOU JUST CALLED OUT LIKE THAT? LMAO!!Fuel efficiency? Cost of running the cars? (Note: I'm not just talking about the recent bail out. Go and research into what George Bush snr did to Japan in the early 1990s and read the article I earlier posted about the voluntary restrictions of 1981). |
pazienza: So,we have all been turned to slavesof dangote and co in our own country,what kind of rubbish is this? So dangote is the head of so called cabal holding this country down, he thrives on our sufferings,and our government are in bed with them. God punish devil. *apoplectic*That's why we need to push for the measures I advocated. This is what I've been saying from the beginning. I did a study of privatisation around 12 years ago and discovered that privatisation is not a problem. The problem is the way it is carried out. I believe that a democracy like ours needs strong and transparent regulatory agencies (Manny mentioned this earlier), two of those agencies are Competitions Commission and INEC. Dangote donated $2 million to PDP because there was no campaign finance laws to prevent that kind of thing from happening. He controls the market because there's no credible and transparent competitions commission to prevent that. And what I'm telling you is that it's not only Dangote, there are several people who do these things. |
pazienza: US government have a welfare package for the less privileged and her unemployed citizens, Nigeria has none. So don't even compare Nigeria with USDangote will simply collude with government and own the import licenses. |
biafranqueen: I never said he suddenly became wealthy I just said that he has bought Aso Rock which you agreed with your post! I am well aware that he is part of the elite!I wasn't referring to you. I'll go back and search for the person's post. |
I don't know if any of you ever watched the telecoms consumers parliament. It is the best example of a regulatory agency that I've seen. If you have any issue with a telco, you can write to NCC or simply attend a session of the parliament (which is broadcast live) and state your case against the telco. Officials from NCC, the major telcoms companies, etc are all there to respond to your complaints. Imagine a competitions commission with that level of transparency! |
0lumide: naptu2, nobody said we don't have a competition commission. We are saying Dangote and his likes bought them all!!!! And they look away when they are suppose to get to work and get mad at Dangote.Actually, we don't have a competitions commission. I'm happy I posted the article about Dangote's great grandfather. Go and read it. He had monopoly over groundnuts, kolanuts and other such commodities that ordinary people are good at selling (he established the first textile factory in Kano). All it takes for Dangote to monopolise the tomato or textile business I just one government regulation. |
The answer is to have an independent and transparent competitions commission (which will ensure that new players can enter the market), improve infrastructure (to improve efficiency), enact campaign finance laws (overseen and enforced by an independent inec) which will ensure that businessmen cannot buy politicians by funding their campaigns, etc. This is what I'm saying. If you focus solely on Dangote and cement, then the problem will continue (there were others before Dangote, there will be others after him, if my measures are not put in place). The US had similar problems in the late 1800s and early 1900s. They had what were called the "robber barons". People who created huge monopolies like Exxon, The Bell Corporation, etc. What did they do to combat it? They enacted the measures that I've outlined (competitions commissions broke up The Bell Corporation and other such entities). |
In fact, it's funny, if you think that importation is the answer, you'll suddenly discover that Dangote is the biggest importer of cement and that he is the only one with a license to import (Umaru Dikko and rice, Femi Otedola and diesel and even Dangote and cement importation). |
pazienza: The measures you are suggesting are not in place and not going to be in place any time soon. And stop talking like cement is the only goods we can produce, what we have with dangote currently is the masses suffering, while one man keep climbing the Forbes's list, that cannot continue. Let's import at cheaper prices, that way,the people suffer less, and we can improve other areas we have comparative advantage on,like agriculture, and use them to balance our export-import ratio.The measures are not in place. How do we put them in place? There's currently a tariff on imported cement, how do you remove the tariff? Isn't it by putting pressure on government? The same pressure you put on government to remove import tariffs is the same pressure you can put on government to create a competitions commission, to improve infrastructure, etc. Cement is not the only good we can produce. Haven't you heard what I've been saying? I said that the government is implementing the same policies in other sectors (see my articles about the automotive sector). You've mentioned agriculture (rice to be specific), didn't you see what someone posted? Dangote had a near monopoly on rice during the Abacha era. If you advocate that we depend on rice, you'll suddenly find out that Dangote is the biggest producer of rice! That's what I'm saying, it's not about cement, neither is it about Dangote, it is about putting in place measure that will ensure equity for everybody (competition commission, better infrastructure, campaign financing laws, etc). If you don't do this, you'll continue creating more people like Dangote (in 1966 it was Festus Okotie-Eboh and shoes, in the 1970s it was MKO Abiola and phones). |
pazienza: If we have no competitive advantage in Cement,then maybe we should stop producing it, we should focus more on things we have competitive advantage on, things like agriculture, for example, a bag of abakaliki rice is cheaper than the thailand equivalent, if the government grant those farmers more loans and credit facilities, they will be able to produce enough rice to feed the country ,at a cheaper price to the final consumer, so that in the end, we will have a win-win situation for the farmer,government and the people(consumers).You will never find a situation where a government will surrender critical sectors of its economy to importation. I've already given you an example of the US auto industry which has been supported by the US government (even given bail out funds) despite the fact that it is inefficient and there are better and cheaper Japanese alternatives. The complaint in Nigeria for decades has been the fact that we do not manufacture anything, but simply rely on extractive industries (mainly oil). Any sensible government will work towards improving efficiency and even exporting, which is what the government is doing. We cannot surrender ourselves to the unstable commodity market (we've seen the effect of that in the 1980s) which is why government must seek to diversify the economy and improve efficiency. Importation is not the answer. |
0lumide: What do we do manny? We can all be on nairaland and act like the el rufais and co.. becoming internet activists hoping the next generation will learn from data files left behind on some internet servers that may die anytime. Or we can all just troop out enmass and shut this nation down once and for all untill the government is transparent, open and sincere....What do you mean by "Nigerians like Naptu2". I posted those stories in response to someone who said that Dangote "suddenly" became wealthy and I posted them to show that his great grandfather and other relatives were already wealthy, is that true or false? Didn't he have family members that were already wealthy, who had access to government and who gave him loans? Please don't misrepresent my posts or put words in my mouth. |
0lumide: Nobody is saying we import everything, I'm saying we focus on what we have a competitive advantage in so we can export and import what we can't efficiently produce.Can you point out that thing that we have competitive advantage in? |
0lumide: Naptu2, my guy, let's be honest with our selves for once. Dangote's wealth is ill gotten.Can you point to anywhere that I said that Dangote did not seek favours from government? Can you point to anywhere that I said he is not corrupt? I actually stated that he did seek and get favours from government. I used the example of Festus Okotie-Eboh and american businessmen to buttress my point (please go back and read), but I stated that importation is not the solution. That will damage the economy. The solutions are the measures that I pointed out. That's where you came in a nd attacked me, but you've not disproved anything I said. |
0lumide: Naptu.. Do you understand economics? economy? and the social responsibility of the economy?What is the job of a competitions commission? |
[size=14pt]European Commissioner for Competition[/size] |
[size=14pt]United States v. Microsoft Corp.[/size]http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Corp. |
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) is an independent agency of the United States government, established in 1914 by the Federal Trade Commission Act. Its principal mission is the promotion of consumer protection and the elimination and prevention of anti-competitive business practices, such as coercive monopoly. The Federal Trade Commission Act was one of President Woodrow Wilson's major acts against trusts. Trusts and trust-busting were significant political concerns during the Progressive Era. Since its inception, the FTC has enforced the provisions of the Clayton Act, a key antitrust statute, as well as the provisions of the FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. § 41 et seq. Over time, the FTC has been delegated the enforcement of additional business regulation statutes and has promulgated a number of regulations (codified in Title 16 of the Code of Federal Regulations).http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Trade_Commission |
Examples of what I mean by competition commission. |
biafranqueen: you are absolutely right I heard the bread industry was destroyed at that time because flour was not allowed to be imported and great industries went bankrupt because inferior flour was used that would not allow the bread to rise. It destroyed empiresI remember that period very well. At that time you could buy any foreign good you wanted at very cheap prices. There mega stores like Kingsway, Leventis, UTC, Bhojsons, CFAO, etc that were stocked with the latest imported goods. The problem was that we stopped producing anything and depended solely on oil revenue and imported goods. Then the price of oil crashed in 1982 and we couldn't afford those imported goods anymore. Local industries were not strong enough to take the burden. The naira started falling and all hell was let lose. Then came military coup after military coup. The rest is history. |
biafranqueen: Nwanna LET US GET to work forcing them to do the right thing. How often do we hear about Nigerians coming together to make the government work for us. We have to start Political Action Groups. I am working on it now for Nnewi business owners every town needs to have a group and we have one state chapter. Stay tuned on Nairaland the website is comingThat's the kind of thing I like. May God bless your efforts. |
We've been through this in the past (the 1982 crisis). If you import everything you need, simply because you are not efficient at the moment, you'll get to a point where you have no money to pay for those imports (what do you produce to earn money to pay for those imports and how much does what you produce cost?) |
biafranqueen: great idea it amazes me that Ibeto never thought of this. I agree with you 100% we really have to pressure the next Governor to work on security, the sea/airport, and roads in that order. After that we will be unstopable. We can not wait we have to apply pressure as group, we can not sit back and wait for these thiefs to do the right thing.And that's precisely what I'm saying. If he is artificially inflating prices, then new producers can come into the market with lower prices. This will trigger a price war (just like in the telecoms sector) which will benefit consumers. |
manny4life: First off, when you own your own power plant, YOU SAVE MONEY. If you depended on public electricity, you have to pay more because the public utilities have to make their profits anyway. Whenever someone generate or build on their own, they save... At least, under the theory of marginal cost to produce. There are companies like mining companies here who produce their own, and large manufacturing companies generate theirs because it's cheaper anyway. Newer building they build now that spend a lot on solar power do so because in the long run, it's way cheaper than to depend on public electricity (this includes ALL associated costs).Public power companies are supplying more people, so they can charge less and still make a profit (that is, the scale of their operation). I agree with your second point (see my post above). |
And this is why I used the Glo example. If Dangote is artificially keeping prices high, then someone can come into the market, undercut him and build up market share. The solution is: To have a competitions commission to monitor and regulate against unfair practices (the commission should be independent and transparent) To have campaign finance laws that will limit the amount that individuals and corporations can donate to government. And to improve infrastructure so that companies can be more efficient. The answer does not lie in importation. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 2314 2315 2316 2317 2318 2319 2320 2321 2322 (of 2585 pages)

) who is also a Commission Vice-President.