Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP) and Centre for Journalism Innovation and Development have filed a lawsuit against President Muhammadu Buhari and Mr Lai Mohammed, Minister of Information and Culture, asking the court to “declare illegal the gag order stopping journalists and broadcast stations from reporting details of terrorist attacks and victims, as the order violates media freedom, and Nigerians’ freedom of expression and access to information.”
Joined in the suit as Defendant is the National Broadcasting Commission (NBC).
The suit followed the directive by the NBC asking journalists, television and radio stations in Nigeria to stop “glamourising and giving too many details on the nefarious activities of terrorists and kidnappers” during their daily newspaper reviews.
In the suit number FHC/ABJ/CS/725/2021 filed last Friday, SERAP and PTCIJ are seeking: “an order of perpetual injunction restraining the government of President Buhari, the NBC, and Mr Lai Muhammed or any other persons from imposing fines or other sanctions on broadcast stations for carrying out their constitutional duties of reporting details of terrorist attacks and victims during daily newspaper reviews.”
In the suit, SERAP and PTCIJ are seeking “an order to compel and direct the NBC and Mr Lai Muhammed to withdraw the directive asking journalists and broadcast stations to stop reporting details on terrorist attacks and victims, as the directive is unlawful and inconsistent with the Nigerian Constitution of 1999 [as amended], and the country’s international human rights obligations.”
SERAP and PTCIJ are also seeking “an order setting aside the directive on reporting of terrorist attacks and victims, for being inconsistent and incompatible with sections 22 and 39 of the Nigerian Constitution, Article 9 of the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights and Article 19 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.”
According to SERAP: “Unless the reliefs sought are urgently granted by this Honourable Court, the directive by the NBC and Mr Lai Muhammed would be used to impermissibly restrict Nigerians’ rights to freedom of expression, access to information, media freedom, and victims’ right to justice and effective remedies.”
SERAP and PTCIJ are arguing that “the failure by the government of President Buhari to direct the NBC to withdraw its directive on reporting of terrorist attacks and victims violates sections 5[a] and [b], 147 and 148 of the Nigerian Constitution, Code of Conduct for Public Officers [Fifth Schedule Part 1], and Oath of office [Seventh Schedule] of the Constitution.”
SERAP and PTCIJ are also seeking “a declaration that sections 5.4.1[f] and 5.4.3 of the National Broadcasting Code and their application to the daily review of newspaper headlines by broadcast stations are inconsistent with sections 22 and 39 of the Nigerian Constitution, Article 9 of the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights and Article 19 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.”
According to SERAP and PTCIJ: “The NBC directive fails to establish a direct and immediate connection between the reporting by broadcast stations and purported risks to national security and peace. The NBC is using ‘national security’ as a pretext to intimidate and harass journalists and broadcast stations, and to violate Nigerians’ rights to freedom of expression and access to information.”
SERAP and PTCIJ are also arguing that: “Factual reporting on the growing violence in some parts of Nigeria is a matter of public interest. National security considerations should be limited in application to situations in which the interest of the whole nation is at stake, which would thereby exclude restrictions in the sole interest of a government, regime, or power group.”
The suit filed on behalf of SERAP and PTCIJ by their lawyers Kolawole Oluwadare and Opeyemi Owolabi, read in part: “The NBC and Mr Lai Muhammed lack the power and authority to restrict the ability of journalists and broadcast stations to carry out their constitutional duties and to unlawfully impose penalty such as fines and other sanctions on any journalists and broadcast stations for reporting on details of terrorist attacks and victims in the country.”
“SERAP and PTCIJ together with several millions of Nigerians easily access information, news and form opinions on government policies through the daily newspaper reviews by journalists and broadcast stations in Nigeria.”
“While the NBC has the powers to make rules to enable it perform its statutory functions under section 2[1] [a] to [u] of NBC Act, such statutory powers ought to be exercised in line with the Nigerian Constitution, and the country’s international human rights obligations.”
“The pertinent questions that arise from the directive are: Who determines what would amount to ‘too many details’, ‘glamourising’, ‘divisive rhetoric’, and ‘security issues’ during the daily review of newspaper headlines? What constitutes ‘divisive materials’ during the daily review of newspaper headlines by journalists and broadcast stations?”
“In law, a regulation that is vague and loose in its scope cannot be used to take away constitutionally and internationally recognized human rights to freedom of expression, access to information, and media freedom.”
“The interference with the constitutional and legal duties of journalists and broadcast stations cannot be justified, as Nigerian authorities have failed to show that reporting of terrorist attacks and victims would impose a specific risk of harm to a legitimate State interest that outweighs the public’s interest in such information.”
“The Constitution is the grundnorm and the fundamental law of the land. All other legislations in this country take their hierarchy from the provisions of the Constitution. It is not a mere common legal document.”
“The Courts as the veritable agency for the protection and preservation of rule of law should ensure that persons and institutions operate within the defined ambit of constitutional and statutory limitations.”
“Where agencies of government are allowed to operate at large and at their whims and caprices in the guise of performing their statutory duties, the end result will be anarchy, licentiousness, authoritarianism and brigandage leading to the loss of the much cherished and constitutionally guaranteed freedom and liberty.”
No date has been fixed for the hearing of the application for interim injunction, and the substantive suit.
May God punish all the sponsors of herdsmen and Boko Haram and the politicians that brought them upon our nation to cause mayhem. May the people that support and sponsor them all die painfully, and may they suffer so much pains as long as they live on earth before dying in shame.
If you are not one of the people supporting the evil sponsors of these herdsmen, kindly say A BIG AMEN To these little prayers.
God pass dem. They will all end miserably in life.
********************* ****************** ******************** All sponsors and enabler of all the terrorist organizations in our darling country, from this evil Boko Boys, to bandits, Igbos terrorists organization, evil fulani herdsmen must all be fished out. They will all never know peace as long as it is sorrow, tears and blood they want flowing in our nation.....along with their evil supporters.
Especially all the terrorist organizations (Boko Haram and Igbos terrorist groups) killing our military personnel. Evil, sorrow, tears and blood shall be their end at the end of it all.
Peace shall reign in our nation. God bless Nigeria
A big amen to that! And may God punish of supporters of a terrorist government that shields terrorists like Pantami, Gumi and Miyetti allah! They their days be short and full of sorrow! Can i get an amen too?
We answered that before and we will answer that again. A big amen to that! All sponsors and enabler of all the terrorist organizations in our darling country, from this evil Boko Boys, to bandits, Igbos terrorists organization, evil fulani herdsmen must all be fished out. They will all never know peace as long as it is sorrow, tears and blood they want flowing in our nation.....along with their evil supporters.
Nigerians should not worry their minds. Those who are sheildin the terrorists would be consumed by the same group. Let the sane Nigerians secure themselves during this perilous times...
May God punish all the sponsors of herdsmen and Boko Haram and the politicians that brought them upon our nation to cause mayhem. May the people that support and sponsor them all die painfully, and may they suffer so much pains as long as they live on earth before dying in shame.
If you are not one of the people supporting the evil sponsors of these herdsmen, kindly say A BIG AMEN To these little prayers.
God pass dem. They will all end miserably in life.
********************* ****************** ******************** All sponsors and enabler of all the terrorist organizations in our darling country, from this evil Boko Boys, to bandits, Igbos terrorists organization, evil fulani herdsmen must all be fished out. They will all never know peace as long as it is sorrow, tears and blood they want flowing in our nation.....along with their evil supporters.
Especially all the terrorist organizations (Boko Haram and Igbos terrorist groups) killing our military personnel. Evil, sorrow, tears and blood shall be their end at the end of it all.
Peace shall reign in our nation. God bless Nigeria
We answered that before and we will answer that again. A big amen to that! All sponsors and enabler of all the terrorist organizations in our darling country, from this evil Boko Boys, to bandits, Igbos terrorists organization, evil fulani herdsmen must all be fished out. They will all never know peace as long as it is sorrow, tears and blood they want flowing in our nation.....along with their evil supporters.
So shall it be!!! No evil person will escape this calamity. Never!
That prayer will start on top of your Darling daddy in aso rock. Why do you support someone blindly? Are u been paid or what? I don't need your reply cos I know what exactly you will say. I have been seeing your comments for months and they are very inconsistent and blind towards a man who you said he is not corrupt but we have seen unprecedented level of corruption in his regime
I am not surprised. Cos even a kid with no proper training can hide behind keyboard to throw all manners of sentiments (tribal,religious,political) here
Ladies Your Boyfriend Already knows Who He will Marry, if u like be Wearing His Polo to The Market & be Asking “ Baby Are We Eating semo or rice tonight ?
May God punish all the sponsors of herdsmen and Boko Haram and the politicians that brought them upon our nation to cause mayhem. May the people that support and sponsor them all die painfully, and may they suffer so much pains as long as they live on earth before dying in shame.
If you are not one of the people supporting the evil sponsors of these herdsmen, kindly say A BIG AMEN To these little prayers.
God pass dem. They will all end miserably in life.
********************* ****************** ******************** All sponsors and enabler of all the terrorist organizations in our darling country, from this evil Boko Boys, to bandits, Igbos terrorists organization, evil fulani herdsmen must all be fished out. They will all never know peace as long as it is sorrow, tears and blood they want flowing in our nation.....along with their evil supporters.
Especially all the terrorist organizations (Boko Haram and Igbos terrorist groups) killing our military personnel. Evil, sorrow, tears and blood shall be their end at the end of it all.
Peace shall reign in our nation. God bless Nigeria
We answered that before and we will answer that again. A big amen to that! All sponsors and enabler of all the terrorist organizations in our darling country, from this evil Boko Boys, to bandits, Igbos terrorists organization, evil fulani herdsmen must all be fished out. They will all never know peace as long as it is sorrow, tears and blood they want flowing in our nation.....along with their evil supporters.
So shall it be!!! No evil person will escape this calamity. Never!
There is no need for all these prayers and suing from government, let's just divide and see how southern region will cleanse their lands and hang the heads of those northern terrorist in a stake.
May God punish all the sponsors of herdsmen and Boko Haram and the politicians that brought them upon our nation to cause mayhem. May the people that support and sponsor them all die painfully, and may they suffer so much pains as long as they live on earth before dying in shame.
If you are not one of the people supporting the evil sponsors of these herdsmen, kindly say A BIG AMEN To these little prayers.
God pass dem. They will all end miserably in life.
********************* ****************** ******************** All sponsors and enabler of all the terrorist organizations in our darling country, from this evil Boko Boys, to bandits, Igbos terrorists organization, evil fulani herdsmen must all be fished out. They will all never know peace as long as it is sorrow, tears and blood they want flowing in our nation.....along with their evil supporters.
Especially all the terrorist organizations (Boko Haram and Igbos terrorist groups) killing our military personnel. Evil, sorrow, tears and blood shall be their end at the end of it all.
Peace shall reign in our nation. God bless Nigeria
We answered that before and we will answer that again. A big amen to that! All sponsors and enabler of all the terrorist organizations in our darling country, from this evil Boko Boys, to bandits, Igbos terrorists organization, evil fulani herdsmen must all be fished out. They will all never know peace as long as it is sorrow, tears and blood they want flowing in our nation.....along with their evil supporters.
So shall it be!!! No evil person will escape this calamity. Never!
May God punish all the sponsors of herdsmen and Boko Haram and the politicians that brought them upon our nation to cause mayhem. May the people that support and sponsor them all die painfully, and may they suffer so much pains as long as they live on earth before dying in shame.
If you are not one of the people supporting the evil sponsors of these herdsmen, kindly say A BIG AMEN To these little prayers.
God pass dem. They will all end miserably in life.
********************* ****************** ******************** All sponsors and enabler of all the terrorist organizations in our darling country, from this evil Boko Boys, to bandits, Igbos terrorists organization, evil fulani herdsmen must all be fished out. They will all never know peace as long as it is sorrow, tears and blood they want flowing in our nation.....along with their evil supporters.
Especially all the terrorist organizations (Boko Haram and Igbos terrorist groups) killing our military personnel. Evil, sorrow, tears and blood shall be their end at the end of it all.
Peace shall reign in our nation. God bless Nigeria
We answered that before and we will answer that again. A big amen to that! All sponsors and enabler of all the terrorist organizations in our darling country, from this evil Boko Boys, to bandits, Igbos terrorists organization, evil fulani herdsmen must all be fished out. They will all never know peace as long as it is sorrow, tears and blood they want flowing in our nation.....along with their evil supporters.
So shall it be!!! No evil person will escape this calamity. Never!
Whether Bo-kohari and his demons like it or not righteousness will reign in Nigeria and the evil shall bow to the good and the wicked at the gate of the righteous. Halleluyah !
