Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / NewStats: 3,194,833 members, 7,956,153 topics. Date: Monday, 23 September 2024 at 05:50 AM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Islam for Muslims / Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? (7290 Views)
Hadith GPT: AI Tools Trained With 40,000 Hadiths / Story Of The Leper, The Bald Man And The Blind Man – Sahih Bukhari / Fabrications And Errors In Sahih Bukhari and Muslim (2) (3) (4)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (Reply) (Go Down)
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Crayfish09: 6:59pm On Jul 30, 2021 |
Biodun556: This is the point I'm trying to make. More needs to be worked on. |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Crayfish09: 7:01pm On Jul 30, 2021 |
Hassanmaye: Yes, the Hadiths teaches us many things and a lot of them are truly authentic. I still apply many Hadiths in my way of life but it's just a few that I am not convinced with. 1 Like |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by AlBaqir(m): 7:30pm On Jul 30, 2021 |
nisai: Beard is simply a recommended act, NEVER a compulsory act. 2 Likes |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Hendtime: 8:10pm On Jul 30, 2021 |
GreenCovering:Show me proof |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by nisai: 8:19pm On Jul 30, 2021 |
AlBaqir:Ok sir. But I will appreciate proof to back it up. |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by GreenCovering: 8:31pm On Jul 30, 2021 |
Hendtime: Show which proof. Is it not you who claimed that Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala did not use His creative power of be and it is to create Adam? Hendtime: The onus is on you to show the proof of your claim now. Inability to show that proof means you are on your own for mocking Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala. It is what your hands are preparing for you ahead of your meeting Him. |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Baker77: 8:32pm On Jul 30, 2021 |
Alhajiemeritus: قاتل is pronounce as qo'tala while قتل pronounce as qotala..check dictionary
|
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by AlBaqir(m): 7:08am On Jul 31, 2021 |
nisai: The only hadith of the Prophet that talks about beard says, "trim your moustache and leave your beard so you can be different from the Jews" Fi'l al-Amr [commanding verb] usually indicates either: compulsion (waajib) or recommendation (isti'bab). If something is compulsory and you do it not intentionally, then there is punishment for it. Recommended act if done attracts great reward but if left undone, it attracts no punishment. In the abovementioned hadith, the "command" in its tone and style is a recommendation, never compulsory (even if some too know group of people have made it compulsory for themselves). You can decide to have beard, trim or shorten it. It's a choice. Sincerely, beard is manly and always look good if kept well. 1 Like |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Usernamesucks: 7:23am On Jul 31, 2021 |
Crayfish09: Indeed. I believe since he authored the books, he could have opened atleast one or two of those false hadiths. By the way, I'd advise you to seek clarifications from a learned scholar about your thoughts. You may not get what you seek here. May Allah guide us aright. Aameen |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Alhajiemeritus: 8:29am On Jul 31, 2021 |
Baker77:You do not understand my point. |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by AntiChristian: 8:51am On Jul 31, 2021 |
gentleibraheem: I don't get your point please. |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by AntiChristian: 8:52am On Jul 31, 2021 |
Hassanmaye: Most of all these i stated have no backing from the Qur'an too. So they are questionable right? |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by AntiChristian: 9:12am On Jul 31, 2021 |
drealaz24: So explain the verses independent of each other. |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Hassanmaye(m): 9:19am On Jul 31, 2021 |
AntiChristian: Nap, if they have Qur'an backing they Not questionable, the fact that albani Said some Hadith sahih Bukhari are daeef said it all. Only book of Allah is free from error |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by AntiChristian: 9:45am On Jul 31, 2021 |
Hassanmaye: No one is claiming the generality of the "Sahih ahadith" to be 100% as Allah has destined the Qur'an only to be such. But saying ahadith without backing from the Qur'an is questionable is false and lacks merit. |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by AntiChristian: 9:47am On Jul 31, 2021 |
Itzlinda: Yes I do know them. Even Sahih Muslim join. |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Hassanmaye(m): 10:17am On Jul 31, 2021 |
AntiChristian:Ok sir |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by nisai: 4:07pm On Jul 31, 2021 |
AlBaqir:Nice. Thank u so much, sir. I like how u analyze issues here. I have been your silent follower for long and I know you are shia. The other person I admire here is Sino, a Sunni I believe. How can I acquire Islamic knowledge? Do you have like madrasa? 1 Like 1 Share |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by ANTIlSLAM(m): 4:18pm On Aug 01, 2021 |
Abdoolbuster: Antichristian shey you see wetin this your brother compton11 yarn? Una no go kill person with laugh oo 1 Like 1 Share |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by compton11(m): 4:37pm On Aug 01, 2021 |
ANTIlSLAM:what did I say? |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by ANTIlSLAM(m): 7:02pm On Aug 01, 2021 |
compton11: This is what you said "Sahih is not 100% percent reliable especially sahih Bukhari,thya book needs to be revised cos it has cause much wahala in Islamic world." You just finish Islam |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by compton11(m): 7:13pm On Aug 01, 2021 |
ANTIlSLAM:yes cos Bukhari collected those Hadith from people after like 400 years after prophet! And some are not reliable |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by ANTIlSLAM(m): 12:50am On Aug 02, 2021 |
compton11: But ur brother antichris said Sahih bukhari is the best and 100% reliable |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Abdoolbuster: 6:52am On Aug 02, 2021 |
MakotoShishio:In fact Sahih Hadiths has been elevated beyond Quran in certain ways For example the Qur'an gave instructions that when gays are caught they should be beaten with sandals but Hadiths says that they should be killed lmao |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Abdoolbuster: 6:53am On Aug 02, 2021 |
ANTIlSLAM: Even the Qur'an was collected hundreds of years after Muhammad has long died |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Abdoolbuster: 6:55am On Aug 02, 2021 |
compton11: It is the same people who collected and transmitted the Qur'an that collected and transmitted the hadiths also. If you must reject the hadiths then you must reject the Qur'an they transmitted too. This is the Dilemma of abdools |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Alhajiemeritus: 9:03am On Aug 02, 2021 |
compton11:Imam Bukhari didn't even write Sahih Buhari |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by Alhajiemeritus: 9:04am On Aug 02, 2021 |
Abdoolbuster:Wrong. |
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by ANTIlSLAM(m): 9:18am On Aug 02, 2021 |
Abdoolbuster: 1 Like
|
Re: Should Sahih Hadiths Really Be 100% Accepted? by compton11(m): 10:46am On Aug 02, 2021 |
Alhajiemeritus:wa llahu alam |
Smart Phones, Social Media, And Muslim Kids / Eid Al Adha Is On Sunday 6/11/11 / Becoming One Of Allah's Special People
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 46 |