Skoonheid:
What did Muhammad do in the cave Hira (Ghar Hiraa)?  Islamic books say that Muhammad used to go to cave Hira to worship for several nights at a time.

According to the Islamic resources ,Muhammad used to go there to worship, following the example of Al Hanifa like his grandfather Abd El Mutalib.  The Islamic resources also mention that Khadija said, “I wish you would become the prophet of this nation.”  They saw that the Jews had Moses as their own prophet & Christians had Issa (Jesus) as their prophet [Muslims also few Jesus as a prophet] so why don’t the Arab nations have their own prophet?  Therefore, they were looking forward to having their own prophet.  Sheikh Khalil Abd El Karim, the graduate of Al Azhar Mosque in Egypt, mentioned in his book, ‘The Forming Period In The Life of The Sincere & Faithful’, that Khadija, Warago Bin Noufal & Pastor Buhaira formed the first school that trained & prepared Muhammad to hopefully become a prophet.  During the first five years of this preparation period Khadija used to go with Muhammad to an area near the cave Hira where she used to wait for him until he came back from his seclusion.  She had learned that Moses & other prophets went to the mountains & then became prophets, so she wanted to lead Muhammad along the same path hoping that something might happen to him which would signify was the prophet they desired. 
What happened in this cave?

when Muhammad went to cave Hira why could he not recognize that what he met was either a Jinn, a demon or an angel?  & Why did Muhammad leave trembling?

According to the Sira books, Muhammad never thought that what he met was an angel!  He always believed that it was a Jinn & that it was his (Muhammad’s) follower & that he was touched by the Jinn & that he had Jinn’s.  The Sira books never mention that Muhammad though he saw an angel there.  Why, because the appearance of an angel to a human being has always been accompanied with many signs.  The most important sign throughout the holy history, in both the Old & New Testaments, was that the angel would bring peace!  For example, when the angel appeared to the Virgin Mary he said, “Peace is upon you.  You are full of blessings & God is with you.”  The angel’s appearance brought peace, comfort & tranquility.  But the appearance of what was named Jibril (Gabriel) to Muhammad was accompanied with a strange thing, it was strangling him!  That is why Muhammad had no doubt that it was the Jinn & that this Jinn was his follower!

The sign of angel appearance is peace but what happened to Muhammad was never peaceful.

Horror.  The angel strangled him, according to the story three times the angel says, “Read”,  Muhammad answers, “I can’t read”, then the angel strangled him.  So how can that be an angel if he’s strangling him?  Angels come as agents of mercy in order to give life, not to strangle people!  From here was Muhammad’s doubt that this could not be an angel.  Muhammad never thought that it was an angel.  He thought that it was a demon & he went to Khadija & told her, “I saw a follower, or I was touched by a Jinn.”  That was all he thought!

For all the Muslim travellers and other travellers out there, don't just take everything you see in some scripture, reason if what you're instructed can give you the eternity you seek.

FxMasterz:


The so called angel Mohammed saw was obviously a jinn but then, who later convinced him that the jinn was an angel? I'll like to know.

It's even more hilarious that Mohammed was going to the cave in order to become a prophet. TenQ and Advocatejare, come see something o.

Kukutente23:
AntiChristian will not like this

AntiChristian:


What's the proof for this Christian lie?

FxMasterz:


Have you been to white garment churches or cults to see how they convulse whenever demons take them over? Mohammed convulsed the same way.

Is it not written in your books that Mohammed was possessed of a demon? Who exorcized him?

The fact that you guys believe that there are Muslim demons tells it all. It contradicts all previous revelations of the prophets regarding demons. Tell me which prophet used of God in Israel was ever possessed of a demon or preached that there are demons who serve God. If they're serving God, what makes them demons in the first place?

AntiChristian:
Of course i have been to C and S before. So what are the similarities between them and Muhammad's?

Where was it written please? Possessed of a demon precisely!

I hope you won't later change it to afflicted by witchcraft as a liar we have known you all to be!

Affliction is different from possession. Job was afflicted with sores and death of family and properties!


We believe in the world of Jinns! You can call them demon but we don't call them such! Allah created them and us to worship Him alone without partners! As there are righteous Jinns so also there are evil ones!

Satan is a Jinn too!

As for the Previous Prophets none was sent to the Jinn-Kind!
Only Solomon was given authority to control them!

FxMasterz:


Perhaps you don't know that demonic affliction is an offshoot of demonic . possession. Demons possess, then afflict.

The similarities in the white garment and mohammed's experiences is the convulsion. A known occultic means of demon possession.

Solomon was able to control demons according to who? You mean the same Solomon who could not control his demonic lust for women and even died worshipping Ashera?

AntiChristian:


What's the proof for this Christian lie?