Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,152,840 members, 7,817,483 topics. Date: Saturday, 04 May 2024 at 01:00 PM

Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas - Culture (4) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Culture / Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas (4075 Views)

Addressing The Menace Called African Time / The Invasion Of Oyo Empire By Tsoede,The King Of Nupe In 1457 / Bini Are Original Owners Of Lagos, Not Yoruba – Layi Ajayi-Bembe (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Trizyd(m): 11:40am On May 13, 2023

Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 11:41am On May 13, 2023
phineas:

Here's a fun fact.The title of Oni historically was that of a priest not a king.The story of the kings of ancient Yoruba is another story entirely ...
Yoruba is an other spelling for yarri.ba which is the former name of Oyo. And it's king is titled Alafin, also it has nothing to do with what Nigerians identify as Yoruba today.
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 11:42am On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oyo_Empire
Dude you look ridiculous with your newly made Wikipedia map.
Do I need to say it is fake ? Or does the fact the people who made it had access to computers say it all.
I posted Precolonial maps and you are posting post-wikipedia maps 😂
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 11:45am On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:
...
Will you stop with the fake maps ?
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Trizyd(m): 11:57am On May 13, 2023
Stoplying:

Dude you look ridiculous with your newly made Wikipedia map.
Do I need to say it is fake ? Or does the fact the people who made it had access to computers says it all.
I posted Precolonial maps and you are posting post-wikipedia maps 😂


Ignorant dude. You can't even chill to educate. Can't blame you. I will do it for you.
Sources.

1. https://www.penn.museum/sites/expedition/benin-oyo-and-dahomey/

"At its height during the 15th and 16th centuries the Benin kingdom reached its natural boundaries at the River Niger to the east and the sea to the south, and established suzerainty over Yoruba areas to the west and southwest up to the border of what was to become Dahomey. In the late 16th century it reached a common boundary with the kingdom of Oyo."

2. https://www.britannica.com/place/Oyo-empire
3. https://africankingdoms.co.uk/dahomey-2/
4. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/history-in-africa/article/abs/early-oyo-history-reconsidered/C053D1874C73CC6E6A001083F9BD63DA

I gave you some by your white masters you believe.

2 Likes

Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Trizyd(m): 11:59am On May 13, 2023
Stoplying:

Will you stop with the fake maps ?

Like you surveyed and drew yours. grin grin grin

1 Like

Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 12:01pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:


Like you surveyed and drew yours. grin grin grin
Mine were drawn by people who visited the region hundreds of years ago, yours were drawn by people who went to get a haircut yesterday.
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 12:03pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:



Ignorant dude. You can't even chill to educate. Can't blame you. I will do it for you.
Sources.

1. https://www.penn.museum/sites/expedition/benin-oyo-and-dahomey/

"At its height during the 15th and 16th centuries the Benin kingdom reached its natural boundaries at the River Niger to the east and the sea to the south, and established suzerainty over Yoruba areas to the west and southwest up to the border of what was to become Dahomey. In the late 16th century it reached a common boundary with the kingdom of Oyo."

2. https://www.britannica.com/place/Oyo-empire
3. https://africankingdoms.co.uk/dahomey-2/
4. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/history-in-africa/article/abs/early-oyo-history-reconsidered/C053D1874C73CC6E6A001083F9BD63DA

I gave you some by your white masters you believe.

Unsubstantiated story.
When studying history, you need to look for eyewitness written documents, not unsubstantiated declarations, irrespective of the pedigree of whomever is making the claims.
In case you don't get it, this debate is not at the level of the consumer of history but at the level of the researcher of history. So you basically need to do the type of work which you believe those you quoted have done.
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Trizyd(m): 12:06pm On May 13, 2023
Stoplying:

Unsubstantiated story.
When studying history, you need to look for eyewitness written documents, not unsubstantiated declarations, irrespective of the pedigree of whomever is making the claims.

😁🤣🤣🤣🙄 Eye witness written documents how can we go back now and ask someone from Oyo Empire and Benin Empire to bring their written documents. Or show me, in your words the "eyewitness written documents"

1 Like

Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Trizyd(m): 12:07pm On May 13, 2023
Stoplying:

Mine were drawn by people who visited the region hundreds of years ago, yours were drawn by people who went to get a haircut yesterday.

Who drew it? What time period? Or they don't use name and date?

1 Like

Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 12:11pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:


😁🤣🤣🤣🙄 Eye witness written documents how can we go back now and ask someone from Oyo Empire and Benin Empire to bring their written documents. Or show me, in your words the "eyewitness written documents"
It seems you might actually learn something.
This question is the essence of history.
History is the study of documents written by eyewitnesses. For example, I gave a document written by a French guy who visited West Africa around 1830. That document is an eyewitness written document, that is what history is about.
I also gave Precolonial maps drawn by people who visited our region in the middle ages. That is an eyewitness made document.
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 12:12pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:


Who drew it? What time period? Or they don't use name and date?
Try and grow some brain cells. I gave you the source, you can go through it and get the information yourself.
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 12:13pm On May 13, 2023
Stoplying:

In case you don't get it, this debate is not at the level of the consumer of history but at the level of the researcher of history. So you basically need to do the type of work which you believe those you quoted have done.
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Trizyd(m): 12:35pm On May 13, 2023
Stoplying:

It seems you might actually learn something.
This question is the essence of history.
History is the study of documents written by eyewitnesses. For example, I gave a document written by a French guy who visited West Africa around 1830. That document is an eyewitness written document, that is what history is about.

Are you deluded? How can a document by a French explorer in 1890 be a witness for an empire existing way before then?

You need older records and as you said 'documents written by eyewitnesses'. It's like saying dinosaurs never existed because an explorer wrote it down during his exploration in year 1800.

The French explore came 1890, saw your about to collapse empire, recorded it and drew maps of what he saw, and you call that your history You don't know what you are saying. Bringing up the benin bronze would have made more sense.

If I were to go by your methodology, here is an eye witness documentation on Oyo Empire.

"By the time Captain Hugh Clapperton visited Oyo-Ile in 1825 during the reign of Alaafin Majotu, the empire was already in a state of decline. Clapperton's party recorded passing numerous Oyo villages burned by the Fulani of Ilorin while Majotu had also sought the help of the English king and the Oba of Benin in putting down the Ilorin rebellion. Clapperton also noticed a shortage of horses, even though the Oyo were renowned as a great cavalry force;"
Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oyo_Empire
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugh_Clapperton
https://plants.jstor.org/stable/10.5555/al.ap.person.bm000001530

1 Like

Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 12:57pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:


Are you deluded? How can a document by a French explorer in 1890 be a witness for an empire existing way before then?

You are dumber then you look.
The eyewitness is an eyewitness to his period of time and his testimony is what he writes in the document!
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 1:00pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:


Are you deluded? How can a document by a French explorer in 1890 be a witness for an empire existing way before then?

You are dumber then you look.
The eyewitness is an eyewitness to his period of time and his testimony is what he writes in the document!
By the way, it is 1880 you dumbass
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 1:02pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:

You need older records and as you said 'documents written by eyewitnesses'. It's like saying dinosaurs never existed because an explorer wrote it down during his exploration in year 1800.
Do you really not understand the difference between history and archaeology? Are you that dumb ?
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Trizyd(m): 1:03pm On May 13, 2023
Stoplying:

You are dumber then you look.
The eyewitness is an eyewitness to his period of time and his testimony is what he writes in the document!
By the way, it is 1830 you dumbass

Ouch... I guess i touched a nerve. I am sorry.

1 Like

Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Trizyd(m): 1:09pm On May 13, 2023
Stoplying:

Do you really not understand the difference between history and archaeology? Are you that dumb ?


History: A written record of past events, [things that happened]. , there are certain events that may not be recorded or retold to 100% accuracy.

Archaeology is the study of the ancient and recent human past through material remains.

I never told you to dig up anything. dinosaurs are part of earth history. Kapish?

1 Like

Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 1:14pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:


Ouch... I guess i touched a nerve. I am sorry.
No, I actually thought for a second that you were smarter than this.
I am only disappointed, by the way, I'm on a train and my internet access is not very fluid right now, that is why it is hard to respond in time right now.

Tell me what you meant by this:
Trizyd:


Are you deluded? How can a document by a French explorer in 1890 be a witness for an empire existing way before then?
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 1:16pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:

History: A written record of past events, [things that happened]. , there are certain events that may not be recorded or retold to 100% accuracy.
Archaeology is the study of the ancient and recent human past through material remains.
I never told you to dig up anything. dinosaurs are part of earth history. Kapish?
1) history is a collection of human events which are proven to have taken place
2) archeology is the study of human or animal remains

I haven't even finished addressing your long uneducated post.
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 1:25pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:


The French explore came 1890, saw your about to collapse empire, recorded it and drew maps of what he saw, and you call that your history You don't know what you are saying. Bringing up the benin bronze would have made more sense.
1) I just checked the date of publication of the book, it is 1880.
2) who told you the maps were made by the same person ?
3) one of the maps was made in the 17th century (1600's), hundreds of years before the French author was born
4) I let you check for the date of publication of the other map
5) where did I say that these are all the historical documents which I have access to or which exist ? Or am I expected to expose the entirety of eyewitness written records each time I talk about Benin ? What stupid point are you trying to make here ?
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 1:30pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:

You don't know what you are saying. Bringing up the benin bronze would have made more sense.
You still clearly fail to understand the meaning of the word history.
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Trizyd(m): 1:31pm On May 13, 2023
Stoplying:

No, I actually thought for a second that you were smarter than this.
I am only disappointed, by the way, I'm on a train and my internet access is not very fluid right now, that is why it is hard to respond in time right now.

Tell me what you meant by this:


You are the one doing History, I am not. I am still on the topic with you. History will not sort out the issues here.
You are said Oyo Empire never existed, I don't need history to counter your points.

History, according to Oxford "the whole series of past events connected with a particular person or thing", is not enough to prove if something existed or not. History is biased by definition, and you shouldn't expect it to be 100% accurate.

I have presented, eye witness accounts, geographical maps, geographical events during the timeline. It was even called the Kingdom of Oyo, well known to the British and French. Benin Empire was conquered not long after the Kingdom of Oyo fell.

1 Like

Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 1:34pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:

"By the time Captain Hugh Clapperton visited Oyo-Ile in 1825 during the reign of Alaafin Majotu, the empire was already in a state of decline. Clapperton's party recorded passing numerous Oyo villages burned by the Fulani of Ilorin while Majotu had also sought the help of the English king and the Oba of Benin in putting down the Ilorin rebellion. Clapperton also noticed a shortage of horses, even though the Oyo were renowned as a great cavalry force;"
Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oyo_Empire
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugh_Clapperton
https://plants.jstor.org/stable/10.5555/al.ap.person.bm000001530
This is you bringing home your fake argument.
And it all starts with your inability to understand what the word "eyewitness" means.
I brought a book written by a person who visited our region in the precolonial era. That person witnessed what he wrote down ! He wasn't telling a story which he didn't witness, like a story which supposedly happened in an era in which his great grand parents weren't born! The type of stories you and your fellow Yoruba like to tell.

Definition: an eyewitness written document is a document describing an event which the author witnessed ! That is the type of document which is relevant to history. Again, not documents in which people describe a period which preceded their great grand fathers.
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by ItooWorWor(m): 1:53pm On May 13, 2023
Who still takes Bini jokers serious grin

1 Like

Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 2:05pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:

You are the one doing History, I am not. I am still on the topic with you. History will not sort out the issues here.
You are said Oyo Empire never existed, I don't need history to counter your points.
The only thing which was witnessed about Oyo was a small kingdom being overran by Fula, no empire was witnessed, your fellow Yoruba created that myth.
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 2:07pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:

History, according to Oxford "the whole series of past events connected with a particular person or thing", is not enough to prove if something existed or not. History is biased by definition, and you shouldn't expect it to be 100% accurate.
If you are going to start quoting the Oxford dictionary like a little school kid then do I need to tell you your intellectual level ?
"The whole series of past events" is not available to mankind, a better and more accessible definition for history is what I gave you.
"History is biased", nope, once again look at the definition of history and stop conforming to your childhood intuition of it.
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Stoplying: 2:22pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:

I have presented, eye witness accounts, geographical maps, geographical events during the timeline. It was even called the Kingdom of Oyo, well known to the British and French. Benin Empire was conquered not long after the Kingdom of Oyo fell.
"Eyewitness account" is an attempt to commit fraud, you can basically write anything and claim it is somehow an "eyewitness account". What matters are eyewitness written docs.
You presented no such thing about oyo's "glorious" past.
You presented fake maps and you kept quoting Wikipedia.
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by Odogwuzack: 2:59pm On May 13, 2023
Stoplying:

"Eyewitness account" is an attempt to commit fraud, you can basically write anything and claim it is somehow an "eyewitness account". What matters are eyewitness written docs.
You presented no such thing about oyo's "glorious" past.
You presented fake maps and you kept quoting Wikipedia.

Why are you barking?

You are way too emotionally weak to partake in civil and educative discussion.
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by PoloG: 3:29pm On May 13, 2023
Vado2:



In Yorubaland, the culture of hookups is accepted. Only in Yoruba land would you witness a woman with a husband and children engaging in hookups. Also a Yoruba man, is the inventor of cultism in Nigeria. All tribes are only playing catch up; the Yorubas are the ones that created 419.
tiny bini should compare
Re: Addressing The Misconceptions Regarding The Great Bini Empire By Yorubas by gaddafe(m): 3:30pm On May 13, 2023
Trizyd:


😁🤣🤣🤣🙄 Eye witness written documents how can we go back now and ask someone from Oyo Empire and Benin Empire to bring their written documents. Or show me, in your words the "eyewitness written documents"

I initially did not want to comment on this thread as I've seen a lot ridiculous to even stupid fact that anyone with a basic level of IQ will detect the fallacy. However I just want to let you know it's not impossible to find eyewitness documents or account. I personally met someone (although already late) who witness the battle that overthrew Ovoranmen from Benin Kingdom. If you can get the guardian newspaper of January 1, 2000 you will see the interview of a man who lived to see 3 century. I personally know the man in question as he's related to me. Most of the information we got from them are verifyable. Why I'm I saying this? It is possible to get eye witness documents. If you can't get hold of eye witness documents in Oyo then something is wrong with the history. Also another fallacy I see here is that there was nothing like the Yoruba history. What we had was various tribes. It was the British that first brought the idea of Yoruba per se. So when I see Yoruba history here and there, I just laugh.

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (Reply)

Lets Discuss The Possibility Of An Igbo Language Section / How Many Igbo Dialects Do U Speak And Understand? / Are Ibaji And Oturukpo People Bilingual?

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 83
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.