Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,153,183 members, 7,818,590 topics. Date: Sunday, 05 May 2024 at 07:23 PM

Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an - Religion (5) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an (2740 Views)

When the Qur'an is misinterpretated : Did Jesus Die On The Cross? / The Error Of Constantine That Birthed The Trinity Doctrine, Paganism With Christ / The Error Of Daddy Freeze . (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by CrystalBliss: 10:08am On Nov 14, 2023
Explore2xmore:


By motherly relations does Jesus have a Levi ancestry?

Of course. That's why He becomes our High Priest.

What does the Levitical ancestry have to do with Mary being the sister of Aaron?
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by AntiChristian: 10:10am On Nov 14, 2023
TenQ:

You never hear of the three daughters of Allah whose intercession is desired.
It was abrogated by Mohammed himself!

Tell me you're hearing of this for the first time!?

Only holy spirit confused fellows dey parrot such nonsense!
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by Explore2xmore: 10:15am On Nov 14, 2023
CrystalBliss:


Of course. That's why He becomes our High Priest.

What does the Levitical ancestry have to do with Mary being the sister of Aaron?

Sister by being of the same tribe.
Sister in regards of relations to the jewish temple
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by Explore2xmore: 10:29am On Nov 14, 2023
SIRTee15:


My friend leave all this whataboutism and give us dawah. We here to learn about Islam and its tales by moonlight, not your lecture on what u know nothing about.

If u want us to talk about the biblical version of David, open another thread. But here we want to know about Islam and to test it's book.

I just don't understand all these modern Muslims, u ask them a question about Koran, they quickly run to the bible.
Can't Koran be defended standing alone, must u seek validation from another religion b4 the Koran makes sense.

Explain to us how a poor man convinced a rich man to climb wall so that the poor man can report the rich man to the king.

Give a logical explanation to the forgiveness asked by dawood in the story.

You said the 2 men were angels and u claim they disappeared, back this up with evidence from your koran. Show me anything from your Koran that depicts them as supernatural beings.
If they have powers, why are they climbing walls like thieves.

Is this too hard to ask for of the koran? Why are u dragging the bible into your mess created by your own book?


I've debated you and other Muslims on this platform multiple times, u will never see me ducking to the Koran to defend the bible. Not once.
It makes no sense seeking validation for your faith in another religion. It's an indirect way of saying 'my religion makes no sense, so I must also discredit yours so that both are inside potopoto- mud'

My friend, if islam no make sense, try another religion. I'm very much happy to welcome u to the Christian fold. if u want to give Jesus Christ a chance, trust me u will never regret it.



Are u ok? how Ashanti take relates to Yoruba that they will be ones correcting our history.
And what has the white man got to do with this? U well so? Wetin concern colonial division of Africa with our native ancient history, is it the white man that wrote it? My guy u not making sense here.

My example is same everywhere. A french man cannot be correcting the history of king Henry VIII and his 7 wives, neither can an English man be telling us what actually happened to queen Marie Antoinette.

If I want to learn about muhamed, I will check Arab sources. I wont travel to Israel to start researching Muhammed in the Talmud. Do u get it now?

Besides, If at all we should even accept the Abrahamic genealogy of Arabs, they got cut off from chain link 1000yrs b4 the story of David and bathsheba happened. Arabs are in no position to be telling us the history of the Jews.
It makes no sense my friend and you know it. If not for religion and blind faith, u would not even consider it.

David realised he did not give perfect justice haven not listened to both sides of the dispute.


You talked about Ashanti and the Yoruba mythological Sango. What do Yoruba and Ashanti share in common?


Arabs getting cut off removes a shared ancestry through Ishmael to Abraham. Please explain. Or what exactly were they cut off from?

"try another religion. I'm very much happy to welcome u to the Christian fold." You say yet?

SIRTee15:

so why should I discuss it with u.
Will I change your mind if I explain the biblical exegesis to u? No?

Are you expecting me to blindly follow or come under your spell? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Just saw someone refer to you as having some anointing. Oh please.
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by SIRTee15: 11:22am On Nov 14, 2023
Explore2xmore:


David realised he did not give perfect justice haven not listened to both sides of the dispute.


You talked about Ashanti and the Yoruba mythological Sango. What do Yoruba and Ashanti share in common?


Arabs getting cut off removes a shared ancestry through Ishmael to Abraham. Please explain. Or what exactly were they cut off from?

"try another religion. I'm very much happy to welcome u to the Christian fold." You say yet?



Are you expecting me to blindly follow or come under your spell? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Just saw someone refer to you as having some anointing. Oh please.

Yoruba and Ashanti share the same west African ancestry. The Haplogroups E1b1a and E1b1b are found in both tribes in varying frequencies.
Go and read about the battle of atakpame to learn about engagement btw both tribes prior to your colonial division claim.

That we share same ancestry doesn't mean Ashanti should be correcting the history of sango for the yorubas. It makes no sense. Sango is a unique historical events for the Yorubas only.

The Arabs were never called Israelites, they are not levants, they were never regarded as cannanites. The story of David happened when Israelites had settled in the land of Canaan, they had no interaction with the Arabs.
Maybe if the philistines had written about David and bathsheba, I would give it serious consideration because they had regular engagement with the Israelites.

Arabs never linked their lineage to Abraham until Muhammed appeared on stage.
The kabba was a shrine dedicated to a Nabataean deity called Hubal for hundreds of years. There's no pre islamic evidence that Abraham and Ismael built the kabba.

Muhammed is the one who should explain how he came about all these fascinating tales. Simple.
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by Explore2xmore: 11:43am On Nov 14, 2023
SIRTee15:


Yoruba and Ashanti share the same west African ancestry. The Haplogroups E1b1a and E1b1b are found in both tribes in varying frequencies.
Go and read about the battle of atakpame to learn about engagement btw both tribes prior to your colonial division claim.

That we share same ancestry doesn't mean Ashanti should be correcting the history of sango for the yorubas. It makes no sense. Sango is a unique historical events for the Yorubas only.

The Arabs were never called Israelites, they are not levants, they were never regarded as cannanites. The story of David happened when Israelites had settled in the land of Canaan, they had no interaction with the Arabs.
Maybe if the philistines had written about David and bathsheba, I would give it serious consideration because they had regular engagement with the Israelites.

Arabs never linked their lineage to Abraham until Muhammed appeared on stage.
The kabba was a shrine dedicated to a Nabataean deity called Hubal for hundreds of years. There's no pre islamic evidence that Abraham and Ismael built the kabba.

Muhammed is the one who should explain how he came about all these fascinating tales. Simple.

Pure Bunkum. Tell me exact persons in their ancestral lineage not genetics. When you tell me a common character between Ashanti and Yoruba not geographical generalization there may be an axiom for discussion.

Where did Arabs come from? Can their ancestry be traced?

Tell me too are the Indians cut off? I know no mention of an Indian prophet in the Bible.

I see your problem is the source of information. How lowly you view the ability of God.
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by CrystalBliss: 11:47am On Nov 14, 2023
Explore2xmore:


Sister by being of the same tribe.
Sister in regards of relations to the jewish temple

Lol.

She's a descendant and can in no way be called a sister of Aaron. Stop lying. Are you the brother of your grandfather?
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by TenQ: 12:07pm On Nov 14, 2023
AntiChristian:


Only holy spirit confused fellows dey parrot such nonsense!
So will you be kind enough to tell us of the three daughters of Allah whose intercession is desired?

We are waiting!
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by Explore2xmore: 12:41pm On Nov 14, 2023
CrystalBliss:


Lol.

She's a descendant and can in no way be called a sister of Aaron. Stop lying. Are you the brother of your grandfather?

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
You decide the lies you believe isn't it?

Over how many centuries is Jesus a son of David?
Explain precisely the differences in the relativity?

Sisters who share the same tribe origins possess a unique and profound bond. Their shared cultural heritage acts as a unifying force, providing them with a deep understanding of each other's experiences, values, and traditions. This common background allows sisters to strengthen their connection and forge a powerful sisterhood rooted in their shared roots.

Sisters who share the same tribe origins but are not related by blood or familial ties showcase the power of kinship and the significance of culture in forging connections.

This surely cannot make sense to you.
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by SIRTee15: 12:42pm On Nov 14, 2023
Explore2xmore:


Pure Bunkum. Tell me exact persons in their ancestral lineage not genetics. When you tell me a common character between Ashanti and Yoruba not geographical generalization there may be an axiom for discussion.

So u will take oral tradition over science? Is that what u saying. Are u arguing historical records trumps scientific evidence? Seriously.
Then why all the noise about DNA test. If your wife tells u this is your child why do u dispute it when DNA evidence says otherwise.
Abegi, this one no be talk.

Explore2xmore:


Where did Arabs come from? Can their ancestry be traced?

Tell me too are the Indians cut off? I know no mention of an Indian prophet in the Bible.

I see your problem is the source of information. How lowly you view the ability of God.

🥱🥱🥱🥱
Seriously I don't even understand what u talking here. Where did Indians take enter the picture. Did their gods also gave them a story about David and bathsheba?

My friend rest. West African history u no sabi. Arab history that u follow their religion, u no sabi.

I've been asking u to provide just one evidence from the Koran that the 2 litigants are supernatural beings. U failed to give a response.

I think this case is now done and dusted. Muhammed's story is a big lie. Baba iro.
Thank u TenQ for doing a good job bringing this up.

As for my faith. I think I have debated the bible with u b4. If I'm right, we discussed the book of 2nd Peter.
I'm never afraid nor ashamed to discuss the gospel. It's the power of salvation to everyone.
Feel free to tag me whenever u open a thread about the bible and we will cure your doubt/ignorance

Something u guys couldn't do here.

Maranatha. God bless.

1 Like

Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by Explore2xmore: 12:46pm On Nov 14, 2023
So you have done scientific study to authenticate all the people you are related to?
Is there this much dishonesty in your family so you disbelieve who your parents tell you are relatives?

Were these scientific studies done to prove kinship by the people you read about in your bible?

Don't be a clown.
SIRTee15:


So u will take oral tradition over science? Is that what u saying. Are u arguing historical records trumps scientific evidence? Seriously.
Then why all the noise about DNA test. If your wife tells u this is your child why do u dispute it when DNA evidence says otherwise.
Abegi, this one no be talk.



🥱🥱🥱🥱
Seriously I don't even understand what u talking here. Where did Indians take enter the picture. Did their gods also gave them a story about David and bathsheba?

My friend rest. West African history u no sabi. Arab history that u follow their religion, u no sabi.

I've been asking u to provide just one evidence from the Koran that the 2 litigants are supernatural beings. U failed to give a response.

I think this case is now done and dusted. Muhammed's story is a big lie. Baba iro.
Thank u TenQ for doing a good job bringing this up.

As for my faith. I think I have debated the bible with u b4. If I'm right, we discussed the book of 2nd Peter.
I'm never afraid nor ashamed to discuss the gospel. It's the power of salvation to everyone.
Feel free to tag me whenever u open a thread about the bible and we will cure your doubt/ignorance

Something u guys couldn't do here.

Maranatha. God bless.
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by CrystalBliss: 1:14pm On Nov 14, 2023
Explore2xmore:


🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
You decide the lies you believe isn't it?

Over how many centuries is Jesus a son of David?
Explain precisely the differences in the relativity?

Sisters who share the same tribe origins possess a unique and profound bond. Their shared cultural heritage acts as a unifying force, providing them with a deep understanding of each other's experiences, values, and traditions. This common background allows sisters to strengthen their connection and forge a powerful sisterhood rooted in their shared roots.

Sisters who share the same tribe origins but are not related by blood or familial ties showcase the power of kinship and the significance of culture in forging connections.

This surely cannot make sense to you.

Are you Yoruba? Over how many centuries are you the son of Oduduwa? Why do you guys love lies?

Your talk about sisterhood up there is absolute nonsense. Are you the brother of your grandfather by that warped logic? A descendant of a matriarch or patriarch is never referred to as sister or brother in any culture. Stop lying! Mary was never the sister of Aaron, Mariam was. And, Mary is different from Mariam! Allah goofed. Mary is a daughter of Aaron, as Jesus is the Son of David in the flesh, not brother.
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by Qasim6(m): 1:40pm On Nov 14, 2023
AntiChristian:


Leave the ignorant ninny alone..Na daft he daft in Christianity!

Akhi, I tire for the guy. He's giving me story of when they likely start using pharaoh for Egyptian kings.

They are as Allah describe them, Their hearts are blind.

Qur'an they always claim copied the Bible stories did not make mistake of calling the Egyptian kings of old kingdom pharaoh.

1 Like

Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by SIRTee15: 2:04pm On Nov 14, 2023
Explore2xmore:
So you have done scientific study to authenticate all the people you are related to?
Is there this much dishonesty in your family so you disbelieve who your parents tell you are relatives?

Were these scientific studies done to prove kinship by the people you read about in your bible?

Don't be a clown.

Guy rest u just waffling.
DNA evidence proves Ashanti and Yoruba shares same west African ancestry. But that doesn't mean they should be correcting Yoruba history on Sango.
That's my point.

If u choose to believe your wife's story over DNA test when it comes to paternity of your child, all when and good. U won't be the first. Feminists worldwide will celebrate u.
Sha don't complain when the child grows up and start looking like your tenant.

Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by Explore2xmore: 2:25pm On Nov 14, 2023
CrystalBliss:


Are you Yoruba? Over how many centuries are you the son of Oduduwa? Why do you guys love lies?

Your talk about sisterhood up there is absolute nonsense. Are you the brother of your grandfather by that warped logic? A descendant of a matriarch or patriarch is never referred to as sister or brother in any culture. Stop lying! Mary was never the sister of Aaron, Mariam was. And, Mary is different from Mariam! Allah goofed. Mary is a daughter of Aaron, as Jesus is the Son of David in the flesh, not brother.

Old Testament Hebrew Lexicon - KJV
'achowth
https://www.biblestudytools.com/lexicons/hebrew/kjv/achowth.html

Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by Explore2xmore: 2:36pm On Nov 14, 2023
This doesn't mean zit.
Bringforth historically documented persons showing common Ashanti and Yoruba heritage.

Though they may speak different languages and eat distinct foods, people from far-flung geographical locations are genetically very similar, researchers say.

Lineage refers to the direct line of descent from an ancestor, typically through the male line. It is a term used in genealogy to trace family relationships and establish a person’s ancestry.

Ancestry, on the other hand, refers to a person’s family or ethnic background, including all of their ancestors, both male and female, and their cultural heritage. It is a broader term than lineage, encompassing all of the people who have contributed to a person’s genetic makeup and cultural identity.


SIRTee15:


Guy rest u just waffling.
DNA evidence proves Ashanti and Yoruba shares same west African ancestry. But that doesn't mean they should be correcting Yoruba history on Sango.
That's my point.

If u choose to believe your wife's story over DNA test when it comes to paternity of your child, all when and good. U won't be the first. Feminists worldwide will celebrate u.
Sha don't complain when the child grows up and start looking like your tenant.

Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by CrystalBliss: 2:37pm On Nov 14, 2023
Explore2xmore:


Old Testament Hebrew Lexicon - KJV
'achowth
https://www.biblestudytools.com/lexicons/hebrew/kjv/achowth.html

Sister is Metaphor for Northern Israel and Judah relationship. Not blood family relations. The metaphor is used in Ezekiel 23. Ezekiel refers to Oholah and Oholibah and identifies them as Samaria (the capital of Israel) and Jerusalem (the capital of Judah) in Ezekiel 23:4. The sisters are “daughters of the same mother” (verse 2) because Israel and Judah were originally one nation, Israel.

The term is used like saying South Korea and North Korea are sister nations. We are talking about blood relations here. Mary was not just a tribeswoman of Aaron. She was his descendant. Not her sister. No Israelite would even ever refer to Aaron as brother because of his position as high priest. He is the father of the Levitical priesthood. Mary is not Mariam. Allah goofed.
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by Explore2xmore: 2:50pm On Nov 14, 2023
CrystalBliss:


Sister is Metaphor for Northern Israel and Judah relationship. Not blood family relations. The metaphor is used in Ezekiel 23. Ezekiel refers to Oholah and Oholibah and identifies them as Samaria (the capital of Israel) and Jerusalem (the capital of Judah) in Ezekiel 23:4. The sisters are “daughters of the same mother” (verse 2) because Israel and Judah were originally one nation, Israel.

The term is used like saying South Korea and North Korea are sister nations. We are talking about blood relations here. Mary was not just a tribeswoman of Aaron. She was his descendant. Not her sister. No Israelite would even ever refer to Aaron as brother because of his position as high priest. He is the father of the Levitical priesthood. Mary is not Mariam. Allah goofed.

the sister
'achowth (aw-khoth')
a sister (used very widely, literally and figuratively) -- (an-)other, sister, together.
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by SIRTee15: 3:42pm On Nov 14, 2023
Explore2xmore:
This doesn't mean zit.
Bringforth historically documented persons showing common Ashanti and Yoruba heritage.

Though they may speak different languages and eat distinct foods, people from far-flung geographical locations are genetically very similar, researchers say.

Lineage refers to the direct line of descent from an ancestor, typically through the male line. It is a term used in genealogy to trace family relationships and establish a person’s ancestry.

Ancestry, on the other hand, refers to a person’s family or ethnic background, including all of their ancestors, both male and female, and their cultural heritage. It is a broader term than lineage, encompassing all of the people who have contributed to a person’s genetic makeup and cultural identity.



Show me pre islamic evidence that Arabs linked their lineage to Abraham or claim they are descendants of Abraham.

Then show me evidence Arabs had any interaction with Israelites in the 10th century BCE to know enough about what's going on in david's court.
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by SIRTee15: 4:01pm On Nov 14, 2023
Explore2xmore:


the sister
'achowth (aw-khoth')
a sister (used very widely, literally and figuratively) -- (an-)other, sister, together.

My friend, Jews don't make reference to their genealogy with sister or uncle.
It's always son or daughter when linking themselves to their lineage.

The first time using sister or uncle as reference to JEWISH ANCESTRY came up in the Koran, a book written by non Jews.
No Jew will ever say Mary, sister of Aaron to establish Mary's ancestry. It must be Mary daughter of Aaron and Imran.

show me anywhere a Jew was linked to his or her genealogy using sister or uncle.
Just one evidence.

Muhammed confused Miriam for Mary when dictating the Koran because the two names bear Maryam in the Arabic language.
So Muhammed must have heard Arab Christians mentioning Maryam being the sister of Aaron and also heard Maryam being the mother of Jesus.
When u understand above, the confusion and extrapolation becomes obvious.

1 Like

Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by MightySparrow: 4:09pm On Nov 14, 2023
AntiChristian:


You're a comedian now!


Agreed, answer my question anyway.
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by Explore2xmore: 4:20pm On Nov 14, 2023
In absolute Truth Jesus has no earthly father. How then is his case treated?

SIRTee15:


My friend, Jews don't make reference to their genealogy with sister or uncle.
It's always son or daughter when linking themselves to their lineage.

The first time using sister or uncle as reference to JEWISH ANCESTRY came up in the Koran, a book written by non Jews.
No Jew will ever say Mary, sister of Aaron to establish Mary's ancestry. It must be Mary daughter of Aaron and Imran.

show me anywhere a Jew was linked to his or her genealogy using sister or uncle.
Just one evidence.

Muhammed confused Miriam for Mary when dictating the Koran because the two names bear Maryam in the Arabic language.
So Muhammed must have heard Arab Christians mentioning Maryam being the sister of Aaron and also heard Maryam being the mother of Jesus.
When u understand above, the confusion and extrapolation becomes obvious.
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by AntiChristian: 4:45pm On Nov 14, 2023
MightySparrow:


Agreed, answer my question anyway.

What question?
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by CrystalBliss: 4:46pm On Nov 14, 2023
Explore2xmore:


the sister
'achowth (aw-khoth')
a sister (used very widely, literally and figuratively) -- (an-)other, sister, together.

I didn't say it's not widely in use. The screenshot you posted pointed out a metaphoric use between Israel and Judah which you wanted to use to defend the lie. Mary was not the sister of Aaron. Please stop this nonsense.
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by MightySparrow: 5:08pm On Nov 14, 2023
AntiChristian:


What question?


Is the Quran from Allah, Shytan, or from Mohammed?
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by SIRTee15: 5:10pm On Nov 14, 2023
Explore2xmore:
In absolute Truth Jesus has no earthly father. How then is his case treated?


We debating the Miriam, Mary and Maryam conundrum. Stay on topic.
Defend the Koran alone.
U like talking off point too much.

I've told u, it u want to talk about the bible create a thread and tag me.
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by Explore2xmore: 7:12pm On Nov 14, 2023
The subject of this thread is Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an - Religion until CrystalBliss derailed it.

Perharps you can open a thread to discuss your last statement.
SIRTee15:


We debating the Miriam, Mary and Maryam conundrum. Stay on topic.
Defend the Koran alone.
U like talking off point too much.

I've told u, it u want to talk about the bible create a thread and tag me.
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by TenQ: 7:46pm On Nov 14, 2023
Explore2xmore:
In absolute Truth Jesus has no earthly father. How then is his case treated?

Treated from both Joseph and Mary.
Joseph as his foster father
John 6:42:
"And they said, Is not this Jesus, the son of Joseph, whose father and mother we know? how is it then that he said, I came down from heaven?"

Matt 1:1-17
And Mary as biological Mother (Mary's Father)
Luke 2:23-38


But this is not even the theme of the discussion : see how you conveniently avoided my questions.

Back to the theme of discussion

It didn't dawn on you that as you Muslims usually claim that "the Qur'an is not a storybook" that Allah or is it Mohammed summarised the story . If not, can you tell us what finally happened to the ewe in question?

Is this an exact replica of what happened between the litigant and David?

If it is,
1. Did David now asked the rich man to tell his own side of the story after his repentance?
2. What then was the aftermath of the litigation?
3. What happened to the Ewe in question: did David divide it into two?

Above for your response

By the way,
How did the poor man convince the rich man to climb the fence with him to seek redress with the king
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by Explore2xmore: 7:52pm On Nov 14, 2023
When you pretend not to see:

Explore2xmore:

A sound judge is one who makes fair and well-reasoned decisions based on the available evidence and in accordance with the law. However, being perfectly correct is an unattainable standard for any human being, including a judge. It is important to recognize that judges are not infallible and are susceptible to making mistakes just like anyone else.

Do answer Both of them jointly said?

Q38: 23. “This brother of mine has ninety-nine ewes, and I have one ewe, and he said, ‘Entrust it to me,’ and he pressured me with words.”

(SINCERELY ANSWER)

Anxiously waiting

How then can you see the conclusion?
TenQ:

Treated from both Joseph and Mary.
Joseph as his foster father
John 6:42:
"And they said, Is not this Jesus, the son of Joseph, whose father and mother we know? how is it then that he said, I came down from heaven?"

Matt 1:1-17
And Mary as biological Mother (Mary's Father)
Luke 2:23-38


But this is not even the theme of the discussion : see how you conveniently avoided my questions.

Back to the theme of discussion

It didn't dawn on you that as you Muslims usually claim that "the Qur'an is not a storybook" that Allah or is it Mohammed summarised the story . If not, can you tell us what finally happened to the ewe in question?

Is this an exact replica of what happened between the litigant and David?

If it is,
1. Did David now asked the rich man to tell his own side of the story after his repentance?
2. What then was the aftermath of the litigation?
3. What happened to the Ewe in question: did David divide it into two?

Above for your response

By the way,
How did the poor man convince the rich man to climb the fence with him to seek redress with the king


Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by TenQ: 7:59pm On Nov 14, 2023
Explore2xmore:
When you pretend not to see:


How then can you see the conclusion?

If you had checked, you'd have seen this

TenQ:

If David was wrong in his judgement of the two men, tell us how the rich man was correct and the poor man wrong?

The question is simple to comprehend isn't it?


And note that you were the one avoiding a response



Followed by
TenQ:

Unfortunately unlike you Muslims, we don't belive in the Destiny of Allah as Allah has destined David to both be wise and foolish at the same time. David was a man after God's heart and he did everything God asked him to do except that he also did what he was not sent to by God like Adultery and Murder against Uriah the Hittite. I am sure you know that God doesn't tell David EVERYTHING to do like when to sleep with his wives or go to the toilet or when to worship or when to read the scriptures.

Unfortunately, If you check your Quran, you will notice that the verse on Allah bestowing wisdom and sagacity of judgement immediately preceeded his perceived stupidity. This is an apparent contradiction which is inexcusable.

Secondly,
You will note that Allah was telling a story that was already in existence

Qur'an 38:21
AND YET, has the story of the litigants come within thy ken - [the story of the two] who surmounted the walls of the sanctuary [in which David prayed]

Allah was asking if you Muslims have heard of this story..

Please, I ask you:
From who would you Muslims hear the story if not from Jews and Christians?
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by Explore2xmore: 8:19pm On Nov 14, 2023
Explore2xmore:
🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔

Even the Biblical Jesus says only the almighty God is good.

Both of them jointly said?

23. “This brother of mine has ninety-nine ewes, and I have one ewe, and he said, ‘Entrust it to me,’ and he pressured me with words.”

(SINCERELY ANSWER)

So because David was bestowed with Wisdom it means he has all wisdom and is infallible?

You fail to understand as you switch your intellect off to see the lesson being thought on how to do justice where there is a dispute more so on an issue you have no fore knowledge of.

Are you akin to who Fela refers to as Zombie or Mr Follow follow?

How can I know the degree of correctness in David's judgement when the other persons story is not narrated before a judgement was passed. Some exegesis state these were even angels that disappeared and David realised his error and realized what he was being taught. (tested) True to his nature he sort forgiveness regretting his hasty and impatient reaction without hearing the other side.

You are in a fantasy or ai world that imagines an immediate delivery or some mystical ability to know the unseen?

When there is a dispute between two people and your input for justice is sought by them together would you have them jointly present their case or listen to one and then the other?
Please be real and sincere!

TenQ:


If you had checked, you'd have seen this




And note that you were the one avoiding a response



Followed by

Show me your response on me questioning you of Q38:23
Re: Obvious Error Of Comprehension In The Qur'an by AntiChristian: 8:52pm On Nov 14, 2023
MightySparrow:



Is the Quran from Allah, Shytan, or from Mohammed?

This is an asinine question!

Muhammad salallahu alayhi wasalam didn't write Anything from the Qur'an!

And how will Satan write?

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (Reply)

Is Religion Or Practising 2 (main) Religions A Curse Or A Blessing For Nigeria? / A Thread For Members Of Celestial Church Of Christ / How Old Is Jesus This Year?

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 96
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.